Matt Nagy: We’re going to stick with Andy Dalton No. 1, Justin Fields No. 2

USA TODAY Sports

Justin Fields said in May that he’s going to push to be the starting quarterback for the Bears, but the word from the team has been that they’re pretty set on starting Andy Dalton to kick off the 2021 season.

Head coach Matt Nagy said that after the team traded up to take Fields, reiterated it last month and PFT reported this month that the Bears told Dalton he would be the No. 1 quarterback when he was drafted. Nagy has pointed to his experience in Kansas City with Alex Smith and Patrick Mahomes in 2017 as a blueprint for how the Bears plan to move forward this season.

During an appearance on Cris Collinsworth’s podcast this week, Collinsworth asked Nagy if there’s any scenario he could envision changing courses before the start of the regular season.

“No, I mean, Andy is our starter. Again, I can’t predict anything. You know how it goes. There’s so many things that can happen between today and that Week 1, but Andy is our starter and Justin is our No. 2 and we’re going to stick to this plan,” Nagy said. “You always hope nothing happens to Andy as far as injuries or anything like that and that’s why I can’t say 100 percent . . . Andy is where we want him to be, he’s had a great OTAs and we’re just gonna continue to build with that.”

The Chiefs won 10 games and went to the playoffs in 2017, which made it much easier to stick with Smith while letting Mahomes develop. Nagy says that’s how things will go in Chicago “in a perfect world,” but there’s no guarantee lightning’s going to strike twice.

39 responses to “Matt Nagy: We’re going to stick with Andy Dalton No. 1, Justin Fields No. 2

  1. Word out of early team activities is that Fields is significantly outplaying Andy Dalton. With an emphasis on “significantly”. Nagy may not have a choice unless his bosses don’t feel winning is all that important.

  2. As a lifelong Bear fan, I am OK with Dalton starting, and hopefully playing most of the year. Let Justin sit and learn, as he will be the one to take the Bears to the Super Bowl within a few years. The Green Bay reign on the NFC North is OVER.

  3. Foles brought them to the playoffs last year and isn’t even being discussed

  4. “But let me assure bear nation. As soon as number two is ready to take over as 1, I assure you 2 will be ready and that will be my first priority after a number 2”

  5. The Bears are playing chess while the Packers and Vikings are playing checkers. And the Lions are playing…that’s too easy, I won’t make fun of them.

  6. correctingerrors says:
    June 15, 2021 at 4:07 pm

    Foles brought them to the playoffs last year and isn’t even being discussed
    __________________________________________________________

    Starts Win Lose
    Mitchell Trubisky 52 29 – 23
    Nick Foles 7 2 – 5

  7. This is the smart move. It’s like when the Bills went with Nathan Peterman week 1 in 2018, and Allen was the starter by half time.

  8. A lot of it may come down to if the defense rebounds this year. If they’re as average to borderline bad as they were last year, the Bears will need a lot of points and the extra pressure on the other team’s defense that Fields’ athleticism presents. But if Desai gets them back to a top 10-12 unit the offense has more margin for error and Dalton could stick in the lineup for a while.

  9. Dalton is a potential HOF QB (his numbers at this point are similar to Favre and Eli’s respectively). It’s very difficult for a rookie to come in and unseat a guy who may likely have 5 more good to great seasons left in him. Of course Fields will back him up. The Bears were actually decent under Trubisky (64% completion rate, 29-21 record, and a 1.72 TD to INT ratio). Trubisky only played 4 years and is 5th alltime in passing yards and they ran him out of town on a rail). Bear fans are nuts.

  10. CHI-TOWN HEAT

    As a Lions fan I say, ok, good zinger. As a lions fan I’d also say I think you got some pronouns mixed up you implied that Chi town is working its division foes and playing on another level…. Did you just come out of a 36 year coma? If not I question how you came to the conclusion you did? GB has been working us all in this division for awhile, you guys included. I’d give the Vikings the tiebreaker after that for 2 in recent history. And us oh yeah we’re in 4th, but we can reach out and say hi you guys live 1 floor above the basement? We’re neighbors! And as long as you have that GM/Coach/Yet to be proven QB your comment requires a laugh track.

  11. Dalton in HOF? Never won a damn thing. Farvrer and Eli actually won SBs and playoff games. Regular season stats mean so very little. If he somehow wins 2 SBs as a starting QB, maybe.

