NFL ponders playoff seeding without playing Bills-Bengals

Buffalo Bills v Kansas City Chiefs
Getty Images

The NFL continues to discuss and deliberate the unfinished Bills-Bengals game from Week 17.

Nothing is official yet. Here’s what we currently know.

Bills-Bengals most likely will not be played. The players don’t want to do it. And there’s no good way to fit it into the schedule.

The best bad solution in this regard would be to play the NFC wild-card round and Bills-Bengals next weekend, with the AFC wild-card round being played the next weekend. This would wipe out the week between the conference championships and the Super Bowl. There’s no appetite for that approach.

The question then becomes seeding the AFC playoffs without Bills-Bengals. Winning percentage becomes the most obvious method. But there are concerns about equity, given that the winner of the Bills-Bengals game would have been in position to be one of the top seed AFC seeds.

One possibility would be to add an eighth team to the playoff field in the AFC. This would eliminate the bye for the No. 1 seed.

To ensure competitive balance, there would have to be eight teams in the NFC, too.

The NFL Players Association would have to agree to a temporary expansion of the playoff field.

Discussions also are continuing on the possibility of making the AFC Championship a neutral-site game. The problem with this approach is that if, for example, a team other than the Bills, Chiefs, or Bengals qualifies for the game, there’s no need to use a neutral site.

However it plays out, a decision needs to be made soon — especially if the playoff field will unexpectedly grow, in both conferences. It changes the dynamics for the teams vying for playoff positioning.

107 responses to “NFL ponders playoff seeding without playing Bills-Bengals

  1. The continued positive news coming from Hamlin’s family should make this decision a little less dire regarding optics.

    PS- what wonderful news!

  2. I say, just call the game a tie and deal with it. If they didn’t want to finish it, then so it goes.

  3. This is getting tiresome.
    The simplest solution if Bills/Bengals isn’t going to happen is to have any playoff game that involves two of Cincinnati, Buffalo, or KC at a neutral site. Neither of them have clearly won home field therefore none deserve it.
    The number #1 seed has becomes all but meaningless anyways because if it isn’t the Bengals or Bills, all three of the current top seeds would have had essentially a bye week in January.

  4. Just flip a coin.

    Having the Bills/Bengals play week 19 could potentially give the Chiefs a 2 week vacation before they host their first game.

    Why reward a team that was beaten by the Bills and Bengals?

  5. How is it a problem for a neutral game site even if those 3 teams don’t make it? If they don’t make it, then play it at whosever team’s stadium it should be played at based on seeding. Then just cut the neutral stadium team a small check for holding it available. You don’t know who the teams are until a week before it’s played anyways.

  6. Thank Goodness Damar Hamlin is improving.
    This is gonna be chaos, if they dont resume the game chiefs beat raiders get the 1, but your gonna give buffalo the 2 over cincy? Burrow has beat mahomes and was gonna beat allen too. So your gonna send cincy to buffalo? INSANITY.

  7. This seems like the way to go. Obviously, it’s not perfect, and it’s not fair – but life isn’t that fair, anyway. It’s probably as equitable a solution as they could come up with.

    The biggest beneficiary is KC. I don’t love the thought of the Bills having to go there again when they were so close to earning a chance of being able to host that game (if it happens).

    But ultimately, all of the teams who were going to make the playoffs are still going to make the playoffs, and all of the teams who still have a chance to make the playoffs will still have that chance.

  8. The game needs to be played in order to be fair to everybody else.
    It’s the only way.
    The fact that Damar Hamlin has now opened his eyes and is responding should make that an easier call for everybody. Glad he’s OK… 👍

  9. the nfl can figure out how to play this game, it really cant be that hard. expanding the number of playoff teams is a horrendous idea…that cannot happen, its ludicrous. any other solution is better than one that includes bringing in a team that is absolutely not worthy.

    An offseason solution to some of these nail biter issues imbedded in this situation is to
    bring back the top 2 seeds getting a bye instead of only 1 which in this situation puts huge pressure on everyone to make the right decision, when there really isnt one.

