Why would Carson Wentz want to play for the Bears?

Chicago Bears v Philadelphia Eagles
Getty Images

As the Eagles continue to wait for someone to make them an offer they won’t refuse for quarterback Carson Wentz, the belief remains that the two suitors for Wentz are the Colts and the Bears.

Assuming that the Bears are truly interested in Wentz (more on that in a second), why would Wentz want to play for the Bears?

After dealing with the rabid Philly fans, Wentz potentially would be setting himself up for even worse in Chicago. Plenty of Bears fans would make their best constipation faces when hearing that the deal is done, and the grace period for Wentz would be maybe one or two drives in Week One.

Then there’s the reality that seats are getting hot in Chicago. Wentz, if he fails in 2021, could see plenty of people with the team get fired. That would put a ton of extra pressure on him for the coming season, and it could result in Wentz being traded again after 2021.

Although Wentz doesn’t have a no-trade clause, why would the Bears want him if he doesn’t want to be there? A well-time call from his agent to G.M. Ryan Pace could make that point clear, and it would become the ultimate caveat emptor for the courtship of Carson Wentz.

Wentz should want to go to the Colts and only to the Colts. This creates a problem for the Eagles, since it undermines their leverage to have only one team at the table.

Still, it makes some sense for the Bears to be interested, given the other options. Unless a deal can be done for Russell Wilson or Deshaun Watson, the Bears will be looking at a free-agent market headlined by (assuming Dak Prescott isn’t available) Jameis Winston. Or maybe (if he’s released by Washington) Alex Smith, who has experience in the Chicago offense from his time in Kansas City. Or Andy Dalton or Ryan Fitzpatrick or Mitch Trubisky or plenty of guys who when are their best are a far cry from Wentz at his best.

The key becomes knowing whether Wentz’s best can be brought back, or whether he is who he was in 2020. That’s the risk that someone will be taking. Before the Bears do it, they should be certain that Wentz embraces the opportunity — especially if the Bears plan to have Nick Foles looming on the depth chart behind Wentz.

55 responses to “Why would Carson Wentz want to play for the Bears?

  1. Cousins to either San Fran or NE for a 2nd. Minnesota’s 1st and 2nd for Wentz. Then he’d be playing for his hometown essentially.

  2. Because he might actually get to play there? The market for him at his current salary is very small. And if Philly doesn’t trade him he’s going to be holding a clipboard for them.

  3. This would be the worst possible fit. If the Bears make a deal for Wentz, everyone will be canned in Chicago…

  4. It baffles me that given both its salary cap situation and its options at QB–be it through free agency or the draft–the Bears aren’t more seriously considering Winston, who has relatively the same level of upside/downside as Wentz without the hits to the cap and draft capital/existing talent. The Bears are in 8-8 purgatory now, and the only guaranteed outcome of “fixing” Wentz is doing so at the expense of drafting or recruiting OL and WR talent; it’s destined to keep them in the mediocre middle, or worse. Why not take a flyer on Winston for a year and rebuild the skill positions (again)? The likelihood of backfiring–because we’re Bears fans: success never happens–is the same as with Wentz; and, if nothing else, it would leave a foundation on which the next coach/GM could build.

  5. The better question is, why would anyone want Wentz?

    Wentz has been injury prone his entire career. He hasn’t won in the playoffs – was injured before the playoff runs in 2017 and 18 and was concussed in 2019 after going 1-4 for 25 years against the seahawks. In addition, he handled his disagreements with his coach poorly and publicly – after he had a rough 2020 season. Now granted, the talent level/injuries of his team had a bearing on that too – but QB is easier to change than the remaining 10 players on offense.

    I question his mental toughness, and at his current contract – its too much to pay with too much risk. I think the eagles will need to pay someone to take him off their hands, IMHO

  6. Bears fan do not want anything to do with Wentz. Those two names shouldn’t even be mentioned in the same sentence anymore, this is Ludacris. If this happen, you can expect all of Illinois to walk Pace out of Chicago sooner rather then later.

  7. Jameis Winston is the right hire here. Tons of upside, wouldn’t be expensive enough to have to sabotage the rest of the team and would immediately add a personality to the offense in a way no QB since McMahon has in Chicago. Get him to cut down on INT’s even by a third, and you’ve got a Bears offense that could actually put up the yards and points needed to compete with Green Bay and support the Defense.

  8. snowlock2013 says:
    February 16, 2021 at 10:46 am
    Cousins to either San Fran or NE for a 2nd. Minnesota’s 1st and 2nd for Wentz. Then he’d be playing for his hometown essentially.

