Texans’ Josh McCown interview makes mockery of process

USA TODAY Sports

Josh McCown is a great player and a great person, one of the most underrated quarterbacks of the past generation. But McCown should not be considered for a head-coaching position in the NFL. Not yet.

Maybe in time he’ll become a head coach, and maybe he’ll be a great one. Maybe he’ll win Super Bowls. Maybe there eventually will be a bronze bust in the Hall of Fame that looks conspicuously like Dolph Lundgren.

That doesn’t mean that the Texans or anyone else should interview someone with no coaching experience to be an NFL head coach. And it reveals a stunning lack of self-awareness by the Texans, a franchise that has become regarded as the most dysfunctional in football.

Or maybe the Texans are fully aware, and maybe they’ve extended a middle finger to anyone who would say that Jack Easterby isn’t qualified to serve as executive V.P. of football operations and/or that Easterby has owner Cal McNair somewhere between bamboozled and hypnotized. It’s fitting, frankly, that a team with a grossly unfit executive V.P. of football operations would consider a grossly unprepared candidate for coach.

Easterby is so far over his skis that he thinks he’s learned to fly. But the only opinion that matters belongs to McNair, who seems to think Easterby is soaring like an eagle.

In this specific case, the decision to consider McCown for a head-coaching job with no coaching experience becomes an affront to all qualified candidates, regardless of race. And, please, don’t play the “he did coaching as a quarterback” card. All quarterbacks worth their cleats do coaching. Does that mean Philip Rivers, who’ll coach high-school football now that he has retired, should have been interviewed by the Chargers?

Does that mean anyone instantly will be offering head-coaching jobs to Drew Brees or Tom Brady or Aaron Rodgers as their playing careers end?

In a cycle that has seen five of six head-coaching jobs go to white candidates and no Black coaches hired, the ultimate indignity has come from the Texans, who have interviewed — and by all appearances are considering — making Josh McCown the head coach without ever working as a coach at the college or NFL level.

139 responses to “Texans’ Josh McCown interview makes mockery of process

  1. “Josh mccown is a great player…” …..stopped reading right there.

  2. the press said similar about joe torres when he got the yankees managers job. he did ok.

  3. It’s a copycat league. I’m sure the Texans would like it if the league followed them for once. LoL

  4. Wow, this has got to make JJ and Watson thrilled. Talk about throwing away careers with a joke of an organization. Be careful McNair you are starting to get into Jerruh and Snyder levels of incompetence

  5. John Lynch had no GM experience and he put together a front office and coaching staffs that quickly made them competitive and get to the super bowl.

    I have no problem with teams thinking out of the box, particularly when it’s someone of McCown’s caliber

    I’m rooting for him!

  6. Looks like the heir apparent for the Browns crown for worse team in NFL. Jets close 2nd.

  7. To be fair- I’m a huge chiefs fan and love Bieniemy. I’m also frustrated and confused why he hasn’t landed a HC gig. My above point still stands.

  8. I didn’t find anything wrong with McCown getting just an interview. Maybe they know they have an immature but talented QB that needed a career QB mentor.

  9. Please let this happen! Now with Gase gone we need a new grossly underqualified coach to make fun of! (And the Vikings need Dashaun Watson).

  10. Does that mean anyone instantly will be offering head-coaching jobs to Drew Brees or Tom Brady or Aaron Rodgers as their playing careers end?
    __________________________________

    That would require actual work and dedication, which is why you never see star QBs like those guys ending up as head coaches, but you see career backups like Pederson, Kubiak, and Reich and likely McCown one day as head coaches.

  11. C’mon, you can’t say he Josh McCown has no experience in the area of football decision making.
    After all, he did coaching as a quarterback.

    Hey….hey..did you see what I did up there.
    I played that card.

  12. its a ridiculous move and to agree with it is simply to be contrarian to the article. the only, and i mean only reason for this wouldve been to expose mccown to the interview process for later in his coaching career. but even then, you dont advertise, or you explain thats what it was

  13. Give Easterby a break. He is probably really busy making up new false and phony items to put on his resume.

  14. “Maybe in time he’ll become a head coach, and maybe he’ll be a great one. Maybe he’ll win Super Bowls. Maybe there eventually will be a bronze bust in the Hall of Fame that looks conspicuously like Dolph Lundgren.”

