Sunday Night Football: Calls go against Commanders in 20-12 loss to Giants

NFL: DEC 18 Giants at Commanders
Getty Images

The Giants won for the first time in five weeks, moving into the sixth spot in the NFC playoff picture. Their 20-12 victory over the Commanders clinched a playoff berth for the Cowboys, who lost to the Jaguars earlier in the day.

The Giants are 8-5-1, while the Commanders fell to 7-6-1 but remain in the seventh spot in the playoff chase.

The Commanders scored a touchdown with 1:01 remaining on Brian Robinson‘s 1-yard run, but Terry McLaurin was cited for an illegal formation. Washington got two more chances, and both were incompletions.

Taylor Heinicke‘s fourth-down pass into the end zone was intended for Curtis Samuel, who had Darnay Holmes wrapped all over him with no chance to catch the ball. Holmes got away with pass interference with 48 seconds left, and the Giants escaped with a win two weeks after the teams tied 20-20.

NBC rules analyst Terry McAulay said he wouldn’t have called the illegal formation, referring to it as “too technical,” and he disagreed with the non-call for pass interference.

The Commanders still would have had to convert a 2-point conversion to tie it.

On a 2-point conversion in the third quarter, Heinicke hit Samuel in the end zone, but Jahan Dotson was cited for offensive pass interference for blocking Holmes. (McAulay agreed with that call.)

It was that kind of night for Washington.

Washington led 3-0 after its first drive of the night, but it’s the only time the Commanders led. They trailed by 11 at halftime.

Rookie edge rusher Kayvon Thibodeaux starred for the Giants, with 12 tackles, three tackles for loss, a sack, a forced fumble and a fumble he recovered for a 1-yard touchdown.

Saquon Barkley had 87 yards on 18 carries, and Daniel Jones went 21-of-32 for 160 yards.

The Commanders had 99 more yards than the Giants, gaining 387. Heinicke was 17-of-29 for 249 yards and a touchdown. He also lost two fumbles, the one that Thibodeaux returned for a touchdown and another in the red zone.

Robinson ran for 89 yards on 12 carries, and Dotson caught four passes for 105 yards and a touchdown.

72 responses to “Sunday Night Football: Calls go against Commanders in 20-12 loss to Giants

  1. Did you just seen an exciting play in an NFL game? There’s more than a 50% chance now that the play will get negated by something that is happening on the opposite side of the field. Hope you’re having fun!

  2. Not a Commanders fan but they straight got robbed by the officials. Doesn’t mean there have won, but the chance to take it to overtime is everything in a close divisional game in December on Sunday night football. I mean, give me a break.

  3. It is absolutely baffling to me how the NFL partnering with sports books and profiting from the legalization of gambling has coincided with officiating becoming absolutely atrocious and inconsistent…..

  4. Officiating in the NFL is a really poor product this season and it continues to get worse each week.

  5. Giants have been screwed by some bad OPI calls all year, so I’ll take it. I also wonder how Thibodeaux got poked in the eye but is not illegal hands to the face. Either way, Giants made fewer mistakes and weren’t great but a win is a win

  6. Yes, that 4th down pass at the end was DPI, but I agree with what Mike and Cris said in the booth… no official wants to make that call unless it’s beyond blatant. Samuel still had the opportunity to catch it after Holmes initially pinned his arms. These teams are evenly matched, and the NFC East is well positioned to make noise in the playoffs.

  7. The pass interference was so obvious – nothing even remotely subtle. Saying the game was rigged is more flattering than the real answer which is massive incompetency. A sky judge fixes this problem – this reoccurring problem.

  8. The announcers after the non PI call at the end were discussing how refs don’t like to make big calls at the end that can affect the outcome of the game. But wasn’t that exactly what that illegal formation call was? A call at the end that affected the outcome? The only consistency among refs is their inconsistency. The NFL needs to do something about it, but who knows, they could be nudging refs a certain way to appease betters.

  9. Hmm lets see there was the phony holding call that negated Joe Burrow being sacked for 20 plus yards that got the Bengals back in the game, there was Dolphins receivers getting mugged all Saturday Night yet when Bills get jammed at the line it was an instant flag, now a blantant holding call in the endzone gets missed and screws Washington out of a potential overtime. That is 3 games that were tainted by phony officiating and screwed teams directly out of victories in one week.

