Deshaun Watson’s lawyer: First plaintiff sought $100K before filing suit

Getty Images

At a press conference at lawyer Tony Buzbee’s office on Tuesday, a woman named Ashley Solis revealed that she is the plaintiff in the first sexual assault lawsuit filed against Texans quarterback Deshaun Watson.

While it was the first time Solis publicly revealed her identity, it was not the first time Watson’s camp became aware that she was making those allegations. Watson’s lawyer Rusty Hardin released emails between Scott Gaffield, the general counsel for Watson’s agency Athletes First and Buzbee’s office regarding a demand of $100,000 to avoid the lawsuit while noting that Solis said she is not “doing this just for money.”

Hardin’s statement shares an email from Gaffield saying that they “don’t believe that the alleged facts show that Deshaun did anything wrong with regards to Ms. Solis” while asking “if Ms. Solis wanted to either help us understand the rationale behind the $100k demand or come back with a different figure.” It also includes Buzbee’s response from February 19.

“We made a legit demand. You rejected it,” Buzbee wrote. “We won’t be making another or bid against ourselves. We also won’t be having an extended dialogue about why you think your client did nothing wrong or how you want this to be a “learning” experience for your “high profile athlete,” as you refer to him. This is Houston, Texas. Perhaps you should find him a lawyer here so you can apprise both you and your client of the landscape here and who you are dealing with. Talk soon.”

Gaffield prepared a statement that was also included with the release from Hardin’s office.

“My email exchanges with Mr. Buzbee and [Buzbee’s associate] Ms. Brandfield-Harvey were very clear,” Gaffield wrote. “We did not think that the facts showed that Deshaun did anything wrong with their client. We believed then — and fully believe now — that Deshaun learned a lesson about putting himself in this type of situation by interacting with people he does not know. As the emails show, we were willing to continue discussions on Deshaun’s behalf to explore ways to prevent a lawsuit and a public spectacle. But Mr. Buzbee informed us that he was unwilling to do so. We expect that this matter will be resolved in court.”

75 responses to “Deshaun Watson’s lawyer: First plaintiff sought $100K before filing suit

  1. I have a feeling that $100,000 will very soon sound like a bargain to Watson. It may turn out to have been the price for the rest of his life as he knew it.

  2. Wow…if true – Deshawn and his lawyer completely blew this by not paying it. Now she is in line to get 10x that -/ PLUS Deshawn is going to lose $15M + in salary with his suspension.

  3. $100k x 22 plaintiffs = 2.2 million, a figure which probably now seems like a bargain, versus what this will eventually cost Watson.

  4. If the timing and the close proximity between the owner of the Texans and this Buzzbee fellow does not strike you in any way as peculiar, then you have zero intuition. Not to add the fact there wasn’t a weapon or any language used here or shown to us that proves he made anyone do anything. What happened to calling the police at the scene of a crime? Not to say he didn’t do anything over the boundary, but sex trafficking sounds waaaay too much here!

  5. IF Watson would have paid the $100K, you can bet that Buzbee would have demanded the same for every one of the other “plaintiffs”.

    This sure sounds like a shakedown. Buzbee was counting on the fact that Watson would know that simply being accused of these crimes would cost him millions in future revenue.

    The timing of the accusations, just when other teams would start bidding to get Watson, likely played into Buzbee’s decision to create the lawsuits.

  6. “We believed then — and fully believe now — that Deshaun learned a lesson about putting himself in this type of situation by interacting with people he does not know.”

    ——————————————————————————-

    Apparently not because one of the latest allegations was from March of this year.

  7. All the people here saying he should have paid are assuming guilt against this brother already and that is sad.

  8. I don’t see how the league can suspend him without pay without doing anything. Is he just suppose to just pay these gold diggers whenever they come ask for money. He should have the right to defend himself in court. But either way lets says if he is guilty i don’t see how these victims get paid. Assuming the Texans got after his signing bonus for the contract extension that takes away 27 million plus all the endorsement he will lose he will end up filing for bankruptcy and these girls get no money.