  12. Acutally as a life long Bear fan I’m intriqued with the Dalton signing. He has a winning record at a dysfunctional Bengel organization and put the Cowboys in a position to win the East last year. The longer JF has to learn without the frnachise on his back the better. I really like Chirs Simms idea of JF package of plays to insert at opportune time during a game to get JF some experience and see if his presence is disturbing to the opponents D.

  13. correctingerrors says:
    June 15, 2021 at 4:07 pm
    Foles brought them to the playoffs last year and isn’t even being discussed
    ————————————————————————————————-
    Hahahahahah! Foles went 2-5 as a Bears starter last season and was benched in favor of the guy he was brought in to replace. What discussion would you like?

  14. bassplucker says:
    Word out of early team activities is that Fields is significantly outplaying Andy Dalton.
    ==

    Justin Fields may well “look” smoother or sharper than Andy Dalton right now, but nobody can say with a straight face that anyone is “outplaying” anyone else when all they’re wearing is helmets and shorts and there’s no real pass rush, scheming, blitzing et al going on.
    Fields may well be the guy come September. Right now he’s just a promising youngster that hasn’t yet experienced the fury, quick decision-making or speed of the game at this level. I personally prefer to wait until we see these guys in some all-out, 11-on-11 padded football before I start evaluating who’s actually playing better.

  15. Dalton will start, as long as they win. Andy can get you there. He is a good player. Smart. As A Bengal fan, he took Cincy to playoffs five straight years. His M.O., wilts in big games. Under the lights. Playoff time. I saw it last year in Dallas. Sorry Andy, I’ve watched all your games. Pressure changes him. If they get to playoffs with Andy, that’s the time for Fields. Buckeye fan here. Ive seen all his games too. Bears have a very good problem here. Its a win, win.

  16. The original plan with Trubisky was to bring him along slowly. Then the Bears traded for Mack, and all of the sudden they started talking about Super Bowl, and Trubisky wasn’t near ready (or maybe he never would have been, we’ll never really know that answer). I’m all for the Bears sitting Fields for a bit and letting Dalton QB. No reason to throw Fields into the fire immediately. This isn’t a Super Bowl team with anyone at QB this year.

  17. As lifelong Bronco’s fan, the Bears are definitely the winner since the Mack trade. Three seasons since and the Bears made the playoffs (twice) and won the division. None of that happening for the Raiders and they missed on a QB with all those draft picks we bragged about.

    Raiders 19-25
    Bears 28-20

  18. CHI TOWN HEAT makes mention of AD’s TD/INT ratio, whch is sub 2/1, not good. He raised it last year from prior and last year at CIN, he’s ended up clsoe to 2/1 in big D. If he can keep the picks down there’s a decent chance he can improve again this year, which would be awesome for everyone, includeing JF. I thinkk the Bears have one of the better QB rooms if that doesn’t bend your mind as a Bears fan.

  19. As a lifelong Raiders fan, the Bears are definitely the winner since the Mack trade. Three seasons since and the Bears made the playoffs (twice) and won the division. None of that happening for the Raiders and they missed on a QB with all those draft picks we bragged about.

    Raiders 19-25
    Bears 28-20

  20. While the Bears clearly won the trade, Mack hasn’t really returned much in value. Where are the sacks?

    Raiders are just beginning the rebuild Gruden and Mayock have completely screwed up!

  21. I guess maybe Dalton has earned that right by being good once in 2015. He’s the 3rd best QB on the squad but Nagy gonna Nagy.

  22. Maybe if the Lions were relevant the division would be more even, but they are horrible. Trubisky and Nagy owned the Lions – 5 out of 6 Wins, imagine how bad it will be for Goff going against arguably the best front seven in the game twice a year. Those rookie linemen are going to get a nice welcome to the NFL.

  23. Meanwhile, Giants fans be rubbing their hands together in joy knowing they’ll have a top slotted pick in the first round after the Bears fall on their face this year.

  24. I hope Chicago fans get their wish and Fields ends up the starter week 1. This would destroy any chance he has of being a decent QB in this league. Throw the kid into the fire and let’s see how he transitions from Ohio State’s pee wee style offense to an intricate professional offense.

