If necessary, Roger Goodell would determine neutral site for AFC Championship Game

Miami Dolphins v Buffalo Bills
Getty Images

NFL owners approved a change to the rules for handling a cancelled game on Friday and one of the changes opens the door to the AFC Championship Game being played at a neutral site.

That will happen in the following three scenarios:

  1. Buffalo and Kansas City both win or both tie — a Buffalo vs Kansas City championship game would be at a neutral site.
  2. Buffalo and Kansas City both lose and Baltimore wins or ties — a Buffalo vs Kansas City championship game would be at a neutral site.
  3. Buffalo and Kansas City both lose and Cincinnati wins — a Buffalo or Cincinnati vs Kansas City championship game would be at a neutral site.

The resolution that NFL owners approved on Friday says that NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell will choose the neutral site under that scenario. There is nothing in the resolution about the criteria for choosing a site and there have been discussions about indoor and outdoor possibilities.

With most of the league done playing by the conference championship, there will be a number of options in both categories in the event the NFL ultimately has to go down that route. If it does and is planning to attend what would be a notable event in NFL history, Goodell will get to choose the building where he’d get booed by fans of at least one team.

104 responses to “If necessary, Roger Goodell would determine neutral site for AFC Championship Game

  1. A neutral site/ Why, so both sets of fans can feel screwed? Better to flip a coin.

  2. What about a Bengals – Bills round 2 matchup? How in the world could they justify that game being in Buffalo? If Bills are 2 seed because they had the better record before Monday, then hold that same philosophy for the Bengals and Ravens. Either way, the Bengals were rolling for the last 2 months and I’m sure this is more motivation.

  3. Under scenario 3, Chiefs still get #1 by virtue of playing all their games? Or will there be a three-way tiebreaker used? Or flip the coin a few times? Who knows now, right?

  4. Seems like Cincinatti is the one left out here. Lesson learned for Zac Taylor, I guess.

  5. Teams play for home field advantage, this makes no sense. Play the game week 19 and push playoffs back 1 week, so simple

  6. Roger Goodell was hired by a group of private business owners to run their football league. Their private businesses have done very well under his guidance, but the owners are still the boss. Goodell has whatever amount of power the owners are willing to give him.

  7. With bullet point #1, which teams get the 1st rd Bye?

    Also, if Buffalo chose to skip their game, why isn’t that a forfeit?

  8. If Baltimore and Cincinnati tie, is there some sort of additional tiebreaker mechanism? War? Roll a die? The neutral site will be Detroit or Dallas (they won’t be in it at that point)

  9. And no money will change hands behind the scenes as part of this decision process.

  10. NFL owners and their minion GODell did it again. They continue to have zero regard for their customers(aka fans). Then again it seems these days most all companies operate in same manner. Sad world.

  11. It’s so refreshing that fans and players are ok with the Hamlin situation quite possibly may send them packing for the season !

  12. First assumption would be Canton, OH (HOF Stadium, but same state conflict).

    Neutral site options: 1. Heinz Field (Only Yinzers may attend)

    2. Texans Stadium (Rarely used post season).

    3. Jerry’s World (Unlikely since it will be in use in the post season).

    4. Lambau Field (Packers will be eliminated so it will be available).

    5. Mile High (See #2 & #4). 

  13. This is so much crap. Sad story but now the Chiefs are punished because the Bills Bangles didn’t finish their game.

  14. This is just BS.

    Ravens got screwed with no chance for the AFCN title. And these cities could be screwed. Nothing like taking a major home playoff game (and the gameday revenue) away from all of the cities that would have earned it.

  15. After the game, I said I didn’t care what happened w/ the Bills’ seeding & where they had to play, and I still feel that way. If they have to play all 3 games and be on the road for each of them, that’s a fine trade-off by me. Hamlin is recovering & that was the top priority.

    On Monday, it felt like the NFL world was pretty united. No one thought the game should continue – including BOTH teams.

    Today, I’m hearing some different stories, bordering on blaming the Bills for “their” choice to not continue playing. It’s like a lot of fans have amnesia.