  9. If he did nothing wrong, and I’m not saying he did or didn’t, why would your response be “come back with a different number”

    And how does it seem like he learned his lesson in this type of situation. I definitely don’t think he did

  10. Sniff, sniff. Believe me. I am a “victim” who wants to get paid. I mean that’s the most important thing here.

  11. This is Houston, Texas. Perhaps you should find him a lawyer here so you can apprise both you and your client of the landscape here and who you are dealing with. Talk soon.”

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

    Buzbee personifies the old saying: “The only thing wrong with Texas is that it’s full of Texans.”

    Can’t we just give it back to Mexico and be done with it already?

  12. I’m going to set the over/under on how many times Buzbee used the word “uppity” today at 2.5.

    How about thumbs up for over and thumbs down for under.

  13. One thing is for sure. Hardin is already a winner here with his retainer and legal fees, and Buzbee is already a big winner in terms of free advertising. Hasn’t even gone to court yet and the attorneys are victorious already, and only stand to make much more.

  14. Didn’t watch the video, so not sure, but is her quote “it’s not just about the money” entirely accurate? The word JUST has HUGE meaning for Watson’s defense – it can literally be read as “this IS about money and other things”.

    Dunno folks. Is someone that feels violated really thinking about money? Don’t get me wrong, with this many people accusing him, I don’t doubt that he’s done MORE than a little wrong here – but any accuser saying “it’s not just about the money” is weak at best.

  15. smartestguyintheroom says:
    April 6, 2021 at 5:15 pm
    Pretty damning. Nothing but a shakedown.
    _______________________
    Making a settlement demand is not a “shakedown.” It’s a settlement offer. It means very little as to whether the underlying allegations are true or not. Our civil justice system is designed to strongly encourage settlements. A pre-litigation settlement demand is extremely common. And, yes, I’m an attorney involved in civil litigation every day.

  16. Man this is getting insanely messier by the day. Outside of my opinions on Tony Buzbee being an attention seeker, I really don’t know what to think. In the case of some athletes that I won’t name, there’s been room to see that they have done some inappropriate things. But the further this one goes the more back and forth and convoluted it becomes

  17. Probably should’ve paid her. Now you’ve got 21 other women who’ve come forward lol

  18. Why isn’t anybody talking about the fact that this is happening at a time where Watson and the Texans are navigating an unamicable split? Remember a few years ago when Dez Bryant was looking for a new contract and all of a sudden this mystery “Walmart Video” threatened to make the Ray Rice situation look like a play fight?

    ps – the video doesn’t and never did exist. It is impossible to trust anybody’s word in these situations when millions of dollars are at stake.

  19. I haven’t seena denial that he didn’t sexually assault them. Just a lot of lawyer deflectionary attempts.

    He’ll be paying a lot more than that now.

  20. It’s not about money… but your initial conversation is a 100k shakedown with absolutely no room to negotiate. In my opinion, Watson looks bad as more potential victims come forward. But Buzbee looks even worse with his false claims (it’s not about money, we’re not going to be in the media, etc) and the way he has handled this overall. If I were a potential victim, I would run as far away from Buzbee as I could and hire someone else.

  21. 22 or 24 women whatever the number is and not one of them went to the police? Right

  22. ‘Come back with a different figure”… means that Watson did something to this lady,but they didn’t want pay 100 grand to make her go away. Why else would they say that?

  23. Lawyers for the plantiffs usually provide free service in these lawsuits and will only get paid if they win, but if they win they take most of the money.

  24. Who is afraid to surmise that this whole show isnt being orchestrated by the Texans….saves them a ton of cash to dump a player that doesnt want to be there…just a thought?

