Joe Montana says Tom Brady is clearly the greatest quarterback of all time

Super Bowl LIV - San Francisco 49ers v Kansas City Chiefs
Getty Images

Last year, Tom Brady wouldn’t say that he’s better than Joe Montana was. Brady doesn’t need to; Montana has done it for him.

“I think Tom has, you know, taken his place on the top up there a long time ago,” Montana said Wednesday on ESPN. “So he’s had a tremendous career, is fun to watch. Yeah, there’s always — everybody always contests over that, but I think if you look at what Tom has been able to accomplish in his time that he’s played, I think it puts him definitely up there in the top of the list. There’s a lot of great guys, as I said, before me, even you go back to Otto Graham, who won ten or eleven championships. So it’s hard to compare them, but you know if you’re looking at it, yeah, definitely Tom at that point.”

Montana won four Super Bowls. Brady now has seven.

His success has put Brady beyond the conversation of whether he’s the greatest quarterback of all time. Receiver Jerry Rice, long regarded as the greatest player at any position (despite the persistent efforts of Randy Moss to call himself the greatest receiver ever), happily gave Brady the GOAT status after Super Bowl LV.

The opinions of Montana and Brady are hardly unanimous, however. Last year, Terry Bradshaw declined to call Tom Brady the greatest quarterback of all time. Maybe Bradshaw was referring to the Tom Brady who had elbow surgery 38 years ago yesterday.

39 responses to “Joe Montana says Tom Brady is clearly the greatest quarterback of all time

  1. Hard to argue with Joe. I think Brady’s ring number 7 removes all doubt (and asteriks) with his time involving NE and their many cheating scandals. Tom is hands-down the GOAT and rightfully so. Congrats!

  2. I think Brady wants an 8th ring just for the simple fact that Otto Graham won 7 championships, too. Two super bowl repeats would be legendary. The only other quarterback to win back to back super bowls twice was Terry Bradshaw.

  3. I was , and am, a huge Montana fan from the 80’s. After Brady had his third SB ring, I was still hesitant to say he was at Montana’s level because the Pats were a defensive team. Time and Time again, we saw the conservative play on 3rd down, trusting the D to get the ball back. The 49ers of the ’80s were a offensive team, who’s defense relied on the offense to win the time of possession and field position, making it easier on the D. Now, especially with the Seahawks SB, 28-3, and now the Bucs, it is no longer an argument. Brady is the GOAT. Kudos to both Montana and Rice for having their egos under control and dealing with the reality of the situation, instead of the egomaniacle idiots infesting the league today.

  4. Otto Graham won 7 championships in 10 seasons, under Paul Brown.

    I think the QB position today requires a higher level of skill and specialization. So the tiebreaker goes to Tom Brady, who convincingly did it under two different but EXCELLENT coaches.

  5. Opinions will always vary as rules have changed over time and it is hard to compare the game today vs. what is was 30 years ago. GOAT? I think so. Most Accomplished? Absolutely. Even the haters have to admit that.

  6. Everyone’s already forgotten Peyton Manning. He’s the GOAT still. Maybe not the rings, but throw for throw, read for read, he was always better than Brady.

  7. I strongly disagree.

    Comparing QBs from different eras is like comparing apples to oranges. Modern rules protect the QB, and prioritize the passing game. So, sure, modern-era QBs are going to have way better numbers.

    Put Brady in the old-era game — where QBs called the plays, DLs could head-slap and do pretty-much anything against OLs, OLs were constrained on how they could pass-protect, QBs could and would be hit almost anytime, WRs could and would be ambushed and beat-up everywhere — then tell me how Brady would do.

    I concede that Brady is the GOAT of his era. Nothing more.

  8. Everyone’s already forgotten Peyton Manning. He’s the GOAT still. Maybe not the rings, but throw for throw, read for read, he was always better than Brady.
    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
    Since you just threw rings out the window, Dan Marino was better than Peyton.

  9. Tom Brady definitely deserves the tiebreaker over Otto Graham, considering Brady won his championships in the salary cap era of a 32-team league, but the main point is that he wants to accomplish something that no quarterback in the history of football will ever match again. That’s why an 8th ring will push him far ahead of any quarterback from the fifties and sixties.

