Packers say they don’t need to see more from Jordan Love to decide on fifth-year option

Green Bay Packers v Chicago Bears
Getty Images

Even if Aaron Rodgers returns to the Packers for 2023, there’s no guarantee that he’ll be back for 2024. And there’s one specific way the Packers need to plan for that. The team believes it already has everything it needs to make that decision.

By May 3, the Packers have to decide whether to pick up the fifth-year option for quarterback Jordan Love. Meeting with reporters earlier this week, G.M. Brian Gutekunst said the organization already has what it needs to make that decision.

“We’re really pleased with his progression, and what he’s been able to do,” Gutekunst told reporters regarding Love. “I think it would be really good for him, the growth that you need to go through. Seeing things for the first time. Making the mistakes that you need to make. But I think from our end of it, we’ve seen what we need to see.”

How have they seen it, given his limited regular-season playing time?

“We’ve seen him for three years in practice, and doing the things that he’s doing,” Gutekunst said. “There’s a stretch here where Aaron’s been banged up, where he’s had a lot of reps with the ones. I think it was great for him. It was great for us to see. But it was also just really, really good for him to experience game-planning each week.

“I think quarterback’s got to get in this league, play a bunch of games before they learn how to win. But I do think we feel very confident that Jordan can move the ball, score points, and do the things that we ask of our quarterbacks.”

Gutekunst was asked whether he believes Love is ready to be a starter in the NFL.

“I do,” Gutekunst said, with a caveat. “You’ve got to go out and do it in real games, and all that. And I think that’s important. But all young quarterbacks go through a period of time where no matter what individual success, I think it takes them a little bit of time to win in this league. And that’s going to be important for Jordan whenever he gets his opportunity. But that’s a big part of it. I mean, it’s — learning within the game is very important for that development.”

The question becomes when Love will get that chance in Green Bay. At some point, “when” will become “if.”

Either way, the next big “if” relates to whether the team will pick up Love’s option, when the deadline rolls around in less than five months. If they pick up the option, Love will be under contract at least for two more years.

47 responses to “Packers say they don’t need to see more from Jordan Love to decide on fifth-year option

  1. If they give him the 5th year option, the packers will be exhibit A on how to NOT handle a rookie QB contract. They’ll also be dedicating alot of cap space next year to two QBs

  2. Aaron Brett Favre Rodgers probably has only a couple of years of mediocre play left, and that’s if he doesn’t check out early

  3. Jury’s still out imo but he looked good against Philly. Not much to go on but all we got…

  4. Hmmmmm, backpedaling on one of the worst drafting of that year? That year they had the 31 st ranked defense and horrible WRs besides Adam’s. So they draft a QB in the first round that they could have gotten in the 5th round. 👌🤣

  5. He’s cheap. I think they’ll let him play out his 5th year option, then draft somebody new afterwards.

    If Love had shown any serious promise in the last off-season, they would’ve let #12 go, and went with Love. But they didn’t they gave #12 a boatload of money they could’ve spent elsewhere, and maybe been better off.

  6. ariani1985 says:

    Hmmmmm, backpedaling on one of the worst drafting of that year?
    +++++
    They could have taken Jeff Gladney… how’d that pick work out for the Vikings? I forget.

  7. They would be morons to pick up his 5th year. He stinks but who else are they going to get? Jimmi G. next year? Baker? Kaep? Jeff George??

  8. Regardless of how Love turns out, the Packers have put on a clinic about how not to benefit from a QB rookie scale contract. The sole benefit of a young QB taking their lumps while figuring out how to play the position is that the team has several years to sink that extra 20 to 50 million into the rest of the roster.

    If (and it’s a big “if”) the Packers traded Rodgers after this season, the packers would get a single year of a reasonably priced QB. After that, they’ll owe Love a cool 20 million for his 5th year option. If he shows enough to take a chance on him moving forward, the price only goes up.

    Love seems like a good kid and I wish him well, but drafting him was one of the all time great screw ups in the history of NFL personnel management. A team fresh off of a 13-3 season in desperate need of another high end weapon (Justin Jefferson anyone?) to get over the hump decides to trade up and reach for a QB that can never, ever benefit their aging HoF QB. And then they waste every cost controlled year of the kid’s contract. Unbelievable incompetence.

  9. I mean, some QBs come in the Leagh and sit for years. Others come in and start day one. The team has to cut the starter, and let the new guy in. Can you say Burrow!

  10. He stinks but who else are they going to get?
    —–
    How do you know that? I’m a packer fan and I don’t have a clue how good he is, so how in the world do you know?

  11. Hmmmmm, backpedaling on one of the worst drafting of that year? That year they had the 31 st ranked defense and horrible WRs besides Adam’s. So they draft a QB in the first round that they could have gotten in the 5th round. 👌
    —-
    And none of that changes the fact that they’ve owned the division since 1993.

  12. That ball was friggin movin’. Jordan Love was whipping that thing.
    —–
    I noticed that. His motion was smoother and his confidence seemed high. Gave me some hope! Rodgers has a cannon but Loves’ passes made his look like I was chucking it.