  25. It’s not about money, but she never went to the cops and asked for money before filing the lawsuit…I’m going to go out on a limb and guess she wasn’t going to donate that money to organizations that help victims of sexual assault…

  26. Those who say Watson should have paid the 100k seem to forget that would have been the floor for the other 20+ alleged victims. It appears Buzbee didn’t account for Watson not falling for his shakedown attempt, nor did he ever intend for the Houston Police Department to get involved.

    The Houston Police Department should look at this from all angles and determine if Watson is a serial sexual assaulter and/or the victim of extortion.

  27. chawkup says:
    April 6, 2021 at 5:53 pm
    smartestguyintheroom says:
    April 6, 2021 at 5:15 pm
    Pretty damning. Nothing but a shakedown.
    _______________________
    Making a settlement demand is not a “shakedown.” It’s a settlement offer. It means very little as to whether the underlying allegations are true or not. Our civil justice system is designed to strongly encourage settlements. A pre-litigation settlement demand is extremely common. And, yes, I’m an attorney involved in civil litigation every day.
    ———————————————

    I am aware how civil litigation works. I am not saying it’s a shakedown on the basis of one settlement proposal. That is but one piece of the puzzle. Buzbee has trotted out 22 of these suits at this time, so there are many pieces to evaluate in the overall puzzle. To this point he has not presented any credible evidence despite his insistence that he has and will. Will he at some point? We shall see. Hardin has at least provided evidence that refuted Buzbee’s claims of HPD involvement (at that time) and of Buzbee grandstanding and rolling out vague intimidation tactics about not knowing the local landscape. I’m sure that is also done all the time, again, for intimidation as part of a shakedown. Now that HPD is involved, let’s see what they uncover. My guess is nothing, and not because of Hardin family connections that Buzbee is already claiming. He’s trying to distract from the facts, use intimidation and scare Watson into a settlement. Those are tactics civil litigators use. Often as part of a shakedown.

  28. Had he paid the one off the attorney had another 21 in line.. Dont think that attorney was stopping after the 1st payment…

  29. Look, none of us knows what happened between Watson and any of these therapists. But we DO know that Buzbee has handled this situation like a snake oil salesman and con man. He has done nothing to help the credibility of the accusers.

    This whole thing feels off and slimy. It feels like a public lynching – and yes, I chose that word on purpose.

    To people asking why McNair would be involved – because at some point teaching Watson (and present & future Texans) a lesson about respect and who’s really in charge? That may be crazy, but you tell me that Buzbee’s tactics have seemed like an attempt to take allegations of sexual assault seriously.

  30. I’m of the opinion that Watson did behave inappropriately with some or all of these women. I am also of the opinion that these women and their lawyer are a collection of gold diggers and vultures who care more about a payday than getting justice for sexual assault.

  31. “I can no longer practice the profession I love the most without my hands shaking during the session. I got into massage therapy to heal people. To heal their minds and bodies. To bring peace to their souls. Deshaun Watson has robbed me of that. He also robbed me of $100k…..*sniff*”

  32. Scott Baily says:
    April 6, 2021 at 6:27 pm
    Had he paid the one off the attorney had another 21 in line.. Dont think that attorney was stopping after the 1st payment…

    ———
    If Watson had just “taken care” of himself he could have saved a lot of aggravation

  33. His lawyers responded by saying let’s use this as a learning lesson for all involved, and then mentioned perhaps we’d settle for less? Since then Watson had contacted MANY other therapists, so apparently he hasn’t learned the most basic lesson that as a high profile athlete he shouldn’t put himself in those types of situations, and meet women alone with no other witnesses in hotel rooms for massage sessions. He’s starting to look very guilty this isn’t going to end well for him

  34. A very interesting point here….

    Had Deshaun Watson settled with this woman for the reported 100k then that would also assume that she would remain silent…

    What would happen to the whole mentally injured, hero, can’t stay silent, protect other women thing at that point?

