Steelers could be in danger of a historically bad season

Getty Images

For the first Sunday this season, the Steelers won’t play. Which means that, for the first Sunday this season, the Steelers won’t lose.

As the winless six-time Super Bowl champions prepare to face the equally winless Bengals on Monday night, Steelers fans should begin to at least consider the possibility that the team could be in danger of having their worst season in 50 years.

It was 1969. That’s when Chuck Noll arrived to turn around a historically mediocre-at-best franchise, drafted Hall of Fame defensive tackle Joe Greene with the fourth overall selection, and then lost 13 of 14 games, laying the foundation to draft quarterback Terry Bradshaw with the first overall pick in 1970.

In 1970, the Steelers generated a 5-9 record. Since then, the Steelers have never won fewer than five games. Only once, in 1988, did the Steelers generate a five-win season.

With three losses in three games to start 2019, the Steelers now need to go 5-8 over the next 13 games to avoid producing their worst season since 1969.

They’ll have to do it without Ben Roethlisberger, obviously. And with a receiving corps that doesn’t seem to be nearly as talented as it’s been in recent years. And with a running game that can’t get going because the downfield passing game scares no one.

So here’s the challenge, in a nutshell: Win five games against the Bengals twice, the Ravens twice, at the Chargers, the Dolphins, Colts, Rams, the Browns twice, at the Cardinals, and at the Jets. Even with a depleted team, victories should come against the Dolphins, at least one against the Bengals, and the Cardinals.

Ultimately, whether the Steelers go 5-11 or 4-12 could come down to a Week 17 showdown against former Steelers running back Le'Veon Bell. And if the Steelers do indeed fail to turn things around, they won’t have the solace of the high first-round pick that became in past disastrous years the likes of Joe Greene and Terry Bradshaw.

Thanks to the Minkah Fitzpatrick trade, the Dolphins own that pick.

47 responses to “Steelers could be in danger of a historically bad season

  1. The Steelers have a really good team. They lost to the Patriots in week one. The Patriots have only given up 17 points in 3 games, so the Pats are just a monster. Then they played a close game and lost to Russell Wilson. Wilson is a top five QB, and the Steelers are breaking in a young QB. Then week 3 they gave the 49ers game away. Had the game in the bag and Conner put the ball on the ground. The bye week will help get everyone acclimated to Mason Rudolph, who is a great young QB. They have a few things to figure out, but they could still win 10 games.

  2. “Then week 3 they gave the 49ers game away. Had the game in the bag and Conner put the ball on the ground.”

    The 49ers turned the ball over 5 times and the Steelers didn’t take advantage. They deserved to lose.

  3. In case anyone hasn’t noticed, the combined record of the 3 teams the Steelers lost to is 8-1 and they almost won 2 of those games.

  4. That shouldn’t come as a surprise when you consider they lost to two of the worst teams in the league last year along the way to collapsing in the final half of the season and missing the playoffs despite having the MOST Pro Bowl players of any team. If that wasn’t enough to show the front office that they need a leader, not a cheerleader, then I don’t know what will. Maybe they’ll stick with Tomlin for ten years of winning five games or less before they realize he needs to go.

    This is what made that Minkah Fitzpatrick trade so puzzling. Sure, he’s a good player but why trade a #1 pick during a lost season? Now that #1 is beginning to look like a top 5 pick. Why didn’t they pick up a safety in free agency? Long-time Steelers fan here but that team is an absolute mess. Losing to the Broncos and the Raiders last year was inexcusable and told me enough that they need a change from Tomlin.

  5. Wow, that Fitzpatrick trade now looks like a disaster. Also, no clue why they stubbornly hang on to head coaches for so long. Three coaches in 50 years. Admirable stability, but what’s the point?

  6. @PrimeTime. Why would they be tanking? They traded their first round pick away. They just aren’t playing good at all. From a Steelers fan. SMH.

  7. Love how everyone jumps on Steelers yet they play the Bungales that have all this talent that continue to lose even with a new coach.

  8. Its going to be a real shame when the Dolphins draft Tua & Chase Young 1 & 2 in next years draft and set up a dynasty for years to come. Thanks Pittsburgh!

  9. When Ben went down with season ending injury the Steelers should have been trading players for draft picks, not picks for players. Ben’s best years are behind him and the elbow injury will be a career ender.

  10. derekgorgonstar says:
    September 29, 2019 at 10:08 am
    Good thing you traded away a pick that could have gotten you a franchise quarterback.

    ————————-

    There are no franchise QBs coming out next draft, that happens in 2021 when Trever Lawerence is eligible. That’s why you grab a guy like Fitzpatrick ahead of time who’s a top 10 talent at a strong position of need, which more than makes up for losing the pick. Try to keep up please.

  11. melikefootball says:
    September 29, 2019 at 10:48 am
    Love how everyone jumps on Steelers yet they play the Bungales that have all this talent that continue to lose even with a new coach.
    ___________________________________________________________________________________________

    You see any talent on the Bengals offensive line? There isn’t any. They lost both their starting Tackles and their best offensive linemen from last year retired suddenly. No AJ Green either. Bengals are exactly where we thought they would be. Admittedly, they should have beaten the Seahawks in week 1. Take it from a Bengals fan, they aren’t winning more than 4 games this year.

