Aaron Rodgers holds all the cards for 2023

Detroit Lions v Green Bay Packers
Getty Images

Quarterback Aaron Rodgers says he won’t hold the Packers hostage. Regardless, he currently holds all the cards.

Under the contract Rodgers received in March 2022, his compensation for 2023 shoots to nearly $60 million. And it’s fully guaranteed.

If Rodgers wants to stay, he’s staying. If they’d cut him (they won’t), they’d owe him the money. And while they could trade him, no other team would take on that financial responsibility if he makes it clear he doesn’t want to be there.

So while Rodgers called the coming decision “mutual,” it really isn’t. Last year, he secured the unilateral ability to continue, or not continue, the relationship for two years.

If he wants to stay, he will. And if the Packers decide they want him to go, the challenge in the coming weeks will be to get him to come to that conclusion on his own.

But why would he retire? It’s $60 million. For one more year of football. Sixty million.

While it seems as if he’s at least thinking about not playing, money talks. Sixty million screams. And no amount of kicking and screaming by the Packers will change that fact.

118 responses to “Aaron Rodgers holds all the cards for 2023

  1. Ted used to say that it’s better to be a year too early than a year too late when moving on from a player. That lesson seems to have been ignored in this case.

  2. The Packers deserve whatever they get for putting themselves in this position.

  3. Would Rodgers have to repay his prorated signing bonus if he retires? Thats $37M. So he could make $110m for playing 2 more years or pay $37M.

    Hmmm, tough decision.

  4. Gutey caved and he is finally paying the price. Gutey is in over his head that is clear. What did Gutey get for caving to Rodgers. A one and done playoff and failing to qualify for the playoffs losing season. Well done Gutey I hope you stay there for decades.

  5. We won’t know until the last possible second. Rodgers loves nothing more than taking his sweet time making decisions and having everyone play the “will he/won’t he” game as if he’s not a late-30s me-first weirdo underachiever.

  6. Something tells me the head coach would drive him to the airport if things went his way ! I would be tired of being under Erin’s reign of terror!

  7. Hold them hostage. Anyone have a legitimate reason why he shouldn’t? Don’t bother appealing to emotion. $60mm automatically makes emotional reasons moot.

  8. I can’t picture him playing anywhere else. I’ve never seen such a great team get to the playoffs so many times and blow it with a Hall of Fame quarterback. A lot of it was on Rodgers, but regardless, it was a colossal disappointment for everyone involved.

  9. Aaron Rodgers last time making the Superbowl = 2011. All stats, a lot of brat, a Lot of big games lost at Home. 60 mil seriously

  10. I just looked up his net worth and while $60M is a whole lot of cash he certainly would not be hurting if he left. One possibility is he agrees to walk away and gets part of the cash.

    Nah, what am I saying? It’s Rodgers. He’ll hold the Pack hostage for months.

  11. Who negotiated that contract? Shareholder revolt!!! The drama queen will do enough “thought” to remain in the headlines and RELUCTANTLY TAKE THE $$$$$$$. What a disaster, free agent freeze and lucky to pay draft picks, All the while your QB whines and gives his opinion of whom you should be hiring, while keeping his wallet full and laughing all the way to the bank,

  12. ….of course he does….he’s, shall we say inherently privy…..

    More drama than AB….but a midwestern darling.

  13. With his declining skills that’s not a bad gig. 60 million riding the pine behind Jordan Love.

  14. Rodgers really manifested a great playoff run didn’t he? All his Ayahuasca and rhe his belief in the “the power is the mind” really resulted in a great season didn’t it? ARodg has confused being able to throw a football amazingly well with being a visionary. Narcissism will do that to a man. The sooner Aaron Rodgers is done with football, the sooner he can get out into the world and get some scale for his average intelligence and learn that his great skill in life was his ability to throw(which resulted in one super bowl( just like Favre who he thought he was so much smarter than). Then he can take on the challenge of life and he will look back at the time when he was celebrated for his great gift(which he mostly squandered by wanting to be something other than a great quarterback and teammmate). Au revoir Monsiuer Rodgers. We will miss your boring, underachieving self.

  15. He is too old and his skills have declined measurably. He’s a Packer or retired…nobody going to pay him top money anymore.

  16. Go away Aaron..you will never win another SB and winning only 1 is not enough to put you in with the great ones of all time.