    If any of that comes true then wouldn’t the Texans be geniuses for hiring him?

  15. As a Charger’s fan, I’m offended by this article. Everyone knows our organization is the most dysfunctional in all of professional sports. Let’s keep it real folks. The Texans are a distant second.

  16. Why can’t it be as simple as the Texans letting him interview for the experience? Maybe they just did him a favor. It is definitely not as big of a deal as made out in this article.

  17. Chiefs fan in LA says:
    January 22, 2021 at 7:24 pm

    the press said similar about joe torres when he got the yankees managers job. he did ok.

    ———–===============———-

    Joe Torre had 14 years experience as a manager when the Yankees hired him.

  18. In this specific case, the decision to consider McCown for a head-coaching job with no coaching experience becomes an affront to all qualified candidates, regardless of race. And, please, don’t play the “he did coaching as a quarterback” card. Interesting race and card arent far apart in your statement ?

  19. McCown shouldn’t be considered a HC candidate yet. However, let’s not go overboard about the lack of black HCs getting hired. I support diversity too and I feel like Bieniemy would be a great HC, but sometimes, it depends on who all is out there.

  20. For anyone mocking Josh McCown as a player, the dude played in the NFL for 17 years. Started 76 games at quarterback. Passed for 17k yards and 98 TDs. Rushed for 1100 yards and 13 more TDs. Always carried the respect of his teammates and peers. He is also 6′ 4″ and made a cool $48m in his career. If you want to call him a loser then you better have done some pretty impressive things with your life.

  21. Who cares who they hire??? The wokesters are losing their minds, the rest of us are amused.

  22. I’m just saying. There is a valid reason that Deshaun Watson wants to leave Houston and salvage his career before it’s too late.

  23. And I thought my teams owner and management were dysfunctional.
    They may as well trade Deshaun Watson and become an expansion team.

  24. We’re 2 weeks into 2021 and we already have racist accusations being thrown around because Bieniemy isn’t a HC, the Texans hired the GM they’ve been trying to hire for 2 years, and Dan Campbell said something about knee caps. Stop it.

  25. Chiefs fan in LA says:
    January 22, 2021 at 7:24 pm

    the press said similar about joe torres when he got the yankees managers job. he did ok.

    ———————-

    Joe Torre had 12 years as a major league manager before getting the Yankees job. 😉

  26. I was going to agree but the NFL needs new faces. That’s why I applaud the Jags on picking Meyer. And same with Saleh and the chargers with their HC.
    We’ve already seen what Rex Ryan, Hue Jackson, Raheem.Morris and others can do. NFL needs fresh faces

  27. It’s all good. It’s a shame they already filled the GM spot, he probably would want that roll as well.

  28. Why does no one ever bring up Eric Bieniemy‘s very troubled legal past? It’s absolutely a concern.

  29. A guy that actually ran plays and probably diagnosed plays at the line of scrimmage seems like an improvement to me. Some of these hires seem way off base (to me).

  30. Lost me with the race stuff but of all the potential hires, white or black, former players with no head coaching experience, how we would end up at Josh McCown is just insanity. Any comment on doing him a solid for experience makes no sense. He can be a QC coach for some experience. With the spotlight being on them already it highlights exactly why they are in the spotlight with a head scratching idea like this one.

  31. And Mike Brown is thinking “that’s the ticket “, I’ll make Joe Burrow player/head coach and save a bundle!!

  32. The NFL will never let them hire Bieniemy as a HC, hes a wife beater… We all know the image they try to portray even when its a fake. This interview is reason enough for houston go take over title of largest dumpster fire!

  33. If this was my workplace, and I saw someone with Zero relevant experience being considered for a job that is pivotal to whether the organization will succeed or fail … I would be angry too! Especially with the track record the Texans have…
    Now Josh could turn out to be a real inspired HC choice (maybe the second coming of Bill Belichick), but c’mon, do you really expect the Texans to be right?

