Could Deshaun Watson force a trade by telling the Texans he’s ready to play?

Cincinnati Bengals v Houston Texans
Getty Images

One of the best things about the two-hour cruise of the NFL that happens every morning on PFT Live is that the unrehearsed, loosely outlined conversation often results in Simms or me thinking of something that hadn’t previously occurred to us.

Today, while discussing the lingering presence of quarterback Deshaun Watson on the Houston roster, a light flickered for me. What happens if Watson tells the Texans, “I’m ready to play”?

Sure, Watson is done with the Texans. But the Texans are also done with Watson. If he plays and gets injured, their chances of getting multiple first-round picks plus more goes out the window.

The Houston talking points regarding Watson involve focusing on a daily approach. Day-to-day. One day at a time. What if that’s aimed at keeping Watson on board by making him think that it’s coming? “It’s coming. Be patient, Deshaun. It’s coming.”

Watson is a football player. Football players play football. Week One is coming. Watson, despite his direct responsibility for his present circumstances, wants to play football. He doesn’t want to get paid to give up a season of his career.

This isn’t a question of whether he truly wants to play for the Texans. It’s a question of whether he’ll tell the Texans he’s ready to play in order to force Houston’s hand. With Tyrod Taylor, Jeff Driskel, and Davis Mills on the roster, what happens if Watson says, “Put me in, Coach? I’m ready to play.”

That could be the only way to get the Texans to trade Watson during the 2021 season.

And while in theory the Texans could still choose to deactivate him every week, it’s tougher to make a de facto paid suspension work if the player isn’t on board with it. The 2006 CBA, negotiated a year after the Eagles eventually sent Terrell Owens home with pay, wiped out the ability of a team to do that. If Watson wants to fight a refusal to let him practice or play, he could.

68 responses to “Could Deshaun Watson force a trade by telling the Texans he’s ready to play?

  1. It doesn’t matter who he is traded to, he’s going to be a PR nightmare for teams and a distraction for everyone involved around him. Its been a long time since he’s even taken a snap and he’s going to be on the commish exempt list even if he’s not found guilty… which is a stretch at this point. If you are trading for this guy, you arent going to see a ROI for about three years.

  2. If the Texans are willing to pay Desean Watson’s salary even if he’s not playing — and that seems to be the case right now — why would they be afraid to pay his salary while he sits on the bench and pouts? They don’t have to send him home or refuse to let him practice.
    As others have pointed out, the Texans should TELL him he’s starting, like it or not, and if he refuses withhold his salary over conduct detrimental to the team. If Watson wants to pout, or reluctantly takes the field and intentionally plays poorly, he’ll further damage his reputation and chances of getting traded, something he clearly wants.

  3. What if Joe Flacco tells the Eagles he wants to play? It doesn’t matter. If you don’t want them to play you don’t play them. That’s pretty simple.

  4. “The 2006 CBA, negotiated a year after the Eagles eventually sent Terrell Owens home with pay, wiped out the ability of a team to do that. If Watson wants to fight a refusal to let him practice or play, he could.”
    ———–
    Well its not complicated group to Watson. If he wants to play/practice then that’s fine, you give him the red jersey for no contact and make him 3rd string leading the scout team. The texans cant just send Watson home if he doesnt want without repercussions but just because Watson says he wants to play/start theres nothing that says or guarantees he gets to start and theres nothong he can do to force the Texans hand on that if their allowing him to practice and train because who plays is up to the team(whether the team is putting the best players out there makes no difference either its still up to them)

  5. He can’t put the Texans in checkmate with that move. The team could dress him on Sundays and leave him on the bench. They could say Tyrod Taylor fits their scheme better and Watson is the backup.

  6. The siding blows off the stadium every time there is a stiff wind. Cheap quality just like the fans.

  7. Everyone says it’s gonna take a long time for the PR nightmare to subside but it really won’t. We have short memories. Almost no one remembers Ben Roethlisberger’s indiscretions or legal trouble. It will be the same with Watson.

  8. I would imagine he could force himself onto the practice field and the locker room but it is the coach’s decision who gets dressed on game day. Just ask Malcolm Butler.

  9. the texans should bench him each week. until he’s traded they are stuck with his salary, even if he gets hurt (which would kill his trade value, if any is left). as such, they need to suck it up, bench him, and see what they can get.

    if he’s still there next year, do the same next year. at some point either they will get a trade for him, or, he will no longer have a career because he wouldn’t have played for a long time.

  10. footballismybusiness says:
    September 2, 2021 at 2:28 pm
    Everyone says it’s gonna take a long time for the PR nightmare to subside but it really won’t. We have short memories. Almost no one remembers Ben Roethlisberger’s indiscretions or legal trouble. It will be the same with Watson.

    —————————————————-

    Everyone remembers the Roethlisberger indiscretions except Steeler’s fans. However, money got him out of trouble completely and he has been able to stay out of trouble since. It’s yet to be seen if money can get Watson out of trouble.

  11. I understand the Texans are a pretty dysfunctional organization but I don’t think they have their QBs adjusting the depth chart and making their roster decisions.