    This was never going to work out equitably after that game was canceled. That’s just the way it is. Every team that was going to make the playoffs or have a chance for the playoffs will still make it, or have that chance. It’s not perfect, but it’s fine.

  16. If it’s Buffalo/KC, Indy seems the obvious choice. Indoors, and about a 7 hour drive from both places, so fans of both could fairly easily attend.

    CIN/KC is a little trickier, since the short drive from Cincy to Indy could essentially make it a Bengals home game. That would seem to open up a bunch of other options.

  17. It’ll be an NFC domed stadium far away from those three cities, and not LA because the Chiefs play there every year. I’d say that makes the Superdome the leading candidate.

  18. So we’re are going win %.

    So we are throwing out long standing tie breaker rules.

    So we are going to neutral fields.

    What next? Just play the damn games and stop rigging them!

  19. If this happens my interest in the AFC Championship just evaporated and I support an NFC team.

  20. Lambeau would be perfect. AFC teams only get to play there once every eight years.

  21. assuming its gotta be an open air stadium right since all 3 have stadiums as such and a colder climate. Assuming teams wouldnt want to deal with the altitidue if they dont have to in Denver. Philly likely out because they very likely could be hosting their own conference championship that day

    People keep mentioning Met Life but that seems a little wonky with Buffalo being upstate

    New England
    Chicago
    Green Bay
    Cleveland
    Pittsburgh
    Washington
    Carolina (? whats climate like there now?)

  22. touchback6 says:
    January 6, 2023 at 2:14 pm

    Also, if Buffalo chose to skip their game, why isn’t that a forfeit?

    *****
    Buffalo AND Cinci both chose to stop but it seems like bengals assumed it would be continued. Taylor doesnt sound too thrilled today

  23. Buffalo getting screwed here–they had an excellent chance to be playing the championship game in their cold, windy, miserable house, (possibly against a warm weather team) and now that advantage has been negated

  24. Casey fans seem awfully quiet, and deservedly so, But this affects them too. If they happen to win the super bowl there will always be an asterisk.

  25. Probable round 2 matchup: Cincinnati at Buffalo. Why isn’t that matchup also at a neutral site. Cincy had a clear path to the #2 seed over Buffalo by winning out and didn’t get the chance.

  26. Notre Dame Stadium. Outdoors, 80k plus seats, turf field (so no concerns over field conditions). Almost equidistant from all 3 top seeds.

  27. cnc33 says:
    January 6, 2023 at 2:32 pm
    It’ll be an NFC domed stadium far away from those three cities, and not LA because the Chiefs play there every year. I’d say that makes the Superdome the leading candidate.

    ******************
    Would the 3 outdoor cold climate teams want a dome? Maybe they would I dont know but worth asking

  28. Buffalo must forfeit the Bengals game. It is the only fair outcome. But, of course, being the darlings of the NFL, that isn’t going to happen.

  29. Where can I get a blue Goodell clown shirt? I need to order it before my team has to play an away game despite earning the the 1 seed….

  30. doctorrumack says:
    January 6, 2023 at 2:42 pm
    Casey fans seem awfully quiet, and deservedly so, But this affects them too. If they happen to win the super bowl there will always be an asterisk

    Chiefs fans are furious. This in no way benefits the Chiefs.

  31. The NFL has officially become WWE 2.0! Someone got hurt and that’s terrible
    That’s also part of the game . Now teams are putting in season long work to have their playoff chances determined by a coin flip the NFL and Roger Goodell should be embarrassed.

  32. “ghjjf says:
    January 6, 2023 at 2:47 pm
    We will never know who the best AFC team is in the 2022 season!”
    _______________

    Sure we will. The AFC team that plays in the SB will be the best AFC team.

  33. converge241 says:
    January 6, 2023 at 2:39 pm
    touchback6 says:
    January 6, 2023 at 2:14 pm

    Also, if Buffalo chose to skip their game, why isn’t that a forfeit?