  10. snowlock2013 says:
    March 4, 2021 at 12:57 pm
    Everyone’s already forgotten Peyton Manning. He’s the GOAT still. Maybe not the rings, but throw for throw, read for read, he was always better than Brady.
    —————————————–
    Is it true Ty Law just picked off Manning’s yellow jacket?

  11. So there you have it. Even Montana, Bradys childhood idol, has acknowledged that Tom is the GOAT. Can everyone stop arguing about this now? Its so obvious to objective football fans. And to the few remaining “Manning is the GOAT” People, give it a rest. Brady is SO far ahead of Manning its almost laughable. Was Peyton great, absolutely. Was their rivalry one of the best, absolutely. Manning has more MVPs than Brady, but Brady has EVERYTHING else. Brady IS the GOAT, just enjoy watching him while you still can, he MUCH closer to the end than the beginning.

  12. As a fan, I’m more than happy to concede the point. Especially if it means we can go a day without talking about who the GOAT is.

    There are actually other aspects to the game of football.

  13. Everyone’s problem with Peyton Manning were his performances in the playoffs. He threw like 3 touchdowns to 5 interceptions in four super bowls, with two of those interceptions being pick sixes. Remember that big blowout loss against the Seahawks? Not to mention, Peyton had nine one and dones. Look at how he won his two championships in those seasons. He threw 3 touchdowns to 7 interceptions in the playoffs on the 2006 Colts, and he threw 17 picks in the regular season back in 2015. His coach benched him in favor for Brock Osweiler as well.

  14. “throw for throw, read for read.” What the heck kind of delineator is that? May as well revert to the contrived, manufactured “Greatest Regular Season Quarterback.”

  15. Graham did not win 7 in the NFL. He won 3. He was king of something called the AAFC before that. Yankees, Dodgers, Dons, and Rockets were half the league.

  16. Usually when I say this PFT doesn’t allow the comment, but yea, this isn’t fantasy or stat football, it’s wins and losses.

    Brady is the best of all time, ever. Montana and Bradshaw are tied for second, then Aikman, then the Mannings and then every one else who one once. Marino, Fouts, Rivers etc don’t make the list.

  17. Put Brady in the old-era game — where QBs called the plays, DLs could head-slap and do pretty-much anything against OLs,

    —————————
    merde4brains,

    Your point doesn’t hold water, because Brady is the best ever at handling pressure, like Saints’ Cam Jordan said : “When you’re releasing the ball at 2.5 seconds, it doesn’t matter what offensive line is in front of him.”

    Further, because Brady stayed in a small pocket, so when he was hit, it is like he is hit by a bike. When other QB like Montana were hit out of pocket, they were hit by a car.

    We saw what Brady did in playoff when he had the weapons, 4 straight games of 30 or more points. If he had the stacked teams like Montana had or Bradshaw had, he would have had no problem winning multiple SB.

  18. William Lee said: Your point doesn’t hold water, because Brady is the best ever at handling pressure, like Saints’ Cam Jordan said : “When you’re releasing the ball at 2.5 seconds, it doesn’t matter what offensive line is in front of him.”

    ———-

    Do you think Brady could get rid of the ball in 2.5 seconds if his WRs were being mugged and harassed everywhere, not just within 5 yards of the LOS (as the modern rules state)? NOT A CHANCE! Brady is a statue, he’d be hit ALMOST EVERY pass play and he sure as heck wouldn’t last 10 seasons.

  19. “Usually when I say this PFT doesn’t allow the comment, but yea, this isn’t fantasy or stat football, it’s wins and losses.

    Brady is the best of all time, ever. Montana and Bradshaw are tied for second, then Aikman, then the Mannings and then every one else who one once. Marino, Fouts, Rivers etc don’t make the list.”

    Football is a team game, and wins & losses are team stats.

