Schefter backtracks dramatically on report of Miami’s interest in Deshaun Watson

Indianapolis Colts v Houston Texans
Getty Images

On the first day of the 2021 postseason, the Dolphins pushed a new, and factually unsupported, narrative regarding the team’s past interest in Deshaun Watson. Reporters from both ESPN and NFL Network, in an effort to remain in the good graces of those who eventually will be leaking news of the next coaching hire in Miami, gladly passed along the team’s alternative narrative, truth be damned.

Adam Schefter shared a particularly egregious tweet, which tried to pin all past interest in Watson on Miami’s former coach.

“With Brian Flores out in Miami, the chances of the Dolphins pursuing or acquiring Texans’ QB Deshaun Watson are greatly diminished, if not gone, per sources,” Schefter tweeted. “Flores had an interest in exploring a Watson deal, but others in organization, including owner Steven Ross, did not.”

As we explained, that claim is factually inaccurate. The Dolphins were ready to trade for Watson. The only requirement was that he settle the 22 civil lawsuits pending against him first. As PFT has previously reported, 18 of the plaintiffs were poised to settle; four weren’t. If the other four had agreed, the trade would have happened.

Coincidentally, or not, Schefter later posted a dramatic backtrack on his tweet. “Another source insisted today that the Dolphins were all on the same page and that they all wanted Deshaun Watson. ‘100 percent,’ one source said.”

So where’s the truth in all of this? Unfortunately, truth often becomes a casualty of today’s copy-and-paste text-message journalism. In order to at all times, and at all costs, preserve the ability to alert the world to transactions five minutes before they are announced, some reporters will from time to time hold their noses and serve as the messenger for someone who currently wants to paint a certain picture — and who can be counted on later to, for example, share the name of the next Miami coach five minutes before anyone else has it.

It’s a transactional approach that is all about boosting the value of the reporter without regard to the interests of the audience. Really, what are Schefter’s 8.9 million Twitter followers supposed to think tonight? The Dolphins didn’t want Watson, unless they did.

At a time when the New York Times reportedly is considering making a run at Schefter, who becomes a free agent in June, it’s fair to wonder whether one-source reporting will satisfy the Gray Lady’s standards. Unless those standards will be changing, it won’t.

Still, even if the Times reflects the times and authorizes reporting based on something less exacting than two sources (very often, the phrase “per sources” is cover for the fact that it’s one agent sending out a group text message), it’s hard to imagine any media outlet with any amount of credibility shrugging at two tweets that are nearly diametrically opposed in the message they send.

By the way, here’s the truth. The second tweet is the right tweet. The first tweet is the self-serving B.S. aimed at blaming all dysfunction in Miami on former coach Brian Flores. Schefter posted the first tweet to preserve his ability to break the news of the next Miami coach. He posted the second tweet when, apparently, someone he trusts made it very clear to him that the first tweet was as wrong as it could have been.

22 responses to “Schefter backtracks dramatically on report of Miami’s interest in Deshaun Watson

  1. Classic blame the guy who isn’t there anymore. Dolphins ownership sucks and by way of extension, so does the entire leadership. They will never win a Super Bowl with Ross as owner.

  2. Thanks for explaining that agents use the media to get their stories out …. much like you amplified the previous report of Dalvin Cook’s agent getting his version of events into the public domain without knowing jack.

  3. All of these gossipy NFL hangers on have been swallowing false stories leaked to them all season. OBJ?

  4. Schefter posted the first tweet to preserve his ability to break the news of the next Miami coach.
    The source on the first tweet is likely none other than Chris Grier, who would be the first to know the name of the next Miami coach and can give Schefty is 5 minutes of fame.

  5. Schefter is a shill for the NFL, the more he reports these rumors the less relevant he becomes.

  6. Hes always wrong and then backtracks like a little weasel. Remember him releasing medical records? Total sleaze

  7. schefter is not sports journalism. He is hired to create clicks, views whatever his employer wishes. The whole “accumulation of information” he just HAD to release on draft day soured me on ever taking anything he reports as credible and serious.

  8. Has everyone forgotten last year when Fitz was benched. His family heard about it prior to Fitz even hearing! Same people involved… I’ll even go out on a limb and state, it was likely Grier behind it then as well.

  9. This isnt that hard to understand

    Flores wants a player. Greir tries to get the player for his coach. Ross always wants superstar talent.

    Flores is gone. Greir is no longer trying to get the player he wants, Ross will sign the checks for the hopefully superstar player that Greir and the new coach want

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.