Report: Jameson Williams suffers torn ACL in national championship game

2022 CFP National Championship - Georgia v Alabama
Getty Images

The pursuit of a national championship carried a major price for one of its key players.

Alabama receiver Jameson Williams, one of the top draft prospects in the 2022 class, suffered a torn ACL in Monday night’s game, via Adam Schefter of ESPN.com.

Williams was regarded as a potential top-10 pick. Although doctors reportedly expect a full recovery (don’t they always?), the injury necessarily will impact his status, and it will potentially result in much later selection than previously anticipated.

It’s extremely unfortunate, and it’s a reminder that college football players deserve to be paid for their skills, abilities, and sacrifices. Williams, by helping the Crimson Tide pursue yet another championship, compromised his future earnings, significantly. It’s unfortunate, and it’s unfair. It will become less unfair only if/when players like Williams begin getting a slice of the billions that college football generates for the various universities.

92 responses to “Report: Jameson Williams suffers torn ACL in national championship game

  1. Here’s to a speedy and full recovery. And, hope he took out injury insurance prior to this game.

  2. ” it’s a reminder that college football players deserve to be paid for their skills, abilities, and sacrifices.” They’re called scholarships, genius.

  3. Come on man…he knew the risks, he played to enhance his draft status and he is probably already insured. That being said, the young man deserves our support and doesn’t need to be associated with some thing that none has any control over.

  4. Kirk Herbstreit should be happy he played. The kid lost one or 2 million, even with an insurance policy. He will never be the same

    Too bad, great to watch him catch passes

  5. Don’t they already get paid? I got a college degree that cost me 50k per year in tuition, room board, fees, food, clothes, airfare to travel 6-8 times per year, personal trainer costs, tutor costs, tickets to the games.

  6. He’s a good player, but not worth a top ten pick. I’m not even sure he is first round talent anyway. I think the success of the last set of bama wrs is overhyping this guy. He was a late first, early second going into the game. Now he’s probably a day 3 pick or if you already have a good team you could take shot in the late second.

  7. College football is just a slew of exhibition games to the fans of the professional game.

  8. I saw the replay,… the knee bent out. I’ve looked at some mock drafts and every one had Williams at pick 10 to 20 first round.

  9. Right. Now here comes the sanctimonious “outrage!!” that these college players should have skipped the games to “preserve” their draft status.

    The entire starting Alabama and Georgia lineups should’ve sat out and just let the backups play. In fact, all ranked high school players should just sit out their three years eligiblity to “preserve” their rankings too.

  10. Who knows, maybe he falls to a team like KC or Green Bay and ends up in a better situation and puts up monster numbers that allows him to get a huge second contract. Falling in the draft isn’t always a bad thing

  11. Bad news is he just lost his rookie year and 1st round selection… good news is he just got to his first FA a year sooner.

  12. OR, he is still extremely fortunate that he gets to play a game for a living, and will still make more money than 99% of the fans. Also, maybe we should start paying 5 star recruit high school football players, too.

  13. They are paid. Free school, free board, free food, free training, free gym use, and much much more!!!!!!!

  14. I guarantee his production on the football field during the regular season leading up to this game MORE than paid for his “scholarship.” Advantage: University of Alabama; ESPN; NCAA…

  15. Free agency (transfer portal) and pay disparity (NIL) will be the ruin of college football.

  16. Everyone forgets the value of exposure and development. Did Joe Burrow get no value from his final year at LSU?
    Kyler Murray?

  17. The guys that go to Alabama usually have their choice of any college in the country. They choose Alabama because it will greatly assist their lifetime earnings potential. Part of the deal that helps make Alabama the place all these kids want to play, is the fact that they’ll be playing in National Championship games. They could sign with a school like Indiana or Western Michigan, where they’d be safely sitting at home watching these Alabama guys take risks. But then on draft day, they’ll watch a great many of those Alabama guys become millionaires. But nobody is forcing these kids to play football, and nobody is forcing these kids to get drafted and collect millions of dollars because of the exposure they get playing college football. That exposure is worth a ton, and maybe kids should pay the colleges for that exposure. Just another way to look at it. But also, I see plenty of players making tens of millions of dollars that have had knee surgery. But also, a college education costs a couple hundred thousand dollars. Even if they don’t end up in the NFL, the earnings potential for a college kid is much greater than for a non-college kid, and their children will benefit from being raised in a more affluent household. To say that these kids aren’t being rewarded is just false. Also, guys that are potential high draft picks usually get an insurance policy to protect themselves. By the way, it took me twenty years to pay off my student loans.

