Sammy Watkins: Aaron Rodgers is on another level than Patrick Mahomes

USA TODAY Sports

If the Chiefs and quarterback Patrick Mahomes are looking for reasons to be motivated in 2022, they don’t have to look very hard.

A pair of former Chiefs receivers have, in praising their new quarterbacks, thrown a jab or two at Mahomes, already one of the very best quarterbacks the game has ever seen.

First, it was Tyreek Hill, with the cartoonish suggestion that Dolphins quarterback Tua Tagovailoa throws the ball more accurately than Mahomes. More recently, Sammy Watkins heaped heavy praise on his new quarterback in comparison to Mahome.

In an interview of Watkins on the Packers’ official website, Larry McCarren attributed this quote to Watkins, when asked by Packers receiver Randall Cobb to compare Mahomes to Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers.

“I think Pat is incredibly good, but A-Rod is on a whole ‘nother level,” Watkins told Cobb. (And when McCarren repeated that quote to Watkins, Watkins didn’t deny saying it.)

“He’s amazing,” Watkins said of Rodgers. “How he controls the ball. How he puts everyone in place. I’ve been with a lot of quarterbacks, and I’ve never seen them carry themselves like Aaron Rodgers.”

That obviously includes Mahomes. And it would be difficult for Mahomes to get too bent out of shape about Watkins regarding Rodgers more highly. But Mahomes has accomplished more from a team standpoint in four years as a starter than Rodgers has in fourteen. By the time Mahomes is in his late 30s, he could be far more accomplished from an individual standpoint, too.

Mahomes surely won’t complain about any of it. He’ll file it away, and he’ll use it as fuel to avoid complacency and likely get on the brink of the Super Bowl for a fifth straight year — if not make it there for a third time.

88 responses to “Sammy Watkins: Aaron Rodgers is on another level than Patrick Mahomes

  1. ” Mahomes, already one of the very best quarterbacks the game has ever seen.”

    waayyyy premature on that statement, c’mon man- very good so far, not even close to best ever seen. there are more than a dozen ahead of him right now, let’s see what happens over the next decade, then we might be able to make that statement

  2. Why do you think it’s “cartoonish” to say Tua is the more accurate QB? I’ve seen Mahomes thread the needle and make some incredible throws to Tyreek and Travis Kelce. First and foremost you have to give those two pass catchers a ton of credit. Mahomes may end up being better than Rodgers at the end of his career. But Rodgers has been doing this MVP thing far longer than Mahomes and Brady. Say what you want about Aaron off the field, but on it, ball don’t lie.

  3. If by ‘another level’ they mean unable to lead a team in the playoffs well then yeah.

    Then again… Sammy Watkins…

  4. Aaron Rodgers is the best thrower of the football ever. I didn’t say he was the best QB ever.

  5. And yet they each have one SB ring, oh wait, Rodgers has more one and done in playoffs too.

  6. Not sure I see what the big deal is. Whether Watkins believes it or not, he wants Rodgers to throw him the ball and so he’ll stay in his good graces. I’m sure the receivers for Tom Brady would say hes the best, Mahomies guys would say he’s the best..etc..Rodgers is a 4 time MVP, this is hardly bulletin board stuff.

  7. Compare Mahomes first three years in the league with those of Brady, Rodgers, Manning (Peyton) and Brees and he leads in every category except interceptions of which he has the least.

    Make the same comparison between Mahomes and Marino, Farve, Montana and Elway and the only one who tops him is Marino and only in TDs and total yards.

    But Rodgers does lead in petty grievances and petulant behavior, so he has that.

  8. It’s not a slam on Mahomes. If You read closely what he’s saying he’s talking about his command on the field and getting guys lined up. He’s the best at that.

  9. Lots of people think Rodgers has been the best QB in the league for the last decade, and he has a ton more experience than Mahomes. Rodgers is incredible. I think Joe Montana is better than Tom Brady, but that doesn’t mean Brady is a bad QB. But when one of your Ex-teammates says something like this, it gets headlines, but the players around the league know who they respect and who they don’t, and that’s why a guy like Watkins is a frequent flyer. He might end up with the NFL record for most teams played for. For whatever reason, he wears out his welcome wherever he goes. I haven’t seen one instance where his ex-teammates, on any of his teams went to bat for him. They basically opened the door for him.