  34. The ONLY criteria for hiring a HC or any other coaching or front office position should be his qualifications! Period! Not his age, his past experience, or the color of his skin or his ethnicity.

  35. This is an 11/10 reaction for what should barely garner a 1. It is just an interview, no one should honestly believe that a guy with 0 coaching experience is gonna become an HC. Calm down.

  36. Bad teams stink for a reason. And usually the reason owns the team. Houston, J-E-T-S, Jax, all terrible owners and teams. But nobody, I mean nobody, holds a candle to Danny Snyder and his Football Team. They are so freaking bad they can’t even have a name. Nobody does it worser. Makes me feel sad for the rest.

  37. “Does that mean Philip Rivers, who’ll coach high-school football now that he has retired, should have been interviewed by the Chargers?

    Does that mean anyone instantly will be offering head-coaching jobs to Drew Brees or Tom Brady or Aaron Rodgers as their playing careers end?”

    John Elway skipped coaching and went straight to running whole operation. Outside of having a smarter horse than him play QB for a couple years, Elway has made all kinds of goofy personnel decisions and is totally out of his depth wandering without supervision across the battlefield of current near-TMZ-worthy ownership lawfare.

    Broncos a good example that a good team starts with the owner. And ends with said owner as well. No way around it.

  38. Houston You Have a PROBLEM !!!! and they are many …..

    This speaks volumes of your football team !!!

    Elite Quarterback and your going screw it up !!!!!!

  39. stoneydog1000 says:
    January 22, 2021 at 8:33 pm
    And Mike Brown is thinking “that’s the ticket “, I’ll make Joe Burrow player/head coach and save a bundle!!
    ***************************
    That’s funnier than hell. But don’t give him any ideas. Lol

  40. Some reporters have said for some time the owner is intimidated by the front office and cows down to whatever Easterby wants to do. It’s always said briefly in radio interviews etc cuz no one will come out and put their name on it. But the owner is intimidated, that much is clear, even though people in the know are keeping it under their hat.

  41. It’s just an interview. Very low chance he’s in any way being considered right now. Much more likely they have just identified him as a promising future candidate and want to get an early read on him for future reference. “Ultimate indignity” seems like hyperbole.

    While I’m surprised in a way that no black coaches have been hired so far this go-round, and some of the hires so far have been puzzling, it’s also not shocking. The leading candidates are mostly known quantities who didn’t excel when they got prior HC chances. There are others in the pipeline who will get their shots with a little more experience. Wouldn’t surprise me if Leftwich is next up.

  42. I remember when the Ravens hired Harbaugh and people flipped because he was a Special Teams Coordinator. Got a SB and a consistent team since then. Philly and the Rams hired dudes that casters had to pretend that they heard of. Campbell is up in Detroit talking like the Juggernaut. Nothing wrong with them interviewing a guy that from every teammate and coach interviewed about him, raved about as a pro, mentor, human and savvy football guy. I can’t figure out as to why no one on the broadcast or blog circuit has asked why Bieniemy has been passed by for three years. After Campbell eating kneecaps, I doubt it’s because of interviewing. Something in his known and private history has made him radioactive. I’d stop stumping for him until he opens up.

  43. Your rationale and reaction is idiotic as per usual Florio. Why is thinking outside of the norm a bad thing? Caldwell has been a head coach, has been fired more than once because he didn’t do a good job as a head coach, and now it’s a bad thing to interview a guy who has been in the huddle with a team and has been on a football field more than a day or two somehow is considered a negative thing. I would say to keep bringing back the same coaches to let them fail over and over wasting everyone’s time is a bad thing. Screw the “good ol’ boy” club. I would ask, what makes Urban Meyer a good choice, but McCown not? Meyer got a chance with no experience. Why should a repeat failure like McCarthy get multiple chances while McCown can’t get a single shot? Are you afraid that McCown may have some success which makes the NFL coaches clique look incompetent? I would take a new face over a repeated failure any day, if anything for experimentation purposes.

