Could Cowboys rescind Dak Prescott’s franchise tag?

Getty Images

Presumably, Andy Dalton becomes the backup to Dak Prescott in Dallas. But with Prescott not yet accepting a franchise tender with a value in excess of $31 million, it’s reasonable to ask the question posed in the headline of this item: Would the Cowboys rescind Dak’s tender?

Until Prescott accepts the one-year offer, the Cowboys have the ability to yank it. And Dalton gives Dallas an intriguing bird in the hand in the event that the Cowboys can’t work something out with Prescott and potentially decide, depending on the whims of owner/G.M. Jerry Jones, to rescind the franchise tender, making Dalton the Dallas starter and saving well over $20 million in the process.

While that’s highly unlikely, stranger things have happened. And if coach Mike McCarthy, who has no history with Prescott, is comfortable with Dalton and if Jerry and Stephen Jones grow sufficiently weary of Dak’s demands, it’s impossible to completely and entirely rule out the possibility of a Texas native taking over America’s Team.

It that were to happen, what would happen with Dak? The starting jobs are set for most teams, and those that would consider Prescott (primarily, the Patriots and the Jaguars) don’t have the cap space to give him the kind of money he’d make in Dallas, if he were to accept the tender.

Beyond New England and Jacksonville, which other teams would even consider turning their plans for 2020 upside down and signing Dak to the kind of deal he’s demanding in Dallas? Would the Jets bench Sam Darnold? Would the Browns bump Baker Mayfield? Would the Raiders jettison Derek Carr? Would Washington pull the plug on Dwayne Haskins?

With the Cowboys to date intent on keeping Dak, the question of whether and to what extent another team would make a move for Prescott has yet to be raised. Budgets have been set and money has been spent and if the Cowboys wait until, say, July to make the move, Prescott would be very hard pressed to find a landing spot.

Again, it’s unlikely. But it’s a suddenly fascinating possibility, and it gives the Cowboys a little extra leverage at a time when they otherwise have none.

152 responses to “Could Cowboys rescind Dak Prescott’s franchise tag?

  1. If there is a gap in talent in Dak’s favor, it’s certainly not $30M worth.

  2. Exactly. How many teams would actually dump their starter and have the cap space to pay Dak. Jerry is simply bidding against himself at this point. Rescind the tag. Then let’s get back to the real negotiating. Love the Dalton signing.

  3. He’s not good enough to demand anywhere close to $31 million, it would serve him right for them to rescind the tag.

  4. If he couldn’t find a seat on the carousel, assuming they rescind the tag, I wonder what his “demands” would be at that point?

  5. Won’t Jerry get confused when it looks like the head coach he just fired is suddenly under center?

  6. All these guys claiming that Dalton is better than Prescott LOL. Bad receivers were never his problem. Andy Dalton had a 7 time Pro Bowl receiver in AJ Green along with tons of other weapons and never won a single playoff game in 9 years as the starter.

  7. I hope the let Dak go. I’ve never been a fan believing he is way overrated. Keep Dalton, make him the starter.

  8. The Jaguars have enough cap space to make it happen with a well-constructed contract. Prescott would be an upgrade over Carr, but the Raiders have even less cap space than the Jaguars. Dumping Haskins would be incredibly premature, but this is Dan Snyder we’re talking about. His love for a big name can’t be overstated.

  9. Any sane businessman would take Dalton as the starting QB and dump the $30M headache.

  10. Dak Prescott- 30 TDs 11 Ints 65% completion pct. 4902 yards. 99.7 QBR
    Andy Dalton – 16 TDs 14 Int’s 59% completion pct. 3494 yds. 78.3 QBR.

    Dalton better than Dak?

    I don’t think so.

    Dalton is a good backup. Pay Dak.

  11. They should do it, just to get the asking price down to a reasonable amount. Is he $10 million better than Garoppolo, Brady, Brees, Roethlisberger, or Rodgers? Of course not. But that’s what he’s asking for. If he’s looking at Goff, well, everyone knows he’s getting way overpaid, just like Gurley was. That shouldn’t set the market.

    If they withdraw the franchise tag, no one else is going to sign Prescott for within $10 million of what the Cowboys already offered.

    With Dalton, they’re now fine at QB. Prescott should also be fine with a much smaller contract than what he’s asking for. Too much greed.

  12. At Jerry’s age, he’s not messing around with Andy Dalton. Dak Prescott is one of the top NFL QB’s, and he’s still improving. He gives the Cowboys a good chance to win every Sunday, and in the playoffs. Dalton is close to the perfect backup, and he suddenly became available. Jerry and his people had to make a quick decision.

  13. Why in the world would the Patriots want Dak, especially at $30 Million? even if they had the cap space? I think BB likes Jarrett Stidham enough to move forward with him.

  14. Washington makes the most sense for Dak. He is better than any QB they have on the roster and he knows the division. Plus he would get a chance to stick it to the Cowboys twice a year.

