49ers beat Raiders in overtime in Brock Purdy-Jarrett Stidham QB duel

San Francisco 49ers v Las Vegas Raiders
Getty Images

It would have sounded crazy to say this a few months ago, but 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy and Raiders quarterback Jarrett Stidham just played an outstanding quarterback duel.

In the end, however, it was a Stidham interception in overtime that set up the 49ers for their game-winning field goal in a 37-34 win.

Purdy completed 22 of 35 passes for 284 yards, with two touchdowns, one interception and no sacks, and he continues to look like a shockingly good quarterback for someone who entered the league as “Mr. Irrelevant” in the 2022 NFL draft.

But Stidham also looked good, making the first start of his career. He completed 23 of 34 passes for 365 yards with three touchdowns and two interceptions, although that final interception was costly.

Raiders wide receiver Davante Adams made no secret of the fact that he was disappointed that Derek Carr was benched for Stidham. But Adams is a consummate professional, and he turned in a great game for Stidham, topping 150 receiving yards and making one of the plays of the year in the NFL this season with a spectacular diving catch.

Christian McCaffrey topped 100 rushing yards while Brandon Aiyuk topped 100 receiving yards for the 49ers, who won their ninth in a row and remain in contention for the No. 1 seed in the NFC.

60 responses to “49ers beat Raiders in overtime in Brock Purdy-Jarrett Stidham QB duel

  1. This game was not good for my heart. Stidham is the real deal, Raiders got a good QB for near season.

  2. Just a friendly reminder that the 49ers still have not beaten a top team this season.
    In their only major test they were blown out by KC.

  3. Im 100% convinced Mcdaniels sabotaged Carr at this point. The proof is the first drive of the 3rd where Stidham was allowed to audible into a different play (Something Carr wasnt allowed to do). Not a single reverse called, and he finally schemed the players into what they do best (renfrow in space// waller on LBs).
    To go outta your way to embarrass the Franchise’s all time best QB to boost your own career and ego should be cause enough to fire. Shame nothing will come from this, not even firing the defensive coordinator is bewildering. Salute to Stidham for playing a solid game, his ability to move adds a spark but coaching per usual blew this game. Season officially over.

  4. One really has to wonder about Trey Lance’s future with the 49ers. I know they gave up a LOT for him, but if Purdy continues to win, I don’t see how you can replace him with a complete unknown.

  5. Stidham did a real good job but you can only throw up so many jump balls. Especially against this defense. Great showing by the Raiders. I’m surprised how much effort these guys put in and looking forward to a win against KC before the circus comes to town.

  6. Raidering definition #219: Benching/forcing your franchise QB to quit, then play great a few days later, against a top team. Get to overtime, then the raidering commences and you blow it, again. Stidham looked a lot like Carr, in overtime…

    Just lose baby!

  7. Wild game was honestly expected
    It’s 9ERS/Raiders New Years day. The environment was insane just from a TV view.

    That adversity and environment will only help the QB and going to make team better

    Good game but, the Raider O-line came in with the game plan of holding, my gawd

    Good win

    BangBang

  8. Battle of the Bay 2.0!!!

    Any given Sunday as they say and this certainly was a wake up call for the 49er defense. You gotta give it to Las Vegas for playing with nothing to lose and smacking us in the mouth. That Stidham guy looks the part btw, so Happy New Year to Raider fans next season.

    Onto Arizona and the highest seed they can earn.

    GO NINERS!!!!!

  9. As we ,”cash out” in vegas, we now march south to lol at the cardinals. Nobody is stopping this train to six. #goniners #bangbang

  10. How is the league allowing the Raiders to sit Derek Carr versus the chiefs in his last game as a raider. Chiefs/raiders is one of the all time AFC rivalries. It’s a slap in the face to competitiveness.

  11. MortimerInMiami says:
    January 1, 2023 at 7:32 pm
    Just a friendly reminder that the 49ers still have not beaten a top team this season.
    In their only major test they were blown out by KC

    ———————————————

    Just a friendly reminder that the Dolphins are terrible and Mortimer is a casual.

