Jim Irsay on coaching job: Jeff Saturday is a candidate, but there are “a lot of great” ones

USA TODAY Sports

In 24 days, the Colts will officially commence their search for a new head coach. Interim coach Jeff Saturday wants the job.

Colts owner Jim Irsay, who already may have decided to hire Saturday but who has no reason whatsoever to say that until completing a Rooney Rule-compliant search, addressed the situation with reporters on Wednesday.

“I’m looking forward to the interview process,” Irsay said. “I think Jeff’s a candidate but there’s a lot of great candidates out there. I think there’s a lot of great candidates in college. I think the pool needs to be broadened somewhat more. There’s some great college coaches that may be capable. There’s some unknown coaches that may be capable.”

It’s odd that Irsay would consider college candidates, other than Michigan coach (and former Colts quarterback) Jim Harbaugh. (Harbaugh has said he’s not returning to the NFL; Nick Saban also said he won’t be the Alabama coach.) College coaches without extensive NFL coaching experience simply don’t do well in the NFL.

Still, Irsay has shown that he’s willing to embrace the unconventional. From inexperienced to unknown, he seems to be willing to cast a wide net — and to keep something other than the most obvious fish.

Regardless, the favorite seems to be Saturday. We’ll see if that changes when Irsay assesses the full scope of Saturday’s performance and begins talking to candidates.

17 responses to “Jim Irsay on coaching job: Jeff Saturday is a candidate, but there are “a lot of great” ones

  1. “Nick Saban also said he won’t be the Alabama coach” Huh? Is that true or am I reading that wrong.

  2. A lot of coaches with NFL experience don’t do well either, I wouldn’t go ruling out all college coaches except Harbaugh

  3. If Irsay would agree to allow him full control of personnel,.. Sean Payton would be a prime candidate. He’ll demand a huge salary,.. but so what. Do you want a Super Bowl team Indy ?

  4. The coaches with the best players win. In college, you have to be a good recruiter. If you’re a great recruiter and your team is good, you can sign unlimited numbers of the top players. In the NFL you have to rely on a good scouting system and good talent evaluators. But in the NFL if your team is good, you have to choose from the leftovers. A coach with lots of charm and charisma can’t just go to the top ten draftable players and convince eight of them to sign with your team, like a college coach can. College is designed for the rich to get richer. The NFL draft is designed for the poor to get richer.

  5. Pretty sure that college coach Harbaugh has already proven he can coach in the NFL also. If Michigan wins the National title a SB win is the only thing left on his bucket list.

  6. Probably not the first morning he has awakened and said, “what in the world was I thinking?”

  7. Tony Awesome says:
    December 15, 2022 at 1:19 pm
    If Irsay would agree to allow him full control of personnel,.. Sean Payton would be a prime candidate. He’ll demand a huge salary,.. but so what. Do you want a Super Bowl team Indy ?

    ——————

    Lol. There’s a reason Payton left the Saints and it wasn’t because he wanted to try his hand at broadcasting. He tried one year without a hall of fame QB and got out of there before costing himself long term.

    Belichek was a great coach, when he coached Brady. Pre-brady and Post-brady not so much. Sure the Colts can rebound quickly if they draft the right rookie QB but if they draft a Zach Wilson the Colts are still screwed regardless of Paytons credentials.

  8. charliecharger says:
    December 15, 2022 at 1:41 pm
    The coaches with the best players win. In college, you have to be a good recruiter. If you’re a great recruiter and your team is good, you can sign unlimited numbers of the top players.
    _____________

    Recruiting does not work that way anymore. In the new era of NIL it is only about which school is paying the most.

  9. Harbaugh to the Colts and he reaches out to Luck to return. That is the game plan. Luck talking to the media about football and his regrets leaving has opened the door and harbaugh is one of the few coaches he would come back to play for

  10. So, Matt Ryan is the Colts QB of the present and future, and the Colts only concern is their HC?

    As a long time proud Colts hater, that works for me; especially if they go with Saturday as HC.

  11. In reality, it’s the Rooney rule that seems unfair by giving preferential treatment to a select section of the population. Isn’t it the goal of every owner to do what’s best to help their team win, in which case they’d want to pick the BEST qualified candidate, irrespective of what section of the population they represent. Where does one draw the line? Race, gender, religion, etc? May the best candidate be chosen.

  12. Those good coaches will pass on the Colts too many holes to fill, this is a rebuild needed not a contender. Hairball and Payton will want a better team then the Colts. Denver is close if they get a real QB and some offensive talent, the D is solid and looking for offense.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.