  15. The cowboys cn sign jadeveon clowney and everson griffen with that money.
    Probably win more games than paying Dak $31 mil

  16. Look at Daltons numbers when he had talent around him. If I’m jerry I lwt dak walk. Hes not worth what he wants. Use dalton as a stop gap and draft a QB or even go with Dalton long term. Either way you save millions without a dropoff in play. Plus dak will see hes not anywhere near worth what he thinks when he doesnt get anywhere close to 30 million on the open market

  17. Is it too late to apply a nonexclusive tag on Dak? 2 first round pics sure sounds good.

  18. Seriously why not sign Cam? He’ll probably play for much less than $31 million

  19. Dak. You want one play hard ball??? See you. You will never see a 33 million offer again. You made your bed. Now sleep in it.

  20. Dak was born on 3rd base and thinks he hit a triple. 4th round pick for a reason. The Cowboys have to pay Zeke and average Amari just to make their “franchise” QB look competent. Dak doesn’t elevate those around him. Those around, elevate him.

  21. Washington is most likely destination if they dump him.

  22. If the franchise tag was rescinded, that would also remove Dak as the lightning rod for fans who are peeved about the Cowboys’ lack of playoff success over the past 25 or so years. Dak would be free to sign with other teams, including the Canadian Football League, and the Jones’ would be free to explain why they paid everyone, including a QB released by the Bengals, before paying the QB who led the Dallas offense to No. 1 in 2019.

  23. I would. This is like the Melvin Gordon thing a year ago. What exactly are you paying for? Prescott playing hard ball like he’s Peyton Manning in his prime has been strange to watch.

  24. Presumably, Andy Dalton becomes the backup to Dak Prescott in Dallas.

    ———-

    Yeah, umm, no. The only ones making that assumption are those with ulterior motive to do so. Presumably, the Dallas Cowboys are finished trying to negotiate with Dak Prescott, a mediocre mid tier QB not worth more than 2-3 mil per year.

    Dalton is a bettwr QB in every facet, a proven winner, a locker room leader and willing to come in and EARN a big contract as opposed to demanding one ala Prescott.

    If I were Dallas I pull the offer and tell Prescott good luck on the open market. San Diego or Jacksonville MIGHT throw him a contract, but it won’t be for what he is demanding. Not even close.

  25. Trade him to Jacksonville for Yannick and a 1st round draft pick.

    Use the extra $30m to sign Jadaveon Clowney and Everson Griffen. Maybe trade for a vet DB who you can now fit under your cap.

    Win a super bowl with the best front 7 the league has ever seen and draft a new franchise QB next year.

  26. If they had any brains they would rescind it. Prescott isn’t that good and isn’t a leader. More than that he isn’t worth the money. PASS. Cut him loose.

  27. It might be a little far-fetched, but I can see the Chargers paying for Dak and letting Hebert ride the bench for a year or two. The Chargers still have some big holes to fill and I don’t think this is a good time for them to start a rookie.

  28. What’s gotten into Jerry lately? The Cowboys did a good job with the draft by all accounts and this is one of the shrewder moves he’s made in a long time. He’s done playing with Dak.

  29. Yes, so juicy!

    Dak will never be an elite QB. Don’t pay him like he is. I don’t like Dallas, not a fan. But I’d love to see them rescind the tag. Dak is not a great QB…

  30. It’s a moot issue as there is likely no NFL football in 2020. And that creates another set of salary problems.

  31. With that offense even Dalton could put up decent numbers, for a fraction of the price.

  32. I would not give up on Darnold or Carr for Dak. And there’s your answer to if this guy is worth over $35+ million.

  33. I mean… Andy Dalton is so bad his last team just landed the first overall pick. He’s terrible. Its outright ludicrous to even mention him in the same sentence as Dak Prescott.

  34. Dalton is a better QB. He has been stuck on a perennial terrible team. With other solid talent around him he will win some games.
    Bye bye Dak

  35. I’ve got nothing against Dak, but I have ZERO sympathy for guys who try to work the system and lose. Lookin’ at you, Clowney!

  36. Dak may have overplayed his pair of deuces hand here. “You got to know when to hold ’em. Know when to fold ’em. Know when to walk away and know when to run.”

  37. The Dak discussion has centered on his lack of value to his own team, Dallas, from whom he is hoping to extort more money. But if Dalton is close in talent, Dak has made a big error because his value is considered lower even on other teams. There are still several free agent qb’s who are obviously better than Dax.

  38. Dak will play one year under the tag.
    All bets are off beyond one year.
    And if Dak stinks it up, it’s over for him in Dallas.

  39. At a time when millions of people are losing their jobs, companies and many individuals will have to file for bankruptcy, thousands of people are dying from Covid-19, and people in cities across the country are waiting in long lines to get donations of food, Dak is hesitating to sign a contract that will pay him in excess of 31 million dollars.

    That makes perfect sense to nobody.

  40. Funny thing is, Dak and Andy are about even when it comes to talent. Andy has the experience and would save the team $20 million+.