  17. I cant see Rodgers wanting to go out on a season like this one. The 60 million just makes his decision a LOT easier.

  18. He always holds all the cards, because the GM, HC, and President don’t have a set to tell him otherwise. No Pack No. 😂😂😂

  19. He’s not retiring. Every player sounds like they’re done after the last game of the season… Give him a month off… Let him go on vacation with his billionaire girlfriend and he’ll be ready to go for another year or two. He’s not walking away from that kind of $$$.

  20. wouldn’t put it against Rodgers to do so. Selfish until the end. Watching the Lions humiliate him last night was the best part of the season.

  21. He ain’t going anywhere. He’s too self absorbed to do anything other than bask in the attention he will get all off-season as he “decides”. Then he’ll come back or demand a trade. Can’t wait for him to just go away.

  22. Whatever he does, it won’t be done quickly. Prolonged speculation means a prolonged spotlight. And Aaron Rodgers l-o-o-o-ves the spotlight.

  23. fmc651 says:
    January 9, 2023 at 11:22 am
    Gutey caved and he is finally paying the price. Gutey is in over his head that is clear. What did Gutey get for caving to Rodgers. A one and done playoff and failing to qualify for the playoffs losing season. Well done Gutey I hope you stay there for decades.
    —————————————————————————-
    One and done playoffs, but a QB that was the league MVP. I suppose you think Jordan Love would’ve even got them to the playoffs, or even into a win and in situation? Hahahahaha. By the way, I don’t like Rodgers.

  24. What he means with the “not hold them hostage” comment is clear. He’ll re-negotiate the contact and let the Packers off the hook.

  25. Watching Aaron Rodgers lose along with the Patriots might have been better than the Steelers making the playoffs.

    Beautiful to behold.

  26. I think he might be trying to get the best of both retirement and the $60M guarantee. He can negotiate a settlement: “You pay me $30M and I will walk away.”

  27. Or the Packers could be proactive announce that Jordan Love will be the starter going forward, then wait to see what Rogers decides to do. If he chooses to stay in Green Bay, they’d have a competent backup. They’re going to have to pay him one way or another. But he’d probably ask to be traded. I don’t think his ego would allow him to go out as a backup. And if no team is willing to take on the contract, the Packers would then have the leverage to approach him about renegotiating his contract in order to facilitate a trade. If they still can’t pull off a trade, leave him as the backup. If he causes too much drama, suspend him for conduct detrimental to the team and recoup some of that salary.

  28. Bait DPI.

    Hard count free play.

    Catch the D in a substitution.

    Run the ball, if they can.

    That’s what $60MM will get Green Bay and what they’ve been getting for the last several years.

  29. Packers have mishandled this from the outset, thanks to a poor effort from the front office. They wasted a draft pick on Jordan Love, when they could have instead drafted a Tee Higgins or Michael Pittman with that pick and given their QB some help in thin WR room. Compared to some other teams, they’ve done a pretty poor job of putting a team around Rodgers.

  30. Lee VanCleef says:
    January 9, 2023 at 11:38 am
    Go away Aaron..you will never win another SB and winning only 1 is not enough to put you in with the great ones of all time.
    ———————————-
    How many rings does HoFers Dan Marino, Jim Kelly have combined? How many times have Dan and Jim been the NFL MVP combined? Hint: less than Aaron Rodgers

  31. This guy comes off as a lost soul. It doesn’t appear as though he even knows who he is, off the football field, and and his age, that’s a problem. Might be time to ride off into the sunset and figure yourself out.

  32. He‘s a good quarterback, but no longer a great one. He needs to put time into his craft and into his relationships with his young receivers, because part of his greatness during his MVP season was his connection with Davante Adams that was so perfect that he could simply throw the ball wherever he wanted and Adams knew exactly where to had to go to catch. You build these relationships during OTAs, voluntary camps and regular camps.
    I‘m not sure if Rodgers still wants it that bad or if he’s just happy with the attention he’s getting and by simply sticking it to the Packers and make them eat crow until they release Jordan Love.
    It’s definitely not about money – he has enough of it. This is about attention and revenge.
    We‘ll see if it’s about success and his legacy, if and when he participates in offseason programs and camp.
    My guess is he‘ll have another cup of tea.

  33. Who says AR is holding the Packers hostage? Did he alone sign the contract between GB and him? Or did an authorized team representative sign it on behalf of the team? A deal’s a deal, isn’t it? What about if you buy a used car from and a few months later it springs an oil leak, the tranny starts slipping and it accumulates a fender dent or two? Do you think the dealer will take it back?

