Source: Peyton Manning receives his official Hall of Fame notification

Denver Broncos vs. against the Oakland Raiders, NFL Week 2
Getty Images

The Pro Football Hall of Fame has done a great job of keeping the identity of the new class of Hall of Fames secret for the last two weeks. In four nights, the names of up to eight new Hall of Famers will be revealed.

At least one of them already has received official word of his enshrinement. Per a league source, Hall of Fame president David Baker has informed quarterback Peyton Manning that he has qualified for the Hall of Fame in his first year of eligibility. The news came at a party in Peyton’s honor. The event was filmed, and footage undoubtedly will be released once the official announcement happens on Saturday night.

It’s no surprise that Manning got in. The presentation from Mike Chappell of FOX59 and CBS4 in Indianapolis latest seconds. No debate ensued. Manning undoubtedly received the necessary votes to secure status as a finalist and eventual enshrinement.

It will be interesting to see whether other names of other Hall of Famers emerge over the next few days. It’s amazing that it took two weeks for the first one to get out.

44 responses to “Source: Peyton Manning receives his official Hall of Fame notification

  1. “Congrats Peyton. Wish you could be here in Tampa this weekend to watch me win another Super Bowl.” Tom.

  2. They could have saved time and informed him of his induction in the 2021 HOF class on March 7th, 2016 right after he announced his retirement. This one was a no doubter.

  3. He didn’t have Belichick, so he didn’t have the Superbowls. But Peyton is the GOAT people have just forgotten since he hasn’t been playing. But in his heyday there was none better, including Brady.

  4. Best of all-time. Field generalship at its best. Easily proven. What did his team’s do when he wasn’t at the helm? Ah, you couldn’t even watch it. Brady’s teams, not miss a beat.

  5. Regardless if you are a fan of him or not, or if you like him personally or not there is no debate that Manning was the consumate professional on and off tbe field.

    I was never a huge fan of his, but he’s one of the best ever and deserves all the accolades.

  6. Well deserved. A rival to the Pats for most of my childhood/adulthood and a pleasure to watch run an offense, though I preferred to see him on the bench when playing the Pats. Nothing but appreciation for his game and a no doubt first ballot HOFer

  7. diehard pats fan. I was lucky enough to watch Peyton and tommy Duel on opening night 2004 when Vanderjagt missed a game tying field goal. I was then lucky enough to meet Peyton at the pro bowl practice when it was held on Hickam AFB.

    A LEGEND. WELL DESERVED

  8. Peyton’s hilarious SNL United Way skit alone should be enough to qualify him for the Hall of Fame. That’s still one of the funniest things I’ve ever seen. Classic.

  9. Hey Peyton… This is Tom got a favor to ask….can you hold my seat for say about the next 9 years… lol…Got me a super bowl to win this weekend so I am kinda STILL BUSY!!!!

  10. But seriously Peyton truly belongs in the hall of Fame for sure. So says a life long NE Patriot fan dating all the way back to 1969.

    One of the greatest QB’s to put on a helmet.

  11. @snowlock2013 you got the thumbs down but I am publicly giving you the thumbs up. You’re right. I do not personally believe in a GOAT. Wish Brady would have had to play when defenses were real and QBs skipped the skirts. Manning would have been a GOAT candidate in all eras. Never had a team. And still did it.

    Also didn’t need 22 seasons to break QB-worthy records. Kinda like Emmitt Smith. Like the guy, but if I played for 46 years I would beat Walter too.

  12. nite2al says:
    February 3, 2021 at 3:58 am
    Best of all-time. Field generalship at its best. Easily proven. What did his team’s do when he wasn’t at the helm? Ah, you couldn’t even watch it. Brady’s teams, not miss a beat.
    _____________________________________________________

    Perhaps you should consult the current NFL season when referring to what Brady’s teams do without him. Smh

  13. The HOF opened up a new section for stat-padding. Manning is the founding member. If his Denver years are going to count (HGH was the great equalizer) then Barry Bonds and Mark McGwire should be HOF locks as well.

  14. The HOF pretty much lets anybody in. They can put his bust next to Jerome Bettis. Keep the underserving “good but not great” players in the same area.

  15. People lose their memories really quick on this site. Peyton Manning is about as slam dunk a HOFer as there is, but for those saying “he didn’t have a team” – c’mon now. He had tons of talent on the offensive side of the ball—as much as Brady has this year.

    Kudos to him knowing how to use it. He was a smart and talented player.

    If Brady and the Pats weren’t in his way all those years, he’d have a couple more SBs to his name.

  16. It probably doesn’t make sense to anyone when I say Brady is the GOAT but Manning is the best.

  17. snowlock2013 says:
    February 3, 2021 at 12:28 am
    He didn’t have Belichick, so he didn’t have the Superbowls. But Peyton is the GOAT people have just forgotten since he hasn’t been playing. But in his heyday there was none better, including Brady.

    —–

    His record 9 one-and-dones say otherwise

  18. “As a Pats fan..” “My boy Tahmmyyy” Pats fans trying to make Peyton Manning’s amazing career all about them somehow.

  19. It probably doesn’t make sense to anyone when I say Brady is the GOAT but Manning is the best

    It doesn’t because they DO NOT mean two different things
    If you’re called the “GOAT” it means the “best”
    See below….

    The person considered the BEST to ever compete, perform, or participate in a particular game or field, typically a certain sport. Commonly abbreviated with the acronym “GOAT.”