  44. How does playing in the league qualify you to be a coach? How many years did Bill Belichick play? Playing and coaching are two different skill sets.

  45. Maybe they’re trying to appease whatever wishes Watson has to try and keep him, and he’s just messing with them. “Yeah I think McCown would be a great coach, and you should look at Fireman Ed next!”

  46. From all I’ve read about Easterby, he sounds like a narcissit (a person who has an excessive interest in or admiration of themselves.)
    I’ve known guys like him…they smooth-talk everyone around them isolating them into their tidy little circle of control. In the process they make themselves appear to be an expert on everything while, in reality, they’re far from it. Intelligent, yes, but only at getting others to do for them what they can’t do for themselves. As Florio put it, he’s over his skis, and the mess will get worse and worse for the Texans as long as this ‘pretender’ is running that show. Once he’s out they’ll all see it. Until then the Texans will just circle the drain.

  47. Did they label it an interview for the HC position? Or was it them talking to him ABOUT the HC position? For all anyone knows they could be asking a guy who’s played 17 years in the league to give feedback on which coaches he thinks are most effective and why? A guy who’s been on 12 different rosters for various lengths of time can probably give some pretty insightful thoughts on the matter.

  48. Only one qualification to be an NFL head coach and that is to be who the owner wants. nothing else matters

  49. Boston Celtics Bill Russell might strongly disagree with you PFT. As player/coach Russell coached the Celtics to two world championships in 68 & 69. He had no prior coaching experience.

    You have no idea what McCown knows about football. He may know a heck of a lot more than some head coachs out there now but don’t make light of the idea of someone doing it just because it’s a first for the NFL.

  50. You’ve all heard how Josh is brought in to be another coach on the field from team to team with a young inexperienced qb. What’s the difference with him being the head coach.I’m sure he relates to most players better than some of these recent coaches and qb whisperers like Adam Gase.

  51. It’s no more of a mockery than interviewing a guy that’s been repeatedly fired and has a losing record….which seems to happen every single year.

  52. Or maybe you shouldn’t be speculating on things you know nothing about like coaching football. If your point is he has no experience being a coach, then you have no experience being a GM or owner choosing said coach. Sometimes big ideas that pay off are those that everyone laughed at originally.

  53. So people knock Bienemy saying he doesn’t call the plays. But let’s look at people with no coaching experience, losing coaching experience, let’s hire a special teams coach like Joe Judge (how many offensive plays did he call), let’s talk to position coaches.

  54. At some point everyone has gotten a job because the employer decided to take a leap of faith. There were more qualified candidates, people who had achieved more, but you got the job because they saw something in you.

    It is not offensive or racist to hire a candidate that was a position coach or a special teams coach if the employer thinks they can make it at the next level. Outside the box thinking works in all professions, but especially football.

  55. He has a point, it’s crazy to think of guys like Eric Bienemy & Duce Staley not getting HC offers but Josh McCown, who I REALLY like, getting one first. They might as well abolish the Rooney rule, it’s a joke. The NFL has a responsibility to get more black HC in the league. How can a league be 70% black & the coaching ranks be like 10-15%? (don’t quote me on that number being exact)
    It just doesn’t add up when so many coaches are former players & if you think it does, you’re out of your mind & probably a bigot.

  56. A creative and brilliant football mind should be passed over by a more experienced candidate that has had a mediocre career?

  57. yinzerssuck says:
    January 22, 2021 at 7:27 pm

    Wow, this has got to make JJ and Watson thrilled. Talk about throwing away careers with a joke of an organization. Be careful McNair you are starting to get into Jerruh and Snyder levels of incompetence

    ———–

    I think McNair has already passed those levels. It’s awe-inspiring in a way…

  58. It’s not uncommon to conduct courtesy interviews of staff members — I recall it happening several times with my team. Many former players dot the staffs across the league. There is no conspiracy or sinister plot here.

    Unless Cal loses it completely, they will soon hire/already agreed with Bienemy and Watson starts for the SAME team next year as this.