  13. There are a lot of experts on how to develop a QB – even a rookie. Look at Pittsburgh – started with Trubisky and a horrible Oline and he played horribly of course . So they put in Pickett and he is struggling but the Oline is improving. But do they know – not yet – but their approach is not necessarily wrong – unless he happens to get hurt = like Lance – who sat for a year and then got his season ended in game 1 of his second year. Love never had a chance even to be a backup due to Covid and lack of any thing. He got a little bit year 2. So maybe his slow approach is ok. How many Bakers, Darnolds, RG3’s, Johnny M etc etc.
    It looks like Love might just have it – and because he didnt play – his 5th year is going to be relatively cheap – $19 million Between Lowry and Amos – $56 million – and there is the opportunity to kick some of 16’s money down the road.

  14. Did anyone point out to Gutekunst that he doesn’t know his arse from a hole in the ground when it comes to evaluating NFL talent?

  15. I get that the Love pick will always be controversial (unless the Packers somehow become the only team ever to have 3 HoF QBs in a row) but could we please quit it with the Justin Jefferson nonsense?

    Jefferson was drafted 22nd. The Packers picked Love 26th, and they had to trade up to get there.

    They never had a shot at Jefferson (and if they hadn’t taken Love, they probably would have drafted Patrick Queen, to try and fix their ILB mess).

  16. There are certainly a whole lot of Monday Morning QB’s here in PFT. Most of them have never set foot on a gridiron.

  17. Smh at those who continue to say the Packers passed on Jefferson. He was gone before the draft got to the position GB traded up into. If he had been there, the Packers quite probably would have taken him. He wasn’t.

  18. As a lions fan, I completely agree. Give the 5th year option and pay Rodgers to blow it all up again. Love it

  19. If Gute picks up Love’s or Rogers’ option or both options, he should be fired on the spot if he even says he’s thinking about it behind the closed back in Green Bay. To not trade Aaron when you get a chance to some desperate team, kinda like a certain desperate team did over in Ohio did, is totally absurd and a total failure in doing your job as the GM of a NFL team. The Texans fleeced the Browns for 3 consecutive first round picks and a few other picks for a possible PR nightmare of a QB that may never play at a elite level ever again. What would Rogers bring? If Aaron is the greatest QB to ever throw a football like all the delusional fanboys say, dude, you could set the Packers up with so many draft picks that you would set the Packers up possibly for years and years and years to come. Gute better be planning on getting Aaron’s nonsense out of your hair to better the team in the long run. This should be priority numero uno.

  20. A problem any team would love to have is a first round quarterback pick with tremendous athletic upside waiting in the wings and avoiding wear and tear while watching and learning from a first ballot HOF journeyman ….like Rodgers did. How did that work out?

  21. Love seems like a good kid and I wish him well, but drafting him was one of the all time great screw ups in the history of NFL personnel management.
    ===========

    It motivated Rodgers, and drove him to 2 more MVPs.

    They had 2 really good shots at the Super Bowl. Maybe if bleachers were full the Covid year?

    .. we can play Draft what-if every year. Who would they have picked? Probably defense, and look at how that has been working out?!

  22. I think you’ll see Jordan Love on the field for parts of the next 4 games.
    The thing I immediately noticed when Love came in against the Eagles for the 4th qtr,… he looked a lot more comfortable and calm compared to the previous years. Does that mean the Packers give him the option year ?
    Maybe they trade Jordan Love this offseason. Nobody knows at this point.
    Maybe Rodgers retires.

  23. philmccracken says:
    December 7, 2022 at 9:43 pm
    It’s amazing – almost like a HOF QB factory.
    ____
    Just like is was amazing how the Packers were a loxk to win their then precious nfcn title back in July. Hoot!

  24. lunscr says:
    December 7, 2022 at 10:33 pm
    I get that the Love pick will always be controversial (unless the Packers somehow become the only team ever to have 3 HoF QBs in a row) but could we please quit it with the Justin Jefferson nonsense?

    Jefferson was drafted 22nd. The Packers picked Love 26th, and they had to trade up to get there.

    They never had a shot at Jefferson (and if they hadn’t taken Love, they probably would have drafted Patrick Queen, to try and fix their ILB mess).
    ========================

    I think everyone is aware of this, lunscr. The point is that if you’re going to mortgage draft capital to move up, do it right and get another weapon for a team that was on the brink of going to the Super Bowl just a few months prior to the draft.

    Instead they decided to draft a player that would never get this collection of players over that hill. Then they compounded the mistake by wasting all of the cost-controlled years of Love’s contract.

    As to the other comments rationalizing the drafting of Love pushing Rodgers to new heights of play, this is an extraordinarily sunny rationalization of what can only be called a bad personnel move.

  25. As to the other comments rationalizing the drafting of Love pushing Rodgers to new heights of play, this is an extraordinarily sunny rationalization of what can only be called a bad personnel move.
    ==========

    They haven’t drafted particularly well, so one would have to assume they hit on the pick. I’m not willing to stand on that limb.