  10. scarletknight says:
    December 18, 2022 at 11:56 pm
    Meanwhile, Thibs, Williams and Dex Lawrence were held on every play.

    Sweat, Payne and Allen feel their pain

  11. That was like watching two, very mediocre, but evenly-matched JV teams go at it. If these two met 10 times they’d each win 2, with 6 ties, and in no game would either team score more than 20 pts.

  12. Eagles got screwed by the refs in their lone loss vs the commanders so a little poetic justice there. BUT…. It’s freaking time we figure out a way to not let these things happen again.

    STOP EXCUSING THE REFS. We need a new system

  13. Another WWE Fix … the NFL and its Refs had a really bad weekend. Incompetence , League Initiative, or Mob Gambling?

  14. A game with major playoff implications with in the the division and a Ron Rivera coaches team does a no call no show….color me shocked

    Ball on the one yard line and Scott “my dad got me this job” turner decides to line up in shotgun formation?

    PATHETIC PLAY ALL AROUND

    and chaseless young is still on a milk carton

  15. Also I can’t believe how they made the qb fumble the ball twice and the kicker miss an extra point. What a travesty.

  16. I’m not understanding why a coach can’t challenge a pass interference call non call! They are usually the missed calls that affect games more than any other. So why would any coach be kept from deciding it should be challenged. They are also usually the plays that hardest to get right because they happen fast and farthest away from officials so often.
    Let the coaches decide what they want to challenge.

  17. Meanwhile the New York Nightmara Family Crime Syndicate wide receivers were holding on almost all plays thrown to the sidelines.

  18. To be so by-the-book on the illegal formation and then so let-them-play two plays later on the PI — that’s aggravating.

  19. A very wiseman in Nevada once said…”He who controls the officials,….controls the outcome”.

  20. That was a pretty bad blatant no-call at the end. It is plays like that that make people say the NFL is rigged. It is no bigger call there as it is in the 1sr quarter. Has the same impact on the game and should be called.

  21. NFL officiating has become an abstract art. Too often I stare at my TV on the wall as if in a museum, tilting my head, chin in hand, and saying, “Hmmmmm.” Picasso could have defined pass interference or RTP more concretely than the NFL.

  22. McLaurin: Is this where I am supposed to be?
    Ref: Yes.
    Ref throws flag for illegal formation on McLaurin.

  23. In any other business one would see management pull together emergency meetings and mandate urgent changes in order to rectify a situation threatening the business.

    And, clearly, the combination of on-field officiating and New York review have become an urgent threat to the consistency and quality of the product, and faith among their customers in the product itself.

    They can’t do anything immediate concerning changing of rules. But they can issue new guidance to the officiating crews and they can initiate Tuesday zoom calls to discuss blown calls and they can OVERHAUL THE ENTIRE NEW YORK REPLAY REVIEW CREW!

  24. “somebody had the under”. Uhhhhh. The score was 20-12. Unless there is a monsoon you will probably never in history see an under low enough for that score to hit. What?

  25. Cry me a river. I don’t recall one time the media went this nuts for calls against any other team. Yeah, like this is THE first time the refs screwed up.

  26. 60ftlesbianoctopus says:
    December 18, 2022 at 11:46 pm

    It is absolutely baffling to me how the NFL partnering with sports books and profiting from the legalization of gambling has coincided with officiating becoming absolutely atrocious//////////

    Right there, it is why in the past owners and commissioners stayed away from anything to do with gambling and the NFL. I think the owners and Roger think they are bullet proof. I got news for them, they are not. I will walk away from it.

  27. the nfll has told you you can’t trust your eyes, but don’t worry the integrity of the shield is paramount! seems like over 50% of games are now decided by the zebras and not the teams- this is what happens when tens of millions of dollars are at stake for every game- if you still think it’s legit, you are not paying attention. Many of you seemed to believe whatever replay review tells you rather than trusting your own eyes– foot out of bounds on a TD, it’s okay we reviewed it, and it’s just an optical illusion. they may flop in soccer, but they are not blatantlu dictating games like the nfl and nba do

  28. meadowlandssports says:
    December 18, 2022 at 11:49 pm
    Yes, that 4th down pass at the end was DPI, but I agree with what Mike and Cris said in the booth… no official wants to make that call unless it’s beyond blatant.