  25. Nagy’s job is on the line, he’s already on the house at. Fields starts, no later than week 4. Book it.

  26. I’m fine with Dalton starting week 1, but why promise him anything? Dalton isn’t a top-10 QB who needs the job to be his. Just say best QB starts week 1. It’ll probably be Dalton. I think Nagy just has this “plan” where he thinks it’s like Alex Smith and Mahomes, but the problem is Dalton is not Smith and Fields is not Mahomes. Just let the best QB take the field. This is just creating unnecessary drama and questions.

  27. Nagy is going to use Mahommes as his blueprint? Andy Reid knows how to develop QB talent and create an offense around their strengths. That is not part of the Bears culture.

  28. dejadoh says:
    June 15, 2021 at 4:39 pm
    Dalton is a potential HOF QB

    ———

    Thanks!!! I needed a good laugh!!!!

  29. Dalton’s numbers are good, and he’s tough. At this point Fields isn’t better than Trubisky.

  30. Considering the track record Ohio State QBs have in the NFL letting him sit and learn is in my opinion the best approach for him to succeed, and I’m saying that as a Vikings fan. Unless Dalton is injured I wouldn’t suggest throwing him to the fire, that hasn’t gone well for OSU QB’s, and I don’t just mean Haskins.

  31. Dalton is a better QB than fields. When the real defenses start playing, Fields won’t know what to do. At some point, Fields might become the better QB, but that’s a long way off. The QB position in the NFL is 95% mental. Why do you think old guys like Peyton Manning and Tom Brady win super bowls when they can barely move? Believe me, they’re not outrunning anyone. This is completely different than Alex Smith and Mahomes. Mahomes was the better QB from day 1, and it was never close.

  32. Reminds me of the Chargers. Herbert wasn’t going to start last year. It didn’t matter if he was ready. The plan was to lose games for at least one year with Tyrod.

    Turns out the coaching staff was wrong on whether he was ready and ended up being out on the street.

    I could see history repeat itself with the Bears.

  33. OK let’s look at some facts here:

    1) the bust rate for 1st round QBs drafted since 2000 stands right at 70%.

    2) well over 95% of those busts were thrown to the wolves to start or with-in 5-6wks.

    3) Between 2000 and 2018 at least 5 of the top 10 QB’s in the league were let to sit and learn for at least a year before starting their first game.

    4) These rookie QBs go from a limit of 20hrs practice including game time to full time in the NFL(over 40hrs a week), they also go from a 40-50 play college playbook to an NFL playbook with well over 200 plays and they’ll be going against defensive schemes they’ve never seen before and players that are at a level they could never have imagined in college.

    All of that can’t be learned in a few short weeks of training camp and three pre-season games so why would anyone think throwing a QB straight to the wolves at the highest level of the sport is the right thing to do? Over 90% of the time it hasn’t worked out good at all!

    But throwing them straight into the fire sure does increase the percentage of getting a bust, is that what you Bears fans want?

    Brees, Brady, Palmer, Rivers, Rodgers and now Mahomes, all QBs at the top of the NFL for most of their careers and they all have one thing in common, they were let to sit and learn for at least 1yr, does anyone need any more proof than what I’ve already given?

  34. Saberwolf says:
    June 15, 2021 at 7:49 pm
    Considering the track record Ohio State QBs have in the NFL letting him sit and learn is in my opinion the best approach ….

    ————

    I hate OSU, but that’s like saying Herbert shouldn’t have played for SD because he was a rookie and needed to sit because Oregon QBs don’t have a good track record. Ole Miss didn’t have a good track record, either, but Eli was drafted. Tennessee, same. Let’s try and assess the player and not the program. OSU never had a QB rated as high as JF was coming out of HS. 5-star players who play up to their ratings in college is a better indicator of NFL capabilities.

    All the talk of development is hysterical, because there is not one path to being successful. These opinions are just that—not facts. Josh Allen developed despite being mediocre for years. Herbert didn’t need to sit. Daniel Jones sucks because he wasn’t anything great at Duke. Deshaun didn’t need to sit because he was ready.

    By all accounts, JF has one of the highest IQs coming out of the draft and he has the highest college football accuracy rating since PFF has started. If he’s ready, he’s ready. Assess the individual, not some stupid unwritten book of when.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.