    But I can draw a straight line from Love being drafted to Rodgers playing arguably as well as he ever has.

  26. When did Packers fans become so dumb ? Loves debut stunk yes so did Favre’s the Young man looked great a few weeks ago seems to me Rodgers is pulling out every trick to make sure we don’t ever know if he’s better like he did versus Favre. Every team will take a young gifted QB over an old gifted QB 10 out of 10 times and Rodgers knows it.

  27. Gutenkust is the Darrel Bevel of Gms. No matter what else he does in his career, he’ll always be remembered for one terrible pick.

  28. A team fresh off of a 13-3 season in desperate need of another high end weapon (Justin Jefferson anyone?) to get over the hump decides to trade up and reach for a QB that can never, ever benefit their aging HoF QB. And then they waste every cost controlled year of the kid’s contract. Unbelievable incompetence.

    This is so tiresome. Jefferson was off the board, as was their second guy (Brandon Aiyuk). They could have perhaps had Tee Higgins or Michael Pittman, but to date both of those guys have been good but not great. Drafting Love might turn out to be a mistake, but the idea that the Packers blew off Justin Jefferson to draft Jordan Love is simply wrong.

  29. The point is that if you’re going to mortgage draft capital to move up, do it right and get another weapon for a team that was on the brink of going to the Super Bowl just a few months prior to the draft.

    +++++

    Before that draft every Purple was posting how Rodgers was only 10-12-1 in his last 23 games, and the Packers went 6-9-1.

    How does that equate to being on the brink of going to the Super Bowl? I will wait.

  30. When did Packers fans become so dumb ? Loves debut stunk yes so did Favre’s the Young man looked great a few weeks ago seems to me Rodgers is pulling out every trick to make sure we don’t ever know if he’s better like he did versus Favre.
    ==========

    Rodgers has been hurt, and has played some of the worst football of his career. Arguably THE worst.

    Why didn’t LaFleur sit him?
    If LaFleur wasn’t willing to take that stand, why didn’t Gutekunst mandate it?

    If Love was the better player, he would have been on the field.

  31. Read: AR we got the message. You’re in charge and we once again bow down to you oh great one. Please don’t screw us any more.

  32. If he isn’t any better than what Aaron has played then he flat out isn’t worth a darn. Better trade him and try again.

  33. So there going to spend 19 million dollars on Love based on what they have seen in 1 quarter play this year against a prevent defense. They are preparing you to not get upset on playing young players the rest of the year. Next year the roster will be even worse because of the salary cap. They need high draft picks and a good draft and they are still a year out from being a contender

  34. Next year the roster will be even worse because of the salary cap. They need high draft picks and a good draft and they are still a year out from being a contender
    ===========

    Elgton Jenkins is the only significant FA. Lazard and Tonyan too.. but its not hard to argue they are expendable.

    They’re not going to struggle with the cap. Savage is on his way out (nearly $8mil) Preston Smith has a ludicrous roster bonus ($8 more) Gary can be extended, his number is nearly $11mil. Couple that with whatever the cap increase is… they’re fine. Absolute non-starter.

    The issue is the same as it has been for years now; how fast can they fix that defense??!

  35. harryhands09 says:

    If he isn’t any better than what Aaron has played then he flat out isn’t worth a darn.
    +++++
    Aaron has a better QB rating than Cousins. You heard it here from a Vikings fan:

    Cousins isn’t worth a darn. Extension soon to follow.

  36. iliketurtles says:
    December 7, 2022 at 8:04 pm
    If they give him the 5th year option, the packers will be exhibit A on how to NOT handle a rookie QB contract. They’ll also be dedicating alot of cap space next year to two QBs

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

    And then Rodgers retires after 2023, and Jordan Love makes you spend another 15 years crying about how the Packers “just lucked right into another one.”

    Meanwhile, your team continues its “draft and destroy” methodology and runs through another 20 or so promising young kids at QB.

  37. I expect the Packers will not pick up the fifth year option, but rather will sign Love to a three year extension.

  38. iliketurtles says:
    December 7, 2022 at 8:04 pm
    If they give him the 5th year option, the packers will be exhibit A on how to NOT handle a rookie QB contract. They’ll also be dedicating alot of cap space next year to two QBs
    =======================================================================================

    Yeah but all the old heads must love this. They firmly believe in drafting a QB to “sit and learn” for years, and completely disregard salary, team construction, and 5th year options. If you aren’t starting your cheap first round QB by midseason, you’re doing it wrong.

  39. Rodgers won’t retire next season get real he has 100m waiting for him in the next two seasons so he will take full advantage of this terrible contract. Nor will he ever win anything above a divisional championship which is no big deal for 50M a year. Th wise move is to trade him to SF or Las Vegas some tea with a realistic shot at the SB.

  40. Rodgers $59M in 2023 and if they take the option on Love it is $20 so $79M on 2 players and only 1 can play. Good work packers and Gutey.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.