  41. Just for the pure FUN of it they should. It’s like paying Lamborghini money for a basic Toyota.

  42. Last year they went 8 and 8 in the weakest division in football. That’s not a knock it just is what happened.

  43. Id cut him. I really dont think he’s THAT good and i bet if he got cut there would not be a huge market for him. Yeah hes better than Winston but things can change REAL quick for starting qb’s in NFL.
    Winston goes from 1st overall pick to signing as a backup for chump change $1m.
    Trubisky on his way to backup and once that happens will prob never be a starter again.
    Noone cares about Cam Newton.

    Things change quick.

  44. Dak should have taken 30 million a year and not pretended that he was better and more valuable than Russell Wilson.

    Greed is going to bite him.

    Speaking of 30 million, that’s how many people are out of work in the United States at the moment.

    I would just roll with Andy to make a point.

  45. Going to be fun to see how McCarthy’s pass oriented offense does in Dallas. Will he use Zeke or go with 3-4-5 wr sets as he did in GB. Regardless, Dallas made their bed with this qb “problem” and Andy Dalton being their qb would be a hoot. Jerry Jones certainly knows how to keep the pot stirring.

  46. For the Pats, what the media should be focusing on is will Stidham be as good as Garropolo, and what about intriguing undrafted signings Brian Lewerke and J’Mar Smith? But no, after years trying hard to deny Brady is the greatest QB to ever play (because they say a lot of is Belichick’s system), the salty mountain of media hate’s narrative is now more or less saying that Belichick can’t draft, got lucky with Brady (and er, JimmyG) and is lost without some other team’s expensive reject.

  47. Dak played his hand poorly in this matter. Dalton is a mid tier QB, but can win with a strong supporting cast and the Jones group probably see this. Cowboys now have the upper hand in this contractual stalemate.

    On a somewhat related note: Cam Newton should take note and go the route of Winston and Dalton.

  48. #hackthedak How many times did he take a sack instead of throw the ball away ? He would not throw it away because it would hurt him completion percentage. I don’t need a stat chaser

  49. Things go bad. Packers fire Mike McCarthy.
    People say Rodgers poisoned the relationship.

    The next year AR and a rookie HC win 14 games, 1 away from the Superbowl. McCarthy picks a fight with a high school basketball ref.

    McCarthy in Dallas, while negotiating an AR sized contract with their QB, poisoned the relationship by grabbing Dalton.

    What’s the common denominator?

  50. the dalton signing was exactly what the cowboys needed to do in order to have the high ground like Obi-Wan.

  51. I’d pull the tag. Prescott isn’t elite by any stretch and he turned his nose up at elite money. Cowboys could sign Clowney and Cam for that money and still have a bunch left over.

  52. Paying Fat Zeke then losing Dak would be so Jerry Jones, snatching defeat from the jaws of victory.

  53. It’s probably a good spot for Dalton regardless. Anyone else seeing that guy become a coach? If you can’t do, teach kinda thing…

  54. I wouldn’t be surprised if Dallas cuts Dak. Jerry doesn’t like him. I would think Pittsburgh would be a dark horse in signing Dak if he is cut.

  55. A year ago Pollard was lighting up the preseason running the ball for the Cowboys, there was talk he could replace Zeke and you know what happened?

    Jerry gave Zeke everything he wanted.

    It’s great to speculate but despite his tough talk Jerry has a long track record of caving to his star players.

  56. Jerry had a great draft and it looks like he’s made some smart moves in free agency but will he have the balls to use this leverage?

  57. I’d pull it and try to sign another QB that could compete for the starting job for a fraction of the cost and look at the draft next year. Certainly would at least take another look at Cam Newton.

  58. Signing Dalton gives the cowboys some leverage. My guess is that Dak will continue to hold out and not sign the tender until the league is cleared to resume activities. If a long term deal hasn’t been worked out by then, he will then sign the tender. If he decides to continue his hold out and not sign, Dallas will move forward with Dalton.

  59. 1. When did $30 million stop being a lot of money? I would sign that so fast, play the year and ride off into a glorious Texas sunset.

    2. How much can the fans afford for tickets? No need to elaborate here, what do yours cost you per year?

    3. He’s not even that good.

  60. i might actually start rooting for the cowboys if the cut greedhead dak.

  61. Jerry is a loyal guy, so if the franchise tag gets yanked I’ll bet he offers Dak a job as a member of the crew on his yacht.

  62. No financial hit to Dallas if it chooses to move on. Dak should have signed that $30+ million tender the moment it landed on his desk. They say the most powerful word in Hollywood is “no.” But you gotta mean it. We’re going to find out real soon whether Dak meant it.

  63. Time to reset the average qb market. All of the top passing teams last year did not make the playoffs.

  64. The way these salaries are getting out of control, I would trade Dak, Dalton has a couple years left in him. Pick up a QB, In next year’s draft. That would save a lot of money. That QB would come cheap. Just a thought.

