Eagles’ choice of Milton Williams wasn’t met with enthusiasm from entire draft room

Dallas Cowboys v Philadelphia Eagles
Getty Images

Televised shots from draft rooms around the league have shown owners, front office personnel, coaches, scouts and other staffers celebrating picks in the first three rounds. They are always something of a photo op.

But the Eagles’ third-round selection of Louisiana Tech defensive lineman Milton Williams didn’t deliver the expected reaction from everyone in the room.

The ABC draft broadcast showed General Manager Howie Roseman in a discussion with senior football advisor Tom Donahoe. Roseman extended a fist bump to Donahoe, who half-heartedly returned the gesture.

Donahoe shrugged, keeping his hands in his pockets, after Roseman said something to him. Roseman then extended his hands, as if in dismay, before ABC left the feed.

Roseman explained in his news conference the exchange was about losing out on a player in a trade down from No. 70. The Giants selected cornerback Aaron Robinson at No. 71 and the Lions took North Carolina State defensive tackle Alim McNeill at No. 72.

“These guys spend all year scouting these guys and you get favorites, guys you feel strongly about. We all do,” Roseman said, via Chris Franklin of NJ.com. “That’s the fun part of being in the draft room, the emotions of it.”

19 responses to “Eagles’ choice of Milton Williams wasn’t met with enthusiasm from entire draft room

  1. Half these guys in the first 3 rounds don’t make it. Maybe this guy will or won’t.

  2. Based on Roseman’s explanation, I can see why Donahue was unhappy. The Eagles are already loaded with low round picks in this mediocre draft. All the trade down netted the Eagles was a 6th round pick that the team didn’t need. No reason why not to stay put.

  3. The Eagles quality on the field has been decreasing. And their process to acquire and improve talent has been decreasing off the field also. Drama not talented seems a better adjective for a year or more and if they weren’t in that dumpster fire of a division they would be in even worse shape. Can you imagine them in the AFC North or AFC West(just for competitive argument not geography) they would be getting their hat handed to them before halftime. Story could be right and it’s just scouts living and dying with their favorites. But as pointed out you don’t often see those optics on draft day

  4. Robinson is yet another a lot CB they don’t need. Need a #2 outside CB to pair with Slay.

  5. I understand that this type of stuff isn’t usually caught on camera, but if you honestly think everyone in the other 31 draft rooms all agree on their picks, you are way off.

  6. boogermcf says:
    May 1, 2021 at 12:11 am
    Based on Roseman’s explanation, I can see why Donahue was unhappy. The Eagles are already loaded with low round picks in this mediocre draft. All the trade down netted the Eagles was a 6th round pick that the team didn’t need. No reason why not to stay put.
    ——–
    I agree. And Howie also admitted that after they moved back 3 spots, some targets went off the board before their pick. My guess is cb Aaron Robinson was the target.

  7. Tom Donahoe. Sheesh, that guy is still baning around? I see now he’s in a job with no accountability like a GM has. He did a terrible job in Buffalo.

  8. The Eagles needed that Cornerback. As of now the Eagles have drafted 0 CBs and 0 LBs, their biggest weaknesses.

    The Eagles draft record with 4th round and lower picks are beyond horrible so they may as well say at this point they didn’t draft either of those positions.

    The Eagles need players who can play this year, not developmental long shots.

  9. boogermcf says:
    May 1, 2021 at 12:11 am

    Based on Roseman’s explanation, I can see why Donahue was unhappy. The Eagles are already loaded with low round picks in this mediocre draft. All the trade down netted the Eagles was a 6th round pick that the team didn’t need. No reason why not to stay put.
    ————————–

    The eagles wake up thinking ‘How can we screw the Giants today’. The Giants ‘needed’ Oline and sure enough the BYU OT was selected at 70. So the Giants take the Nicklel Back, which was not a need (great pick, though) and my guess for the swing and miss fist bump.

  10. On May 15th the Eagles will be having an open try out open to the public for the cornerback position.

  11. This is like the super bowl all over again. Howie woke up Friday and read all the positive comments about doing a great job in round 1 and hubris sets in and right back to stupid picks. What a waste all kinds of talent at 37 and 70 and we have no hope of getting a CB in this draft now just a total waste and 2 player who probably see no real time playing.

    Mr Laurie fire Howie

  12. Enjoy that 6th round pick, Howie. We didn’t really need help at corner.

    What does it take for this man to lose the job he is not fit to hold

  13. Milton will quietly clog the middle for years to come, but DT is not a high stat position. As a result, many Philly fans will continue to call him a bust no matter how good he is at taking on double teams while other guys grab the glory. They won’t notice.

    And this video will follow him throughout his career just because Tom Donahoe wasn’t grown up enough to do the right thing, and give his boss a fist bump with the cameras rolling. Donahoe should be ashamed of himself for what he just did to this kid’s career. Pretty selfish of him.

  14. Watching Roseman sprinting around that room trying to force enthusiasm for the camera feed with his bouncy extra super happy fist-bumping was this draft’s underrated most hilarious moments.

    Howie has no peer in the manipulation game. None.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.