Joe Schoen on trading down in second round: More picks would benefit us the most

NFL Combine
Getty Images

No one really knows which draft picks will turn into the best NFL players, but the more picks you have, the greater your chances of hitting on some of them. That’s something Giants General Manager Joe Schoen thought about during the second round of the draft.

Schoen started Round 2 of the draft with the 36th overall pick, but he traded down to 38 and picked up a fifth-round pick in the process. Then he moved down again, from No. 38 to No. 43, and picked up a fourth-round pick in the process. Schoen said those additional players are a part of his roster-building plan.

“We just thought it was what was best for us at this time. More picks would benefit us the most, we thought, based on who was on our board,” Schoen said, via ESPN. “We had deals in place before the draft started. So we were confident. We knew we could move back. That was part of the plan.”

The Giants ended up with Kentucky wide receiver Wan’Dale Robinson in the second round, then grabbed Iowa safety Dane Belton with his extra fourth-round pick and Indiana linebacker Micah McFadden with his extra fifth-round pick. Only time will tell whether Belton and McFadden become solid contributors to the Giants’ defense, but Schoen gave himself a better chance of improving his roster by adding more picks.

9 responses to “Joe Schoen on trading down in second round: More picks would benefit us the most

  1. Not judging his picks, but given the astonishing number of holes we have in our roster, I can’t argue with his reasoning.

  2. Actually, Schoen knew he could keep trading back in round 2 because his target WR had a mid 3rd round grade by everyone else. Not that everyone else was correct, only time will tell.

    I bet they would have traded back one more time but no one called.

  3. Well, if your plan is to take Wan’Dale Robinson in the second round, you can trade down all you want and be confident that he’ll still be there. I think he’s a good player but Skyy Moore is a similar type of player that literally everyone had higher on their draft boards. George Pickens, John Metchie, and Alec Pierce were also taken shortly after Robinson.

    At least they didn’t take Tyquan Thornton.

  4. Well sir you took over from a mess, so there is only way to go from there. The best move you made was you latest firing.

  5. I think it will take Joe Schoen and the Giants several years to overcome the disaster that Dave Gettleman left behind.

  6. He should have traded some future picks to move up for a QB next year.

  7. I SINCERELY hope I’m wrong, but I can’t help but to think I would’ve preferred Malik Wills instead of Wan’dale Robinson at the traded back Round 2 spot. Would’ve given Jones 1 more year to see if he can be anything more than the Backup QB he’s looked lik thus far, and allowed Wills to develop and turn that “upside potential” into something more tangible. Yet Giants fans….Here We Are Lol…..

  8. As an Eagles fan I’d far prefer NYG had kept Gettleman over Schoen simply because Schoen seems to have a clue.

  9. bigblu73 says:
    May 3, 2022 at 1:46 pm

    I SINCERELY hope I’m wrong, but I can’t help but to think I would’ve preferred Malik Wills instead of Wan’dale Robinson at the traded back Round 2 spot. Would’ve given Jones 1 more year to see if he can be anything more than the Backup QB he’s looked lik thus far, and allowed Wills to develop and turn that “upside potential” into something more tangible. Yet Giants fans….Here We Are Lol…..
    __________

    The NFL determined that Willis was morth a mid-third round pick. That’s a real long shot to be a future NFL starter, let alone any better than Daniel Jones. Despite having a pretty good draft, the Giants will be drafting in the top 10 again next year if Jones plays poorly enough to lose his job. Next year there will be quarterbacks who are expected to be requisite of a top-10 pick, so it’s better to draft one next year than to get a guy this year with a much lower chance of succeeding.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.