  65. Dak…1 playoff win. Dalton….zero playoffs wins. Not attractive options. At least Dalton costs much less for playoff mediocrity.

  66. Rescind the tag, give the core talent a raise, sign cam Newton as well and jadeveon clowny to one year deals. Have a veteran QB competition. Go all in on the short year.

  67. Wait, you mean it’s not inevitable that he gets a big contract?

  68. Andy Dalton wants to be a starter. What if the cowboys made an offer like this:
    a low base but with incentives that if Dalton produces he would get paid like a good quarterback. If he has a great year, which is unlikely , he would get paid a lot.
    You would give him a chance to earn a starting position which I assume is worth more to him than a few million dollars in guaranteed salary.

  69. firerogergoodell says:
    May 2, 2020 at 11:19 pm
    All these guys claiming that Dalton is better than Prescott LOL. Bad receivers were never his problem. Andy Dalton had a 7 time Pro Bowl receiver in AJ Green along with tons of other weapons and never won a single playoff game in 9 years as the starter.
    …………………………………………………………………………..
    AJ Green has missed 2 full seasons in the last 4 years….tyler eifert hurt every year..running backs hurt every year…first rd picks hurt every year or a bust…terrible coaching and an org that doesn’t care about winning…but yes go on you seem to know what you’re talking about….

  70. Now that we know that they can pull the tender, the question is should they. I say yes.

    Look at the recent QB signings, no way Dak makes more than 15M this season from any team other than Dallas.

  71. trade dak to washington for haskins and a 2021 3rd round pick. make haskins the backup
    to dalton. it is time to show these greedy players who is in charge.

  72. Just think how much Dak will want if he wins two playoff games.

  73. Hardheaded Jerry finally learned after over paying Zeke and getting……

  74. Money well spent by Jerry. Had to get a veteran on the roster at this point.

    I always thought Dak was the beneficiary of being on a talented team, especially on O. He’s not bad but also far from elite. Last year against Miami at times he had 5-6 seconds to make a play and just wasn’t that impressive.

    They can’t outright let him walk because you lose an asset for nothing and take a big risk with just AD.

    Dalton’s greatest value comes in negotiations with Dak and keeping the pressure on him to produce during the season.

    Look at the output from Ryan Tannehill after having to battle back to the starting position. Love the guy, but in Miami, he never felt the pressure from another QB.

  75. geobh says:
    trade dak to washington for haskins and a 2021 3rd round pick. make haskins the backup
    to dalton. it is time to show these greedy players who is in charge.
    —-
    The Redskins are committed to giving Haskins a chance. Otherwise they would have picked up Tua.

  76. About 90% of the time the talent that’s around the QB has more to do with how good a QB looks than the QB himself does!

  77. Jones is playing the press like a fiddle, what is a better way to keep the Cowboys in the news every day. The qb will sign when Jones has milked the press and the TV boys for all they can and since nothing else is news his Cowboys are front and center.

  78. Dallas will not rescind. However if Dak does not show up to start the season-he could find himself replaced if Dalton does well.

    The ‘wally pipp’ scenario has happened many times in sports

  79. One thing Cousins did twice, was sign the tag right and participate in offseason. Dak has a new coach and playbook ans since he’s a free agent, no access. Demand Dak sign the tag by Friday and rescind the tag if he doesn’t.

  80. jimmygeewhiz says:
    May 3, 2020 at 9:21 am
    No financial hit to Dallas if it chooses to move on. Dak should have signed that $30+ million tender the moment it landed on his desk. They say the most powerful word in Hollywood is “no.” But you gotta mean it. We’re going to find out real soon whether Dak meant it.

    ———

    Or the long term deal they offered him prior to tagging him.

  81. I thought the Cowboys were cash strapped. Where do they get their money to sign all these people? Is there enough money left for Prescott? Or are they robbing Peter to pay Paul?

  82. Jerry will eventually cave and pay Dak in spite of this signing. He falls in love with certain players and can’t help himself when they want a big contract.

    I’d try to find a way to trade Dak for draft picks. Use the cap savings to bulk up the defense. The offense will be good whether Dak or Dalton is the QB. The defense needs some upgrades. Better to put the cap money into the defense than grossly overpaying a slightly above average QB for 4 years. That’s the way to compete for a Super Bowl.

  83. Make an example of Dak to the entire league and for those greedy Agents.
    The man has 1 playoff win and he wants Aaron Rodgers money.
    Let em’ walk.

  84. The Cowboys could have signed Winston and Dalton for a fifth of what it costs to tag Dak for a year.

  85. transpo says:
    May 3, 2020 at 8:12 am
    Things go bad. Packers fire Mike McCarthy.
    People say Rodgers poisoned the relationship.

    The next year AR and a rookie HC win 14 games, 1 away from the Superbowl. McCarthy picks a fight with a high school basketball ref.

    McCarthy in Dallas, while negotiating an AR sized contract with their QB, poisoned the relationship by grabbing Dalton.

    What’s the common denominator?