    Couldn’t have gotten any more blatant than that.

  29. The refs were in COMMAND of the game .. so much whining on these replies.. Better team won..GIANTS are in year one of rebuilding and are playoff bound !!!!

  30. The breaks and missed calls even out over time. As a Giants fan I’ve been on the other side many times. But Big Blue’s front liners and wounded warriors stepped up. Good for them. And don’t worry about Evan Neal. He’ll see some Pro Bowls. Give him time.

  31. It’s time for the government to pull its antitrust exemption and start investigating the NFL for collusion.

  32. If you have to blame the refs, then you just did not take care of business in the first place. Simple. Only losers blame the refs. Even if they suck and call the game badly, overcome it.

  33. NFL has an officiating problem that needs to be a bigger issue. These clowns are going to blow a playoff game.

  34. Yes, I’m a biased Eagles fan, but it’s hard for me to have a ton of sympathy for Washington after the hideous no-call on them on the Goedert face mask.

  35. Although I love it when the patriots lose, and really enjoyed that last play that gave the raiders victory; that guys foot was clearly out of bounds on the that touchdown reception by the raiders. Whats with the Mysterious lack of a good viewing angle? Well, payback to Belichek for that pass interference non-call against the rams that kept the saints out of the Superbowl…Washington also got screwed, anything to give the cowboys a wild card slot…Bags of Cash make things happen!

  36. I love it when the patriots lose, and really enjoyed that last play that gave the raiders victory; that guys foot was clearly out of bounds on the touchdown reception by the raiders. Whats with the Mysterious lack of a good viewing angle? Well, payback to Belichek for that pass interference non-call against the rams that kept the saints out of the Superbowl…Washington also got screwed, anything to give the cowboys a wild card slot…Bags of Cash make things happen!

  37. the non call didn’t cost Washington the game; it was Rivera and his terrible OC that refused to scheme help to block the giant pass rushers… how many times will a LB come off the edge and hit the QB, before you realize you need help?

  38. Calls go against…hahahah. cute. Any calls make the Giants strip sack fumble td or calls for the 97 yd drive for a td? Both decent teams but your record is who you are…

  39. Officiating seems to have regressed since the (mostly) national legalization of sports gambling. These refs may have had a tough game last night, but I’m sure their Draft Kings accounts did well.

  40. What I found interesting is that Terry McAulay said that you have to call the PI if you would call it in the first quarter you should call it there but then he said that they should not have called the illegal formation because it is too technical. You can’t have it both ways, if you would call one you should call the other. Sounds like McAulay isa big ol bitter Commanders fan.

  41. Was this technically a penalty? Probably. But I do feel like flags shouldn’t be thrown at crucial points of the game when they have no bearing on the outcome of the play. With the inclusion of RPO’s in a lot of offenses, I see a lot of “illegal man downfield” penalties called when the offensive lineman aren’t even touching anyone or in the vicinity of the play. Yet it’s called all the time despite the fact that it rarely has any bearing on the play. I understand the rules, but in my opinion, this type of penalty (and the one against McLaurin)should be more subjective. Think about it…if the penalty “isn’t” called, would anyone complain? If the answer is no, the penalty shouldn’t be called IMO.

    That said, the Commanders had 2 shots in the past 3 weeks against the Giants. In a must-win game with playoff implications, it shouldn’t have come down to a couple plays. Bad calls happen every week to every team. It’s the teams that can overcome them that are successful. Washington clearly isn’t there yet.

  42. As Commanders fan, yeh i was upset for about 5 minutes for those non-calls, but lets be real people, even if they both skins and giants make it to playoffs, how deep they gonna go in p.offs? the way i see it now, skins just gained couple of spots in draft by this loss. on sidenote, does anyone else think nfl decision are starting to go against d.snyder since its now in open snyder had everybody and their mothers followed by Private Investigators.