  10. So apparently the league doesn’t want to give up the two week bye between the conference championships and the Super Bowl. It would just throw everything topsy- turvy. It means having a standalone game instead of the Wild Card Playoffs. It would change everything. Make it easier for a Wild Card team to get to the Super Bowl because of the extra rest those teams would have. Sure they play an extra game but you are allowing them to get healthy too. Meanwhile the #1 seeded teams with a bye will get stale. Much for the league to contemplate. There is no easy solution.

  11. Bills/Cinci don’t deserve a L or a DNF (Did Not Finish), and the Chiefs don’t deserve 1st seed–both teams beat the Chiefs. Play it with the 1st NFC WC round and play the AFC WC round the following week. If you must use win %, that still screws them. Bills deferred and never got to the 2nd half, let alone the 2nd QUARTER!

  12. Don’t worry things will work out just fine … the Chiefs lose and Bills get #1 seed just ask Roger.

  13. If they don’t want to play it, then ask them “Y’all good with a 7-3 Bengals win?” and move on?

  14. mjkwarch says:
    January 5, 2023 at 1:12 pm
    “Does everyone in attendance from last Monday night get ticket refunds?”

    Good luck with Mike Brown on this one!

  15. Both of these team willingly forfeited, and the playoffs should be seeded without them.

  16. It should be a tie or no game in the standings. The two teams effectively agreed to a tie when they walked off the field. The Bills would have prob had to forfeit because they couldn’t continue, but the Bengals did the right thing and also left the field. So it’s a tie, and all the other implications for other teams are what they are. Problem solved.

  17. Expanding the field to eight teams or messing around with home field or byes or whatever creates more inequity than it solves.

  18. onlymyopinioncounts says:
    January 5, 2023 at 1:14 pm
    Just flip a coin.

    Having the Bills/Bengals play week 19 could potentially give the Chiefs a 2 week vacation before they host their first game.

    Why reward a team that was beaten by the Bills and Bengals?

    Why reward a team that doesn’t want to play a game?

  19. If they can they should play the game. They should move the playoffs one week and loose the extra week between the Conference title games and Super Bowl. In football terms if they don’t play, it probably give an unfair advantage to the Chiefs for Home field and probably the Bengals for the division. Both are major!

    They did everything right on Monday night. A man’s life comes first. They need to keep doing thing right for fairness of the game.

    Please don’t bring up the waist of time Pro Bowl that should be after the Super Bowl anyway.

  20. Love the idea of adding an 8th playoff team to each conference. Then you’d have miami/jets/pitt at KC and Campbell/GB/Seattle @ Philly.

  21. Why not consider this: if KC and Buffalo win this week, use win percentage to seed. KC gets the bye, BUT if the championship game is KC/Buffalo that game will be played in Buffalo. Seems like a fair compromise that wouldn’t change everything for the other playoff teams, and Buffalo did beat KC.

  22. If they add an 8th team to each conference this year, I suspect those 2 extra televised playoff games will become permanent.

  23. Why should KC get penalized because bills/Cincy refuse to resume game ??!!….Eirher play game or let seedings land where they may. If bills & Cincy don’t want to resume game then they reap what they sow re: playoff seedings

  24. If it isn’t determined by tonight or early tomorrow morning, then they are not rescheduling it.

  25. Let’s assume KC is the 1 and Buffalo is the 2. I read that it was also being considered to give KC the choice of home field or bye, and Buffalo chooses whichever KC doesnt take. KC would likely take the bye.

    This makes more sense and is more equitable than either neutral site or 8th seed. With both the 8th seed and neutral site options, Buffalo is effectively conceding their chance at both the bye and home field. With this third alternative, both Buffalo and KC give up 1 and keep 1.

    A 4th option- KC loses and Buffalo/Cinci both win. Relegate KC to the third seed. Same number of losses and they lost to both Buff/Cinci. Who cares if they won one more than Cinci in that case, they lost to them. Then you hash out Cinci/Buffalo with a coin toss in lieu of the game.

  26. Bills beat the Pats and Chiefs and Cincinnati both lose this weekend. Bills would then be #1 seed even if they lost Monday night. Problem solved.