    No matter what happens and whether he is guilty or not of something, this accuser lost a lot of credibility with this discovery and that whole hero angle is gone.

  35. Had he paid then1st client, Buzbee then woukdve demanded the payout for every single client. When they say enough is enough, then he’ll use the other settlements against him.

    DeShawn was right for not settling. This is all about money.

  36. So……………..she offered DW a chance to settle out of court, he declined and she filed suit. Sounds like standard stuff. Now, let it play out in court and whatever happens, happens.

  37. Quite frankly, unless and until Buzbee takes his charges to court, I’ll continue to consider Buzbee to be a greedy charlatan.

    Look at how long this has been going on without going to court.

    And since these are CIVIL charges, any court case would only require a simple jury majority to win.

  38. I have no idea if these allegations are true or not, but you have to wonder why Watson went through so many massage therapist’s. Could it be that they refused to accept any other appointments from him, that appears to be likely.

  39. Buzzard didn’t attempt mediation or arbitration on this matter. He went right to the press to create maximum leverage. Without question, this was and is a shakedown. Did Watson physically touch any of these women? Not from what we are hearing. Did he expose himself to them? Probably (which can be argued, frequently happens during a massage). Did he say suggestive things? Possibly, also possibly with double entendre. Does this all add up to sexual harassment? Possibly. But what are the damages experienced by these women? Is it the first time anyone has come on to them on the massage table? Doubtful. But all the others probably had a net worth of $150,000, not $50M, so it wasn’t worth their time. So, at the end of the day, what are the damages that can be reasonably proven? This isn’t the traditional workplace where some scumbag attempts to use sex to advance a woman or keep a woman down. I think if this goes to civil court, they’ll be lucky to get $25,000 each. And that’s why Buzzard is pressing the matter now.

  40. Those who say Watson should have paid the 100k seem to forget that would have been the floor for the other 20+ alleged victims. It appears Buzbee didn’t account for Watson not falling for his shakedown attempt, nor did he ever intend for the Houston Police Department to get involved.

    The Houston Police Department should look at this from all angles and determine if Watson is a serial sexual assaulter and/or the victim of extortion.
    —————————————————————————————–
    And Buzbee has already built a get out of jail free card by stating he does not believe the HPD will be fair, knowing that they very well may find nothing but a guy who wanted to fulfill a sexual fantasy.
    One woman already said that Watson told her BEFORE that he wanted more than a sports massage…..so she never inquired what he meant by that? Then went to his home to perform said massage.

    Give me a break….t5hey know there is little there…..they are using the volume of incidents to try and bury the guy based on Public overeaction.

  41. Even if Watson didn’t do anything wrong, what in the world was he thinking going all over Houston to get massages from random women advertising on the internet? As dubious as some of their claims are against him, he sure looks guilty.

    Get out the checkbook and plan on a good long suspension from the NFL.

  42. its not “just” about the money, but its at least 99.9999% about the money.

  43. Extortion is a funny thing. Lets say you were extorting someone you caught cheating on their wife. Okay, what you’re doing is wrong and maybe illegal depending on how you did it, BUT you still cheated on your wife. I think people are getting their outrage out to smokescreen that Watson maybe was doing something he wasn’t supposed to do. Just because someone saw dollar signs doesn’t mean he didn’t do it.

  44. I have one honest question: Why is any of this happening?

    A) Massage therapists are gold-diggers
    B) Bad and corrupt things happen in Texas
    C) Deshaun Watson has a pattern of unacceptable behavior
    D) Lawyers are shameless liars
    E) Abusive men are getting called out in today’s culture
    F) All of the above

  45. “I don’t think you are.”

    I suppose you are entitled to your opinion, despite being incorrect.

  46. This “Lawyer ” is a idiot/ scammer. He is going about tainting the jury pool for.. the….country. Find a impartial Jury. Find one. Innocent until proven guilty people.

