Aaron Rodgers says he’s been playing with a broken thumb

Tennessee Titans v Green Bay Packers
Getty Images

Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers hinted that his right thumb might be broken during his weekly appearance with Pat McAfee. Rodgers confirmed it while speaking with reporters in Green Bay on Wednesday.

Rodgers said that he’s played with other broken fingers in the past, but that this is the first time he’s dealt with a broken thumb. He said surgery was never a consideration and that he thinks he’s played through other injuries that have had more of an impact on his play.

“I think I’ve had worse injuries I’ve played with. Definitely a challenge, but the days off helped. Feeling better this week,” Rodgers said, via Matt Schneidman of TheAthletic.com.

Rodgers is coming off a poor game in last Thursday’s loss to the Titans and another losing effort against the Eagles this Sunday night will leave the team with little realistic playoff hope for the season. Given the nature of the injury, it will be interesting to see if the Packers keep playing Rodgers when and if their postseason ambitions are totally extinguished.

66 responses to “Aaron Rodgers says he’s been playing with a broken thumb

  1. “…via Matt Schneidman of TheAthletic.com.

    Favre is coming off a poor game in last Thursday’s loss to the Titans and…”.

    Oh no you didn’t! LOL.

  2. Sorry if I call boshie on this one. Karron Rodgers cries about everything and a broken thumb would have been his catalyst for central attention.

    Remember when Lord Favre played with a broken thumb? Didn’t practice during the week, put that cast on it, a wrap of tape, stepped onto the field and won. John Madden went into hyper Brett love over the broken thumb.

  3. Favre is coming off a poor game in last Thursday’s loss to the Titans
    Favre!!! still living in the good old days!!

  4. Will Rodgers stict his thumb in the camera and cry like he did last year with his toe? Look at me and my thumb everyone!!!

  5. I think Josh is having a few bevvies before Thanksgiving (or the editors). FAVRE???? hahahaha

  6. Um, aren’t these injuries supposed to show up on injury reports? Oddsmakers, gambling, and so on. Am I naive in thinking that this should be sounding alarm bells with the League and the Union?

  7. Favre jokes aside, if he’s played with worse, why mention it this time?
    Sounds like making an excuse while he says “I’m not making an excuse”

  8. It seems like everyone wants to see Love on the field – I wouldnt mind it either – Actually – despite a bad performance by the defense last game against the Titans – AR did have the chance for a comeback – he just missed too many throws in the last quarter – The way that Phillie has played the last 2 games – dont be surprised if the Pack pulls up their socks and surprises them . But maybe not

  9. So…no mention of this on the injury reports? Do the Packers lose a draft pic or does that only happen to the Dolphins these days?

  10. This is getting sad as hell now. I used to really like this guy. Is there any player less likeable than him right now? Maybe Kyler Murray. Insufferable is a good one i think.

  11. Ben Rothlisberger once played an entire playoff game with an unexploded French WWI mortar in his chest . . . unsure how he received it never having been to Verdun. What a champion!! Was removed safety during the off-season without anesthesia, or even an Ypres uttered from his manly lips.

  12. A quarterback with a broken thumb on the throwing should probably be on the bench but kudos to Rodgers for playing with it.

  13. Before we glorify Brett’s broken thumb Performance too much… packers finished 8-8 and he threw 22 td and 23 picks

  14. And Rodgers has been on injury report every week and missed practice most Wednesdays. So no injury report conspiracy

    It also should be noted Rodgwrs passer rating before and after injury are almost identical.

  15. Because you don’t like him he can’t have a broken thumb, or even explore the possibility. He may be washed up, but he just might, in fact, be out there playing with a broken thumb. Some people are just sadly pathetic haters for very few logical reasons.

  16. Sorry Aaron. Not buying it. You want some cheese with that whine?

    You’re a snowflake and you and everyone else knows it. Shut up and play football.

  17. An investigation into the Packers by the NFL should be started immediately for not disclosing this injury….or maybe they know not to waste their time with a known liar!

  18. dfosterf says:
    November 23, 2022 at 7:42 pm
    Because you don’t like him he can’t have a broken thumb, or even explore the possibility. He may be washed up, but he just might, in fact, be out there playing with a broken thumb. Some people are just sadly pathetic haters for very few logical reasons.
    ———————————–
    Could it be both a broken thumb AND being washed up?

  19. Lots of Rodgers haters on this post who were sure Rodgers was on a steep decline, only to get news [unpleasant for them] that an injury was involved. If injury denial doesn’t work, then cite how xxx played through similar-or-worse injuries and get back at Rodgers that way…

    It’s a thumb people; that is how you grip-control the ball….

  20. #12’s right thumb has been on the injury report every week since the Giants game, folks.

  21. Yea, he threw his teammates under the bus and then he threw his coach and playcalling under the bus, so I guess it’s time to blame the thumb now. What a piece of work this guy is…hang it up and call it a career while you’ve still got some dignity left.

  22. Personally I don’t believe anything Rodgers says or talks around at this point. He had a lot of goodwill banked among Packer fans years ago and has managed to throw it all away.

  23. Funny, if a player has an injury that affects his performance and keeps quiet about it, the fans demand everyone involved be suspended for falsifying the injury report. If the player reports it, the fans mock and humiliate him for being a drama queen and not suffering in silence.

  24. There has to be a reason for his crap play. Couldn’t possibly be he doesnt practice or do ota’s or pre season and wonders why his receivers are not on his page

  25. The first Favre ALSO played with a broken thumb and almost won the MVP. Quit the excuses #12…

  26. So another excuse, if he is having such problems why isn’t their 1st round drafted QB playing, this is what they drafted him to do, or is he that bad.

  27. it will be interesting to see if the Packers keep playing Rodgers when and if their postseason ambitions are totally extinguished.
    +++++
    They are extinguished. Aaron should go on IR yesterday. Bak too.

  28. Just like when Russ was playing bad he was hurt too…. Were his receivers hurt when he was throwing them under the bus?

  29. If that’s true and with him it’s 50/50 he should not be playing heck it’s time for Love anyways give the kid his chance Rodgers is yesterdays news .

  30. He only hurt his team by playing with the broken thumb.Jordan Love would have won some of the games given the chance.

  31. Either you love him or hate him; I’m in between. He’s not what he used to be but there’s a number of teams that would take him in a heartbeat. Maybe in the off season that will happen. Either way, it’s been a hell of a ride over the years.

  32. I think it difficult to imagine a football player I dislike more than this one. If you have a broken thumb, don’t play football. The constant excuses for not being prepared, not being a good team mate, pointing fingers at everyone but yourself, it’s getting old. Go away dude

  33. And Rodgers only disclosed this because he told someone at a Make a Wish foundation that it was broken.. and that person tweeted it and it was picked up.
    .

  34. dfosterf says:
    November 23, 2022 at 7:42 pm
    Because you don’t like him he can’t have a broken thumb, or even explore the possibility. He may be washed up, but he just might, in fact, be out there playing with a broken thumb. Some people are just sadly pathetic haters for very few logical reasons.

    It’s Rodgers, that’s a logical enough reason for me ………..

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.