Voluntary bubbles could be the key to minimizing virus transmission

Getty Images

NFL teams have, technically, a “virtual bubble” around each practice facility. But the bubble bursts each night, as players and coaches go home.

Coupled with testing that has a 24-hour turnaround, the ability of players to go home (and potentially catch the virus from a family member, even if the player himself doesn’t go anywhere) creates a real risk of an outbreak. An easy way to limit that risk is to harden the bubble, putting players, coaches, and other essential staff in a hotel.

That issue has been discussed in recent days from the perspective of whether the league should mandate a harder bubble. Apparently, however, there’s another way to skin the cat: Set up a voluntary bubble.

You know, voluntary. Like voluntary workouts. Voluntary, as in not really voluntary.

That’s exactly what the Saints are doing during camp. According to the NFL, nothing prohibits it, because the Saints aren’t mandating it. It’s voluntary.

So why isn’t every team doing it during training camp? Those that do it likely will have fewer outbreaks, and in turn will have a team that is more prepared for the regular season.

As to the regular season, why not continue the voluntary bubble? If the coaches are doing it and the executives are doing it and the team leaders are doing it, everyone else will fall in line. Really, who wants to be the one who’s going home at night and showing up the next day to interact with teammates who are sacrificing family time to remain sequestered? Whether side eye or stink eye or evil eye or some combination of the three, the player who doesn’t go along will have a hard time getting along.

That’s not to say that squeezing a player to choose living with the team over living with his family is right or wrong. But the reality is that teams can set up a voluntary bubble, and that the teams that are the most effective at getting everyone to volunteer will likely do a better job of keeping their players available to play. Which will in turn give them a better chance to win.

32 responses to “Voluntary bubbles could be the key to minimizing virus transmission

  1. Why not do it? Because you’re asking guys to give up family life, that’s why. I’m already uncomfortable enough with wanting these guys to risk their health and even their lives for our entertainment. It’s too much to ask that they should also live for nothing but our entertainment.

    Don’t forget, too, that while baseball, basketball and hockey have multiple games per week, in football you play only once a week. No matter how much training and practice there is, it’s a whole different life from those other sports and a whole different feel if you don’t get to go home to your family during the week.

  2. Ya don’t say?!!!

    All you can do is shake your head. The NFL played fhe Trump card (pun intended) for greed, and they got caught.

    No season.

  3. This will be a bigger disaster than baseball, which is a socially distanced sport. Can’t wait for the mess!

  4. remizak says:
    I’m already uncomfortable enough with wanting these guys to risk their health and even their lives for our entertainment
    ==

    I’m growing weary of reading that sentiment.
    For the record, I think the safe and smart thing to do is shut the whole thing down and send everyone home right now. Nobody plays, nobody is at risk.
    That said, players have had, and for a short while longer will still have the ability to opt out if they’re worried about their safety. Make no mistake about it: Those who have decided to play are doing it for a large PAYCHECK, not out of some sense they need to entertain you or I. A great many of these players quit caring about the fans long ago, if they ever did. Any that have decided to play have done so for their own personal interests.
    As for “being away from their families,” it’s somewhat hypocritical to voluntarily decide to play, complain constantly about your safety, then reject every safety issue that comes down the pike — especially ones that would have the best chance to protect the player and his family.

  5. NFL players already struggle to follow protocol both on and off the field with no pandemic. This season is a recipe for disaster!

  6. touchback6 says:

    August 4, 2020 at 5:47 pm

    Ya don’t say?!!!

    All you can do is shake your head. The NFL played fhe Trump card (pun intended) for greed, and they got caught.

    No season.
    ———-
    I can almost guarantee that if/when there is a season, after you have continually posted on every post claiming no season, you will be no where to be found and will be on to your next burner account.

  7. “Voluntary”?
    Those players won’t be the problem?
    This is just insane.
    Everyone or none is the only way to solve this.

  8. Impractical suggestions don’t help find practical solutions. A season-long bubble has certainly been offered ( and rejected) as a potential option during NFL/NFLPA negotiations. If COVID19 risks are truly taken seriously, and schools and businesses are closed over health concerns, then why are team sports not just eliminated during 2020? It would require state and city governments, team owners, leagues, and players, etc. to stop squabbling and be realistic about protecting public and family health. Do prudent people really expect sports leagues can safely operate during a pandemic, or is it just $$$$ wishful thinking?