  43. Chiefs DB’s weren’t allowed to touch wr’s yesterday but Tampa and NY could manhandle wr’s with no concern for flags. KC was flagged 5 times on 3rd down, giving the Texans 5 1st downs. It saying all 5 were bad, but 3 of them were horrendous. If KC would’ve done what the NY DB did on the last play if the game, he’d be in jail for assault. There is no way one crew should be so much different than the others. The one common denominator is the point spread…. Weird how bad it’s gotten since the betting started. Inexcusable! And it makes it very hard to watch if a certain outcome seems to be in play…

  44. imagine if this happened in the NFCCG and cost a team the superbowl….oh wait. saints fans have been telling everyone for years its a screw job but everyone said theyre just crying.

  45. Officiating needs to be taken away from the NFL and handled by a third party that has full time refs. Each refs weekly stats then need to be tracked and published for the world to see with underperforming refs getting quickly replaced.

    In addition, the NFL needs to start following the NBA no harm no fowl rule. If a penalty is committed away from the play, if it did not have any bearing on the play it should not be called. Games would go much quicker. In this game, the first penalty would not have been called but the PI would have.

  46. No one wants to hear the excuses when it happens to New York so tough and take it. The officiating can be better most games and probably not a job most would want. Jones was responsible and never turned the ball over. Washington QB did. The Giants don’t even have a 1st String receiver to catch a pass. Washington did. The Giants Defense won that game in Wink Martindale Fashion. Accept it.

  47. Nfl using refs to stock the playoffs with the teams they feel will bring in the highest TV ratings = $$$$$.
    The commanders just don’t have ratings the cowboys do….

  48. Evan Neal, pro bowl?

    Who cares! You aren’t watching it. It means nothing. The front lines of the giants just gave up 400 yards… let that sink in. Prolly 500 if it went to OT as it should have

  49. The Giants Defense won that game in Wink Martindale Fashion. Accept it.

    Accept that defense just gave up 400 yards against an undrafted qb. Giants going nowhere.

  50. My take, the referring is getting horrible again. The replay and use of a guy in NYC deciding calls is ridiculous at best.
    I’ve said before the refs listen to Collingsworth and he points out things they missed and then the action stops so they can review it making them look the genius. He didn’t get his pass interference call last night at the end, refs probably 2anted the game over and go home for Christmas.

  51. It took 3 or 4 flagrantly bad calls to get the cowboys a gauranteed playoff spot, but you know the nfl, they always find a way!

  52. I know there are people that say this every year, but this year it really may be true: This season has been the worst officiating I’ve ever seen in the NFL. It’s been a rare game that I’ve watched this season that doesn’t have at least 1-2 major blown calls that have the potential to significantly impact the result of the game.

    This is magnified by the league having more closely decided games this year than any previous year.

    I don’t know how it gets fixed, but personally I think it starts by high profile media members speaking up and calling out the problem. This isn’t a Commanders/Giants problem, this is a league-wide problem.

  53. That guy had his hands all over that poor Washington receiver. But Dan Snyder thinks that is perfectly acceptable behavior.

  54. Most don’t like the Commanders because of the Snyders, an understandable feeling. But let’s not exacerbate the problem by exhibiting no intellectual integrity and harming many of the good people who work for them. Roger Goodell ordering his soldiers to just steel a game like that, so obviously is beyond shameful. It tears at the fabric of human integrity, if there’s any left. I’m just waiting for a class-action lawsuit related to gambling losses from such blatantly obvious deliberately blown calls. There’s no other explanation for what happened to Washington last night. Some of the NFL refs are really (really, really) bad, but no one in the NFL with a job would have blown those calls without direct orders from the top.

  55. Giant fans think they did something. Now they can spit their “their something special about this team. They’ve got swag. They’ve got that winning vibe” nonsense. It’s a December tradition.

  56. Giants fans in this thread: “Bad calls even out…you gotta overcome, brah. Deal with it.”

    Giants fans the next time a call doesn’t go there way: “NOT FAIR MAN WE GOT ROBBED! WAAAH!”

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.