DeMaurice Smith decries “stupidity” of recent comments from Bills G.M. Brandon Beane on vaccinations

NFL: JAN 30 Super Bowl LIV - NFLPA Press Conference
Getty Images

The NFL Players Association stopped short of issuing a statement in response to comments from Bills G.M. Brandon Beane regarding his inclination to cut players who opted not to get the COVID-19 vaccine, since the NFL spoke to Beane about his remarks.

At Monday’s annual Sports Lawyers Association conference, NFLPA executive DeMaurice Smith chimed in on Beane’s remarks.

“When a General Manager speaks out and says something that is not only inconsistent with league policy, but just has a rank disregard for the rights of our players, I don’t know any other way of characterizing that other than just the stupidity that underlines it,” Smith said, via Liz Mullen of Sports Business Journal.

NFL general counsel Jeff Pash, also speaking at the conference, did not mention the Bills or Beane when confirming the rules that apply. “Our labor agreement is pretty clear on what grounds you can and can’t release a player for, and there is not a requirement that players be vaccinated,” Pash said.

The reality is that Beane got in trouble for saying the quiet part out loud. With clear incentives available for players who are vaccinated, teams will know which players have and haven’t gotten it. If a G.M. who prefers to have as many vaccinated players on the team as possible allows that to become a factor in the assessment of the close calls on the roster without saying or doing anything to generate evidence of it, how would the league or the union prove that it happened?

For players deciding whether to get vaccinated, it’s important to understand this reality. Teams will know if you haven’t been vaccinated, and it’s entirely possible that your coach, G.M., or owner will hold that fact against you when it’s time to trim the roster. As long as they keep quiet about it, there’s really nothing anyone can do to stop it from happening.

37 responses to “DeMaurice Smith decries “stupidity” of recent comments from Bills G.M. Brandon Beane on vaccinations

  1. This guy Smith has a ton of nerve. He’s advising players to stay home and skip workouts. That is as certain to get a player cut as much as not getting a vaccine shot.
    Brandon was an easy target for Smith to go after because he knows his union looks ridiculous after what just happened to the Broncos player. He’s got to say something to give the (false) impression he’s behind his players.

  2. Welcome to the new world. If you choose not to get vaccinated, you need to accept the consequences of your actions. For better or worse. Not sure why this is so controversial.

  3. The sooner everyone gets the vaccine, the sooner we can all move on with our lives.

    People not getting the vaccine just increases the chance of some variant growing that the vaccine doesn’t work on, and then we have to repeat 2020 all over again.

    I don’t want to repeat 2020 all over again.

  4. if were looking at cutting players, and two players have similar skill sets, or are at an equal level in skill sets, its likely the one who gets cut…
    .
    is a bad for four the locker room,
    has off field issues
    has previously been suspended by the NFL
    hasnt been vaccinated
    .
    to pretend things like these don’t factor in is just an insult to one’s own intelligence

  5. Why the NFLPA continues to employ this clown is one of the greatest mysteries of the world. He has done nothing but constantly hurt the NFLPA and make them look like the biggest laughing stock of a union in pro sports.

  6. you know he meant expendable guys that could certainly be cut beyond a shadow of a doubt that the reason was not being vaxxed.

  7. I’m hoping all the players get vaccinated so we can do away with this issue.

  8. It depends on the vaccine. I wouldn’t want any of my players to get the Johnson and Johnson vaccine.

  9. This guy is the worst! Terrible and has been for years. Please fire him today

  10. This guy calling other peoples actions stupidity, when he hid behiind the NFLPA’s message for players to stay home. Work out somewhere else. Don’t follow the details of your contract….Really? NFL players who like and or support D smith, you deserve what you get by employing this clown.

  11. Weird times when science and facts are things up for debate. Dont get vaccinated, dont wear a mask–nature will work this out and it will be a better world for the rest of us.

  12. The real stupidity lies with the people who refuse to get vaccinated. If/when they get Covid-19 the medical community should turn them away and refuse treatment. I’m tired of those in denial changing their tune as soon as they get sick. To quote the Darwin awards,” removing them from the gene pool” only improves society.

  13. Beane’s comments made total sense. It wasn’t about judging a player for not getting vaccinated, it was about reaching a certain percentage of players who are vaccinated so that certain group team activities could be enacted.

    So yes, if cutting one player over another means the team can have more meaningful group practices then guess who’s getting cut?

  14. As long as you get your football, who cares?
    Human rights? Irrelevant.
    NFL Teams can do whatever they want.
    So can any corporation.

    Happy now?

  15. Smith is desperate to take attention off all the stupid advice he’s been giving players.

  16. The Johnson & Johnson vaccine is as, if not more, effective as Pfizer and Moderna among the general population. The 6 (SIX) instances of blood clotting issues out of 7 million doses were in patients predisposed to the condition due to some forms of birth control. It took less than a week for immunologists to prep those administering the shots on protocols to combat the extremely rare occurrences.

  17. I’d cut them! Not getting vaccinated during a world pandemic and setting the stage to impact the health and welfare of your teammates and your season says you’re not a team player!

  18. The only stupidity I see once again comes from the mouth of DSmith . Not getting vaccinated is just a continuation of the stupidity that allowed Covid to ravage the country last year .

  19. This
    curtis20 says:
    May 18, 2021 at 1:24 pm
    This guy is the worst! Terrible and has been for years. Please fire him today
    I’ll agree, Smith has to be the Worst!!!