    ——————————————

    First, Jerry Jones makes the decisions in Dallas. The HC has no say.

    Second, you might not have heard, but that rookie HC in Green Bay already made clear that Aaron the Diva isn’t part of his long term plan.

    I say rescind the tag. Don’t make the mistake of overpaying a mediocre QB(looking at you MN).

  86. Dak is a good quarterback. He wants to get paid like an elite QB. Their is a big difference.

  87. Cowboys have one the best teams in the league on both sides of the ball and Zak has done what with it? I didn’t see him hold up the MVP trophy at the super bowl or anything close to that. I could find a lot better ways to spend 30 million a year than on this guy.

  88. justwondering says:
    May 3, 2020 at 12:11 am
    If the franchise tag was rescinded, that would also remove Dak as the lightning rod for fans who are peeved about the Cowboys’ lack of playoff success over the past 25 or so years. Dak would be free to sign with other teams, including the Canadian Football League, and the Jones’ would be free to explain why they paid everyone, including a QB released by the Bengals, before paying the QB who led the Dallas offense to No. 1 in 2019.
    ———————————-

    You forgot to mention Dak also led the Cowboys to an 8-8 record and no playoff games.

  89. Love all the know nothings who are trying to put Dalton down. Too funny. Let’s look at some Andy Dalton facts instead.

    Whwn it comes to Dalton vs Dak, the numbers speak for themselves. Dalton took the Bengals to the playoffs 5 years in a row with half the talent Dallas has given to Dak “8-8” Prescott. To date in Daltons career he has had AJ Green and…….. AJ Green as his help. Never had a Zeke caliber RB, never had two elite WR’s to throw to on the field at the same time, never had an offensive line worth a crap.

    “Yeah butbut he never wins in the playoffs.” Yeah and neither did Carson Palmer in Cinci. Or Jon Kitna. The common denominator among the three? Marvin Lewis, a guy trying to coach like it was 1986 and Mike Brown, an Owner trying to run things like it is 1956. Fun fact: Andy Dalton is the most successful QB in Bengals history. Yes, he did more under those circumstances than any other QB Lewis and Brown had.

    The reality is Andy Dalton is like a Kurt Warner. He is good, but if you get talent around the guy he CAN be elite. He didn’t sign to be the back up in Dallas amd if it ends up being a fair and equal competition? Zero chance mediocre Dak beats the Red Rifle. Less than zero.

  90. I’m still scratching my head at why Dalton would want to sign with Dallas for 3 million dollars as a backup when he made 17 last year and could easily be a starter somewhere. He sold himself short imo.

  91. $33 million/year. If a person made $100K/yr, it would take 330 years to make what Dak would make in ONE year. And somehow this isn’t enough in the mind of Mr. Prescott?

  92. Dak, a little bit of advice. Over 30 million Americans are out of work and worry about paying their bills. You think you deserve 30 million plus? How many super bowls have you won? The same as me, NONE. Play with fire and get burned.

  93. Dak Prescott may end up pricing himself out of the league. He wants more money than Tom Brady is making, even though he has accomplished next to nothing. No Super Bowl ring, no regular season MVP award. No nothing.

  94. Good move by the Cowboys who should rescind their exclusive offer to Dak and replace it with a non exclusive offer and take the two 1st round draft picks for a trade! Use the picks for a QB in the next draft and let Dalton lead the Cowboys! Win Win!

  95. Dalton has never had the talent around him and a great offensive line in front of him like Dallas has. Dalton can win a Super Bowl in Dallas. Send Dak to Cincinnati and then we’ll see if he is worth 40 million dollars a year.

  96. It doesn’t matter who the Cowboys have at QB. As long as Jerruh Jones is running things — and make no mistake, he still is — the Cowboys will not win another championship.

  97. Dak is not 4x better than Andy. Shrewd signing by Cowboys. If I’m a Jones, and I’m not, make Andy the starter and use the $ to sign Clowney and/or other top FA’s. NFC East is Cowboys for the taking…

  98. By now everyone knows Dak is asking for money that exceeds that of the truly great quarterbacks. His body of work doesn’t warrant that. If the Cowboys were smart they would play up the connection between Dalton and the great state of Texas. Welcome home kind of thing. Fans would rally around him to a certain degree, and Dak is quickly becoming the bad guy based on this forum. That hurts sales of misc. Cowboy branded souvenirs. But if everyone knows Dalton is a Texan, he gets seen in a more positive light. Then bad seasons in Cinncy get blamed on bad teams and all is forgiven. This moves all the leverage to the Cowboys. Dak is hurting his brand. 10 years of excellence and he should get money like Rogers or Brady. Even one or two years of carrying a team like Mahomes but today is coming across as greedy and not a team player. Market Dalton as the opposite and you are in the drivers seat.

  99. If I am a Defensive Coordinator playing against the ‘Boys and its 3rd and 10, I would definitely prefer to see Dak in the huddle and not Andy. nuff said.