  9. Sounds like you really want football.

    From writing against voluntary workouts and it’s devastating effects on the little men who needs 5 months off uninterrupted by team’s asking them to sacrifice a couple weeks of that time for the team…..to now asking them to give up family for 4 months voluntarily.

    You really want this season.

  10. Here’s a crazy idea – how about players refrain from being stupid and not go to strip clubs like Lou Williams. How about you go home and stay home after work like a responsible adult and you won’t get covid out in the wild.

  11. ramsfandango says:

    August 4, 2020 at 6:38 pm

    “…Do prudent people really expect sports leagues can safely operate during a pandemic, or is it just $$$$ wishful thinking?”
    ——-
    The NBA and it’s working bubble says hi

  12. I would imagine that the NFL has forgotten about the little kneeling problem they may have with all this covid stuff.

  13. wutangisforthechildren30 says:
    August 4, 2020 at 7:05 pm
    Here’s a crazy idea – how about players refrain from being stupid and not go to strip clubs like Lou Williams. How about you go home and stay home after work like a responsible adult and you won’t get covid out in the wild.

    Yes that is crazy. Are you 21 years old? Do you have 5 million dollars? 1165 of the 1200 will stay home. 35 will party. That’s the way it will be. So don’t act surprised.

  14. meanwhile in other news… ratings for the pro sports that have resumed play have plummeted. They’re getting what they deserve.

  15. Perhaps a team would be smart, since eventually everyone is going to catch it, to have their players exposed to Covid now? Quarantine them as a group when they are positive (in a bubble) and then when the season starts their players would now have natural immunity and not have to worry about a star player being out for several games, while other teams are fighting to fill their rosters each week?

  16. Voluntary Bubbles? No player is going to confine themself to a bubble, unless the strip club is included in the bubble…

  17. Fill the stadiums to double capacity with anti-maskers sitting on each other’s laps, then wait two weeks. Win-win.

  18. Wonder why the NHL is doing so well under “closed doors?”

    Maybe all those power house leagues should learn by trade. The NHL is going to survive. Wish other leagues followed suit and kept politics OUT of sports

  19. glac1 says: “meanwhile in other news… ratings for the pro sports that have resumed play have plummeted. They’re getting what they deserve.”
    ———————-

    WHAT ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT??

    According to TNT and ABC, the restart NBA games are DOUBLING the average viewership pre-shutdown. And the NY Yankees/Washington Nationals telecast drew ESPN’s LARGEST opening-night audience EVER.

    Even post-game shows like Inside The NBA is DOUBLING its season average with 1.29 million viewers.

    YIKES.

  20. The NFL is a microcosm of America. Some teams/ people understand the problem, some don’t.

    Payton, having had the CCP virus already knows how bad it is, he has learnt.

    I live in a country where we eliminated the virus over 100 days ago. Until America decides to do the same thing a bubble is the best you can do. But a bubble is only as strong as its’ edges.

    PS- Lotta fake football fans posting here. Why would a fan not want the season to happen?

    If everyone in America did what the Saints are doing the pandemic would be contained in 2-3 weeks. Please do it.

  21. Mike Florio,
    There is a new technology out in the hospital world called LifeAire – check out LifeAire.com and the company can clean air to 99.99% clean – imagine NFL locker rooms and training rooms with clean air and indoor practice facilities Covid Air FREE! Yes the new company bid on providing hospital clean air to the Javits Center in NY when they were setting the facility to be a pop-up hospital. The LifeAire unit fits between the air conditioning unit and the exit flow of the air – killing bacteria, viruses and even Anthrax the smallest of the airborne molecules. LifeAire cleans and kills the VOCs, Bacteria, Virus, etc. KILLS it does not filter – Kills and cleans the air. Used in hospital ICU units – let’s adapt this to football, ice hockey and basketball facilities plus MLB locker rooms. It is just a calculation of cubic volume of air – the units can be manufactured and install then you can be playing in a clean air environment. The technology works – the company is in the Lehigh Valley! This is a start-up company with clinical studies to proved the air is 99.99% clean and the system is patented! Someone please listen!