    *****
    Buffalo AND Cinci both chose to stop but it seems like bengals assumed it would be continued. Taylor doesnt sound too thrilled today

    ————————-
    I think rather than the Bengals assuming the game would be continued, they assumed the existing policy would rule, and playoff seeding would be determined by winning percentage. No neutral sites, no coin flips. 1.KC 2.Buffalo 3.Cincy – and then Taylor could rest Burrow, Chase, Mixon, etc. against Baltimore.

  34. What about a Bengals – Bills round 2 matchup? How in the world could they justify that game being in Buffalo? If Bills are 2 seed because they had the better record before Monday, then hold that same philosophy for the Bengals and Ravens. Either way, the Bengals were rolling for the last 2 months and I’m sure this is more motivation.

    ——–

    Because the Bills will finish the season 13-3 and the Bengals 12-4. Pretty straightforward. Same number of games, Bills had better record.

  35. Since the Vikings will not be in the NFC championship game, Minnysoda could host the AFC Championship game in the toasty warmth of the Vikes indoor venue.

  36. According to Pro Football Talk, there are rules in place to deal with cancelled games. When you start being able to change the rules as you go, that is a a slippery slope indeed.

  37. Do NBA draft lottery ping pong balls, Patrick Ewing style to ensure they rigging is completed.

  38. What’s really at play here is the NFL doesn’t want the Chiefs to represent the AFC for a third SB in 4 years.

    They are doing anything they can do to appease their Official Gaming Partners bottom line (and theirs) by keeping the Chiefs out (if KC should beat their first playoff opponent at Arrowhead) – then preventing KC from playing the AFCCG against either Buffalo or Cincinnati should those teams march through their playoff matchups.

    Wipe out HFA for KC to TRY to stop Mahomes and Company and level the field.

    It’s more than obviou$ at this point.

    Which teams voted to screw over Lamar Hunt’s son, who has acted like a lap dog to Goodell since his father passed away.

  39. Bengals fans need to get over it.
    1.) the players health is what matters most
    2.) bengals chose to stop the game too
    3.) bengals weren’t guaranteed a W
    4.) where was y’all complaining when nfl admitted to wrongfully giving y’all a TD vs the raiders in a home playoff game off an mistaken whistle…..ended up winning the game by 7 with the wrong call. So y’all been gifted stuff in recent memory by the nfl. So stop complaining

  40. Also, if Buffalo chose to skip their game, why isn’t that a forfeit?

    ———

    Probably because the NFL made the call to pause the game then cancelled it days later.

  41. If Cincinnati is in the AFC Championship, I’m sure he’ll put the game in “neutral” Baltimore or Pittsburgh.

  42. And here come the “Goodell sucks” brigade. I’m not defending him, that would just be insane but there’s really no good solution here. You all should’ve known going in everyone wasn’t gonna like the decision, they really couldn’t give the shaft to Buffalo. I dunno how anyone can blame the league there. Keep the right perspective though; the only thing that really matters, damar hamlin’s well-being, is trending positively. I do, however, think the league should do something to compensate the Bengals for being so accommodating. Maybe give them a 5th or 6th round compensatory pick? As an NFC team fan with no dog in the fight here, something along those lines is the right thing to do in my opinion

  43. They changed the OT rules last year because the beloved Bills lost in playoffs to KC without getting a chance to get their offense on the field…the same beloved Bills get the rules changed DURING the season this year while there were already rules in place for this scenario…not sure why the Bills get such favorable treatment.

  44. Dial up the wayback machine Mr. Peabody, and get ready for Metropolitan Stadium in Bloomington, Minnesota. When men were men.

  45. He will pick an indoor stadium because the fans may not show up at a cold outdoor stadium.

  46. billsrthefuture says:
    January 6, 2023 at 2:57 pm
    “ghjjf says:
    January 6, 2023 at 2:47 pm
    We will never know who the best AFC team is in the 2022 season!”
    _______________

    Sure we will. The AFC team that plays in the SB will be the best AFC team.

    ——-

    Last year after the season was over you kept saying the best team was Buffalo even though they didn’t make the SB.

    Have you changed your tune on that?