  20. If anyone would know stupidity, it’s DeMaurice Smith. He’s an expert practitioner of it. What Beane said was a statement of the obvious.

  21. Threatening to fire employees for refusing an mRNA implant (that’s right, not a vaccine by definition) that is only authorized for emergency use is morally wrong, and not even logical considering it’s now available to anyone who wants it.

  22. You cannot mandate experimental drugs injections per the Nuremberg Code. The NFL is treading dangerous ground that could result in a massive lawsuit for enforcing something that cannot be enforced. In addition, per HIPAA, you cannot force disclosure of vaccinations and health. It’s a privacy issue.

  23. Beane should have stated the obvious more clearly, that “for marginal players, being vaccinated or not might become a tie-breaker as far as roster cuts are concerned.”

    Smith is doing his job but he shouldn’t get into the habit of calling other people stupid. It’s wrong on numerous levels.

  24. It’s ones choice weather to get the injection. Look at the Yankees they got the injection and some of their players came down with covid. So what’s the point in getting it, doesn’t stop you from catching it. Time to move on.

  25. Let’s apply this same logic to a plethora of other issues “for society’s good”, shall we? Would you same people saying “if you choose not get vaccinated, you deal with the consequences” agree with a GM that stated he would not keep players that are delinquent in child support payments? WHat really is more of a burden on our society- unvaccinated people or fatherless children?

  26. mackcarrington says:
    May 18, 2021 at 1:10 pm
    This guy Smith has a ton of nerve. He’s advising players to stay home and skip workouts. That is as certain to get a player cut as much as not getting a vaccine shot.
    Brandon was an easy target for Smith to go after because he knows his union looks ridiculous after what just happened to the Broncos player. He’s got to say something to give the (false) impression he’s behind his players.

    =====================================================================
    I think these are 2 different situations. NFLPA approved the “voluntary workouts” and the reasons a player could/could not be cut. You can’t cut a player for missing voluntary workouts and you can’t cut a player for not get vaccinated. The Broncos jumped at the opportunity to save money and create cap space. He is behind the players, but for some reason, they (NFLPA) agreed that a player could be cut if injured while working out away from the team facility.

  27. bcknights says:
    May 18, 2021 at 2:40 pm
    It’s ones choice weather to get the injection. Look at the Yankees they got the injection and some of their players came down with covid. So what’s the point in getting it, doesn’t stop you from catching it. Time to move on.

    ———————————————-

    Vaccination might not prevent contracting the virus but supposedly the virus will not be as severe.

  28. Quite the number of ***hat comments in here. Refuse treatment if they get sick and are unvaxed? Yeah, ok. Do people who don’t get a flu shot get turned away if they get the flu? Nope. Do people get turned away if they get lung cancer, but never smoked? Nope. The list could go on. The self righteousness of the “I’m vaccinated” crowd is getting ridiculous. There’s a reason that they’re throwing away thousands of doses per day that have expired. There’s a reason that only 35-40% of the people have lined up to get it already. For all of you ***hats who think that your self righteous indignation is cause to force someone else to get it, remember the majority is on the other side. Me? I’m transvaccinal. I haven’t physically gotten the vaccine, but I identify as vaccinated. You’re a bigot if you try to tell me otherwise.

  29. sponz says:
    May 18, 2021 at 1:34 pm
    The real stupidity lies with the people who refuse to get vaccinated. If/when they get Covid-19 the medical community should turn them away and refuse treatment. I’m tired of those in denial changing their tune as soon as they get sick. To quote the Darwin awards,” removing them from the gene pool” only improves society.
    __________________________________________________________________________________________________

    And I am saying the exact same thing about every person that lined up for the jab. It is not a vaccine. It is an RNA-altering treatment which is semi-effective at best. I don’t take treatment for something that I don’t have. I don’t take Advil daily just because its possible I may get a headache at some point. I wish you nothing but good health!! But I am not lining up to be a human guinea pig.

  30. Nothing wrong with what Beane said. Basically if having enough players vaccinated will make their operation and meetings better, it is an advantage. If that means cutting a borderline roster player, it can come to that. That would be a “smart” move.

    Calling him stupid when you told players not to work out at their team facilities, which will be safer and under stricter health protocols than any private gym, for the benefit of what? Nothing but stupid union vs employer tactics that get you nowhere and leave players out of money. Why guys like this get these positions, I have no clue.

  31. The NFLPA is totally willing to stand up in ways that screw players, and unwilling to stand up in ways that help players. I wish the players had a real union to work with them, which they very much need and deserve, but instead they have the NFLPA.

  32. Everyone keeps misspelling the word injection.

    This is not a vaccination, it is an injection. In no point in history has a mRNA mutating injection been approved for general use as a vaccine. A vaccine is the introduction to dead or near dead virus cells. This injection causes your mRNA to grow new proteins (mutate).

  33. why would anyone get injected with something that is NOT FDA APPROVED?? Are you kidding me??? this country can’t figure out Margarine vs Butter, Corporate greed (check out Prizer’s profit) is insane

    we live in a world where people are beating the snot out of each other on TV as CNN tells you they’re peaceful gatherings, Bill Clinton is the keynote speaker at events promoting women, Cardi B’s W-A-P is song of the year but “Baby it’s cold outside” is inappropriate, Jeffrey Epstein killed himself.

    Getting Vaxxed does NOT PREVENT YOU FROM GETTING OR TRANSMITTING COVID!! Think for yourself people!! what the hell is wrong with waiting?

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.