  12. MortimerInMiami says:
    January 1, 2023 at 7:32 pm
    Just a friendly reminder that the 49ers still have not beaten a top team this season.
    In their only major test they were blown out by KC.

    00Rate This
    —————-
    They beat healthy Tua led Miami who were 8-3 when they played each other

  13. Vegas should NOT expend any extra draft picks on a first-round QB next spring. Stidham appears to have the talent to assume the QB1 job while draft assets are deployed to build a respectable D and O-line.

  14. Stidham played great today, for the most part, but let’s calm down with the “Raiders have their franchise QB” talk…it was one game, and how often have we seen this? A guy comes in and plays lights out, then falls back to Earth once there is film on him…just saying, slow the roll. Maybe he’s a gem, but I do think the play calling was much better today for Stidham than it has been all year for Carr.

  15. What a horrible game by the niners D. But all the credit and kudos to stidham. Such poise and accuracy. Wonder if he could be the real deal for the raiders.
    Wouldn’t it be awesome to see that happen while Mac Jones is destroyed by Belichick/Patricia etc.

  16. Raiders once again preparing for “next year” all while it still “this year”. How do they have any fans, 20 years of awfulness and people still claim them. That 1-way relationship takes a special kind of person to stick with them.

  17. Stidham is not the answer.He played pretty well but he lost the game in overtime by throwing the interception.

  18. The best QBs are drafted late.

    Looks like the Pats should’ve drafted Stidham….. oh wait

  19. raider says:
    January 1, 2023 at 8:00 pm
    Stidham is not the answer.He played pretty well but he lost the game in overtime by throwing the interception.

    ————-

    Did you watch the game? Kolton Miller got bull rushed right into him as he threw the ball.

  20. MortimerInMiami says:
    January 1, 2023 at 7:32 pm
    Just a friendly reminder that the 49ers still have not beaten a top team this season.
    In their only major test they were blown out by KC.

    ———–

    Nine wins in a row. Must be tough on you.

  21. MortimerInMiami says:
    January 1, 2023 at 7:32 pm
    Just a friendly reminder that the 49ers still have not beaten a top team this season.
    In their only major test they were blown out by KC.

    *****

    Remember when the Dolphins were 8-3?

  22. It’s true niners haven’t beaten anyone. But they have won 9 straight. Can’t ignore that. They may get a vastly inferior foe in rd 1 or a very very hot team. It will be interesting to see how they do in these playoffs.

  23. springfield says:
    January 1, 2023 at 8:00 pm
    Raiders once again preparing for “next year” all while it still “this year”. How do they have any fans, 20 years of awfulness and people still claim them. That 1-way relationship takes a special kind of person to stick with them.

    ——————

    It’s called being a fan. You think everyone should be bandwagoners.

  24. No defense no win. That 4th and goal at the 2 before half blew the game. That’s McDaniels.

  25. nhpats2011 says:
    January 1, 2023 at 7:44 pm
    Looks like the Pats should have kept Stidham after all
    —-
    Sure. Stidham > Crappe

  26. The Raiders didn’t miss Derek Carr at all. They lose by 3 tds if he’s playing QB for them today.

  27. I’m a chiefs fan, ben one since 85. I know all about fandom. But even in their down years they still had regular post season appearances, regular season excitement, but they just could never win in the playoffs. It was like 25 years for us. The entire Gonzalez era, Priest Holmes, Trent Green but many winning seasons and they probably had 10 playoff appearances in 25 years. You guys are perennial losers. 1 playoff appearance to show for it? Has it been 3 cities in that time? Like I said, you’re special if you’re still hanging around.

  28. Stidham vs 49ers: 23-34 365 yards 3 TD 2 INT 108 rating
    Tiny Arm Tom Brady vs those very same 49ers: 34-55 253 yards 1 TD 2 INT 64 rating

    Therefore Stidham > Tommy. Simple logic. Can’t argue against it.

