Will Trey Lance play much (or at all) on Sunday night?

San Francisco 49ers v Philadelphia Eagles
Getty Images

The much-anticipated two-quarterback system in San Francisco has become four measly snaps in two games for rookie Trey Lance. When the 49ers host the Packers on Sunday night, will we see many or any plays from San Fran’s QB2?

On Friday, 49ers G.M. John Lynch said that, however it plays out, coach Kyle Shanahan makes those decisions.

“It’s all under that Shanahat [sic],” Lynch said, via Cam Inman of the San Jose Mercury News. “He’s got it in there. I don’t think it’s impulsive. He puts so much work in it and is so great at play calling.”

Shanahan has created the impression that, when it comes to the quarterback situation, these decisions are impulsive and not planned. If Lynch is right, then, Shanahan deliberately decided not to use Lance in Week Two. At all.

As previously suggested, Shanahan possibly has decided to go all in with Jimmy Garoppolo until he fails or suffers an injury. Indeed, they decided to draft a quarterback because of (or so they claim) Garoppolo’s inability to stay healthy. So let him do his thing, and if he gets hurt then Lance is the guy.

Until then, the 49ers will get pretty good performance from their QB1. Lynch said that Lance’s presence has “risen the level of [Garoppolo’s] game.”

Obscured by the apparently deliberate pivot to all-Garoppolo is the possibility (if not likelihood) that Lance has yet to impress. Although Lance, as Lynch said, won the scout-team award for impersonating Eagles quarterback Jalen Hurts, the players seem to be aligned behind Garoppolo. He hinted at that after Week One.

So it’s entirely possible that the two-quarterback system has been abandoned, with a conscious decision to ride or die with Garoppolo, confident that if Garoppolo goes down again they’ll have a much better alternative than Nick Mullens or C.J. Beathard.

7 responses to “Will Trey Lance play much (or at all) on Sunday night?

  1. If you draft a QB (the most important position in sports) in Round 1 and your current QB (again, the most important position in sports) improves his play by 20-30 percent, it is worth the pick even If the Round 1 QB never plays.

  2. On a national stage this Sunday night against a rather pathetic Packers’ defense, don’t be surprised if Shanahan reaches into his bag of Trey Lance tricks and dials up some plays he’s been saving for just such an occasion.

  3. Gotta love how narratives get started. The Lions put up 33 on the 49ers but only 17 on the Packers. Who’s really got the pathetic defense?

  4. Of course he will. Comfy confines of the home crowd, mediocre Packer pass rush etc. More than anything, Shanahan is going to throw different looks that will make Pete Carroll burn the midnight oil for the Seattle/SF matchup the following week. Carroll’s strategy against Jimmy Garropollo hasn’t changed in their last 6 head to head matchups. Pressure Jimmy G into making him throw to beat you. With Lance, that has to change as Lance can easily take the top off the defense and huck it deep. I bet Lance sees 30% of the snaps week 4.

  5. “The much-anticipated two-quarterback system in San Francisco has become four measly snaps in two games for rookie Trey Lance.“

    I don’t remember a single person from the 49ers saying that it was going to be a 2 quarterback system. I do remember them saying, repeatedly, that they will put Trey Lance in the game when they feel like it. Apparently they haven’t felt like it much yet.

  6. steaksandwichandsteaksandwich says:

    September 25, 2021 at 9:14 am

    If you draft a QB (the most important position in sports) in Round 1 and your current QB (again, the most important position in sports) improves his play by 20-30 percent, it is worth the pick even If the Round 1 QB never plays.
    ———–
    Even if we concede that your premise is correct about being worth it for a 1st round pick(you forgot to point out it was MULTIPLE 1ST) Jimmy G hasn’t improved his play by 20-30% but instead is playing the same as he previously had with san Fran, his problem wasnt performance but availability.

  7. Sunday Swami says:
    September 25, 2021 at 2:09 pm
    steaksandwichandsteaksandwich says:

    September 25, 2021 at 9:14 am

    If you draft a QB (the most important position in sports) in Round 1 and your current QB (again, the most important position in sports) improves his play by 20-30 percent, it is worth the pick even If the Round 1 QB never plays.
    ———–
    Even if we concede that your premise is correct about being worth it for a 1st round pick(you forgot to point out it was MULTIPLE 1ST) Jimmy G hasn’t improved his play by 20-30% but instead is playing the same as he previously had with san Fran, his problem wasnt performance but availability.

    ———–
    I like Jimmy G but his play is not superlative. He leaves a lot of plays on the table. I’ve seen numerous film breakdowns by people after the KC Super Bowl loss and Jimmy didn’t connect with wide open receivers. If he had been any better we’d have won the super bowl easily. Too bad.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.