  59. Most people who own a business don’t like to be told who to hire or how to run it. If people don’t like a product they simply don’t buy or support it. If houston fans aren’t happy they don’t have to support the team. Seems pretty simple but there is always someone sticking there nose where it doesn’t belong.

  60. My first thought was Caserio is doing Josh a favor and boosting his name for when he eventually is a realistic option. Also giving him some valuable experience interviewing. Teams have done stuff like this for years. But in this cycle with this team? How many own goals can they score?

  61. Who’s to say whether he’d pan out as a head coach. He may the next one mentioned on the “Mt. Rushmore” of coaches for all I know.

    But I do know one thing: Houston has reached levels of dysfunction that make Jerry Jones look level headed.

  62. Complain all you want, he would be better than Bill O’Brien or six other current coaches.

  63. They are clearly toying with Deshaun Watson. They ask him for his opinion, then completely ignore what he has to say. Then when it seems all is lost, they seemingly come to their senses and interview the guy Watson wanted in the first place, only to turn around and interview a white QB with no coaching experience. They are hearing what they could get for Watson and poking him to demand a trade so they come out looking like they had no choice and rake in the haul and unload an expensive loudmouth who would have always insisted on his way or threaten to demand a trade.

  64. John Elway had no front office experience and yet he put together a Superbowl Champion team. McCown has been around man coaches, so there is nothing wrong with interviewing him.

  65. ladymacesq says:
    January 23, 2021 at 12:14 am
    Praying Daniel Snyder doesn’t get wind of this and say ‘hold my beer’.

    Snyder did when he hired Mayhew. Or are we not allowed to address his awful record as Detroit’s GM? Ebron over Aaron Donald is just the tip of the poo show iceberg Mayhew led in Detroit.

  66. Watson I wanted them to interview him? Besides. Interviews do not equate to hiring. In fact, he likely was also being considered for OC & QB Coaching positions. I’m going to have to go back & check how much angst was shown when the Raiders hired their latest GM? He had no experience in front office management, either. Wasn’t Peyton Manning offered a coaching position? Even front office positions, if I recall. When that was brought up, was the establishment spouting how bad that move is, just to be considered?

  67. In fairness, the Eagles wanted Josh McCown to be their offensive coordinator last year so it’s not like no one has ever considered him for a senior coaching position. The Eagles seemed to feel that he was qualified. If you think about it, backup quarterbacks are like coaches and they are intimately knowledgeable of scheme and strategy, both for offense but also defense. They probably get better prepared than a lower level assistant- like a QB coach- because they do it and don’t just teach it. And Josh McCown was in many different systems over the course of his career. The rest is about leadership and ability to connect with people, which Josh appears to have in abundance. This is not crazy at all.

  68. it’s McNair’s business to screw up which he has done royally for some years. If the choice is between a failure like Caldwell and an unproven but knowledgeable ex-player like McCown I go with the unknown. I don’t know why Bienemy doesn’t get HC job but he does have a history that would ordinarily be problematic although what is public is old news.

  69. Josh is an overtly reilgious player. McNair is deeply religious and Easterby has exploited that reliance on religion. McCown is just another step down the path of running the team in a religious way. If the waterboy was singing the gospel he has a chance of becoming managment on this team.

  70. No nothing about the man. But maybe he is a great leader. He’s been in many organizations, so he’s seen how things work. If he can surround himself with experience. I don’t think it’s as big deal as your making it. But he needs to be that special person.

  71. There is a precedent. Norm van brocklin led the Eagles to the 1960 championship and then coached the expansion Vikings in 1961. Didn’t do to badly for an expansion team.

  72. Maybe they just wanted to pick his brain on the direction of Watson and the team. The guy has played on countless teams and behind a bunch of QBs. They probably just called it an interview as a favor to his agent.

  73. This just in: The Texans have hired a ham sandwich to be their next head coach. At press time, a bag of Doritos was thought to have the inside edge to be named offensive coordinator.

  74. Chiefs fan in LA says:
    January 22, 2021 at 7:24 pm
    the press said similar about joe torres when he got the yankees managers job. he did ok.