  20. objectivefootballfan says:
    February 3, 2021 at 10:03 am

    Please Peyton had several HOF players on many of his teams.

    And lets not go there with the could have played in all era’s stuff and no players around today would have lasted 12 seasons with the rules they had in the 60’s, 70’s 80’s

    And for the record… I believe these guys are in the Hall of fame or will be.. all teammates of Peyton…Tony Dungy, Marvin Harrison, Marshal Faulk, Edgerrin James, Reggie Wayne,

  21. When I read the time breakdown of HOF discussions among the voters and noted that they spent 13 seconds on Peyton Manning, it was obviously a no-brainer.

    Congrats Peyton Manning! One of the best (and hella better than his dorky little brother.

  22. Peyton did it the right way and deserves this on the first try (and he was never suspended for a quarter of an NFL season for cheating.)

  23. It’s time to pull out the fact book. I know, it’s been a long time, but all of this needs to be said once again. Not only did Peyton Manning have 9 playoff one-and-dones, he also had better offenses than Brady. He played with Reggie Wayne, Marvin Harrison, Edgerrin James, Joseph Addai, Jeff Saturday, Demaryius Thomas, Emmanuel Sanders, and even Adam Vinatieri. He also had Dwight Freeney on defense and Marshall Faulk for his rookie season as well. It’s a total myth that his teams let him down, especially on the grandest stage. He threw just 3 touchdowns to 5 interceptions in four super bowl games, too, with two of those being a pick-6. He also won his first ring on the 2006 Colts throwing 3 touchdowns to 7 interceptions in the playoffs.

  24. When Peyton had good defenses, he won Superbowls. When he didn’t, he didn’t. Just like Tommy boy.

  25. I’ve never seen anyone play the position as well as he did. Including Joe Montana and Aaron Rodgers.

  26. Didn’t Peyton have a hall of fame coach??? Yeah I thinks his name was Tony Dungy?
    =====

    Dungy is a great man, served the NFL well for through the years, and had good success.

    MANY, MORE worthy coaching candidates are still waiting for their call.

    .. and if we’re going to credit a coach for Mannings success, its Tom Moore.

  27. jameshodges says:
    February 3, 2021 at 11:41 am
    It’s time to pull out the fact book. I know, it’s been a long time, but all of this needs to be said once again. Not only did Peyton Manning have 9 playoff one-and-dones, he also had better offenses than Brady. He played with Reggie Wayne, Marvin Harrison, Edgerrin James, Joseph Addai, Jeff Saturday, Demaryius Thomas, Emmanuel Sanders, and even Adam Vinatieri. He also had Dwight Freeney on defense and Marshall Faulk for his rookie season as well. It’s a total myth that his teams let him down, especially on the grandest stage. He threw just 3 touchdowns to 5 interceptions in four super bowl games, too, with two of those being a pick-6. He also won his first ring on the 2006 Colts throwing 3 touchdowns to 7 interceptions in the playoffs.

    And of those NINE times going one and done
    For EIGHT of them he had BOTH a top TEN defense in scoring and yards allowed. And two of those seven they were ranked number ONE in scoring defense and all those teams had a top ten offense.
    And even with all that still went one and done nine times.

  28. If he were in the league 10 or so years earlier, Brady/Manning would have been an unanswerable debate. But the two careers just happened to collide. And he still accomplished all that he did despite having the brick wall that was TB to deal with every year.

    Congratulations!

  29. “When Peyton had good defenses, he won Superbowls. When he didn’t, he didn’t. Just like Tommy boy.” Um, no. There is a big difference between playing horrible and having a great defense, and playing great while having a great defense, too. Peyton Manning threw 7 interceptions in the playoffs on the 2006 Colts, and he also threw like 17 picks on the 2015 Broncos. When Brady had the best defenses in the early 2000’s and back in 2018, he still didn’t make big mistakes against those playoff contenders. Brady had three consecutive third down conversions in overtime of that AFC championship game against the Chiefs. Brady threw 3 touchdowns against the Eagles and passed for over 500 yards in Super Bowl LII. Peyton never had a performance like that in a super bowl, win or lose.

  30. Why do Brady fans need to hate on Peyton? Their guy will get in first ballot too. As a Niners fan , sure I didn’t root for guys like Aikman or Favre. But I wasn’t blind and recognized talent. Not a good look Pats fan

  31. jjackwagon says:
    February 3, 2021 at 11:52 am
    When Peyton had good defenses, he won Superbowls. When he didn’t, he didn’t. Just like Tommy boy.

    And of those NINE times going one and done
    For EIGHT of them he had BOTH a top TEN defense in scoring and yards allowed. And two of those seven they were ranked number ONE in scoring defense and all those teams had a top ten offense.
    And even with all that still went one and done nine times.

    That would be factual incorrect, AGAIN see below…

  32. His daddy would’ve been in there too if it weren’t for those pesky 1970s Falcons defenses like the Gritz Blitz.

  33. Why do Brady fans need to hate on Peyton?
    =====

    You’d be upset too, if someone tried to defile the alter of your god.

  34. For EIGHT of them he had BOTH a top TEN defense in scoring and yards allowed. And two of those seven they were ranked number ONE in scoring defense and all those teams had a top ten offense.
    And even with all that still went one and done nine times.

    That would be factual incorrect, AGAIN see below…
    ======

    Uh, probably shouldn’t throw stones there, glass house.

    Manning only played with 1 #1 scoring D.. 2007.

  35. Invest in bronze now. The amount needed to create the forehead on that bust will alone drive the price up.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.