  18. Under N.C.A.A. rules, players can still lose their scholarships after being hurt, often pay for their own insurance and are generally responsible for long-term health care for injuries sustained on the playing field. So yeah, it’s nice if you are lucky enough to make it to the draft uninjured, but for players that get unlucky, that free education evaporates.

  19. There’s a easy solution to this. The schools and or NCAA guarantees the money the player lost and would of gotten from their projected draft slot. Example. Top 10 pick gets $20M contract. Injured player drops to 3rd round with $4M contract. The NCAA makes up the difference. That sounds like a lot they has to pay. But these kind of injuries are really rare in bowl games, playoffs. It seems like more because when they happen it’s talked about for days. How many projected 1st round picks got hurt in their last bowl game? Maybe one every couple years? That money is a drop in the bucket compared to what the $$$ the schools and NCAA bring in every year.

  20. Question for all of you who say things like they do get paid it’s called a scholarship: Would it be OK to not pay workers at Taco Bell and Burger King etc. because they get a free sandwich and drink on break?

  21. you guys saying they get their earnings are disgusting. what do you think happens when they can’t play anymore? magically, that scholarship still hangs around? all that free room and board and “education” (read: bogus classes) still hangs out while they’re in a cast?

    dude get a grip. these people are exploited for the schools gain. you’re kidding yourselves if you think otherwise.

  22. The draft could be better for him in the long run if he’s not getting picked up by a bottom of the barrel team.

  23. To bad money has become the most important thing in the NFL for these players. They don’t want to play in bowl games, preseason games, games at the end of the year with no meaning and the pro bowl.

  24. so depending on what we hear about the surgery between now and draft day (assuming its all good) hes just less likely to get picked by a bad “need a receiver NOW” team.
    .
    i always kind of feel bad for the first 5 picks. they are going to garbage teams that may ruin their careers.
    .
    imagine what Barry sanders could have done if he wasnt picked 3rd
    .
    i don’t wish the jets or lions on anyone….EVER.

  25. brianc34 says:
    January 11, 2022 at 7:40 pm
    Don’t they already get paid? I got a college degree that cost me 50k per year in tuition, room board, fees, food, clothes, airfare to travel 6-8 times per year, personal trainer costs, tutor costs, tickets to the games.

    ——————–

    Just cause you got jobbed by over paying for your education doesn’t mean this even comes close to fair compensation. It would be like saying your pay at a brewery should be in free beer. The education and board cost them a fraction of what the player brings in. This is no longer the sit down and do what they think is best culture.

  26. As the parent of a D1 athlete in a non revenue sport every one I knew in every sport, including football, earned every penny of their scholarship.

  27. college football players deserve to be paid

    Something tells me he was already getting paid.

  28. Have you looked at the draft order? The first half of the first round is an absolute horror show of incompetently-run teams going nowhere. The best possible scenario for any rookie is dropping to the bottom half of the round.

  29. It’s hilarious reading people who think that a scholarship is actually equivalent to pay and that they get a “free” education. During finals week, what do you think would happen if a player said “Sorry coach, I can’t make it to practice tomorrow, I need to study for finals.”? The top 1/2 of the roster are there to play football 100% and everything else they do is for appearances only.
    Hell, they don’t even have time for a part time job to make extra money.
    They are there to be football robots and that’s it.

  30. Don’t blame the NCAA. It’s just a shell corporation for the colluding schools at the very top of college football.

    Follow the money people.

  31. I like how bowl games are the tipping point for concern. That whole time spent developing the player’s athletic ability, coaching to improve skills, and nutrition to improve fitness and skills was done for free and at no risk to the school. That is unfair to the schools INVESTING in player development. How many of those players do NOT develop into something special — i guess thst is the schools cost of doing business.

    The player benefits just as much as the school.

  32. Man, I feel really bad for the kid. I was hoping the Raiders would draft him in the first round. Maybe they now have a shot at him in a later round, but it’s terrible that it had to happen this way.

  33. Gonna be rather interesting at the top of the third round for this guy or will a contending team take a bit of a higher flyer in the low second round should the guy be that good compared to whose out there at this particular point in the draft ???.

  34. Great comparison to working at Taco Bell or a brewery because that is where you likely end up for most of your life without a college education!

  35. College scholarships aren’t payment for services. Its no longer an argument as players are now getting PAID. Stop yelling at the clouds old fellas.