    Yea, he did okay, with a team full future of Hall of Famers and as much money as I needed to buy championships in a sport thats dominated by big market teams and most the franchises are out of the playoff race before Opening Day. An MLB managers responsibilities are extremely limited compared to the responsibilities of an NFL coach. You set a lineup, make a few situational calls a game, try to motivate your players, and manage egos. Player development is almost entirely done in the minors.

    So if you throw all that out, along with ignoring that half the NFL is built on parity whereas the MLB over half the teams are out of the playoff race before Opening Day then yea. . . . that’s a great comparison!

  75. The joke is the over reaction. You are missing something. Every previous twitter release the Texans put out related to the coaching and GM opening used the word “interview” to describe the conversation. The tweet yesterday said “have continued discussions” with Caldwell and McCown. They can get his input (he is on the payroll) without it being actually considered for the head job. Not a mockery.

  76. Sports is going more and more toward leadership. Steve Kerr hadn’t coached before. Aaron Boone, Alex Cora, Mike Matheny all went deep into the playoffs in MLB. Sports is getting younger. Hire a guy with leadership ability as a CEO and surround him with good lieutenants, you have a chance.

  77. mackcarrington says:
    January 22, 2021 at 7:56 pm
    Chiefs fan in LA says:
    January 22, 2021 at 7:24 pm

    the press said similar about joe torres when he got the yankees managers job. he did ok.

    ———–===============———-

    Joe Torre had 14 years experience as a manager when the Yankees hired him.
    —————————-

    What was Joe Torre’s record before he came to the Yankees?? I’ll give you a hint ,it was horrible…

  78. I’m a chiefs fan. I watch all of the press conferences. If you hear one Bienemy presser you’ve heard them all. It’s nothing but cliches and fake smiles. He just seems fake. I can’t imagine a hc interview with him inspires anyone to make him the face of their franchise.

  79. I always enjoy when toads on here make statements like “he will make a great coach,” without any examples to support their lame claim.

  80. what does a 24 yr old read option qb know.. he is a player an asset leave the thinking to more experienced men! he is looking for someone to enhance his stats.. not a team guy!

  81. McCown’s career stats
    Comp att % yds y/att TDs int Lng rating
    1584 2633 60.2 17,731 6.7 98 82 80 79.7

    great QB – he wasn’t even a great college QB

  82. Enough of the faux outrage. They can do whatever they want no matter what anyone thinks. It’s impossible to determine if someone will be a good coach or not so why get all worked up over it. Plus, it was just an interview. They didn’t give him the job. #smh

  83. The league should not allow any head coach to be hired until eight days after the Super Bowl.

  84. Not every great player will make a good coach. Look at Mike Singletary. He was a great middle linebacker, but a horror as a head coach.

    Look at Matt Patricia. He was a great DC with the Patriots, but useless as the head coach of the Lions.

    To assume that McCown will be a good head coach, simply because he was a decent backup QB, its taking a leap too far.

  85. berniemadoffsides says:
    January 22, 2021 at 8:21 pm

    Why does no one ever bring up Eric Bieniemy‘s very troubled legal past? It’s absolutely a concern.

    For stuff that happened 20 years ago, when he was young and silly? You’re clutching at straws bro. He wouldn’t be a coach so long if he had serious legal issues.

    As for McCown interviewing? Well no real issue with that, except Josh got the interview as he’s a good ol’ Christian boy. Seems knowing your Scripture is an important prerequisite for the role. Nothing to do with coaching the team.

  86. I have seen plenty of coaches that have lots of experience coaching and still suck as a head coach. So what’s your point?

  87. If a person has been in football all his life he may be qualified. It does not have to be a genius. It’s football. It’s dealing with over paid personalities.

  88. footballpat says:
    January 22, 2021 at 10:47 pm

    So people knock Bienemy saying he doesn’t call the plays. But let’s look at people with no coaching experience, losing coaching experience, let’s hire a special teams coach like Joe Judge (how many offensive plays did he call), let’s talk to position coaches.
    ————————————————————————————
    Ok, lets.