    The real problem is that many of these so-called “general managers” spend someone else’s money and not their own. Perhaps if their compensation packages were tied to team performance, they’d be more careful.

  34. GB is wasting Packers’s fans time. 60 mil per for a user.

    No thank you.

    Brady is in the same category. At some point you need to call out the oligarch instead of being afraid of him.

  35. Another off-season of “the beautiful mystery” begins. Will he or won’t he? Do we care or don’t we? This guy loves drama.

  36. People seem to forget that AR was the MVP the past two seasons. This was a down season caused by many issues; including OL injuries the first half of the season, the changeover in the WR position, and some poor choices by AR. However, there were plenty of great plays by AR. He still has plenty of talent.

  37. It’s $30 mil after taxes. He still has State Farm and Jeopardy money to fall back on. Plus, we don’t know how last week’s events affected him individually. We aren’t the ones taking the hits. It sure looked like this might have been it last night.

  38. It’s a great investment, nearly $60 million to finish third in the North. At least they finished ahead of Chicago, you know the team he “owns.”

  39. Will Aaron play this year? Is answered by the question, Does TB12 retire this year? If Brady retires, then Aaron will play. Aaron won’t want to be the 2nd best quarterback on the ballot. If Brady plays, then Aaron may well retire. Green Bay is not built for going after another Superbowl which is the only reason why Aaron should want to play.

  40. ANOTHER full off-season of Aaron Rodgers this ,and AARON RODGERS THAT, . He loves the attention and the power he has over the Green Bay Packers. He’ll drag it all out till late summer once again….and then come back last week of preseason games.

  41. Time for Rodgers 4-month stint performing Hamlet: To be, or not to be, that is the question/Whether ‘it’s nobler in the mind to suffer/The slings and arrows of outrageous fortune/Or take arms against a sea of troubles.

  42. bozobiden says:

    He’s Brett Favre 2.0 nothing more, nothing less, and it’s time for him to go
    ###

    He’s not as good as Favre. Favre won one SB and made it to another. Favre loved the game, Rodgers loves the attention. Favre was well paid, Rodgers was paid stupid money.

    It is time for him to go, but his arrogance and need for attention will prevent that from happening.

  43. Thank you for your ongoing great journalism, Mike.

    Mike, I’d enjoy a column that suggests it’s time
    for the Green Bay GM to move in a different direction…..similar to how the former GM Mr. Thompson and Mike McCarthy realized Favre
    was no longer the answer after the cold weather home game loss in 2012 vs. NY revealed Favre could no longer function well in
    cold weather.

    The same malady afflicts Rodgers: He’s lost three consecutive playoff games in January from 2021-2023 in Lambeau.

    In addition, his scrambling ability to break free from the pocket and, then, find an open receiver is NO longer effective.

  44. Rodgers may surprise you all. Say what you want about ayahuasca and the like, the man does have some spirituality. He is not a dullard. Yet, he will be plagued by the same demon that every athlete past his prime is. He will not know when it’s time to hang it up. Hindsight is so easy for all the naysayers. Stranger things have happened than to turn down 60 million dollars.
    I find a great amount of evidence to suggest that many hate the Packers because they’ve been so good for so long. I wish Aaron Rodgers and the Packers the best going forward.

  45. Aksetra says:
    January 9, 2023 at 11:53 am
    Bait DPI.

    Hard count free play.

    Catch the D in a substitution.

    Run the ball, if they can.

    That’s what $60MM will get Green Bay and what they’ve been getting for the last several years.

    —————————————————

    4 MVP’s

  46. No wonder he doesn’t care about training camp, because he gets what he wanted. Stupid organization.

  47. He may think he holds all the cards but in reality he’s not playing with a full deck.

  48. On a side note, this is a Rumor Mill. For the last month, Mark Murphys home is DePere WI has been vacant and so far no real estate signs are posted. Did he move? Is he leaving GB and not saying yet? Dunno.

  49. Rodgers is who he is, but he’s still the best QB in the NFCN hands down (and I can’t stand the guy). He’s not $60M for 2023 good though. Given the contract terms and the money it would be a surprise if he wasn’t back in 2023. This all relates back to Gutekunst’s disastrous decision to draft Love, only compounded when Rodgers bent the Packers over on the contract restructure — Packers’ management has been scrambling like a bunch of 13 year olds ever since.