  10. As Big Cat from bar stool says, my Super Bowl is when Aaron Rodgers loses in the playoffs. And I’ve won a lot of Super Bowls. I’ve got a dynasty cookin.

  11. “Mahomes, already one of the very best quarterbacks the game has ever seen.”

    Agreed that that’s a tired narrative. Hes one of the more exciting especially paired with Hill, but he’s only played 4 NFL seasons, only one of them was truly great, and he played his worst year last season. It’s safe to say he’s going to be a good QB for the long-term, but even Watson was being heralded by some as one of the best ever at one point. Let’s have more of a longterm grasp before we start anointing him because he’s exciting for a few years.

  12. MVP awards are great individual accolades,but most quarterbacks would rather get to and win the Super Bowl. Rodgers has done it exactly once in 17 years. Mahomes has a ring already and he’s only been in the league for 4 years. Watkins’ statement is a bit off,in my opinion.

  13. 2011 Aaron Rodgers is probably the best quarterback play I’ll ever see in my lifetime. Watkins is right.

  14. Well, I mean Pat doesn’t have 4 MVP’s and isn’t the reigning MVP is he? So Watkins isn’t speaking false. Just because KC has been able to put a better team around PM doesn’t say anything about their individual talent levels. The only reason the media is so high on Mahommes is because of his ethnicity. If he looked like Mitch Trubisky this article would have a much different tone and we all know it.

  15. Uh…Mahomes wouldn’t just throw the ball away in the red zone in an AFC championship game (with the game on the line) instead of being too afraid to run it in and take the hit.

    Rodgers is on another level allright.A choking level.

  16. Mahomes has a ring already and he’s only been in the league for 4 years.
    —–
    And Rodgers won the SB and SB MVP in year 3 of starting, so your point isn’t really valid.

  17. my Super Bowl is when Aaron Rodgers loses in the playoffs
    —–
    That makes me sad. You and I certainly watch football for very different reasons.

  18. I love that dumb football fans think Rodgers can’t win playoff games. He’s got 11 playoff wins AND a winning playoff record. But who cares about facts?

  19. Sounds like Sammy has done his homework and knows how to get the ball thrown his way!

  20. erickgreynolds says:
    August 23, 2022 at 8:32 pm
    Compare Mahomes first three years in the league with those of Brady, Rodgers, Manning (Peyton) and Brees and he leads in every category except interceptions of which he has the least.

    ———

    Brady already had 2 SB wins

    There….I compared them

  21. irishdude79 says:
    August 23, 2022 at 8:30 pm
    And yet they each have one SB ring, oh wait, Rodgers has more one and done in playoffs too
    ————————————————
    I’m sure you think Barry Sanders was a bad RB, since he has no SB rings and many playoff one and domes. Right?

  22. Aaron Rodgers had three years as a back-up to learn how to position people. That said, State Farm doesn’t care. Haha

  23. The people criticizing the playoff losses have no idea what conditions those games were played under. There were so many injuries going into three of conference championship games that the outcome was a given. Some quirky things happened in some of the other losses.

    AR had an off game in last year’s NFC title game. However, the game would probably have been won if A.J. Dillon had not been lost at halftime.

  24. Sammy is trying anything he can, to stay on the field instead of on the bench. My guess is he is looking over his shoulder at Romeo and Christian. If hope doesn’t trip over the chalk on the field and pull a hammy!

  25. Clearly Rodgers has a command of the offense and knowledge of defenses which comes with the wealth of NFL experience Mahomes simply does not have yet. Mahomes seems to be able to throw a football like a shortstop, and it’s incredible to watch, but Rodgers has some real accuracy as well, so there’s that. Watkins isn’t wrong. But as another one said, Mahomes is a media darling for sure, and gets the extra hype.

  26. Not very professional and in fact quite pathetic, from him, to try to diminish a QB who did accomplish in 4 years what very few were able to do. If you look at his career, one can understand he must be very frustrated.

  27. What has Watkins ever accomplished? He’s just another guy. Empty barrels make the most noise and there sure seem to be a lot of empty barrels in this league.

  28. Put Rodgers with Andy Reid and he’ll have just as much, if not more, success than Mahomes.

  29. Let’s just see how Mahomes does without Hill and an aging Kelce who without Hill around will probably get double teamed or jammed up at the line alot.

  30. So, Sammy is comparing a guy he played with in his 2nd and 3rd years in the league to a guy with 17 years in the league. Whole other level indeed!