  12. So uh…what’s to stop them from just not giving him any reps in practice, and making him a gameday inactive? Obviously not ideal from a 53 man roster standpoint, but I don’t see how he could fight it.

  13. Couldn’t he file a grievance just a thought he could say really tyrosine Taylor jeff Driscoll is better then me?

  14. Okay, When you are as talented as Watson is at playing QB,a true franchise QB you want him on the field playing, period. The league doesn’t want Watson on the field this season to protect the shield. If a team were to make a trade for him at this time, and I believe this has been discussed by the owners at any league meetings, Watson would immediately be placed on the commissioners exempt list, which raises the question, why didn’t you do this before now. The NFL wants to avoid all those questions during this season.

  15. The minute another team trades for Watson most of their fanbase will be so excited they wont care if he had a history of raping puppies! And if he plays well the few others who condemned the trade will fall in line as well. There will be no pr nightmare. For all our big morality talk what we really want to do is win.

  16. How exactly would that force a trade?
    ________
    Put me in coach I’m ready to play
    __________
    No
    __________
    Case closed.

  17. Y’all don’t get it. If DeShaun Watson gets injured, it kills his trade value. He’s going to be mothballed unless the league forces something or he gets traded.

    Even having him on the field practicing any meaningful way is a huge risk. I remember he tore a ligament in practice his rookie year?

    He’s not playing as a Texan. And Florio is right, if he can try to force them to play him, and he might be able to, their hand could be forced

  18. If Watson does somehow force a trade, I just can’t see any fan base getting on board with him as their quarterback. It’s really bad public relations. The accusations will always be attached to him.

  19. People don’t understand the cba. After the Owens incident they made it so you can’t defacto suspend a player by dnp coaches decision. Watson is clearly the best qb on the team and not playing him would in fact be work around on a suspension, that’s not allowed anymore.. Watson would file and grievance and win. If Watson wants to play and he is not suspended by the league they have play him, cut him, or trade him.

    This was all collectively bargained. It doesn’t matter how it works at your job or in college or anywhere else. These are protections afforded to members of the union
    .

  20. You guys should know the landscape of the NFL better than this.

    I have a better chance of playing in the NFL this year than Watson if he isn’t playing for the Texans.

    He’s not getting traded. No matter the stunts like this suggestion.

    No team is giving the Texans what they want with the unknowns out there regarding any legal trouble or NFL suspension.

  21. First he is no longer worth multiple 1st round picks, maybe a first and an option pick based on his playing time which could be zero if he is suspended, which greatly lowers his trade value. Maybe 1 or 2 teams will take on the PR nightmare, we already know the Dolphin’s owner simply doesn’t care they already can’t sell tickets why not eliminate more and piss off all the local groups. Also, he has large contract not to many teams will be willing to take on that risk that he continues his actions.

    If he wants to play let him block on punts and extra points, if he says no then fine/suspend him which then voids his contract and they can go after is prorated bonus money.

  22. brianh992 says:
    September 2, 2021 at 2:10 pm
    Minnesota has the best stadium in the country, period.

    ——-

    And zero SB trophies. Fact

  23. One Watson has NO trade value until his legal troubles clear up.

    After that he has little trade value because he has a huge contract and is NOT a winning QB in the NFL.

    So NO Watson can not force the Texans to play him. They have to pay him either way (unless he gets convicted of a crime)so he holds no cards.

    The best thing he can do right now is tell his camp to shut up (and follow that advice), stay out of trouble and get his legal problems solved.

    THEN, maybe, he’ll be holding a pair of 5s.

  24. Re: “Minnesota has the best stadium in the country, period.”

    Sorry, way too much lutefisk.

  25. I remember when Reid and Veach took Mahomes one spot over him and was elated just for football reason (big arm, diligent mind and being a student to Reid). Never would have imagined this is how it would all play out.

  26. He is the employee, not the owner. He will play when they tell him to play. If they tell him to serve hot dogs during the game…he better do it.

  27. It doesn’t matter….nobody is giving three firsts and two seconds. Not going to happen. The Texans are going to have to pay someone to take him, just like they did with Osweiler.

  28. When did he ever say he wasn’t ready to play? Sure, he wants traded, but he showed up to camp, which presumably means he’s willing to play. If they’re dumb enough they don’t want to play him, that’s on them. Nothing he says can force them to play him.

  29. Well, he’s had plenty of practice with showing up under false pretenses with the 22 women he’s accused of abusing, so why not the football team too?

  30. Oh, so Watson determines if he gets to play or not? It’s not up to the coaches to make those decisions? My goodness, PFT has a lot of bad takes, but this one’s up there with the worst of them.

  31. It’s not his choice to make. But if he went to them saying he wanted to play it’d be in all their best interests to do so, even if only for a game or two. Trade partners have lots of questions including if the league would even allow him to play without suspending him, if he is in shape, and how big of a PR backlash would there be for playing him. All those questions get answered if he even plays one game. His trade value is so low now that even answering just those questions would improve it considerably.

