Michigan won’t have football unless “all students” are back on campus

Getty Images

There’s been a sense in recent weeks that some college football programs will find a way around the “no college football without college” principle by having a flexible definition of what constitutes “college.”

At the University of Michigan, there apparently will be no such flexibility.

Michigan president Mark Schlissel tells the Wall Street Journal that the Wolverines won’t play this fall unless all students are back on campus for classes. Schlissel added that he has “some degree of doubt as to whether there will be college athletics [anywhere], at least in the fall.”

Many have no doubt that some schools will indeed have college football with open stadiums that are either partially or completely filled. Whether it’s anticipated advancements in testing and treatment or a growing desire by many to thrust society back toward normalcy despite the ongoing pandemic, plenty of schools will find a way to play, even if Michigan doesn’t.

Ultimately, it likely will be a school-by-school decision. And one of the major factors will be whether and to what extent the school believes it can get by without football revenue.

Sure, notions of what is and isn’t the “right thing to do” will be mentioned from time to time. But college football is a billion-dollar business, with the Power Five conferences reportedly set to lose $4 billion if there’s no season. That will in plenty of cases nudge the pendulum toward playing the season.

25 responses to “Michigan won’t have football unless “all students” are back on campus

  1. Gotta wonder if any of their players would try to transfer to another school that they knew would play, especially if it’s their last year of eligibility.

  2. Schools are profit-driven, that’s a fact. THAT is why schools are scrambling to get into COVID research, they know that there’s millions of dollars to be made.
    When schools don’t have football and have to cut faculty, staff, and athletic dept personnel, that will be an extremely bad optic for colleges.
    Therefore the schools WILL play football with or without students.

  3. College football provides revenue for student athletes in other sports. Without that money, there cannot be those sports.

    Michigan will have school, just like many campuses across the country. There is too much financial loss at stake for schools and communities if students are not present.

    Find solutions that work and get on with life. We cannot shelter in place forever for a vaccine that may never come anyhow.

  4. Chain Snatcher says:

    Gotta wonder if any of their players would try to transfer to another school that they knew would play, especially if it’s their last year of eligibility.
    ———–
    Doubtful. Transfer means sitting out for a season before they can play again unless they drop down a division so they won’t play anyway. The list of schools not playing at all is growing weekly and is probably not complete. Michigan is a big one but so are all of the State schools in California along with others. I even saw where some Div II schools have decided to end football altogether. With this happening, any decision to play is going to be impacted by revised or reduced schedules.

    To me the ability to rebuild a schedule on the fly to something equitable across all of FBS will be the biggest decision a school faces if they decide to play. Until decisions are made by all schools on what they intend to do makes that impossible and those decisions can’t be made until schools can completely grasp whether they can safely open campuses at all for fall classes.

    No matter what happens, for those wanting to move to the NFL, the NFL has to find some way they deem as fair to draft players from schools that opted to play with or without fans and those that did not play at all.

  5. pensfan1 says:
    May 24, 2020 at 1:16 pm
    Chain Snatcher says:

    Gotta wonder if any of their players would try to transfer to another school that they knew would play, especially if it’s their last year of eligibility.
    ———–
    Doubtful. Transfer means sitting out for a season before they can play again unless they drop down a division so they won’t play anyway.
    —————-
    Good point.

  6. Some of these college coaches are certainly in the ‘at risk’ category. There’s a scary thought.

  7. If any college plays football games while the college is closed, then the NCAA should finally admit it’s all about the money and at least let student athletes have endorsement deals.

  8. At first I was mourning the loss of the Ohio State Michigan game. Then I remembered that rivalry has ended.

  9. pygirl says:
    May 24, 2020 at 3:42 pm
    At first I was mourning the loss of the Ohio State Michigan game. Then I remembered that rivalry has ended.

    ——————
    Correct. The other team needs to win once in a while for it to be a rivalry

  10. Leave it up to their govenor they won’t open up any schools in MI. HOPE they don’t play can’t stand MICH. Anyways.

  11. What boggles my mind is why would there not be school/ Young kids are not being killed by this virus. Its like, if the Flu comes aroung all bets are off? This is May. A lof can happen between now and then. I agree, no fans in the stands whats the point but otherwise, school should open and kids should get on with their life.