    John Harbaugh. Special teams coach for Philadelphia for 7 years. DB Coach for one. No coordinator experience. No HC experience. Super Bowl winning head coach within 5 seasons in Baltimore. One losing season in 12 years as head coach.

    Mike Tomlin. DB coach in Tampa for 5 years. DC in Minnesota for 1. No HC experience Super Bowl win in 2 yrs as Pittsburgh HC. Zero losing seasons in Pittsburgh.

    Andy Reid. TE/OL coach for 5 years QB Coach for two in GB. Super Bowl appearance in 5 years with Philadelphia. Super Bowl WIN with KC in 7 seasons. 2 losing seasons in 14 with Philadelphia. Zero with Kansas City.

    Sometimes you have to let the people that make the decisions for the organization, make the right decisions….and not give in to the pressure to make decisions for other reasons. Those organizations clearly did .

  89. shihtzumum says:
    January 23, 2021 at 2:09 pm

    berniemadoffsides says:
    January 22, 2021 at 8:21 pm

    Why does no one ever bring up Eric Bieniemy‘s very troubled legal past? It’s absolutely a concern.

    For stuff that happened 20 years ago, when he was young and silly? You’re clutching at straws bro. He wouldn’t be a coach so long if he had serious legal issues.

    Really?

    Then why has be only been hired by either institutions he played for ( Colorado) or coaches he played for? (Reid/Childress).

    Take your time.

  90. We have elected politicians to high offices without any experience, so what difference does it make when it comes to a football coach?

  91. I love all you people citing GM’s that were hired with no experience. That is a complete apple to oranges comparison. That’s like the difference between hiring someone with no boating experience as the CEO of Celebrity Cruise Lines vs. hiring someone with no boating experience as the captain of one of their cruise ships.

  92. If players with no coaching experience getting hired to coaching jobs immediately after retiring becomes a trend wouldn’t that automatically solve the “lack of minority coaches” issue since most of the players are minorities? Seems like most of the teams are trending at hiring younger coaches and most experienced minority coaches are on the older side so that would make guys like Tyrod Taylor now qualified (which he should be as the guy is an encyclopedia of knowledge which is probably why every rookie he mentors does extremely well.)

    I mean was Byron Leftwich experienced when he got hired by Bruce Arians right off his roster and now he’s the OC for a team in the NFC title game. Same for Bill Bellichick hiring Ozzie Newsome to his front office. I definitely feel this response is an over reaction and probably under thought since Eric Bieniemy is the it candidate of the sports media and no one is looking at the bigger picture of how many other guys can get opportunities if this were to happen and work out.

  93. It always amazes me when people think that executive leaders must have non-executive skills. Find the best leaders across any industry, they aren’t there because of technical expertise, but rather their ability to communicate a clear vision and instill a culture that supports that vision.

    Having expertise may bring immediate credibility, but the number of coordinators with expertise that couldn’t be great leaders (Gase, Patricia, O’Brien, Lynn, Shurmur) demonstrates that expertise can definitely be overrated.

    Of the group hired recently, Saleh is inspiring.

  94. TheBisonCometh says:
    January 23, 2021 at 2:38 pm

    shihtzumum says:
    January 23, 2021 at 2:09 pm

    berniemadoffsides says:
    January 22, 2021 at 8:21 pm

    Why does no one ever bring up Eric Bieniemy‘s very troubled legal past? It’s absolutely a concern.

    For stuff that happened 20 years ago, when he was young and silly? You’re clutching at straws bro. He wouldn’t be a coach so long if he had serious legal issues.

    Really?

    Then why has be only been hired by either institutions he played for ( Colorado) or coaches he played for? (Reid/Childress).

    Take your time.

    Nope. Still don’t see what the issue is. So Bienemy is hired by people who took his past into consideration, know him and STILL hired him. So what are you trying to say?
    I’ll wait…

  95. Sometimes, you come up with gems that precisely capture the moment.
    This is as brilliant, as it is apropos. Texans franchise is adrift.