  100. People on here calling dak overrated and then saying we should sign clowney..

  101. Listen dalton is coming to Dallas to be a backup and anybody who thinks otherwise is wrong imo. Jerry remembers the post Aikman pre romo era very well.. he lucked out finding dak in the 4th.. is he top tier elite right now? No but he’s a top 10 qb and continually progressing. It’s much easier said than done to let dak walk and just go “draft a franchise qbs next year” and please stop w the “let dak walk sign cam newton and clowney” talk.. this isn’t madden franchise mode

  102. Tightening down the screws on Prescott. Dalton will participate in offseason and learn the playbook, while Prescott is pouting. Nuff said.

  103. This seems to be a gambit by Dak’s agent, but the situation has changed with COVID and now the Red Rifle on board. Time to sign, not whine.

  104. I’m still scratching my head at why Dalton would want to sign with Dallas for 3 million dollars as a backup when he made 17 last year and could easily be a starter somewhere. He sold himself short imo.

    ———–

    Maybe he thinks or even was told that he’s going to be the starter? Maybe a billionaire is fed up with Dak playing games with him?

    Andy is looking at the team and is thinking he doesn’t care how much he makes, it is time to try and get a ring.

    He made 17 mil last year and lost all year. Money doesn’t make that fun and money doesn’t make you a winner. If ANYONE understands this it is Andy Dalton.

    If I was him with all that money in the bank I would take this job for free just to try and get some rings before I retire. Not realistic of course but I don’t need fancy stuff and could retire on 10 million pretty easy.

  105. Never pass up a chance to trash Sam Darnold, who is better than Dak Prescott, and Dwayne Haskins, who will be better than Dak Prescott.

  106. Dak Prescott- 30 TDs 11 Ints 65% completion pct. 4902 yards. 99.7 QBR
    Andy Dalton – 16 TDs 14 Int’s 59% completion pct. 3494 yds. 78.3 QBR.

    Using stats from a year that Dalton only played 13 games isn’t really fair. In the 13 games he did play all were without AJ Green.

    Dak does have marginally better career stats. Put in the years where Dalton had an offensive line rated equal or better than Dak and the numbers favor Dalton.

    The question is always going to be, “Is Dak a 30 million dollars a year improvement over Dalton?” They are pretty much a wsh.

  107. Would be hilarious and would certainly send a signal to players in the future to sign franchise tenders when placed (which I think they should anyway for injury purposes).

  108. Why wouldn’t those teams have signed Winston, Dalton? Newton is still available.

    The Dallas QB position is a huge promotional gig (it’s the best QB position in the NFL). It’s far better than Cincinnati. My thought is that the Cowboy QB could afford to be underpaid because he can make it up with all the promotions. Prescott has worked very well in an establish offense with a strong running attack and pretty good OL and receiver corps. How would the two have performed if they were on the other team? Prescott is a very good QB, but Dallas now has a top 10 QB. He needs Dallas to retain and acquire talent and not sink the team with just his salary. Plus, what happens if 2020 doesn’t happen? Is Dallas going to eat another $30 million?

  109. After reading these comments, I’m convinced no one has actually watched Dalton play for the past 5 years. He’s been terrible and that’s substantiated by every statistical measure.

  110. If I am Jerry, that is exactly what I do. With the talent the Cowboys have, some of us on here could win a game or two.

    Dalton won in Cincinnati. Cincinnati! He’s 32, seasoned, focused and has an unquestionable work ethic.

    Yeah, Dalton, can take this team to the playoffs.

    See ya, Dak.

  111. If I was Jerry, I would pull that tag in a heartbeat. Dak would learn the hard way that he killed the goose that laid the golden egg. What, $30M a year isn’t enough? Sorry Dak, you’re a good QB, but you ain’t so good without that talent assembled around you. Let’s see what a great QB you are for a team like Dolphins.

  112. Let Dak go save 25 million dollars, you have a servicable starting QB, and take and give Clowney a 1 year 20 million deal still saving 5 million, team just got much better……

  113. jrcowboy49 says:
    May 3, 2020 at 12:10 pm
    Good move by the Cowboys who should rescind their exclusive offer to Dak and replace it with a non exclusive offer and take the two 1st round draft picks for a trade! Use the picks for a QB in the next draft and let Dalton lead the Cowboys! Win Win!

    @@@@@@@@222

    Nobody is giving up 2 first for dak junior

  114. brownietheelf32 says:
    May 3, 2020 at 11:49 am
    Love all the know nothings who are trying to put Dalton down. Too funny. Let’s look at some Andy Dalton facts instead.

    Whwn it comes to Dalton vs Dak, the numbers speak for themselves. Dalton took the Bengals to the playoffs 5 years in a row with half the talent Dallas has given to Dak “8-8” Prescott. To date in Daltons career he has had AJ Green and…….. AJ Green as his help. Never had a Zeke caliber RB, never had two elite WR’s to throw to on the field at the same time, never had an offensive line worth a crap.