  12. Had they fired Tomlin and released Ben a year or two ago they would probably be in great shape with Bell and Brown and a highly drafted young QB on a rookie deal. But their blind loyalty to Ben and Tomlin instead gives you 0-3. Steelers front office Screwed up the past few offseasons.

  13. Given that it is now empirically evident that Antonio Brown carried that team for years, could it be possible that the Steelers are one of the team’s that has let Rosenhaus know that they would like to sign AB? 😉

  14. The only way I think you can prove that any team tanks on purpose is if the coaching staff retains their jobs the next season.
    Think about it…
    Unless the head coach knows he’ll have a job, why would he purposely lay down?
    The Browns retained Hue Jackson after a one win season, and then a winless season.
    That smacks of tanking.
    On the other hand, the Colts fired Jim Caldwell after the 2011 season, which disproves the tanking theory in Indy’s case.

  15. Everyone seems to be lashing out at Mike Tomlin, but what exactly has he done wrong? He doesn’t handle personnel issues, that’s the front office.

  16. Everyone seems to be lashing out at Mike Tomlin, but what exactly has he done wrong? He doesn’t handle personnel issues, that’s the front office.
    ————-
    Other than tripping opposing players and failing to make in game adjustments? Nothing.

  17. Wouldn’t panic just yet. Many teams will improve over the rest of the season, the first quarter of the schedule is not necessarily an accurate snapshot. The young QB needs some time.

  18. Lots of drama. Wow.

    They could have a terrible season.
    Statistically valid statement.

    But I doubt it.
    Historically valid statement.

    Look at the franchises that had those seasons.

    Some like Indy tanked.
    Others like Miami, the Jets, Browns, Lions etc were just consistently lousy franchises.

    Steelers are neither, witness the trade.

  19. M Fitzmagic showed well in less than a week w the team. The Steelers have their QB of the future & now have a verified quality return for next year’s first round pick (I don’t remember draft picks being guaranteed quality players before getting on the field). After turning this year around, in part due to our 2020 1st rounder, the pick to the Dolphins shouldn’t be higher than a 16-17 slot, if not lower (knock on wood). Now, Tomlin,Fichtner, & Butler are still the question marks in all of this.

  20. It seems there are so many weak teams this year, some will have to play each other and get a few wins.

  21. SWFLPC.INC says:
    September 29, 2019 at 10:35 am
    All the while Mike Tomlin does nothing

    ———————

    What you suggest he do? He isn’t the GM making these moves. I am not a Steelers fan but Tomlin is the only thing they have going on over there. The wolves are going to howl to fire him and the franchise will suffer even more.

  22. BuckyBadger says:
    September 29, 2019 at 12:33 pm
    SWFLPC.INC says:
    September 29, 2019 at 10:35 am
    All the while Mike Tomlin does nothing

    ———————

    What you suggest he do? He isn’t the GM making these moves. I am not a Steelers fan but Tomlin is the only thing they have going on over there. The wolves are going to howl to fire him and the franchise will suffer even more.

    ———-

    How about make some in-game adjustments? Remember the game against the Patriots where the Jesse James TD was overturned and Tomlin did nothing for three minutes but stare at the Jumbotron? A competent coach would have planned what plays the offense would run in the event the play was overturned….but not Mike….

  23. Thanks for the pick Pittsburgh. It’d be sweet if the Fins owned the No.1 and the No. 2 pick in the draft. Of course the media(haters) thought the Dolphins were stupid for giving up an average CB for a No.1.

  24. “How about make some in-game adjustments?”

    You and these other Tomlin haters would not know an in-game adjustment if it smacked you in the face. We realize that you hate black coaches, but please, confine your criticism to something within your limited knowledge.

  25. So I guess bazookajoeflacco is saying if they would have kept bell and ab that ab wouldn’t be a rapist but you are forgetting we offered bell a good deal

  26. They will run. I see between 150 and 200 yards on the ground against the Bengals.

    The O Line is embarassed. Pouncey. Decastro. These two will carry backs in this game. Hand it to anyone.

  27. whenwilliteverend says:
    September 29, 2019 at 10:39 am

    This is what made that Minkah Fitzpatrick trade so puzzling. Sure, he’s a good player but why trade a #1 pick during a lost season? Now that #1 is beginning to look like a top 5 pick. Why didn’t they pick up a safety in free agency?

    **********************************************************************************

    I still like the Fitzpatrick trade, regardless of what happens this season.

    First, barring Rudolph being an unmitigated disaster this year (which he won’t be), not the Steelers wouldn’t have drafted a QB even with a top-5 or 10 pick. They expect to have Ben 2-3 more years and want to see what Rudolph can do.

    Second, they’ve not done well at drafting in the secondary recently and there’s a need there because of it. Fitzpatrick fills a hole and is also locked up for a few more years. Fairly certain there was no one available in free agency with the potential and contract structure that Fitzpatrick gave.

  28. boiler72 says:
    Wow, that Fitzpatrick trade now looks like a disaster.

    That’s what everyone said about the AB trade, you know, frozen feet, Mr Big Tweet who is on the outside of football looking in.
    A 1st round pick for a 1st round DB who delivered in his first year, I’ll take that any day.

  29. The Fitzpatrick trade looks like a disaster, unless you have followed the Steelers and see the DB disasters we have drafted in the first and second rounds in the last five years.

  30. Or maybe it will be ok. The sky will not fall. The Steelers will not impersonate those perennial crap franchises after all.

    One game back of the division lead.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.