  27. The bye arguments don’t add up. If the game isn’t played, the Bills and Bengals effectively received a week 17 bye. Sure, it wasn’t a bye by normal standards, and there certainly wasn’t a bye mentally. That said, most. Although it is sadly itronic, most players effectively revived a bye week physically. Regardless the tragic circumstances, the extra time away from contact for most Bills and Bengals players at this point in the year is a significant advantage.

  28. The simplest solution is seed based on winning %. Any other solution is convoluted and pulls in more teams that are impacted. As it is, the only change is home field for a series of three teams. That is an important factor, but there’s no guarantee it would be any different if the game were played. Adding a playoff team is the most disruptive possible solution. So much of every NFL game and season is based on luck. It’s impossible to make a solution that is fair to everyone, but the more we change the more unfair it is to more teams.

  29. I know I am a little biased, but just call it a 7-3 bengals win and use that as precedent for any future games that are stopped by mutual agreement of both teams.

  30. Choose a captain for each team and have them play Madden to see who wins the game!

  31. There would be a considerable cost to rescheduling the entire playoffs. Every network needs to reshuffle. For FOX, CBS and ESPN this most certainly would mean termination of broadcasts of college basketball and/or NBA games during that time. There would be financial implications that the NFL would be on the hook for by asking that of the networks and other leagues- reimbursement of the original deals, and likely covering the costs of new deals. No way the NFL wants this when the alternative is simply not playing a game.

  32. The bills still have a chance at the number 1 seed. I don’t understand the logic of the chiefs lost to the bengals and hills, so they shouldn’t get the afc champ game at home. They lost last year to the bills and bengals, but still ended the season with a better record, so the had the Number 1 seed.
    Let’s see how this weekend plays out. If the ills lose to the Pats, and the chiefs beat the raiders, then the bengals game wouldn’t matter.

  33. All because one game wasn’t finished. I say either decide a winner in the game without finishing it or call it a tie game. Then simply carry on as it goes.

  34. I think the NFL is waiting to see the outcome of week 18 and then seeing what would be different for the playoffs if the Bills won, the Bengals won, or they tied. They will then be able to fully assess the what ifs accurately and determine if they can cancel the game because the impact is negligible (or the only teams impacted are the Bengals/Bills) or need an outcome (because the seeding or teams that qualify could be drastically different).

    If they need an outcome, wouldn’t they have a lot of options?

    1. Continue the game (the when is the trickiest part)
    2. Take the score when play was suspended and make it final
    3. Declare it a tie
    4. Modify the rules for the game (like only play overtime)
    5. Bills/Bengals agree on who wins/loses and one team forfeits
    6. Flip a coin

  35. “One possibility would be to add an eighth team to the playoff field in the AFC. This would eliminate the bye for the No. 1 seed.

    To ensure competitive balance, there would have to be eight teams in the NFC, too.”

    ARE YOU KIDDING ME?! So one UNDESERVING teams could be allowed into the playoff field in BOTH conferences. SO much WRONG with this idea! Imagine if one of those teams catches fire and goes to the Super Bowl when they should NEVER have been in the playoffs to begin with! As an Eagles fan, MY team would get screwed over the MOST! The Eagles are the ONE team who should have a #1 Seed and first round playoff bye INDISPUTABLY wrapped up this week. The Eagles are dealing with a multitude of injuries and NEED the first round playoff bye that they have rightfully EARNED in order to get completely healthy! Bills/Bengals vs. Chiefs AFC Championship game on a neutral site… fine. Keep the decision SIMPLE and FAIR. Please don’t EXPAND the playoff field by allowing one or two ELIMINATED teams in. That would be plain WRONG on many levels.

  36. Bills/Cinci don’t deserve a L or a DNF (Did Not Finish), and the Chiefs don’t deserve 1st seed–both teams beat the Chiefs

    ———

    If KC ends up with the most wins in the afc they deserve the 1 seed….that’s how it works. It’s how it always worked. How long have you been watching football?

  37. A lot of crazy ideas…the score of the game was 7-3 before play was halted. Bengals win. Fixes everything.

  38. Sorry but penalizing KC for any of this isn’t an answer either. Everyone is so quick to not want to “punish” the Bills or Bengals but are ready to punish KC which had zero involvement in any of this.