    ” Easterby is so far over his skis that he thinks he’s learned to fly. “

  96. shihtzumum says:
    January 23, 2021 at 4:01 pm

    Nope. Still don’t see what the issue is. So Bienemy is hired by people who took his past into consideration, know him and STILL hired him. So what are you trying to say?
    I’ll wait…

    ________________________________________________________________________________

    No need to wait. I’ll break it down for you right now.
    What some people want to ignore is the NFL is just like any workplace organization. Staffing is built on relationships. People get jobs because of the relationships they have with other people. No matter if the relationships are built on any other factor OTHER than merit. To suggest that isn’t the case with Eric BienIemy or any other coaching hire in league history is hilariously foolish. But for S and G let’s take a look at his credentials:
    Minnesota RB coach for 5 seasons. Coaching a generational talent like Adrian Peterson is heavy lifting.
    I get tired just thinking about it.
    U of Colorado OC for 2 seasons– Avgs 19 pts a game and ranks 109 out of 120 teams in offensive production. Fast tracker there.
    KC RB coach for 5 seasons. Because the likes of Jammal Charles and Kareem Hunt need GUIDANCE and motivation.
    Here’s something very telling: The last two QB coaches and offensive coordinators before EB under Reid ( Matt Nagy and Doug Pederson) have been or are still head coaches in the NFL. They even faced each other in the playoffs. One (Pederson) has won a Super Bowl. Yet, even with the success of the Chiefs offense of the last 3 seasons, a former RB coach now their OC can’t get a head coaching job. Could it be that both Nagy and Pederson and their experience as QBs and subsequently working with QBs as coaches have something to do with that? A couple of NFL owners seem to have thought so. Might want to take that into consideration, as well.
    Might shed some light on why ANOTHER former QB ( who is ….wait for it.. KC’s QB coach and passing game coordinator, Mike Kafka) is on Reid’s coaching staff and has an instrumental role in setting up the game plan WITH Reid weekly.
    See a pattern here?
    Maybe someone doesn’t and seems to think things should happen another way. Wonder why?

  97. stataddict says:
    January 23, 2021 at 3:37 pm
    It always amazes me when people think that executive leaders must have non-executive skills. Find the best leaders across any industry, they aren’t there because of technical expertise, but rather their ability to communicate a clear vision and instill a culture that supports that vision.
    Having expertise may bring immediate credibility, but the number of coordinators with expertise that couldn’t be great leaders (Gase, Patricia, O’Brien, Lynn, Shurmur) demonstrates that expertise can definitely be overrated.
    Of the group hired recently, Saleh is inspiring.

    _________________________________________________________________________________________

    I agree. Saleh was my first choice of the candidates available.

    That being said, I have one question:
    Given that criteria, of communication and instilling a culture, what evidence do you have that Eric Bieniemy has or has the ability to do that? Don’t you think it’s possible that he doesn’t check that box ( one that ownership surely wants checked) in interviews? It would explain a great many things.

  98. We have elected politicians to high offices without any experience, so what difference does it make when it comes to a football coach?
    —————-

    We all just saw what can happen when a person with NO experience in politics was electedto a high office. Worst of the worst. The NFL cannot be compared to being a politician.

    In the NFL, head coaches need to inspire the players. They need to get them to work as a cohesive unit. The most successful teams play as a unit. Many teams are full of great players, but they go nowhere because they don’t play as a team.

  99. Brian Daboll will be the Texans next HC. Daboll has the New England ties and has had a hand in the development of Josh Allen.

  100. supercharger says:
    January 22, 2021 at 8:16 pm
    We’re 2 weeks into 2021 and we already have racist accusations being thrown around because Bieniemy isn’t a HC, the Texans hired the GM they’ve been trying to hire for 2 years, and Dan Campbell said something about knee caps. Stop it.
    ——————————————————-
    3 weeks but who’s counting. At any rate, we only have 3 games left this season so it’s time to start floating conspiracy theories and mock drafts.

  101. These are the made up rules of how you must operate! No one can think outside the box!

  102. You know things are bad when the Cowboys are the best run NFL team in the state.

    This franchise is so trash. I’m gonna cheer for a team with better morals like the Astros instead.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.