Nick Saban says Giants hired a “fantastic” coach in Joe Judge

Getty Images

Joe Judge spent three years as an assistant coach at Alabama, and his former boss thinks he’s the right fit for the Giants.

Alabama coach Nick Saban said the Giants got a good one in Judge, who parlayed his Alabama job into a job on Bill Belichick’s staff in New England, then became the Giants’ head coach thisyear.

When Joe was here, he was a young guy, very bright, enthusiastic, great teacher, really good relationships with the players, had lots of leadership qualities about him because of the example that he set and the energy and the enthusiasm he had on a daily basis,” Saban told Giants.com. “And he was really smart. He had a good understanding of football. So no surprise to me that Joe has gotten to this point in his career, and we certainly wish him well. He did a fantastic job here for us.”

The 38-year-old Judge hasn’t proven himself as a head coach yet, but after the Giants’ last two head coaches lasted only two years each, the Giants are hoping Saban is right about Judge.

26 responses to “Nick Saban says Giants hired a “fantastic” coach in Joe Judge

  1. No one knows what kind of HC Judge will be. Hell, I thought Dave Campo would be a terrific HC. And as much as I liked Campo, I was wrong. Bigley.

  2. Saban said the same thing about Freddie Kitchens after he was hired as a head coach in Cleveland. Look how that turned out.

  3. I often wondered if Saban had signed Brees in Miami, would Alabama have won any of those MNC’s?

  4. Nick was so successful as an NFL head coach, I’m sure he’s got this pegged.

  5. These guys always give us the happy talk about their former players, assistants, coaches, etc. What’s he gonna say? Joe Judge is a tool?

  6. With season tickets orders likely plummeting in the wake of the coronavirus, the Giants are pulling out all the stops to try to generate some enthusiasm for hiring a non-descript special teams coach as their HC. The hiring looks even worse when you consider their NFC East Rival Redskins hired Ron Rivera, a two time NFL coach of the year. One year after the Skins got budding superstar Dwayne Haskins while the Giants got stuck with Daniel Jones that has to hurt.

  7. I wonder why NFL teams eschew hiring people with talent and experience, and are always trying to hire the youngest new thing.
    Lane Kiffin, Zach Taylor, why?

  8. Decent hire. Better than another re-tread. Now if only the Giants would get a better GM and a better ownership group.

  9. With season tickets orders likely plummeting in the wake of the coronavirus, the Giants are pulling out all the stops to try to generate some enthusiasm for hiring a non-descript special teams coach as their HC. The hiring looks even worse when you consider their NFC East Rival Redskins hired Ron Rivera, a two time NFL coach of the year. One year after the Skins got budding superstar Dwayne Haskins while the Giants got stuck with Daniel Jones that has to hurt.
    ——————————————————————————————-
    lmao, you lost me at haskins as a budding superstar, thank you for that. haskins isnt fit to hold jones jock. compare the numbers idiot, it isnt even close. haskins will be a bust, and the redskins will still be irrelevant just like they have been the past 25 years. riviera changes none of that. great coach? apparently the panthers thought otherwise.

  10. @brian Hahn

    Hahahahahaha… You should be running for Congress with that kind of propaganda! Dwayne Haskins played so horribly that he can already be considered a bust. I mean, it’s really difficult for a QB to look THAT bad. Kid has no accuracy and no understanding of how to read defenses. Meanwhile Jones looks like a rising stud of a QB. Jones has things he needs to improve on as well, but it’s night and day when comparing the two.

  11. @ Brian Hahn

    Yeah, Rivera is a great coach. I remember him in the Superbowl watching Cam get his ass kicked play after play and not doing a damn thing.

  12. Nick Saban says Giants hired a “fantastic” coach in Joe Judge
    _____________________________

    Say’s the guy who couldn’t hack it in the NFL! Never take advice from someone that couldn’t do the job they’re commenting about, like Simms on rating QBs.

  13. As much hope as I have, I’m still skeptical of someone who hasn’t had any head coaching experience. Talk is cheap. I want results

  14. The Skins fans who think Haskins is a superstar thought RG3 was a HOFer. Saban and Belichick think Judge will be a successful hc, time will tell if they’re right.

  15. Im a Giants fan since 1979 and I have no clue about how good or bad Judge will be.

    What makes me laugh though is listening to armchair QB’s who talk nonsense about Saban, who is certainly one of the greatest college coaches who has ever lived.

  16. People are freakin’ out in Giantland because they have a second rate GM, a special teams coach who will be teaching PE in five years and a noodled arm quarterback who will be in the IBM junior executive program before you know it. Dwayne Haskins is better than Joe Burrow (beat him out of the starting job) and threw for 4,800 yards, 50 touchdowns and 8 interceptions at OSU. During his last four games of this past season, he was one of the highest ranked qbs in the league. Jones is a nice kid and means well. I wish him well at IBM (or wherever he ends up. But Dan obviously doesn’t have Dwayne’s elite arm talent and these franchises are headed in opposite directions. Look for Ron to win his third coach of year award en route to the Super Bowl as the Giants excel at after point blocking.

  17. arwiv says:
    What makes me laugh though is listening to armchair QB’s who talk nonsense about Saban, who is certainly one of the greatest college coaches who has ever lived.
    ==

    What does one have to with the other?
    He IS a great college coach. But he was an absolute flame-out bust in the NFL, and more than a few of his vaunted Alabama studs have not been all that in the NFL of late. Yet here he is, almost daily it seems, blowing smoke about how well his former players and coaches are going to do in the NFL.
    Just because Nick Saban knows what or WHO works at the college level doesn’t mean he knows jack about how they will transition to the pro game. HE certainly didn’t. THAT’s what people here are criticizing, not his college coaching skills.

  18. Overreacting a bit are we? What’s Savanna supposed to say? “This guy is an idiot and only got the job because they got him confused with an outfielder?” Maybe Judge is the guy, maybe he isn’t, but blasting his ex boss for saying what we all expect is stupid. Come on now.

  19. arwiv says:
    May 10, 2020 at 8:11 pm
    Im a Giants fan since 1979 and I have no clue about how good or bad Judge will be.

    What makes me laugh though is listening to armchair QB’s who talk nonsense about Saban, who is certainly one of the greatest college coaches who has ever lived.
    ___________________________________

    You’re right but the key word is: college. This is the pro’s we’re talking about here and Saban couldn’t handle the NFL!

  20. To be clear, College football is much closer to High School Football than the NFL.
    Watch something else.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.