  39. The game WAS PLAYED…. The Bills & Bengals BOTH wanted to stop the game from continuing & the players have ALREADY been paid… the game ENDED 7-3 with Bengals winning…. IT IS A DONE DEAL!!!
    Proceed with this weeks games reflective of that result & this comes to an end & playoffs proceed as scheduled… SERIOUSLY, it’s really not that difficult…. There are consequences for everything in life… DEAL WITH IT!!!
    The fans & vendors already got hosed….
    Ps: AWESOME to hear Hankins improving!!!!!

  40. Might as well play the AFC tournament in Detroit, the Bills will be comfortable there. I think Roger is going to help the Bills in any manner possible. Shades of Rozelle aiding Pittsburgh in the 70s.

  41. It says in the article that the players don’t want to play the game.

    So, all you guys saying they have to play the game aren’t going to get your way.

  42. Q) Why reward a team that was beaten by the Bills and Bengals?
    A) Because they have a better record… it’s not rewarding them. Chiefs earned it. Forfeit is a thing. Either the bills or cinci can chose to finish the game, chose to forfeit, call it as is, 7-3 win, or call it a tie which is a gift by the nfl and should not be an option. This “beat them earlier in the year” argument is silly. Teams do actually lose games in the regular season and still advance in the playoffs, even as a one seed.

  43. Call it a tie, or call it a no-contest, and go from there. No neutral sites, no extra teams. There’s no perfect answer, so go with the most logical that involves the fewest scheduling and logistical gymnastics.

  44. The real loser, if the game is not played, is the Ravens and I’m far from a Ravens fan. They potentially lose a home game vs Cincy vs an away game against Cincy.

    My hunch is, the NFL lets the week play out before making any decision. If the Bengals win, Raiders win, and Bills win, the missing game has little affect on seeding. I honestly wouldn’t be surprised if the officiating didn’t magically lean this way. If any of those teams lose, it complicates the situation.

  45. This “only the #1 seed team gets a bye” rule is screwing everything up. It’s a stupid rule, and to call the first week of the playoffs, “wildcard weekend” when 6 of the 8 DIVISION winners are playing, is just as asinine.

  46. How come no one is talking about the fact that Cincy has now just been given the AFC North rather than having to play for it this Sunday? Ravens got screwed, instead of playing this Sunday for the AFC North, Cincy is now just given the title and Ravens are told they are wild card because if Ravens win they are 11-5 while Bengals would be 11-4 and get it by percentage. A home playoff game is a huge advantage especially since it could be a rematch the very next week against each other with Cincy at home.

  47. Seed based on winning percentages. However, if Buffalo somehow ends up playing KC, the game is in Buffalo based on Bills’ head to head win. That’s fair for everyone.

  48. Occam’s razor: The simplest solution is the best solution. Bills announce today that they plan to forfeit the game tomorrow. No ties. No no-contests. No rescheduled games. No extra bye weeks. No 8th seeds. No neutral sites. Just a W for Cincinnati and an L for Buffalo.

    And if Cincinnati feels strongly about it before it’s official they can say, “You can’t fire me, I quit” they can forfeit too and the NFL puts the whole thing on the books as a tie.

  49. Why do people keep acting like the Bengals were getting the number 1 seed? The only way that was happening, is if the Chiefs lose this upcoming week. Otherwise, they were never going to be higher than the 2 seed. And, why do the Chiefs get shafted when the Bengals very likely could have won that game, on Monday? It just makes zero sense. Now, if the Chiefs lose Saturday, then it shafts the Bengals.

  50. How could completely shafting the #1 seed in the NFC possibly be in the name of “competitive balance” ? You’re losing your marbles

  51. One scenario that could work is Bills-Bengals play next Thursday night, where the game left off. Same score, same inactive lists. Then everyone is on a bye the following Sunday. Then the playoffs would resume without the bye week before the Super Bowl. They should also ban all teams, players and coaches from the stadium next week except the teams that are playing. This way no team has an extra week to prepare. If teams violate this rule, they should lose a draft pick to the team they play next.
    In no scenario should another team be added to the playoffs, why should a team benefit from a tragedy.