  31. These comments reaffirm the world still cheer against Aaron Rodgers and the Packers just like last January

  32. These comments reaffirm the world still cheers against Aaron Rodgers and the Packers just like last January

  33. Never bet against Arron Rodgers. He has a Bust waiting for Canton. If nothing else Rodgers is the greatest ever at lobbying the refs for extra yards or an extra play.

  34. bradygirl12 says:
    August 23, 2022 at 8:49 pm
    MVP awards are great individual accolades,but most quarterbacks would rather get to and win the Super Bowl. Rodgers has done it exactly once in 17 years. Mahomes has a ring already and he’s only been in the league for 4 years. Watkins’ statement is a bit off,in my opinion.

    _____

    Rodgers won the Super Bowl in year 3 of starting, Mahomes in year 2. Rodgers had Mike McCarthy and some very good receivers. Mahomes had Andy Reid and 2 future hall-of-famers catching balls, including a top 5 TE of all time. You can debate who is a better QB (probably fair to wait until they’re both done playing), but don’t make it sound like it’s not even worthy of a debate.

  35. pkrlvr says:
    August 23, 2022 at 9:00 pm
    I love that dumb football fans think Rodgers can’t win playoff games. He’s got 11 playoff wins AND a winning playoff record. But who cares about facts?
    Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

    As a Packer fan I regret having to be the bearer of bad tidings. Rodgers-the-Wonder Horse becomes a pedestrian quarterback in the postseason, barring one spectacular performance more than a decade ago. The Packers have only missed the postseason one time during that period. Rodgers simply does not show up……as a game-changer….in the postseason. Please spare me the statistics. All things considered I think he should look for another job if he does not win the SuperBowl, this year, with this team. Win or walk.

  36. Rodgers throws the best passes in the league but Mahomes isn’t far behind with a slightly stronger arm and much better legs. Rodgers has about a dozen throws every season that just blow me away. He might be an alien.

    Splitting hairs here. Mahomes is younger but I remember the early 2010 and everyone was talking about how Rodgers would win multiple titles. Gets harder after you pay your QB 20% of your cap and are drafting at the end of each round. Lets see how Mahomes does it. His last time in the playoffs he was looking ordinary like Rodgers can.

  37. Hmmm, it depends on which team you are presently on doesn’t it? Another old receiver trying to keep his job.

  38. Same level; both will be considered in top active tier once the GOAT hangs it up after this year.

  39. Brandin Cooks needs to hold a press conference and claim David Mills has been far better in camp than Watson, Brady, and Brees combined in his experiences.

  40. I had no trouble with Tyreek Hill’s statement about Tua Tagovailoa being more accurate than Patrick Mahomes, and I have less than no trouble about Sammy Watkins’ statement. Neither remark denigrates the great Patrick Mahomes even slightly.

  41. “He’s amazing,” Watkins said of Rodgers. “How he controls the ball. How he puts everyone in place. I’ve been with a lot of quarterbacks, and I’ve never seen them carry themselves like Aaron Rodgers.”

    This is a guy who has been with one Tom Brady. Should we also be having a Brady-was-dissed fest?

  42. Why do we care what a guy who’s averaged 39 catches for 500 yards and 2 touchdowns over the past four years thinks? Sammy hasn’t been relevant on a football field since 2015. If he’s the Packers number one receiver this year, even with Rodgers, they will have problems.

  43. godnollid16 says:
    August 23, 2022 at 8:49 pm
    “Mahomes, already one of the very best quarterbacks the game has ever seen.”

    Agreed that that’s a tired narrative….but he’s only played 4 NFL seasons, only one of them was truly great

    ——————————————————————————
    Yikes.
    Paved Paradise and put up a parking lot…

  44. This is the Jeopardy answer to the clue, “Things you say when you want the ball thrown to you.”

  45. Why does everyone automatically assume that “another level” is higher or better? It could always be lower.

  46. Rogers is a better QB and has been. Talk about Pat in 7 or 8 years as the best ever, until then Rogers is the better QB for sure

  47. But who is better at dressing down his teammates on the field?

    Erin is hof in that category

  48. So put Mahomes in Green Bay, and Put Rodgers with Andy Reid and Tyreek Hill and Travis Kelcie, plus that oline. Rodgers might shut down the league.