    “Yeah butbut he never wins in the playoffs.” Yeah and neither did Carson Palmer in Cinci. Or Jon Kitna. The common denominator among the three? Marvin Lewis, a guy trying to coach like it was 1986 and Mike Brown, an Owner trying to run things like it is 1956. Fun fact: Andy Dalton is the most successful QB in Bengals history. Yes, he did more under those circumstances than any other QB Lewis and Brown had.

    The reality is Andy Dalton is like a Kurt Warner. He is good, but if you get talent around the guy he CAN be elite. He didn’t sign to be the back up in Dallas amd if it ends up being a fair and equal competition? Zero chance mediocre Dak beats the Red Rifle. Less than zero.
    ____________________________________________________________________________________
    Funny you mention Jon Kitna.
    After he left Cincy he became Tony Romo’s backup. You know Romo. Another mediocre
    QB who happens to own most the Cowboy passing records.
    Tony got hurt in 2010 and the team fell apart and Garrett replaced Phillips as coach.
    Kitna redeemed himself the rest of the year but he never got within sniffing distance
    of replacing Romo. He was a damned good backup though.
    Dak replaced Romo.
    Dalton may be a great QB and I hope he turns out to be but I don’t see the team
    turning against Dak and favoring Dalton.
    Dak put up tremendous numbers last year as he has in previous years.
    The team has yet to suffer a losing season with Dak.
    Garrett was a terrible coach and last years record is more on him than Dak.
    I believe Dak under McCarthy can blossom into greatness.
    He isn’t perfect but he is tough, big and strong and will put his pads into a LB
    to gain an extra yard.
    The team believes in him and responds to him.

  115. Dalton is a great insurance policy. He could start, he could back up Dak or in a better move the Cowboys could wait until at least one starter goes down and turn him into a 3rd or 4th round pick to a playoff team desperate for a starter and pay next to nothing for it.

    Without looking deeper teams like Buffalo, Houston, Tennessee, Kansas City, Minnesota and San Francisco would all be willing to throw a 3rd at Dallas if their starter went down early.

  116. jerrystrashcan says:
    May 3, 2020 at 7:08 pm
    ————
    Funny you mention Jon Kitna.
    After he left Cincy he became Tony Romo’s backup. You know Romo. Another mediocre
    QB who happens to own most the Cowboy passing records.
    Tony got hurt in 2010 and the team fell apart and Garrett replaced Phillips as coach.
    Kitna redeemed himself the rest of the year but he never got within sniffing distance
    of replacing Romo. He was a damned good backup though.
    Dak replaced Romo.
    Dalton may be a great QB and I hope he turns out to be but I don’t see the team
    turning against Dak and favoring Dalton.
    Dak put up tremendous numbers last year as he has in previous years.
    The team has yet to suffer a losing season with Dak.
    Garrett was a terrible coach and last years record is more on him than Dak.
    I believe Dak under McCarthy can blossom into greatness.
    He isn’t perfect but he is tough, big and strong and will put his pads into a LB
    to gain an extra yard.
    The team believes in him and responds to him.

    Dak will never be as good as Romo. Not even close.

  117. Why do these misconceptions persist?

    1. At no time would ANY team have given up two first-round picks for Dak. Not even one 1st. And had he been an UFA like Cam, he’d probably home waiting for a call, like Cam

    2. NFL Commissioner and President (of the USA) have said the season will start on time. Who else do you need to hear from? These are two guys who basically answer to nobody in this respect. (I am not a fan of either but that doesn’t change reality)

    3. Yes, if I (or anyone) could choose which guy I would want to be, most would choose younger, more athletic, more potential Dak. But as a GM? Is a 5% upgrade at QB worth 1050% the investment, even forgetting any perceived attitude difference?

  118. I personally dont like the cowboys and not a big fan of Dalton. But JERRY make the smartest decision you’ve ever made with ownership of the cowboys and rescind the tag. Dalton can do the same thing if not more for 20 million less a season. Heck you can probably pay Dalton the 45 million for the next 4 years and have better results.

  119. Dak has overpriced himself. Time for a discount or take your show on the road.

  120. Andy Dalton is so bad his last team just landed the first overall pick. He’s terrible. Its outright ludicrous to even mention him in the same sentence as Dak Prescott.
    #####################################################################################################
    Was Dak Prescott playing with a third string left Tackle last year? Dak Prescott had the benefit of playing behind one of the best O-lines in football. Andy Dalton played behind one of the three worst. You don’t think Left Tackle is important? Ask the Redskins? they drafted right behind the Bengals.

  121. friedbokchoy says:
    May 3, 2020 at 7:34 pm

    Dak will never be as good as Romo. Not even close.
    _________________________________________________

    The numbers say otherwise.
    Dak’s completion pct, TD to Int and Passer rating are a little better over their carrers.
    Plus the team thought Romo to be a prima donna.
    Dak has the teams respect.
    Dalton is pedestrian compared to both Dak and Romo.