  52. Tie or no contest, doesn’t really matter. Don’t mess with the seeding or playoff formatting. It may not be nice to say, but the teams played barely half a quarter. That’s practically a second bye very late in the season. That’s enough to erase the “equity” issues.

  53. If they do that they will be sued by anyone who has placed a bet on just about anything this affects. They are now partners with gambling houses and will be named in a lawsuit. How many long shot bets were made that would be disrupted or canceled on any number of things. Odds to make the playoffs. Super bowl etc. all that stuff changes daily. People who made bets will get screwed

  54. I very happy that Damar Hamlin is improving.

    However, we all know the calculus that is being performed isn’t all about the seeding. The calculus is what scenario causes the least amount of revenue loss to the NFL and teams that get the short end of the stick, how to compensate them, do the players get full game checks if the game is cancelled, do the Bengals have to refund tickets, the players who have contracts with bonuses tied to number of plays played/making the playoffs get paid regardless, trades of players/picks that change based on plays/playoffs, and right down to the governments losing tax revenue for a missed home game based on a league decision when tax payer money was used to fund their stadiums. I would even bet my game check that right now someone is being told to shut up about not having taken their advice to restart the game on Tues/Wed, which would have avoided this mess.

  55. Chiefs don’t deserve 1st seed….actually the Chiefs DO deserve the #1 seed….clearly, they have the most wins in the AFC…that’s how all of this works. Even if they lose to the Raiders but still have the best record, they still deserve the #1 seed.

  56. The game WAS PLAYED…. The Bills & Bengals BOTH wanted to stop the game from continuing & the players have ALREADY been paid… the game ENDED 7-3 with Bengals winning…. IT IS A DONE DEAL!!!
    Proceed with this weeks games reflective of that result & this comes to an end & playoffs proceed as scheduled… SERIOUSLY, it’s really not that difficult…. There are consequences for everything in life… DEAL WITH IT!!!
    The fans & vendors already got hosed….
    Ps: AWESOME to hear Hamlin improving !!!!!
    ********************************************
    Had to fix Damar’s name…. Didn’t notice auto correct had changed it in above post, sorry!!!!

  57. Now they are “pondering”…. what happened to all that momentum from last night? Hmmm?

  58. To ensure competitive balance, there would have to be eight teams in the NFC, too.
    ++++++
    Nope. Just nope.

  59. Sad to see the “we want to do the right thing” Bengals talking about coin tosses, neutral sites, etc., trying to leverage a tragedy into them being equal with the Chiefs and Bills, with three losses each, even though the Bengals have four losses.

  60. Which is better? A bye or home field?

    Thumbs up for bye, thumbs down for home field

    I’d take home field all day long

  61. Finishing the game is the only fair way to settle the top three seeds, considering the NFL didn’t have a contingency plan established prior to the start of the season. If they don’t want to do that and push the playoffs back a week, adding an eighth team to the AFC playoff mix actually makes sense and would make this weekend very exciting.

  62. c’mon man! Stop the nonsense.

    Schedule the completion of the Bills/Bengals game for Wk 19.

    Skip the off week between conference title games and SB.

    Most equitable (read, ONLY) equitable solution.

  63. Ok, essentially the game was stopped with the Bengals leading, I know this is going to upset Bills fans but just award the win to the Bengals. Easy solution.

  64. -Sorry but penalizing KC for any of this isn’t an answer either. Everyone is so quick to not want to “punish” the Bills or Bengals but are ready to punish KC which had zero involvement in any of this.-

    As much as KC shouldn’t get punished, they also shouldn’t be handed something they didn’t earn either. There is no fair solution to this mess without playing that game (and not even entirely fair IF it gets played at this point)…and that game is looking more and more like it’s not going to happen…in which case, someone(s) is/are going to get punished. The question is how to make it the least unfair? They may also be waiting to see how things play out. If KC wins and BUF loses, there’s no question who the 1 seed should be…

  65. I don’t understand what is so bad about 1) finishing the game this Sunday, 2) pushing the rest of the league schedule back a week, and 3) eliminating the week off between conference championships and the Super Bowl. This would be the fairest way to do it for all teams.