  20. Clearly you’re just going by rings which is why it should only be part of the equation. Ridiculous to put Aikman and Bradshaw ahead of Peyton just based on rings. You probably think Plunkett was better than Marino…

    ———————

    jimjets says:
    March 4, 2021 at 1:48 pm
    Usually when I say this PFT doesn’t allow the comment, but yea, this isn’t fantasy or stat football, it’s wins and losses.

    Brady is the best of all time, ever. Montana and Bradshaw are tied for second, then Aikman, then the Mannings and then every one else who one once. Marino, Fouts, Rivers etc don’t make the list.

  21. Do you think Brady could get rid of the ball in 2.5 seconds if his WRs were being mugged and harassed everywhere,
    —————————
    merde4brains,

    Did it ever occur to you that the reason Pats receivers were wide open underneath was that Brady was able to throw the balls a fraction of one second quicker, meaning, defenders were 2 or 3 yards further away from his intended receivers?

    Now you know why Mahomes didn’t dink n dunk in SB. It has nothing to do with QB’s physical ability. You can have a QB who throws 10,000 yards and 100 TD in 16 games, he won’t be able to do what Brady has done.

  22. Guys, its Ok—it’s not even close anymore. Not by any measure you can make.

    There are other debates but this isn’t one of them. When all the experts agree, it’s time to pay attention.

  23. Based on the number of championships, it is not much of a debate. Brady wins. However, it’s very unlikely Brady would have played into his 40’s if he were playing in the 80’s against Lawrence Taylor with no rules protecting him from shots to the knees and helmet to helmet hits. There are also minor rule changes such as kickoff touchbacks starting at the 25 instead of the 20 that impacted offenses, nonetheless.

    If Montana hadn’t had to retire at a younger age due to injuries, it’s very likely that their career MVP’s and Super Bowl wins would have been comparable. One area where Montana will always hold an edge over Brady is Super Bowl winning percentage. Joe never lost one.

  24. kgbdk says:
    March 4, 2021 at 6:42 pm

    One area where Montana will always hold an edge over Brady is Super Bowl winning percentage. Joe never lost one.
    ———————————————————————
    Of all the arguments for Montana that could be made, this is without question the worst. How do you give a guy bonus points for losing in the NFC Championship game?
    A better way to look at it would be to say that in Brady’s 8th, 9th and 10th best seasons he lost in the SB, in Montana’s 8th, 9th and 10th best seasons he was bounced from the playoffs in the FIRST ROUND.

  25. You people are giving Goof Ball Brady too much credit for mediocre play. He did nothing special in this SB and most of the others.

    Did you see the way he played against the Packers in the NFC Championship Game? I thought the clown was trying to lose that game on purpose.

  26. kgbdk says:
    March 4, 2021 at 6:42 pm

    One area where Montana will always hold an edge over Brady is Super Bowl winning percentage. Joe never lost one.
    ————-
    That’s not an edge.

    I mean Trent Dilfer never lost a Super Bowl.

  27. theconfluence says:
    March 4, 2021 at 7:04 pm

    Of all the arguments for Montana that could be made, this is without question the worst. How do you give a guy bonus points for losing in the NFC Championship game?
    A better way to look at it would be to say that in Brady’s 8th, 9th and 10th best seasons he lost in the SB, in Montana’s 8th, 9th and 10th best seasons he was bounced from the playoffs in the FIRST ROUND.

    —-
    7 gold medals and 3 silvers >>>> 4 gold medals and no silvers.

  28. Brady won 2 super bowls in his first 3 seasons, all of them were before the Polian/Colts rule changes to neuter defenses in favor of a passing game.

    So why couldn’t Brady have become GOAT in a different era?

  29. I agree Brady is the GOAT but I think it should be counted as a different era. The defenses are not the same when Montana, Bradshaw and others played. The game has evolved over the years so have the players,

  30. According to a certain expert Brady was only the 15th best Qb in the league last year. Won’t mention any names but his analysis is known for being SIMMplistic.

  31. Of all the arguments for Montana that could be made, this is without question the worst. How do you give a guy bonus points for losing in the NFC Championship game?
    ———

    While I understand your point in theory.. Montana only lost 2 NFCC Games..

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.