  32. The Texans dont owe Watson anything (beyond his salary, until he is suspended). Watson is not a victim here. He has no leverage, and does not deserve anything from the club. He can demand to play but the club or league could suspend him at any point, or just deactivate him each week and let him make a stink to the union and league. This guy deserves zero sympathy. Despite the convenient narrative that the Texans are somehow the bad guy here.

  33. If Watson wants to play and he is not suspended by the league they have play him, cut him, or trade him.

    ————-

    You’re wrong. There’s nothing in any CBA that a team is forced to play a player in any way.

  34. 8 players per team on ALL 32 teams are inactive every week which means 256 players total are Inactive & YES they don’t want to be & it’s not by there choice & there is NOTHING THEY CAN DO about it

    AND Watson is NO different

  35. Just because he thinks he’s ready to play, it doesn’t mean the team thinks he’s ready. The bench has about 28 guys ready to play.

  36. The thing about a trade is it takes two sides, you have to have someone that other teams want and at a price they’re willing to pay and I don’t think the Texans have those two things!

    I truly believe that with Watson’s status being unknown a team would be totally stupid to make a trade for him!

  37. Any team considering trading for Deshaun Watson needs to consider the following: 1.) The salary cap hit. 2.) the expected compensation. 3.) What happens if Mr. Watson faces criminal charges you’re caught unprepared by giving picks to get him. The smart thing is to have a clause stating if Mr. Watson cannot fulfill his part of the deal then there are “escape clauses” that lessen such compensation or voids the deal. Better yet as they would say in the late eighties regarding drugs, Just say: “No!”.

    ARE YOU READING THIS MIAMI DOLPHINS?

  38. the guy isn’t worth a taco – let alone what some people are talking about 3 firsts –

  39. I seriously doubt that any team is willing to send Houston even a single first round pick for Watson. Only 1 team pursued Tom Brady when he was a free agent and he is the GOAT with more Super Bowl rings than he has fingers on one hand. Watson not only has a huge contract, but he has never won a single Super Bowl yet. No GM is going to risk his job by trading for Watson. Aaron Rodgers is becoming a free agent after this season. Any team wanting a chance at winning the Super Bowl would pursue him instead. They will wind up paying Rodgers about the same as Watson is getting, and Rodgers has 1 Super Bowl ring and he is a first ballot hall of famer. No need to send anyone a first round pick by signing Rodgers.

  40. 1. League aint suspending him anytime soon, he hasnt been found guilty of anything.
    2. His requesting to play is a smart move and I thought of this a while ago as in the Texans want to protect their interest but he can become a big thorn in their side, which he wants, by endangering his value if injured. Joke on the Texans.
    Ya if him and his agent come up with a new game plan this may be it, right now its not working for them.

  41. zeus9800 says:

    When did he ever say he wasn’t ready to play? Sure, he wants traded, but he showed up to camp, which presumably means he’s willing to play. If they’re dumb enough they don’t want to play him, that’s on them. Nothing he says can force them to play him.
    ———————–
    His original squak was he would never play another down for the Texans. So long ago I’m sure you forgot

  42. Anyone that gives Texans more then a few late round picks for him is crazy. Only way they get high round picks is AFTER the legal issues and league decisions are done. He could be in jail in 6 months for all anyone knows. OR it could be determined this was a complete money grab due to a immature young entitled athlete. Either way, until his status is determined he isn’t worth squat.

  43. adamb182 says:

    September 2, 2021 at 3:18 pm

    People don’t understand the cba. After the Owens incident they made it so you can’t defacto suspend a player by dnp coaches decision. Watson is clearly the best qb on the team and not playing him would in fact be work around on a suspension, that’s not allowed anymore.. Watson would file and grievance and win. If Watson wants to play and he is not suspended by the league they have play him, cut him, or trade him.

    This was all collectively bargained. It doesn’t matter how it works at your job or in college or anywhere else. These are protections afforded to members of the union

    ———
    It seems the one who doesnt understand the CBA here is you. No team can be forced to play a player period. They however CANT send him home or keep him from practicing, working out or using the facilities which is the protections the players were afforded, no where in the CBA does it say if people think that you’re the best on your team it’s no longer a coaches decision who will start its automatic 🤦‍♂️

  44. Unless there is a criminal offense Watson will play in the NFL someday… but not until all of the legal entanglements are settled. He cannot change that, nor can the Texans. And attempting to create more problems for the Texans, who share his interest in reaching a trade deal, will just make potential trade partners much less interested in him.

  45. That’s what he should do. Not because he wants to play for Houston but so they have to decide what to do. So far, the guy has not been charged with any crime. Yes he lost his “golden boy” status and now is viewed as creepy, but he has not been charged with a crime…yet.

  46. Even sitting him for the year hoping his legal situation clears has risks. More stories could leak or he could be criminally charged. Criminal charges would be disastrous to his career. Only three options and all would be bad: 1. He is convicted and goes to jail 2. He takes a plea and admits guilt 3. He might be acquitted but that would still be a long public trial where all sorts of damaging details would come out.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.