  66. Maybe the best situation is to watch Saturday and then ignore the standings in the AFC. Cancel the buf/cincy game, say this week without a record/winning %, who ever wins between Cincy/Balt gets the division, and if KC beats vegas, they get the number 1 seed. Sorry.

    The 2 and 3 seeds if cincy wins, can be decided between Buf and Cincy based on their 1 game less record. standard rules break the tie. And if Baltimore wins, and KC, its 1. KC 2. Buf and 3. Balt……it works out. Just a thoughtand maybe this isnt fair for Buffalo, but understandly they dont want to play the game so take whats presented and lets put a end to this discussion and focus on more important topics.

  67. I think the main issue is the biggest advantage is not only home field but there are clearly 3 “best” teams in the AFC that are different than the others, so the #1 seed huge advantage is not playing seeds 2 and 3 until the AFC championship game,.

  68. Let’s all think of some absurd ways to avoid having to replay the game…

    1) The NFL should computer simulate the game one million times and then take the average score of those one million games to determine the winner. No skills, just numbers!

    2) Disregard all NFL game outcomes during Week 17, thereby making it a 16-game season once again — and screwing over even more teams’ playoff hopes!

    3) Since it was both teams’ third game against other AFC same-place-different-division opponents, go through every team’s schedule, find the outcome of their third game against their conference’s same-place-different-division opponent, and toss out the result! For example, the Chief’s third game against the other AFC division winners was the Bengals game (they played the Bills and Titans earlier), which they lost, so they don’t count that game, and their record is now 13-2!

  69. Very simple…rank the teams by losses:

    1-KC has 3
    2-BUF has 3
    3-CIN has 4

    If all 3 win Sunday, BUF takes the 1 seed based on H2H
    If KC wins, BUF loses, CIN wins – KC is 1, BUF and CIN are determined by standard tiebreaker
    If KC loses, BUF loses, CIN wins – KC becomes the 3 (H2H losses to BUF and CIN) and the 1 seed determined by standard 2 team tiebreaker rules

  70. The game should have continued as it would with any other injury.

    You don’t want to play? Take the L.

  71. My guess is Goodell figured out a way to profit from this.
    I’m expecting them to add a game to the wild card round.

  72. Basically someone is going to complain about whatever outcome is chosen so now I really don’t care what they do…. LET THE WHINING COMMENCE!!!!

  73. Call me a cynic – and I would take it as neither an insult nor a false accusation! LOL – but if an eighth seed is added in each conference, it will be added permanently.

    Remember when 9/11 resulted in Super Bowl XXXVI being played in February for the first time ever?

    Well guess what: Every Super Bowl played since then – except for the following year’s Super Bowl (which for purely logistical reasons could not have been changed) – has been played in February.

    And neither the NBA nor the NHL have ever had 14 teams make their playoffs; and the NBA now has 20 – thanks to COVID!

  74. 1 YARD SHORT says:
    January 5, 2023 at 1:18 pm
    Thank Goodness Damar Hamlin is improving.
    This is gonna be chaos, if they dont resume the game chiefs beat raiders get the 1, but your gonna give buffalo the 2 over cincy? Burrow has beat mahomes and was gonna beat allen too. So your gonna send cincy to buffalo? INSANITY.

    Your assumption that Cinci was going to beat Buffalo doesn’t hold water. Buffalo moved the ball very well against the Bengals the only time they had the ball. The Bills have been a better second half team than the Bengals have been this year, so it’s a stretch to day Burrows would have beaten Allen. That’s why they play 4 quarters. Besides, the Bills were a game ahead of Cinci in the standings starting the day anyway. And yes, Thank God Damar Hamlin is improving. He still has a long road ahead of him, but at least it’s positive.

  75. mjkwarch says:
    January 5, 2023 at 1:12 pm
    Does everyone in attendance from last Monday night get ticket refunds?
    ————————–
    I’m sure some clown will file a class-action suit on behalf of everyone who was there.