  36. Kinda similar to the unnecessary injuries the second seeded teams will endure this weekend having to play a seventh seed that has no business being in the playoffs.

  37. I feel bad for him as a person, but I don’t feel bad if he only makes $2M a year, or so, playing football. The average American household income is ~$70,000/year, so if his salary falls to something like $2M, it would take the average American over 28 years to earn the same amount. Sorry, but I don’t feel bad for him.

  38. This is why I would never complain about a college kid sitting out a bowl game….I don’t want them to, but I can see why they do it.

  39. It is unfortunate that he sustained this injury. I wish him the best. But where does the paying of student athletes in school start? High School? Guarantee it will go there if you do college. The reason for schooling is obvious, an investment in one’s self to ensure adequate survival. Hence playing school sports is an investment in one’s self. Once you start paying the student athlete, the barn door is open. Numerous liabilities will incur. Once those liabilities are adjudicated, School sports will no longer exists due to taxpayer demands on reduction of risks and costs. Athletes can’t have their cake and eat it too. It’s only the expansion of victimhood in society that is furthering the cause of paying student athletes. No entitlement should be given!

  40. mantastic54 says:
    January 11, 2022 at 7:52 pm
    Who knows, maybe he falls to a team like KC or Green Bay and ends up in a better situation and puts up monster numbers that allows him to get a huge second contract. Falling in the draft isn’t always a bad thing.
    _________________________________________________________________
    Didn’t Aaron Rodgers fall in the draft?

  41. I think the argument is the student players deserve a cut of the billions universities earn, not necessarily that they don’t get some compensation. If they can be earning some money while in college the scholarships could go away or be diverted to other students and if they get hurt like this, at least they were paid for their contribution, not for their potential. It’s just a thought to explore.

  42. If you start paying them, it will be the death of sports. Hear me out: FB and Men’s BB pay for all the others. Besides parents & friends, who goes to swim meets, baseball/softball, volleyball? Like it or not, FB/BB subsidize others. If those die off in college, it will trickle down to high school and so forth. Greed will be the death of sport.

    You’re either part of the team (entire college), or you’re not. That’s the point of the scholarships.

  43. NCAA generates close around 4 Billion dollars from football, these schools can certainly afford to give them more than just an education.The NIL is a start, but that just seemed to be done to get people off of the NCAAs case.

    Even schools like Rutgers brings in 100 Million a year so if they give 100 players a year 100K$ in schooling and other things… they STILL have 99MIl to pay coaches upgrade facilities, and make sure the school is taken care of too. I know it can be scary at times, but wouldn’t be a bad thing to do more than the BARE freaking MINIMUM for these student athletes.

  44. Most likely he’ll still end up making several times what most people ever make in their lifetime. I’m one who thinks that most college athletes should be paid, but the “life isn’t fair” argument can be accurately applied to many more people than this particular young man, whom I wish a full and speedy recovery.

  45. Stop with this bleeding-heart nonsense. Why don’t we make a bigger deal out of how grad students get nothing for doing all the research work on which universities make huge profits.

  46. A player exercising for 4 years, to maintain their scholarship, to play a sport. Got free food, clothes, education and travel. No one’s making them play. You can’t take the scholarship and then complain about performing.

  47. His pro career will be fine the point is he will still be richer then 95 % of us schumks so no i’m not sorry for him because the truth is he’s still one very lucky young man.

  48. Perhaps Jake Butt and Jaylon Smith saw that play & were thinking “I told you so”…Meanwhile perhaps Kirk Herbstreit and Desmond Howard were thinking “now there’s an old school college football player”….

  49. To all the oh he shouldn’t have played grow up your such a bunch of babies most of us take risks every day for what 50-70 k a year this young man will if his skills are good enough will make upwards of 80 million in his career so cry me a river this young man hit the jackpot ACL’s are common place almost every WR will get one sooner or later.

  50. When you take into the free room and food, tuition and books, help from the school finding good paying summer jobs most students couldn’t get, your talking being paid period.
    This poor kid, who I like a lot, will make more money in the next two years that the average family, two incomes, will earn in a lifetime of work.

  51. Nope. Still wrong with all this “pay college athletes” chatter.
    College. Student. Scholarship. Opportunity to make millions despite being dumb as a box of rocks, never going to class and not being able to speak English when you graduate.

    No sympathy.

    Don’t like it? Don’t play football. Someone else will take your place.