  47. If that does happen, the procedes from ticket sales of the neutral site should be given to the Bengals, who had to refund tickets sold for the MNF game.

  48. Somebody asked what the weather was like in Carolina today, and I’m happy to report it’s 59 and sunny with no wind.

    Bring the games here!

  49. If it’s KC Buff play it in Cincy
    If it’s KC Cincy play it in Buffalo
    If it’s Buff Cincy play it in KC

    At least the city not participating gets the game !

  50. I wonder if this is something of test run to see if the NFL prefers the conference championships at a neutral location and whether that would create higher profits for all 32 teams by spreading that money out some. I know after the Covid season in 2020, there are MLB owners who have woken up to the possibility that a neutral site World Series may make more money (and eliminate the travel days, which is irrelevant to the NFL, of course). It would be interesting to see the attendance at a neutral site and how many would attend just to watch the game rather than the specific teams, as with the Super Bowl. Hopefully, PFT will pay attention to this angle, since it has broken so many of these stories before.

  51. So the Chiefs get screwed by a game they had no part of. Nothing like Roger changing the rules when he doesn’t like them.

  52. So now no fan base gets to generate money for local businesses. This is just silly. These games mean a lot to local businesses and the playoffs can generate some of the best days the locals will ever have. Now fans will have to travel and some other city will benefit for their team winning. No thinks past their own interest.

  53. The neutral site is Indy. The NFL loves Indy. I think it should be outdoors, like maybe Chicago. There has been some traction based on safety to get back to grass fields this season. We don’t need another dome game.

  54. Why don’t they just do this: KC vs Buff =Bengals stadium. KC vs Cin =Bills stadium. Buff vs Cin = Chiefs stadium

  55. In baseball, teams often don’t play the same number of games due to rainouts and life goes on without league intervention. I realize that an NFL game is like ten baseball games, but still.

    Why don’t we let the team with the best winning percentage host the championship game? Good grief, not everything has to be completely fair all the time. That would work. Really.

  56. Can’t believe all the Chiefs fans thinking they were screwed, AFTER they LOST to both the Bill’s and Bengals this year!! If anything the Bills/Bengals are getting screwed, if they play the Chiefs it should be at their home field!!

  57. kayes says:
    January 6, 2023 at 3:45 pm
    ok, so what do the ravens get?

    ************
    Ravens get a 50/50 shot at a home wildcard game
    IF they beat Cinci Sunday
    IF they stay as the 6 seed

    IF ravens win and Chargers lose; Balt goes to Jax or Ten

    So yes by winning Sunday Ravens may lose their chance at a home game

  58. Ravens seem to be the team getting screwed the most. If the Bengals had lost to the Bills then the Bengals would have to have beaten the Ravens to win the AFC North. So the Ravens don’t even get the chance to control their own destiny. Seems like the NFL is doing everything they can to make sure Buffalo doesn’t end up playing in KC again. Just let the Bills and Bengals play this weekend and postpone all other games until next weekend, and do away with the bye week before the Superbowl. Thats the only true “fair” option to all teams.

  59. All of this is Roger Goodell doing his best to cheat the Patriots. They have Belichick and Mac Jones. That is enough to give them the #1 seed, regardless of their record.

  60. So LAME! So out of all this the only ones who really get screwed are the fans and the number ONE seed. What a joke!
    NFL=WWE ie: Almost scripted.
    So did the worst ref crew in the NFL get sent to call Raiders Chiefs?

  61. mainewoodchopper says:
    January 6, 2023 at 4:18 pm
    The neutral site is Indy. The NFL loves Indy. I think it should be outdoors, like maybe Chicago. There has been some traction based on safety to get back to grass fields this season. We don’t need another dome game.

    —————-

    My suspicion as well. We know Irsay has a lot of control over Goodell and has for years. This whole thing just reeks of some owners trying to parlay Hamlin’s injury into a greedy strike.

  62. Go check the history of the game, so MANY teams that hosted the Championship game lost to their opponent in the REGULAR season. Posters trying to defend this move by using REGULAR season match ups are SHEEP.