  29. Wow, I didn’t think the 49ers defense was as good as projected, but I didn’t think they were as bad as they looked. If Jarrett Stidham can hang 34 on them that’s not a dominant defense. They might win one or two in the playoffs but I personally think that good coaches will be able to slow down Brock Purdy, and if their defense plays like it did against LV and KC they won’t be able to beat the better teams in the league. We’ll have to see, but it should be interesting to see if they’re everything they’re supposed to be. There is something to be said about the nine wins in a row. I think the Chiefs are somewhat similar in that they haven’t really beaten the best teams in the league and at times it hasn’t looked pretty against the lesser teams but regardless both of them have gotten the wins, which is what matters.

  30. The play calling looked different because Stidham has 3 yrs in the system. The team played hard. They didn’t seem to broken up about the QB change. I wish the Pats had given Stidham a better look during the Cam year.

  31. Lol, it is crazy because it wasn’t a ” quarterback duel”. But it was a fun game.

  32. MortimerInMiami says:
    January 1, 2023 at 7:32 pm
    Just a friendly reminder that the 49ers still have not beaten a top team this season.
    In their only major test they were blown out by KC.
    —————————————-
    5-1 against teams that have either already qualified for the playoffs, or are still in the playoff race. Blown out by KC…is that your measuring stick? It took overtime for KC to beat the worst team in the NFL.

  33. quite the game considering. between the two teams, they are looking to relieve themselves of 3 QBs

  34. The Raiders were getting good under Gruden but not even a year under Mcdaniels and they stink.

  35. If Purdy keeps playing like this,the Niners have their starter. As for Stidham,a very impressive game. I wish that Belichick had given him more of a chance.

  36. GoodellMustGo says:
    January 1, 2023 at 8:27 pm
    nhpats2011 says:
    January 1, 2023 at 7:44 pm
    Looks like the Pats should have kept Stidham after all
    ——————————————————————
    I like Jarrett Stidham as much as the next fan, but please, it was only one game. That would be like saying the Colts should sign Jeff Saturday because he won his first game as a HC.

  37. Great game and Raiders scored 17 points in each half. It was not the usual pathetic second half by the offense. Very good sign for the franchise. #1 they already have a possible replacement for Derek Carr only days after moving on from him. #2: it was the current coaching staff that signed this guy. #3: 500 yards and 29 first downs against a pretty good defense. Let’s be hopeful. For LV this game was all about 2023 and fixing the QB, fixing the offense. A very positive sign indeed. For one game it looked like the Raiders made the correct decision in hiring Josh McDaniels. A great offensive scheme that Carr just for whatever could not grasp. Now there is hope. Week 18 is big, the Raiders need build on this offensive performance. They hope to see another good performance from #3. Raiders looked like New England 5 years ago on offense. That was a big reason for bringing in Josh McDaniels. It is also great sign in the personnel department. Can this coaching staff build a team and draft wisely.

  38. But but Bill the GM is terrible but somehow he drafted Jimmy G and Stidham. Both will start next year.

  39. This Pats fan likes Stidham as much as anyone. I think that given the chance he may one day be as consistently good as Jacoby Brissett, Nick Foles, and Carson Wentz.

  40. Do the Raiders still adhere to the Commitment to Excellence standard?
    —————-
    Not for nearly 40 years.

  41. 14 of the 49ers 17 opponents this season have losing records. They have three losses to teams with double digit losses and barely escaped a Raiders team with a backup QB who shredded their defense. They have just ONE win vs a team over .500. Legit?

  42. patsfan4lifedynasty says:
    January 2, 2023 at 2:59 am
    But but Bill the GM is terrible but somehow he drafted Jimmy G and Stidham. Both will start next year.
    ——————-
    He traded both of them away too.

  43. A few things….

    1: Brock Purrdy is definitely a massive upgrade over Trey Lance. Landing Purrdy may have saved Shanahan after the whole Lance debacle.

    2: The Raiders played like they always play under McDaniels, good 1st half only for the Defense to lose it in the second half. Huh, who would have thought, the problem wasn’t at QB. That said…

    3: Had McDaniels played Carr and opened up the playbook for DC like he did Stidham? The Raiders win that game yesterday.

  44. Raiders played much better than usual, 49ers played below par and Purdy threw some poor throws, maybe the fame has gone to his head

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.