  122. Lots of teams might be willing to free up money for Dak by cutting some vet in the final year of their contract. Dak might be annoyed with Dallas cutting him and take less elsewhere. If Daks demands decrease, he would be a valuable guy to have at the right price, so it would be dumb to give him away for nothing. Then Steelers could be interesting too because Ben is always injured and cant have long left. The Falcons could use a QB who is less bad in the 4th quarter. Dak would surely be an upgrade for Washington or Chicago.

  123. We’ve seen a lot of change in our lives early on in 2020 and the same is true for the NFL. I hope they find a way to play this season because there’s a lot of interesting scenarios that have been created with the usual changes that have taken place during this offseason. To me, it just feels more exciting this year to see how it all plays out. The situation now with Dak is just another example.

  124. I don’t know if it’s Prescott or his agent, but either/or both are playing this wrong. I’ll assume it’s the agent, because he’s working for a commission on the contract. If he were a realtor, 6% of $33 million is a whole lot of money. He’s probably charging 30%, which is a whole lot more money.

    Prescott is making millions in endorsement deals. It comes with being the quarterback for the Dallas Cowboys. Those all vanish the moment he is not. On no other team would he be able to make that kind of money in endorsements, unless he goes somewhere and wins spectacularly, which is unlikely.

    Dalton understands this. Is Andrew a better quarterback than Dakota? That remains to be seen, but it doesn’t matter. Just being the quarterback of the Dallas Cowboys is worth millions. It’s not about the contract; it’s about the endorsements.

    Meredith never won a Super Bowl, but he made a fortune as an announcer. Staubach won Super Bowls, but he made his fortune in real estate. Aikman won Super Bowls, and made a fortune as an announcer. The common denominator is that all three were quarterbacks for the Dallas Cowboys. Look at Romo, who never won anything.

    Prescott is negotiating from a weak position. He has far more to gain by being the quarterback of the Dallas Cowboys, and everything to lose if he is not. No other team is going to offer him anywhere near what Dallas has, and all those endorsement deals, poof! Gone like smoke.

    Dalton knows this. Prescott does not understand. It’s not about the contract; it’s about the endorsements. Millions to be made, just by being the quarterback of the Dallas Cowboys. Win or lose, the simple fact that you became the quarterback for the Dallas Cowboys is worth millions.

    Hey, if Dalton takes over, leads the team to a winning season, a playoff victory or two, maybe a conference championship or a Super Bowl, he’ll be a hero across Texas. Win or lose, endorsement deals will come raining down.

    Do I think the Cowboys have a chance with Dalton under center? No, not any more than I think they have a chance with Prescott under center. But Prescott has everything to lose, while Dalton has everything to gain.

  125. You Cowboy fans are hysterical!! The QB you have grades out at 8th in the league over his first 4 seasons, has been the 64th highest paid QB in the league over those four years, and you sign the QB with last year’s WORST RATING IN THE NFL to twice as much money as your starter has made in any year of his career! Haha! Now you’re hoping that you replace your starter (who hasn’t missed a game in his career) with Dalton! Who has missed 8 games the last two seasons and thrown 6 ints for every 1 TD in the playoffs for his career. Prescott’s worst season over 4 years is in line with Dalton’s best season over that time. Your stupid owner could have saved $50 million if he’d extended Prescott a year ago, but instead he made “hold out Zeke” the highest paid RB in the league by a mile and for every two TDs he rushes for, that QB you don’t want (who doesn’t miss a game) rushes for one! You guys deserve every thing you get. Steven A. is right — you guys deserve everything you get! 🙂

  126. Dak Prescott- 30 TDs 11 Ints 65% completion pct. 4902 yards. 99.7 QBR
    Andy Dalton – 16 TDs 14 Int’s 59% completion pct. 3494 yds. 78.3 QBR.

    Dalton better than Dak?

    I don’t think so.
    ================================

    It should be pointed out that Dalton played for the Bengals for his entire career up to this point. So unless you think that both teams were stacked with similar amounts of talent, your comparison is meaningless.

  127. Dak played behind a great offensive line with a top 3 RB for his entire career. Compare that to the teams Dalton has played for. Dalton also played his college ball in Texas and lives there. My thinking is that Jerry is giving Dak until July to sign his tender before making a move. JJ has always wrapped up his QB’s to long-term deals before their deals have expired. Supposedly Dak turned down $33 per last September. If that isn’t enough for him then I don’t know what is. He just hasn’t played long enough to warrant getting Russell Wilson or Aaron Rodgers money. Not yet. Besides, $33 million with whatever the guaranteed money was should have been enough to get him in the fold. If I were JJ I would jettison Dak if he holds out, play AD and look for the heir apparent to groom for the future. Dak overplayed his hand. Did he actually expect Jerry to stand pat and let him dictate terms? If so then the young signal caller guessed wrong. After all of this I don’t see their relationship moving forward in any meaningful way. Dak’s tenure is Dallas will be tenuous at best. Jerry won’t forget this even if Dak comes to his senses and signs his franchise tender.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.