  52. Tough break but he should still easily go in the 1st round, it stinks that if he does come out this he’ll miss most if not all of his rookie season but better to get paid now while he recovers then wait till next year.

  53. steeelfann0155 says:
    They are paid. Free school, free board, free food, free training, free gym use, and much much more!!!!!!!
    —–
    None of that is “Free”, they work for it.

  54. I’d had told him if he was my son to sit the game out. Get the NFL money and you’re set for life. A $20,000 ring from Alabama or $18 million to wait for the draft. Lastly it’s another non contact injury on Astro turf…study after study proves Astro turf is much harder on ligaments and it’s a 40/1 ratio of non contact knee injuries vs natural grass.

  55. Were acl injuries as prominent in the 70s and 80s or has it increased with turf / cleats gripping technology?

  56. If Trent Baalke is still GM of the Jaguars, this guy gets drafted in 1st round. Nb1 pick is either T Neal or Hutchinson, so the Jaguars will be trading back into 1st round to draft Williams.The trade again in the 2nd for John Metchie. Baalke has very strong history of drafting hurt players – mostly ACL injuries – when draft stock falls for them.
    RB Marcus Lattimore, FB Trey Millard, DL Tank Carradine, G Brandon Thomas , CB Keith Reaser) (that was with 49s9 and took 2 players in 2021 draft in 3rd round with injury concerns – Walker little and Andre Cisco. Baalke was nicknamed All-ACL team in San Francisco. Alabama WR has Jaguars written all over him.

  57. Boiled down, football is nonessential.
    If anything, med, science, and education students should be the ones getting paid.

    Pick your field, take your chances. If you have a brain, think. If you’re athletic, run. If you get a scholarship, you’re being paid. Let’s not act like football is important.

  58. brianc34 says:
    January 11, 2022 at 7:40 pm
    Don’t they already get paid? I got a college degree that cost me 50k per year in tuition, room board, fees, food, clothes, airfare to travel 6-8 times per year, personal trainer costs, tutor costs, tickets to the games.

    ————————————————-

    Were you making the school millions and millions of dollars? Highly doubt that

  59. Allowing players to make money on sponsorship deals was the right call. The schools are providing room and board and tuition.

  60. ghjjf says:
    January 11, 2022 at 7:42 pm
    What do you call a scholarship?
    ———

    I call it less money than you can make in the NFL and less than the college makes exploiting you.

  61. tgsot says:
    January 11, 2022 at 8:31 pm
    The draft could be better for him in the long run if he’s not getting picked up by a bottom of the barrel team.
    ———————————————
    Kinda like when Jamar Chase went #6 to that bottom barrel team who doesn’t have a chance to turn into a playoff team….. oh wait!

  62. Life ain’t fair man! This kid will be fine, and he’ll make his millions, if he puts in the work. His “payment” in college is the priceless degree he should be earning. That’s it, that is all it should be. If he gets NIL money, good for him. But payment for playing, heck no!

  63. Unless he’s an idiot, I’m sure he had an insurance policy protecting him from lost potential earnings due to injury.

  64. You feel bad for the kid of course, and yes he got ‘paid’ via a free education which is a lifelong thing but where I think folks get lost is the relativity of said player getting paid (college tuition and extras) vs millions/billions their team and NCAA are making. It’s pretty Unbalanced.

    I’m in between on thoughts of top players sitting out championship games vs playing and risking injury. I suppose if you are very confident in being a first round pick I could see sitting out, but man that’s a tough message to your teammates, coaches, etc..

  65. Williams is a junior. He might be smart to rehab and come back for his senior year.
    He could sign a lesser contract with the pros or come back to Alabama and show them next season he’s fully recovered. He would likely be a top-5 pick then, assuming he doesn’t get injured again.

    Regarding getting paid: I saw a TV ad the other day with Braelon Allen, Wisconsin’s 18 year old running back. He’s getting paid. What’s all the chatter about getting paid. Seems like the best players are already getting paid.

  66. A young guy, already in great shape is going to recover nicely. If it was all 3 ligaments, that would be a different story.

    He’s still going in Round 1 (hopefully to NE)

  67. golions1 says:
    January 11, 2022 at 8:29 pm
    Question for all of you who say things like they do get paid it’s called a scholarship: Would it be OK to not pay workers at Taco Bell and Burger King etc. because they get a free sandwich and drink on break?
    —————-
    That’s one of the worst analogies I have ever seen. You’re comparing a free education to someone who gets a free sandwich and a drink? I hardly think the sandwich and drink increase an employee’s earnings over the course of their lifetime.

