Jay Gruden: I’d be shocked if the Raiders got rid of Derek Carr

New Orleans Saints v Las Vegas Raiders
Getty Images

Earlier this week, a rumor popped up that the Raiders could be planning to trade Derek Carr to pursue Texans quarterback Deshaun Watson.

If Raiders head coach Jon Gruden commented on Watson, that would be tampering — and he’s already recently engaged in that. But his brother, Jay, currently doesn’t have a job after Jacksonville’s coaching staff got replaced following the end of the regular season.

In an interview with TheAthletic.com, Jay said he didn’t know if his brother would be open to trading Carr. But the younger Gruden made it seem unlikely.

“I never know what Jon’s gonna do. But I’d be shocked, really,” Jay Gruden said. “The way that Derek played this year, I don’t know why he’d want to get rid of him. But who knows, if there’s another guy out there that they really, really like, it is a business at the end of the day. You got to think about not only the year coming up but the future five, six, seven years. Jon’s going to be there for the next six, seven years so he’s got to think about that as well.”

Jay noted he watched a lot of Raiders tape in 2020 in case he wanted to take a play or formation from his older brother, and thought Carr had his pro season.

Carr completed 67.3 percent of his bases for 4,103 yards with 27 touchdowns and nine interceptions in 2020.

8 responses to “Jay Gruden: I’d be shocked if the Raiders got rid of Derek Carr

  1. Because our ceiling with Carr is a wild card berth and likely 1st round out, MAYBE we win a playoff game. But with Herbert and Mahomes in the division, we are a wild card contender with Carr. With Deshaun Watson, we have a Super Bowl ceiling. It’s that simple. Carr is good, but Watson is elite. That’s why we would get rid of him.

  2. stephanebonics says:
    February 5, 2021 at 4:54 pm
    Because our ceiling with Carr is a wild card berth and likely 1st round out, MAYBE we win a playoff game. But with Herbert and Mahomes in the division, we are a wild card contender with Carr. With Deshaun Watson, we have a Super Bowl ceiling. It’s that simple. Carr is good, but Watson is elite. That’s why we would get rid of him.
    _____________

    Career stats since 2017 (Watson 1st year)

    Wins:
    Watson 29
    Carr 25

    Passing yards:
    Watson 14,539
    Carr 15,702

    TD’s:
    Watson 104
    Carr 89

    INT’s:
    Watson 36
    Carr 40

    Both QB’s passer ratings hover around 100 give or take a few points and the Texans have a few post season games in the last few years due to being in a weak division.

    So what you’re saying ( and everybody else clamoring to trade Carr) is that you would trade Carr AND 1st round picks AND pay millions more for a QB that will average you:

    1 extra win a year
    1 less INT a year
    1 extra TD every 4 or 5 games
    300 less passing yards per year.

    Carr is garbage and Watson is elite? LMAO!!!!

    That’s what you would trade all that for?

  3. Unless an extremely talented QB falls into LV’s lap, don’t expect Chucky to do anything at that position except draft/develop his own choice to operate his system.

  4. returntoexcellence says:
    February 5, 2021 at 9:33 pm

    Carr is garbage and Watson is elite? LMAO!!!!
    That’s what you would trade all that for?

    First off, I never said Carr was garbage and Watson was elite. I said Carr is good but Watson is elite. Watson goes to playoffs just about every year with the garbage Texans organization. Carr has never played in a playoff game. Carr had ONE winning season, and that was fluky because all our wins were in one score games. It’s simple, Watson is better than Carr, period. You can disagree, that’s your opinion. However, you cited stats from when Watson entered the league, but you forget that he missed virtually a whole season because he tore his ACL. Lastly, you’re using the wrong numbers and stats because you’re using totals instead of averages. Watson (career) is 67.8% completion, TD% of 5.9, INT% is 2.1, averages 8.3 y/attempt, 269.2 pass yds/game, 104.5 QB rating, sack% of 9.1%, and Watson’s record is 28-25 (53% winning). Carr’s numbers (career, not since 2017) are 47-63 record (43% winning), 64.4 completion %, 4.4 TD%, 1.9 INT%, 7.1 yds/attempt, 244.5 passing yds/game, 92.1 rating, and sack % of 4.9%. So the only metric Carr is better than Watson is interception %, only by .2%. Watson is better in completion percentage, TD%, yards per attempt, QB rating, and passing yards per game all while being sacked more than double the times as Carr. And let’s not forget Watson can run where he has 1,677 yards, 17 rush TDs, and averages 5.5 yds/rush. While Carr, in almost double the amount of games, has 635 yds, 6 rush TDs, and an average of 3.0 yds/rush. Watson is better in every statistical measurement except Carr BARELY edges him in interception % and that’s only because he checks down and plays so conservative. Watson wins more than Carr, goes to the playoffs more than Carr, has better stats than Carr, is younger, more athletic, actually throws the ball downfield, and brings more in the rush game. So, yes, I would trade picks and pay Watson millions more than Carr, he is worth it.

  5. I like Derek Carr a lot and wish he could have success as a Raider. Things looked promising under Del Rio and Bill Musgrave in 2016 but unfortunately under Gruden the Raiders really have no hope of going anywhere. As such as long as Gruden remains HC, Carr’s career will be wasted in the same way that Archie Manning’s was in New Orleans.

    The best hope for Carr going to the offseason and perhaps getting to a Super Bowl is either getting rid of Gruden (which Son-of-Al won’t do) or Carr landing with another team that has a decent HC.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.