In same week NFL reminded teams of the rule, officials missed clear “assisting the runner” foul

USA TODAY Sports

As the Eagles moved toward the end zone for a touchdown that would tie Thursday night’s game at seven in the first quarter, Philadelphia got closer to the goal line when center Jason Kelce pulled running back Kenneth Gainwell forward at the end of the play.

It should have drawn a flag. It didn’t.

Prior to 2006, the rules prohibited pushing a runner. That year, the rule was revised to allow pushing. However, it remained illegal to “pull a runner in any direction at any time.”

As noted by the Football Zebras account on Twitter, a foul hasn’t been called for assisting the running in 30 years. Per a league source, however, the NFL sent this week a video to all teams regarding the “assisting the runner” rule, specifically pointing out that pulling a runner is prohibited.

And the officials still missed it.

Amazon’s rules analyst, former NFL referee Terry McAulay, later explained that a penalty should have been called. (McAulay also mentioned the video, something I didn’t catch during the live broadcast.) As the source who informed us of the recent video described it, the failure to spot the foul reflected “utter incompetence” by the officials.

It happened so early in the game that it’s impossible to say it affected the outcome. But it helped get the Eagles a little closer on a drive that resulted in a 7-7 tie, instead of a 7-3 or 7-0 deficit. And it’s another example of the simple fact that the game officials aren’t as good as they need to be, especially not in an age of ever-spreading legalized wagering.

20 responses to “In same week NFL reminded teams of the rule, officials missed clear “assisting the runner” foul

  1. They sent the video to the teams but forgot to send it to the officials. It’s a simple mistake that any multi-billion dollar-operation can easily make.

  2. Not trying to defend the refs, especially on something that helped the Eagles. But there are so many rules, and one like this which hasn’t been called in about 30 years, while watching it in real time and looking for other penalties, is probably easy to miss. I wish they’d have called it, but I get why they didn’t.

  3. What a dumb rule. If a lineman came up to the side of a running back, are they going to spend 5 minutes reviewing if he was pushing or pulling? Probably.

  4. They never call assisting the runner when linemen push from behind, why should the sky fall when a runner is pulled? Both ways, they ASSIST the runner.

  5. Pretty certain I saw just about half the Houston defense go up to the ref and explain to him that that penalty had just taken place..

    With refs utter incompetence is always the scapegoat for deliberate inaction.

  6. And it’s another example of the simple fact that the game officials aren’t as good as they need to be, especially not in an age of ever-spreading legalized wagering.

    ————–

    Let’s be clear, the refs have never been as good as their press. It’s just usually, in a show of solidarity, the broadcasters used to ignore any incompetence by the union guys. I remember when the league had replacement refs because the league wanted to switch to fulltime refs and every announcer and website put the league on blast swearing AFTER EVERY PLAY that someone was going to get hurt on the field if the league didn’t give in to the union.

    Those who bring up the FAIL MARY play forget that the league official reviewing the play made the call on the play, not the ref on the field but the loud, constant drumbeat from this website (and the broadcasters) made any rational discussion impossible.

  7. What is sad it that the Texan D told the officials what happened, and the refs still ignored it. When presented with facts and how they relate to the rules refs need to correct their calls on the spot. But they’re too proud to admit they missed it.

  8. After watching that a few times it did seem it was more holding up than pulling him forward by his helmut

  9. What is incredibly embarrassing about the play is that several of the Texans immediately recognized and pointed out the penalty to the Ref just standing there….. Sad when the players know the rules better than the officials

  10. You missed the second review where the runner’s knee was down before most if not all of the drag. Yes if they gave the runner the one I would agree its a foul, but they placed the ball at the three so the pull didn’t assist in gaining any advantage or extra yards.

    The officials made it up to the Texans with the roughing call, that was clearly a 1 step pull up.

  11. the league causes its own problems. ive been watching football forever (i;m old). the 2006 change was the cause of the current brouhaha. there wasn’t anything to be gained by having running plays look like rugby scrums, but the league is full of itself. too many lawyers and not enough football people.

    its impossible to officiate some of the goofy rules they think up (read roughing the passer if he is named brady, but not jackson or hurts).

  12. Most fans realize that the REFS can control the game and the way it swings. Very hard to watch football now with the gambling influence that goes hand in hand with it.

  13. 60ftlesbianoctopus says:
    November 4, 2022 at 6:40 am
    Pretty certain I saw just about half the Houston defense go up to the ref and explain to him that that penalty had just taken place..

    With refs utter incompetence is always the scapegoat for deliberate inaction.

    ——–

    Are you actually suggesting that if players go to the ref and say “hey…this guy from the other team [broke a rule]” that the refs are supposed say “oh…okay!” and then throw the yellow flag?

  14. Stupid to allow pushing or pulling a runner, just make assisting the runner in any form a penalty like it use to be!

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.