  47. So far, this appears to be a “She said / He said” kind of case … very difficult to prove, one way or the other. I’m sure it’s been hard times for many massage therapist with all the Covid problems … and after this – it’s going to be even more difficult for these one-on-one kind of sessions. A case like this might just change how the entire industry conducts business.

  48. This is all drummed up by Houston Texans. “If we can’t have you….no one can!”

  49. This is just an attempt to extort money. No police reports were ever filed. I hope Watson defends himself, and counter-sues the women and the attorney for millions, and then donates the money to a battered women’s shelter. If this is a false claim, this woman and her attorney should rot in jail for a very long time.

  50. It appears that the plaintiffs and Buzbee are attempting to exploit a loophole in the law that does not appear to cover physical therapy massages that the recipient may or may not have attempted to divert from their original purpose. Absent any physical trauma suffered by the plaintiffs, or a third party witness, this is at best a ‘she said, he said’ case. Let’s see which side blinks first…

    or, as a wise philosopher once stated… “Streight cash, homie!”

  51. Watson would be wise to capitulate and and apologize to Houston and say he will honor his contract fully.

  52. To all those saying he shoulda settled (and I agree)….

    It would have come out later no matter.
    These things always come out, eventually

  53. Just because she sought 100K doesn’t mean it absolves Dehaun Watson of any guilt. It in fact exemplifies it that she has gone public with her case. Deshaun Watson is in deep doo doo with 22 women and more accusing him of sexual misconduct that is predatory in nature.

  54. Hardin’s attorney appears to be an idiot. Did he not realize what the email said? With Gaffield stating “come back with different figures” it appears to be a smoking gun, a confession of guilt of Watson, trying to low ball the victim. Good luck with a jury, dude.

  55. The lawyer for those 22 women, Buzbee, stands to make one heck of a payday if he wins every case…As for Watson: at what point is he going to settle before it becomes a hemorrhage..??

  56. This situation speaks volumes for how broken our justice system is. I think in many ways it would be better served if records concerning civil cases were sealed until both parties agree to release them.

    Watson, if he has done something criminally wrong he should be tried with the full knowledge of the public on that CRIMINAL activity. But in a civil case, win OR lose, his reputation will suffer, because the situation is out there for the public to see. THAT is what Buzbee is counting on and THAT is why these sorts of cases become “nothing but a shakedown”.

  57. Choices. So far…..it appears that all involved had choices. Poor decisions were made. Apparently. But nobody has yet to use the word FORCE. All we are hearing so far is bad decision making. So far it seems as if all involved had a choice. Idk.

  58. This has no bearing on anything, it’s just a question that came into my head. Don’t they train massage therapists how to deal with customers who want to cross a line? It’s a generally intimate process and, to complicate things, it is mischaracterized and sexualized in our society more often than not.

    Surely there is some form of protection for therapists who go into client’s homes? Someone they can report clients to? Some overseeing organization to help them?

  59. If Watson believes hes innocent, then he shouldnt pay these women a dime and let it play out in court. Paying them anything wpuld be a sign of guilt and would tarnish his name and career.

  60. Michael Nguyen says:
    April 6, 2021 at 5:34 pm
    I don’t see how the league can suspend him without pay without doing anything. Is he just suppose to just pay these gold diggers whenever they come ask for money. He should have the right to defend himself in court. But either way lets says if he is guilty i don’t see how these victims get paid. Assuming the Texans got after his signing bonus for the contract extension that takes away 27 million plus all the endorsement he will lose he will end up filing for bankruptcy and these girls get no money.

    ————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————

    They did this to Zeke Elliot over 1 complaint. Because Watson is a QB they are taking their time. If it were any other position they would have suspended him already. Also, he has money already, they would go after that.

  61. With lawsuits routinely asking for tens of millions of dollars, and knowing that settlements are rarely as high as the opening ask, how is $100K supposed to be a shakedown? Answer: it’s not.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.