  76. Give the Bengals the win and move on. They were up at the time of the stoppage and drivign again. While both teams were affected by Hamlin going down, it was far more mental for the Bills roster. They wouldn’t have recovered and won the game if it was forced to play out.

  77. -I think the main issue is the biggest advantage is not only home field but there are clearly 3 “best” teams in the AFC that are different than the others, so the #1 seed huge advantage is not playing seeds 2 and 3 until the AFC championship game.-

    Exactly. If I got to choose a bye, home field, or positioning myself to only have to play one game against the top 3 seeds…I’d definitely pick the latter! If the team that goes to the SB plays and beats two of the top three, they will definitely have earned that spot!

  78. The NFL should pray that the Chiefs lose Saturday, Bills win Sunday and Cincinnati and Baltimore tie on Sunday, then the Bills-Cincinnati game outcome is immaterial as the outcome would not impact any teams seeding. Pretty large odds on that parlay and if it does not play out…then I’m glad I am not making the decision.

  79. What makes the off week before the Super Bowl so holy that it couldn’t be appropriated for an unprecedented situation like this? I’ve always thought it’s stupid anyway.

  80. “The players don’t want to do it.”

    Then give them both an L.

    This is ridiculous.

  81. Ok, but eveyone should get a 3/4 refund (at least) bc less than a quarter was played.

  82. Here’s a possible solution that I haven’t seen proposed yet: finish the Bills/Bengals game this Sunday, and have the Ravens play the Patriots. Problem (mostly) solved.

  83. So, if the impossible happens and the Ravens beat the Bengals, the the Ravens win the division! They don’t have o worry about seedlings!

  84. Just put it in the rule book that whenever a game cannot be completed in situation like this make it a tie game and move on.

  85. Finishing Bills/Bengals is by far the easiest way to seed the playoffs, but that doesn’t seem to be the way it’s headed. Without playing that game, there’s no perfect solution. If changing the playoffs “punishes” KC, how does changing the schedule not provide them an unearned benefit, since they’re not able to clinch the top seed on their own with a Bills/Bengals game to be played?

    Assuming all teams win this weekend:

    KC: #2 Seed and 1st Round Bye
    BUF: #1 Seed and plays #7 Seed
    CIN: #3 Seed, hosts BUF in AFC Championship Game

    If Cincinnati loses, they’re the #3 Seed under the normal rules. If KC loses, BUF/CIN split #1 Seed / First Round Bye and KC is the #3 Seed. I’m sure similar could be figured out for other scenarios where the lack of the Bills/Bengals game impacts seeding as well

  86. So, in this is the case (going with win %), if the Chiefs finish 14-3, and the Bills 13-3, the Chiefs finish with a 1% edge. KC would be the #1 seed, the Bills the #2 seed. Given that the Bills beat the Chiefs this season, it would only seem fair that if the final two AFC teams are KC and Buffalo, they either play it on a neutral site…or at the very least, give the Bills a coin flip chance to get home-field for that game. The Bills objective all year was to get that #1 seed…they have had a season full of adversity…seems kinda lame that they fought through all that, got to the point to earn that spot, only to have it snatched away by something out of their control.

  87. Seems that the Bills are in the driver seat as to not wanting to play the makeup game, since Cincy basically deferred the decision to them. That being said, I think the Bills take the L with a 7-3 Final or they both get a Tie, sucks for Cincy but seems like those are the only fair options. KC should not have to pay the price for decisions being made by the Bills.

  88. The best solution is to send the Bills FG unit along with their defense FG unit back to Cincy today along with The Bengals FG unit and start at the 50 yd line and kick FG’s until one team misses. After a make by both teams push it back 5 yds each time.They could have a decision on the outcome within 15 minutes. Then they could play their game Sunday.

  89. So, you reward Mahomes, for a tragedy that occurs to another team. I said it watching this kid this season as he took over with the beaten until the closing seconds drives. Dudes the leagues new Brady. Even after games moved for blizzards and a Covid season. They still have no idea what they are doing in this league. What is the point of byes and all that, if you do colossally stupid stuff like this

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.