  63. Lockport Lax says:
    January 6, 2023 at 4:24 pm
    Can’t believe all the Chiefs fans thinking they were screwed, AFTER they LOST to both the Bill’s and Bengals this year!! If anything the Bills/Bengals are getting screwed, if they play the Chiefs it should be at their home field!

    Means nothing. Chiefs have a better record. Why is this so confusing?

  64. It seems the real winners here are the two teams that colluded for an extra bye week: Buffalo and Cincinnati

  65. Should Bengals play under protest? They should never lose to a Lamarless Ravens team and that might be a media distraction but would make for great headlines. What do you think Florio?

  66. They can always play in Houston. That stadium won’t he hosting any playoff games for a long time.

  67. Lockport Lax says:
    January 6, 2023 at 4:24 pm
    Can’t believe all the Chiefs fans thinking they were screwed, AFTER they LOST to both the Bill’s and Bengals this year!! If anything the Bills/Bengals are getting screwed, if they play the Chiefs it should be at their home field!!
    —-

    Because the very first overall tie-breaker is overall wins vs losses. And if the game had been postponed to Wednesday night and played and if the Bengals continued to increase their lead 7 points to every field goal for the Bills squad, the Bengals would’ve won the game handily 28 to 12 – giving Cincy a 12-4 record, Buffalo a 12-4 record and the Chiefs a 13-3 record – and throwing the 1st round seed to the Chiefs – who before the game was even played – owned a half game lead over the Buffalo Bills based on overall record.

    But noooo

    Somehow the NFL reasons rewarding Buffalo for not continuing the game, a game they were losing (the Bengals were driving AGAIN downfield on their next possession of the 1st quarter).

    Basically reprimand the Chiefs for winning as many games as they could, besides losing to 2 of the top 3 teams in the league AND the lowly Colts – giving them only 3 losses for the season (at that point in time).

    Makes perfect competitive sense to everyone, except those of us who know the rules and have watched the games since the 1960s.

    So, the Chiefs have lost to both Bengals and Bills in the regular season. Big deal. They also won more games overall than either of those teams, who had at least one more loss than the Chiefs overall – and Buffalo was losing that game Monday night when they forfeited it.

  68. Agreed upon rules were already in place before the season started. Changing the rules mid season is a bad bad practice. Sometimes emotions need to be removed when making a decision. NFL should have done that here and stuck to their rules. Shame on the owners for voting to approve during the season.

  69. Roger isn’t calling the shots on this one. Neither are the Ownwers. Vegas is. Be careful what you wish for, NFL!

  70. As a Chiefs fan, it’s entirely possible they blow it against a Raiders team that played their tails off last week. If they don’t, I feel this is fair.

    What isn’t, is the hand they dealt Cincy; why shouldn’t an almost enivtable game against Buffalo also be at a neutral site? Not as worried about how it breaks with the Ravens, Bengals will humiliate Lamarless Baltimore Sunday.

  71. I don’t know, they shoulda pushed the playoff out another week but the logistics and planning were already in place, just for example all of the folks who have plans and reservations in place to go and see the games.

  72. After all is said and done one or more teams are going to feel like they got screwed.

  73. No one has any idea how that game would have turned out. A 7-3 lead in the 1st quarter means nothing, in any NFL game.

    And BOTH teams decided to not continue that game. With the support of the entire world at that point, btw.

  74. Can’t believe all the Chiefs fans thinking they were screwed, AFTER they LOST to both the Bill’s and Bengals this year!! If anything the Bills/Bengals are getting screwed, if they play the Chiefs it should be at their home field!!

    ——-

    That’s not the way it works. Best record gets the 1 seed. Always has.

    My opinion: Cincy was going to beat Buffalo the other night. White was having issues covering anyone and the Bengals were rolling. Yes, the Bills would respond but I still think cincy wins that game.

    If that happened , Cincy is 12-4, Buff is 12-4 and KC is 13-3…..KC would have had 1 seed

    KC beats the raiders in week 18 and gets the bye.