    —–

    NE doesn’t want Cousins.. or Wentz

  9. Wentz is a has-been! If he’s not hurt he and he has a superb offensive line in front of him he is capable. But, based on his history and past performance, he will remain injury prone and the Bears will not be able to protect him in order to ensure he has enough time in the pocket and/or doesn’t get hit too often. Other than that . . . . . IMHO, if the Bears were working to actually rebuild the franchise they would stay with what they have and rebuild the offensive line, add receivers (as necessary) and look to draft a quality QB next year. They will either have shown they are competitive with Trubisky and an improved offensive line or will have fallen so flat other face they will be high enough in the draft to select a high performing QB.

  10. Maybe he likes that Delphino (sp) guy who coached him before? Does he even have a choice/no trade clause?

  11. With the 20th pick of the 1st Round of the 2021 NFL Draft the Chicago Bears select QB Mac Jones Alabama. Then they draft offensive line the next 2 rounds.

  12. I mean, say what you want but the Bears were a playoff team last season with Trubisky and Foles playing QB. The defense is top 10. And Chicago is 50x the market that Indianapolis is for what that’s worth.

    If Wentz could capture 80% of his prime in Chicago under his old coach Defilipo, they would be a tough out. But I agree it’s way too risky to trust this Bears staff to restore a QB to his former glory. I’d bet on disaster.

  13. Yes, the remaining quarterbacks are a far cry from Wentz at his best, but so is Wentz.

    Right now, it’s a coin flip whether Wentz will go back to playing like a franchise QB, or whether he will continue to play poorly, like he did last year in Philly.

    Wentz comes with a big contract. ANy team that takes him will want a lot of compensation.

  14. The better question is why would the Eagles be so desperate to trade Wentz? It doesn’t make any sense! You’re on the hook for $34 million no matter what so why not see if Wentz can redeem himself instead of ditching him after one lousy season? It isn’t rational and Jalen Hurts isn’t Russell Wilson no matter how much Howie wants him to be! The Eagles will look like fool’s if Wentz regains his form on another team.

  15. I actually think Wentz will do really well in chicago. Any chance we can throw Howie Roseman in to the deal? Philly will take garbage can in chicago in exchange.

  16. A couple better questions:

    Why would the bears want Carson Wentz?

    And why does it matter what Wentz wants?

  17. If Chicago trades for Wentz it will be only out of shear desperation. It will be a huge mistake that will cost the Bears a few years and will once again guarantee another wasted Defense in Chicago.

  18. I mean Carson Wentz doesn’t really have a choice, does he? He plays for whoever will take a chance on him because he is a total disaster so far.

  19. No, rumorville, you are forgetting about Sexy Rexy Grossman. How could you forget about all that twisted steel and sex appeal?

  20. How in the heck are the Bears going to let Ryan Freaking Pace take ANOTHER swing at a QB? You mortgage the farm and miss that badly on Trubisky, that should be your one and final shot. Woof

  21. Hate to say this but I hope they get him so that the current regime gets canned. The owners don’t help but Nagy and Pace are a wrap. This is a desperation move that will cost the future. Good luck from this former Bears fan. Bear down and hibernate for next season.

  22. “ Winston is the right hire here. Tons of upside, wouldn’t be expensive enough to have to sabotage the rest of the team and would immediately add a personality to the offense in a way no QB since McMahon has in Chicago. Get him to cut down on INT’s even by a third, and you’ve got a Bears offense that could actually put up the yards and points needed to compete with Green Bay and support the Defense.”

    Tons of upside? You’re serious right now? Really? Tons?

  23. The Eagles are under no obligation to trade him. They will if they get the right offer. If they don’t, he’ll be on the roster come April. He can sit at home or on the bench if he wants, but he has done nothing in his career to warrant the Eagles taking less to send him to a team he prefers. So him getting picky about his new team could totally backfire in his face, if he actually likes playing football.

  24. As bad as he’s played, he’s in no position to make any demands. Frankly, neither are the Eagles. To hear some pundits talk, it’s obvious they didn’t watch many Eagles games last year.

  25. I bet the issue is more his contract than anything. I also bet most teams believe he is fixable and are willing to explain away the injuries, but ultimately don’t want to take that bet due to the humongous contract he signed.

  26. The Eagles should let Wentz know that his choices are to be traded to Chicago where he can be a starter, or stay with the Eagles and compete with Hurts. You don’t owe him any favors. Do what is best for the Eagles.

  27. For the Bears – I like Alex Smith. He’s a fit for the personality of Chicago fans and he has skills. I didn’t watch any Bears games last year. My concern would be their offensive line. If it’s still weak, no one will succeed there.

    It wouldn’t shock me if Wentz lands in Houston. Everyone will say that’s nuts, but Watson in Philly could work. Philly would need to offer Houston Wentz plus draft picks, ala the Goff/Stafford trade, to get Watson.

  28. If he can’t handle external pressure like that (and it seems like he can’t), then he doesn’t belong as an NFL starting QB.