  12. No one ever asked Americans to shelter in place or wear masks forever – just long enough to “flatten the curve” to keep health care facilities from being overrun – like happened in New York; and keep the thing from spreading through casual contact. You don’t want to wear a mask? then stay a few feet away from me. Is that too much to ask? is that somehow “UnAmerican”. I guarantee nothing in the Constitution gives you the right to get in my face and spread a deadly virus.
    We also need more time to find an effective vaccine and drugs to treat those that are sick. There seems to be some progress on both fronts, but probably not in time for this year. Is it “UAmerican” to ask people to forgo sports for one year to keep tens of thousand of Americans alive?
    Revenue loss for one year isn’t going to close down legitimate schools. As far as other sports being hurt – no one’s going to be playing them either so no loss there.
    One year of sports to literally save tens of thousands of lives – that’s too much a sacrifice for you?
    What a bunch of spoiled rotten, self centered jerks. (You deserve much stronger language but it’s not allowed here. I won’t go into why that’s “unconstitutional”)
    No wonder this country’s going to hell

  13. “Young kids are not being killed by this virus.”

    There are bizarre side effects such as covid toe effecting young children. Some portion of children are obese, one of the three main vulnerabilities the virus jumps on. Even if they don’t get very sick or remain asymptomatic they will spread it to their parents, grandparents, etc.

    Its sick that so many people seem willing to sacrifice 10s of thousands of obese people, people with diabetes, elderly and other vulnerable people. Americans used to be tough enough to finish the job, now so many who claim to be so tough can’t even tolerate wearing a mask for a few minutes they’re so weak.

  14. Ima Payne says:
    May 24, 2020 at 5:12 pm
    What boggles my mind is why would there not be school/ Young kids are not being killed by this virus. Its like, if the Flu comes aroung all bets are off?

    *************************************************************************************

    First, if you think younger populations aren’t at risk, you’re wrong. Risk is lower for younger people, but there is still risk — particularly for those with complicating health factors.

    Second, if there’s a great environment for spreading COVID-19, it’s college campuses. Outbreaks for other diseases (flu, meningitidis, mumps) at colleges aren’t uncommon at all. People talk about social distancing in classes and cafeterias. That’s great, but just as big a risk is what goes on outside college buildings — tailgating, parties, clubs/bars (if they’re open). Even if school presidents ban tailgating or parties, do you actually think 18/19/20 year olds are going to conform? Not happening. If colleges go back to “business as usual,” it’ll spread like it does in city jails.

  15. With the Governor they have in Michigan I wouldn’t count on football. She’s got half the state curled up in the fetal position hiding in their basement. I’m sure Harbaugh is one of them

  16. stexan says:
    May 24, 2020 at 5:17 pm

    What a bunch of spoiled rotten, self centered jerks. (You deserve much stronger language but it’s not allowed here. I won’t go into why that’s “unconstitutional”)
    No wonder this country’s going to hell

    ———————–

    What a bunch of self-righteous drivel. People are losing jobs, health insurance and retirement due to selfish fear mongers like you fueling the fire to keep everyone locked up. Can you pay everyone’s mortgage for them? Can you guarantee they won’t be thrown out of their houses for missing payments? You are the selfish one.

  17. No one is recommending people be “locked up” (your words not mine). No one is recommending people should stay home forever – open up responsibly. But shoehorning 80,000 college football fans into a stadium with no cure and no vaccine is about as far from responsible as I can think.
    Plenty of economic damage alright, and more to come. But the virus is ultimately to blame – not those who want to protect themselves and others from it.
    100,000 Americans dead in less than three months. In part due to people who refuse to believe it’s real and others who just want to “get on with life”. Those 100,000 Americans don’t have that option.

  18. The state of Michigan has moved from “stay home to slow the spread” to “stay home to flatten the curve” to “stay home until there’s a cure”. If the governor in Michigan can, she will not allow school of any kind in the fall. There won’t be college or high school football in Michigan. The Lions might have to play in another state this year. I am sure the governor of Michigan will move the goal posts again in the future. She has done that several times already. It is time to move on from most of the virus restrictions in this country. We are almost to the point of no return on the economy. Tens of millions will starve to death across the globe if we don’t right the ship soon.

  19. Chain Snatcher says:
    May 24, 2020 at 12:05 pm
    Gotta wonder if any of their players would try to transfer to another school that they knew would play, especially if it’s their last year of eligibility.
    ————————————————————
    It would be pointless in most cases. If you try to transfer without the blessing of you coach and/or school, you have to sit out a season. Just one more way in which the college system screws over student athletes. I remember cases where a player went to a university specifically because a particular coach recruited them, only to have that coach take a job at another college before the season started. So, the student was stuck there, while the coach was free to move about at will.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.