  68. you guys saying they get their earnings are disgusting. what do you think happens when they can’t play anymore? magically, that scholarship still hangs around? all that free room and board and “education” (read: bogus classes) still hangs out while they’re in a cast?

    dude get a grip. these people are exploited for the schools gain. you’re kidding yourselves if you think otherwise.
    ———–
    The degree that they earn determines what life looks like for them once they can’t play anymore. The exploitation is not all just one way either – a number of players are trying to parlay their scholarship into an NFL payday. If they don’t earn their degree, it’s not like they have to pay back their scholarship.

  69. OR, here’s something crazy. He’s a junior, he could just go back to school and rehab on the school’s dime and maybe, just maybe, even finish getting his degree while he’s there. I know, crazy, right? :eyeroll:

  70. harryhodag says:

    Regarding getting paid: I saw a TV ad the other day with Braelon Allen, Wisconsin’s 18 year old running back. He’s getting paid. What’s all the chatter about getting paid. Seems like the best players are already getting paid.
    __________________

    He is being paid by whomever he’s advertising for, much like if you were in a commercial you would be getting paid for it too, as you should, and the reason he is allowed to do that, is the NCAA is hoping that gets people off their case about not paying the people helping them make a huge amount of money. Which seems like it is working with you.

  71. 50DrunksInABar says:
    January 11, 2022 at 9:02 pm
    It’s hilarious reading people who think that a scholarship is actually equivalent to pay and that they get a “free” education. During finals week, what do you think would happen if a player said “Sorry coach, I can’t make it to practice tomorrow, I need to study for finals.”? The top 1/2 of the roster are there to play football 100% and everything else they do is for appearances only.
    Hell, they don’t even have time for a part time job to make extra money.
    They are there to be football robots and that’s it.
    —————————————————————————————-

    I was a tennis player, not a revenue producing sport, and I had time for a “part time” job. I was the last guy out of the facility, turned off the lights and was paid $30.00/practice.

  72. He’ll do just fine in the long run, I wouldn’t worry. Football is going to guarantee him millions of dollars. I’m sorry he got hurt but let’s keep it real. He’s still going to be a high pick as his likelihood for full recovery is very good.

  73. This is the standard “over-reaction to cater to the exception” anytime a top college football or basketball player suffers a major injury. The catch-22 is this: if College basketball & football players, the 2 sports that generate millions of $ revenue were paid, this would reduce the amount of $ that Schools have to fund Sports that are an expense. So would we rather have a very few athletes paid, or would we rather have tens of thousands of kids continue to get full or partial scholarships so they can obtain a college degree?

  74. footballpat says:
    January 12, 2022 at 7:23 am
    ghjjf says:
    January 11, 2022 at 7:42 pm
    What do you call a scholarship?
    ———

    I call it less money than you can make in the NFL and less than the college makes exploiting you.
    —————————————————

    By this logic nobody should work for any company, including the NFL, because you are being exploited by the owners. Even the highest paid NFL player is making substantially less compared to the team’s profits

  75. Blame the NFL and its eligibility rule. These guys go to college to audition for the pros. Not a soul forces anyone to play college football. They do it to showcase for a job. They should stay home and submit a highlight tape after 3 years and try to get drafted. The NCAA isn’t at fault.

  76. For everyone that thinks a scholarship is somehow fair compensation for these kids, it isn’t even close. The top talent is risking 100’s of millions of dollars in future earnings, devoting 50 to 60 hours a week to school and sports, sacrificing the majority of a normal college experience (travel, social, etc…), and generating billions for the NCAA and the schools they represent. I played Division III and then transferred to Division I and I wish I never had, it was the worst 2 years of torture (I am not being dramatic) and I missed out on so much.

  77. brianc34 says:
    January 11, 2022 at 7:40 pm

    Don’t they already get paid? I got a college degree that cost me 50k per year in tuition, room board, fees, food, clothes, airfare to travel 6-8 times per year, personal trainer costs, tutor costs, tickets to the games.

    —-

    Should have gone to a more inexpensive institution. Also, no one was making millions of dollars by your attending/contributing toward the university.

  78. Dude will make his money at some point, but will have to sit out 2022. First contract won’t be as great, but will have 4 yrs on rookie deal to show his worth for a 2nd deal.

  79. I would play long enough to establish draft worth and no more. It is crazy to risk it. All you they get a scholarship as compenastion folks are full of it.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.