  22. Sunday Swami says:
    August 4, 2020 at 6:26 pm
    touchback6 says:

    August 4, 2020 at 5:47 pm

    Ya don’t say?!!!

    All you can do is shake your head. The NFL played fhe Trump card (pun intended) for greed, and they got caught.

    No season.
    ———-
    I can almost guarantee that if/when there is a season, after you have continually posted on every post claiming no season, you will be no where to be found and will be on to your next burner account.

    26 6 Rate This

    ——————-

    I don’t use burner accounts.

    You’d have to be a moron to think there can be a fully operational 16 game season at this point.

    There are only two leagues following a bubble format and they are working. The NFL has arrogantly followed Trump’s lead which is so very obviously the wrong lead to follow.

    The Canadians are smarter and the NHL is smarter. Get it?

    MLB has had outbreaks and they were the most viable sport through a Covid19 pandemic based on how the sport is played, and they too think they’re above it. Greed kills.

    Do you watch the news or just listen to Trump? We’re not even through the first wave of this pandemic. Football is played in the fall
    and winter and second wave will be worse than this because we have a moron as president who only care about his bank account and ego. Sound familiar?

    You can either live in a world of a child and delusion or understand science and reality.

    Lemme guess, you believe in the Easter Bunny, believe Goodell, and think Trump is a smart guy, huh?

    lol

    The players in this league can’t even spend one weekend out of the headlines, yet 50+ players on 32 teams are supposed to never come in contact with the virus, huh? Try a basic math class at the community college over Zoom.

  23. scouseyank says:
    August 4, 2020 at 7:33 pm
    Perhaps a team would be smart, since eventually everyone is going to catch it, to have their players exposed to Covid now?

    ———————-
    That’s herd immunity. it only works if you can’t catch it a second time. This isn’t one of those viruses- the antibodies in your blood only last a couple of months, maybe less. Then you can catch it again. And again. And again.

  24. stellarperformance says:
    August 4, 2020 at 8:12 pm
    Fill the stadiums to double capacity with anti-maskers sitting on each other’s laps, then wait two weeks. Win-win.

    3 0

    ————-

    lol!!

    That and offer them all a Walmart gift card and a free Bill Burr cruise out of all ports in Florida, just in case your idea doesn’t work so well.

  25. brickfinger says:
    August 4, 2020 at 8:41 pm
    scouseyank says:
    August 4, 2020 at 7:33 pm
    Perhaps a team would be smart, since eventually everyone is going to catch it, to have their players exposed to Covid now?

    ———————-
    That’s herd immunity. it only works if you can’t catch it a second time. This isn’t one of those viruses- the antibodies in your blood only last a couple of months, maybe less. Then you can catch it again. And again. And again.

    2 0 Rate This

    —————

    The Trumpy bozos, science-deniers and those that believe everything Goodell says and does they live their parents’ basement in their 20s, never having left home, as know it alls, are completely clueless about this pandemic. They won’t accept it like a little child unwilling to
    accept the first day of school is tomorrow, not 3 months away. They pull the covers over their heads and stick their fingers in their ears. Rinse and repeat.

  26. tpoatsy says:
    August 4, 2020 at 8:38 pm

    LifeAire cleans and kills the VOCs, Bacteria, Virus, etc. KILLS it does not filter – Kills and cleans the air. Used in hospital ICU units – let’s adapt this to football, ice hockey and basketball facilities

    —————————————-

    Does this product kill COVID-19?
    Because if this company has figured out how to kill COVID-19 then why are we even having this conversation?

  27. I think there really could be a season if teams did this and just bubbled themselves. And we can’t sit back and feel bad that they will be apart from their families for a few months. Boo hoo. They have had the last 5 months to spend all day every day with them. And as a Veteran, I have spent up to 15 months away from my family at once. I’m sure the millions of dollars help those families deal with it for a few months.

  28. Millions of people are going to work every single day, returning home every single night, and aren’t part of outbreaks. You don’t need to say goodbye to your family for months or live in a bubble. You just need to social distance, wear a mask, wash your hands, and follow the regular protocol.

  29. remizak says:
    August 4, 2020 at 5:46 pm
    Why not do it? Because you’re asking guys to give up family life, that’s why.

    —–

    We ask our kids in the military to do this on a regular basis…..and for a pittance compared to these players.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.