    That also would have put Cincy in the 2 seed, bc they would have beat Buffalo

    To take away the benefits of the 1 seed from KC and the 2 seed from Cincy seems like Buffalo benefits a lot from all of this.

    Again, this assumes that the Bengals won Monday. Just my opinion.

  75. You should play this game at Gilette Stadium…I swear to God we wont to anything to the balls delflating or communications head set systems…

  76. Why not the Superdome? That way Goodell can import Bill Vinovich and his crew to lay another NOLA no-cal at the most critical point in the gamel on whichever team Roger the Dodger disfavors…

  77. As a Bengal fan. I must say this is unfair to us. BUT, also motivation to go kick butt. No matter where, no matter when, no matter who we play! You don’t want to play us. We did it last year, and we will do it again!

  78. That’s the spirit, vottorific – and it’s exactly how I feel. A week ago, I was all in on the 1 seed, and thinking that’s what the Bills needed to succeed. Now, I don’t care where they play, or what seed they are.

    The playoffs are the start of a new season. Whoever is in controls their own destiny. Good teams overcome adversity.

  79. touchbutt6 says:
    January 6, 2023 at 3:03 pm
    What about a Bengals – Bills round 2 matchup? How in the world could they justify that game being in Buffalo? If Bills are 2 seed because they had the better record before Monday, then hold that same philosophy for the Bengals and Ravens. Either way, the Bengals were rolling for the last 2 months and I’m sure this is more motivation.

    ——–

    Because the Bills will finish the season 13-3 and the Bengals 12-4. Pretty straightforward. Same number of games, Bills had better record.

    ———

    If that the case, then KC should host the AFCCG because their record would be 14-3 to Buffalos 13-3.

    See the inconsistency?

  80. “ Goodell will get to choose the building where he’d get booed by fans of at least one team.”

    If it’s at a neutral site, I’d probably make the trip. And I can also confirm that I’d stand side by side with any Bills/Bengals fan and proudly boo that man.

  81. touchback6 says:
    January 6, 2023 at 4:47 pm
    mainewoodchopper says:
    January 6, 2023 at 4:18 pm
    The neutral site is Indy. The NFL loves Indy. I think it should be outdoors, like maybe Chicago. There has been some traction based on safety to get back to grass fields this season. We don’t need another dome game.

    —————-

    My suspicion as well. We know Irsay has a lot of control over Goodell and has for years. This whole thing just reeks of some owners trying to parlay Hamlin’s injury into a greedy strike.
    ===================================================
    Well, one thing’s for sure. No matter where it’s played, you’ll have a conspiratorial theory tied to Goodell in some fashion and you’ll claim that “you knew it all along”.

  82. There are some inconsistencies with all these coin toss neutral site scenarios, because they only looked at AFCCG and division winning scenarios for the AFC North, based on some hypothetical outcomes of games, but the glaring omission is the Bengals scenario, where they beat the Bills last Monday and would have had a clear path to the 1 seed, but also a clear shot at the 2 seed, which would have guaranteed home field in the Divisional round (possibly against Buffalo), but all these opportunities were taken away.
    Baltimore gets the coin toss opportunity for the Wildcard game, but the Bengals at best get a neutral site for the AFCCG, despite the fact that they displayed great sportsmanship last Monday? That doesn‘t seem right to me. I get the neutral site for the AFCCG, but the coin toss for despite a AFC North win, based on the hypothetical, that the Bengals could have lost the MNF game against Buffalo is clearly taking it too far.

  83. I can’t think of a better neutral site than FedEx Field. Just about every week the fans are split 50/50 and in its nearly 30 years of existence has only hosted maybe 3 playoff games.

  84. bigdaddy says:
    January 6, 2023 at 3:36 pm
    They changed the OT rules last year because the beloved Bills lost in playoffs to KC without getting a chance to get their offense on the field…the same beloved Bills get the rules changed DURING the season this year while there were already rules in place for this scenario…not sure why the Bills get such favorable treatment.

    1715Rate This

    Actually very inaccurate. The rule was changed after New England beat the Chiefs in KC in OT with Brady . KC never got the ball in OT and whined all the way to winter meetings.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.