Kyle Shanahan: “Constant noise” is “form of human torture”

Getty Images

49ers coach Kyle Shanahan recently referred to the constant, steady wall of artificial noise at games played in empty stadiums are a “form of human torture.” He elaborated on that position during a Wednesday session with reporters.

“I think it’ll be a huge adjustment for everyone out there,” Shanahan told reporters. “You don’t realize just what constant noise is like. It’s not about being loud or too low. It’s about just constant. I mean, usually when the play starts, you get to hear the pop and you get to hear football. When things aren’t going on, you can have conversations with people and stuff.

“So just the constant noise, it’s a little tough to deal with, but fans won’t be having to deal with it. That’ll just be us. So hopefully we can make sure that doesn’t affect our game, which it shouldn’t. It’s more about just the irritation of it and you embrace it and realize that that can’t affect you unless you let it affect you and you just go back to playing football.”

The fake noise in empty stadiums will be in the range of 70 to 75 decibels. But it never takes a break, like the vuvuzelas that simulated the sound of a billion mating locusts during the 2010 World Cup. It will be a constant irritant, and the players and coaches and others in the stadium may never get used to it.

10 responses to “Kyle Shanahan: “Constant noise” is “form of human torture”

  1. Why are they introducing this mess? Stop acting like you have to replace everything. It will be different, that won’t change. I would rather get more of the sound of the pads hitting than have speakers hissing incoherently. Who thinks that is a good idea? I might even get cable again if they would give me a PPV with all the sounds on the field.

  2. After the last several seasons I’ve noticed the NFL has been really focused on the field and players with their microphones. You know the crack of pads and at times the occasional swearing and stuff, while filtering fan noise. I get way more excited with fan noise even if this season it might or will be fake.

  3. Fake noise is an absolutely idiotic idea. It’s offensive to me as a sports fan and really, as a functioning adult human being.

    Show us what’s really happening. It’s the tradition of sports broadcasting. It’s a live event that they’re showing us footage of.

    Faking is just dumb and turns the experience into a farce.

  4. Are we supposed to feel sorry for them? I work all day with constant noise… give me a break.

  5. Is there not a knob for volume control? Why not fade and lower sound to match the natural ebb of loudness by a real crowd?

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.