  49. Indeed Aaron Rodgers is all the way up to his neck full of himself more than Mahomes

  50. “But Mahomes has accomplished more from a team standpoint in four years as a starter than Rodgers has in fourteen.” All that means is that the Chiefs have had an overall better team and coaching than the Packers have for the last four years,not quarterback. its no secret that McCarthy cost the Packers wins with his bad coaching and the Packers defense had been one of the worst in the league,and special teams,well we wont even waste our time describing them.the Chiefs excelled in all three,coaching,defense and ST but it wasnt the quarterback who was better in KC, it was the team around their quarterback.

  51. “As Big Cat from bar stool says, my Super Bowl is when Aaron Rodgers loses in the playoffs. And I’ve won a lot of Super Bowls. I’ve got a dynasty cookin.” you and Big Cat got to be Viking fans because thats the only way you two will ever see a Super Bowl.

  52. Rodgers is 11-10 in the post season after playing 17 years Mahomes is 8-3 after playing four years, yeah Sammy tell us again that Erin is on another level than Mahomes. Sammy will be on the IR after week 4 anyway.

  53. I love that dumb football fans think Rodgers can’t win playoff games. He’s got 11 playoff wins AND a winning playoff record. But who cares about facts?

    =====

    Sure he does now, but he’s also 0-4 against inferior SF teams in the playoffs now. And for being as talented as he is doesn’t really have a signature playoff win and only has 1 Super Bowl at this point.

  54. Rodgers is 11-10 in the post season after playing 17 years
    ==========

    4 of those losses, the D gave them absolutely ZERO chance to win.

    3 more of the losses were walkoffs, where Rodgers scored the last time he had the ball in his hands.

  55. Aaron Rodgers is one of the greatest quarterbacks. I don’t dispute that. I’m just saying that it’s a pretty glaring stat for him, with all of his MVP awards, to have only one championship in 17 years. It’s too early to say if Mahomes is going to be on his level, so what Watkins said seems more like a jab at Mahomes than anything else.

  56. And for being as talented as he is doesn’t really have a signature playoff win and only has 1 Super Bowl at this point.
    ===========

    2010 Divisional; he demolished the 1 seed in their building. Nearly had a perfect passer rating.

    His Super Bowl; he could have had a record setting day, the receivers left points and yards on the carpet… he was MVP, regardless.

    Then you had Seattle in 2014. The defending Champs. In their building, the toughest place to play at the time… the D blew what should have been an insurmountable lead.

  57. ((Sammy Watkins says Patrick Mahomes is no Aaron Rodgers))) He is right !! Patrick Mahomes has OBLITERATED all of Aaron Rodgers 17 year Career in just 4 Seasons and did so without a TOP 10 Defense. The last time Rodgers took his team to the Super Bowl I do believe we had Tvs with the Rabbit Ears.

  58. Well of course Rodgers is on another level. As is Brady. Mahomes is 26. Check back in 12 years.

  59. Here’s the thing – in the music business there is a category “One hit Wonders”. Ya know bands that have one hit and then tour off that song for years. That’s exactly what Rodgers is he’s one hit wonder. His last hit was in 2011 and has lived off that for how many years trying to be in the category of Brady, which he will never be. Rodgers will never have another “hit” but he will continue to suck the organization dry of money living off past accomplishments.

  60. Watkins just wants as many targets he can get before he pulls a hammy in week 3 or 4 and is out for 7 weeks.

  61. Very funny that some are trying to downplay how good Mahomes is. “But..but..but…Mahomes has only done it for a few seasons. But…..he wasn’t as good last year”.
    ///////////
    50-13 record. Avg 38 TDs, 4,750 yards a season.
    I mean, by what measure are you comparing him to? Wins? SB wins? Stats? He has them all.

  62. Rodgers-the-Wonder Horse becomes a pedestrian quarterback in the postseason
    ==========

    Regular season QB rating – 104.5 (2nd all-time)
    Postseason QB rating – 100.1 (1 of 7 QBs in history over 100.. #1 all-time through 2014)

  63. I have no doubt Rodgers is amazing, but of course, it is smart to talk up your QB if you want to get the ball.

  64. Super bowl wins aren’t the only measure of one player’s greatness. If that were the case Franco Harris and Rocky Bleier would be the GOAT’s of running backs, and Dan Marino would be ranked as just a whatever for a QB.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.