  29. I’d rather see the Bears struggle for a few seasons and (fingers crossed) hopefully draft the right QB than to trade for another broken QB. Denver let Cutler go coming off a Pro Bowl because they knew his limitations. The Bucs drafted Winston to start over Glennon for much the same reason, and look at Winston’s trajectory since (says much about Glennon). The same is all true for Wentz. I get the aggressive mentality of the front office. They need to win now. But Wentz ain’t the answer. We need a rebuild, but even if we were a QB away (we’re not), that player IS NOT Carson Wentz.

  30. “ Winston is the right hire here. Tons of upside, wouldn’t be expensive enough to have to sabotage the rest of the team and would immediately add a personality to the offense in a way no QB since McMahon has in Chicago. Get him to cut down on INT’s even by a third, and you’ve got a Bears offense that could actually put up the yards and points needed to compete with Green Bay and support the Defense.”

    Tons of upside? You’re serious right now? Really? Tons?

    Yes, dead serious. Winston has elite arm talent and every year he’s played 16 games, he’s thrown for more than 4,000 yards (5,000 once). Cut down the INTs drastically, and he’s an ELITE quarterback. Cut them by even a third, and he’s still more dangerous than anyone the Bears have had.

    I’d MUCH rather the Bears swing for the fences with Winston than play it seemingly save with another Foles/Glennon/Orton/etc. game manager.

  31. Jpiro saying Winston is more dangerous than anyone the Bears have had says absolutely nothing if you look at Chicago’s history. Secondly the picks aren’t gonna go away. the Bears O-line has too many holes for any QB to not constantly have to throw under pressure and Winston lacks the discipline anyway.

  32. “ Winston is the right hire here. Tons of upside, wouldn’t be expensive enough to have to sabotage the rest of the team and would immediately add a personality to the offense in a way no QB since McMahon has in Chicago. Get him to cut down on INT’s even by a third, and you’ve got a Bears offense that could actually put up the yards and points needed to compete with Green Bay and support the Defense.”

    Tons of upside? You’re serious right now? Really? Tons?

    Yes, dead serious. Winston has elite arm talent and every year he’s played 16 games, he’s thrown for more than 4,000 yards (5,000 once). Cut down the INTs drastically, and he’s an ELITE quarterback. Cut them by even a third, and he’s still more dangerous than anyone the Bears have had.

    I’d MUCH rather the Bears swing for the fences with Winston than play it seemingly save with another Foles/Glennon/Orton/etc. game manager.

    ************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************

    If Winston has all this upside I’m guessing the New Orlean Saints would not let him go. I think their coach knows a bit more about judging QB talent than anyone in Chicago.

  33. “I’d MUCH rather the Bears swing for the fences with Winston than play it seemingly save with another Foles/Glennon/Orton/etc. game manager.”

    ************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************

    If Winston has all this upside I’m guessing the New Orlean Saints would not let him go. I think their coach knows a bit more about judging QB talent than anyone in Chicago.

  34. The real question is, why would the Eagles take the cap hit and trade him for buttons ? If you’ve got the hit anyway why would you not see what new coaching can do ? Is he worth much less this time next year, and does it matter ? What’s much less than not much ? Not as if Wentz can sulk and just not try, unless he’s planning on retiring on the first two years of this contract. Perfectly do-able, of course, but hardly maximising one’s career earnings.

  35. See you in camp Carson. You can start over there, with the 2’s, and let’s see what you’ve got.

  36. “If Winston has all this upside I’m guessing the New Orlean Saints would not let him go. I think their coach knows a bit more about judging QB talent than anyone in Chicago.”

    Payton is absolutely a better coach than Chicago has, but in N.O. Winston has to compete with fan-favorite gimmick QB Taysom Hill and has to follow in the footsteps of Brees. In Chicago, he’d have Nick Foles as a clear #2, a team desperate for leadership from that position and a path (with an incentive-laden contract) to become the franchise QB he can still be.

  37. holygamoly says:
    February 16, 2021 at 2:49 pm
    The real question is, why would the Eagles take the cap hit and trade him for buttons ?
    ——————————————

    Because the Eagles are $49M over the cap. Trading Wentz post-June 1 designation gives them over $25M in cap relief. The problem with the post-June 1 means that the Eagles would still have to pay him a $10M roster bonus in a month.

  38. Actually I don’t know if Matt Nagy can be trusted with any QB any more than Pace can be trusted to choose him. Over the past two seasons, the farther the Bears’ offensive design has gotten from Nagy’s “Scheme”, the better it has looked, and vice-versa. That also counts for whoever is playing QB. Trubisky could be better than serviceable in an offense that played to his strengths. What makes anyone think Nagy won’t outsmart himself no matter who’s at QB?

  39. Why would Carson Wentz want to play for the Bears? Easiest question of all time – TO GET OUT OF FILTHY! Next question, please….

  40. After the Trubisky/Foles debacles this is not going to happen as it would cost way too much and would not solve the basic problems in Chicago.

  41. Now that Wentz is off the table looks like another chance for Trubisky. Right now anything better would cost the Bears way too much in future draft choices.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.