Nick Caserio resists the temptation to tank

New England Patriots v Houston Texans
Getty Images

Once a team falls out of contention for the playoffs, winning becomes losing. Specifically, losing ground in the draft order for the following year.

It continues to be one of the great disconnects for the NFL, the idea that every time tries to win every game in every week and the reality that the team that loses the most secures dibs on the best of the incoming players. Every year, trades that happen at the top of the draft illustrate the value of finishing higher rather than lower.

But even beyond the first round, the higher placement makes a difference, whether it’s round two or three or four or any of the rest of them. It’s a basic truth for teams that no longer have a chance to get to the postseason. The deeper they sink in the standings, the higher they rise in the draft order. Who cares about whether the final record is 5-12 or 4-13 or 3-14 or 2-15? For the franchise, the best interests are served by securing better placement in the upcoming draft.

First-year Texans G.M. Nick Caserio doesn’t see it that way. Or, perhaps more accurately, he knows not to say it out loud.

Appearing earlier this week on SportsRadio 610 in Houston, Caserio downplayed a higher draft spot and focused on winning more games.

The goal on Sundays is to win,” Caserio said. “People get too caught up in draft stock. It’s not about where we pick and where we draft. It’s about who we get in the building and what they do when they’re here.”

He’s right, but they have a better chance to get better players in the building if they select higher in the draft. While there will always be busts, teams always prefer picking higher than lower. Besides, given the dramatic changes that happen on a roster from one year to the next, how much will a late-season surge in one year carry over to the next?

The simple truth for the Texans is that these late-season wins, like the Week 16 victory over the Chargers, won’t help the team find better players in 2022. It will cause them to slip in the draft order, allowing others to pick higher — and requiring the Texans to offer up other things in the event they would like to climb higher in order to ensure that they will get the guy they want.

Regardless of whether it does or doesn’t make sense for the Texans to win meaningless games, as the draft approaches and the various possibilities and permutations are pondered, remember that but for a few wins that they really didn’t need, the Texans would be drafting earlier than they will be. It may not matter now. It definitely will matter then.

5 responses to “Nick Caserio resists the temptation to tank

  1. Given that this is a weak Quarterback draft with no clear cut #1,most of these QB’s are not really first round material. hello Christian Ponder Blake Bortles.

  2. I’m very much a ‘if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it’ kind of guy. Never had much of a problem with the way the draft order is set up. But if the NFL instituted a lottery for say, the teams with the worst 5 records the previous season, I could go along with that.

  3. Look up multiple drafts. More than 50% of the top 16 are All Pros at one time or another.

    The next 16 about 25%. Next 16 , 10% and so on. Pretty consistent, minus the odd draft or 2.

    But it’s all irrelevant if you don’t have a QB and people to block for him.

  4. packerbacker1987 says:
    But if the NFL instituted a lottery for say, the teams with the worst 5 records the previous season, I could go along with that.

    I apreciate you point of view, but what wouyld that fix?
    A team in the fourth or fifth position late in the season would have even more reason to tank if it suddenly had an outside shot at the first or second pick. Some teams around the 5-7 spots might also start tanking just to get into the lottery.

  5. Many NBA teams still tank even though the purpose of the draft lottery was to stop tanking. Plus the NBA often gets accused of rigging the draft lottery.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.