  50. The LaBron James of the NFL. Go to a team with the talent you can’t do it. It’s easy to QB when your line gives you 10-15 seconds to throw the with receivers who are great. But when you have an average talent around you you’re an average QB

  51. But…but…but…I was told over and over that Rodgers’ salary cap hit is only $15 million a year!

  52. I’m tired of this perpetual Aaron Rodgers ‘will he stay or will he go’ soap opera drama. Guess what?…I DON’T CARE. There always seems to be a soap opera surrounding this guy.

  53. He’s not as good as Favre. Favre won one SB and made it to another
    ============

    Farve had a top 5 defense from 1994-1997, fewest points and yards allowed in 1996.

    What happened the only year Rodgers played with a top 5 D?

    (only. singular..)

  54. Why would Rodgers want to leave? Lots o’ money to stay, he is perfectly capable of playing at a high level. He is smart enough to know that when he negotiated that contract that he was giving up his “trade me to the team of my choice” card, no one is going to take that contract on. The beginning of the year was rough for GB but they started putting it together in the second half of the season as the young guys caught on. Status quo plus maybe another WR seems highly likely for 2023. I will file this story under “nothing burger” until proven otherwise.

  55. They rolled the dice, thinking they had a year to make a run at it. They failed, miserably. While that little run of wins was cute, this team and Rodgers are clearly declining. The only thing not declining is his massive salary and cap hits. Good luck.

  56. gibson45 says:

    People seem to forget that AR was the MVP the past two seasons. This was a down season caused by many issues; including OL injuries the first half of the season, the changeover in the WR position, and some poor choices by AR. However, there were plenty of great plays by AR. He still has plenty of talent.
    ###

    The down season was primarily caused by Rodgers not being committed enough to show up to the voluntary portion of the preseason in order to get familiar with the new WR’s, despite all the millions of dollars the Packers paid him in advance.

    Blaming his WR’s for not knowing where he wanted them to be was 100% on Aaron.

    His poor choices continued all season as he dissed his new WR’s time and time again.

    Assuming he decides to come back, it will be wash, rinse and repeat season with no better, or possibly worse, results in 2023.

    Jordan Love has a better rapport with these WR’s than Aaron does.

    Past MVP awards mean nothing after the worst season of Aaron’s career.

  57. Matt Ryan has been to a Super Bowl more recently than Rodgers, and Nick Foles WON a Super Bowl more recently than Aaron. Let THAT sink in!

  58. No loss. IF the Packers had won the game, they would have lost to the Niners in the Wildcard game…..as usual. Rodgers is a legend in his own mind.

  59. touchback6 says:
    January 9, 2023 at 12:02 pm
    GB is wasting Packers’s fans time. 60 mil per for a user.

    No thank you.

    Brady is in the same category. At some point you need to call out the oligarch instead of being afraid of him

    ———-

    We have seen how mediocre BB is since Brady left. I expect we will soon see the same regarding Matt Lefleur

  60. Rodgers still has game. Maybe not 50 TD’s game, but still a great QB. They won’t miss out on the playoffs in 2023 because of him.

  61. Remember when the Lions denied the Packers a playoff birth on the last game of the season? Man that was great. And that Packer who decided he wanted to shove a Lions trainer which basically cost them the game? Also great times.

    Please keep Rodgers another year – MNVikings

  62. Watch him retire after the draft or the day before week 1 so he can make sure they don’t have a chance to replace him

  63. They need to do something before Love’s rookie contract is up, no one else in the pipeline

  64. The Packers liked what he did last season so much when they lost in the playoffs at home to the 49ers that they gave him $60 million to not make the playoffs at all this season. This team is obviously run by a group of Einsteins.

  65. Packers deserve to be strapped with his ridiculous cap sucking contract. I find it hilarious that His Arrogance plays this game with them every off-season.

  66. Rodgers track record in the postseason (with the exception of 2010) is not good.

  67. The Packers are in a no-win situation because Love sucks, badly, and was a totally wasted pick, and AR can do whatever he wants.
    The Packers had better start rebuilding from OL/DL out in order to compete going forward.

  68. Look it should be obvious by now to anyone Aaron Rodgers isn’t going to be steered to a conclusion by anything the Packers do or don’t do. Isn’t that obvious?

  69. 60 mil is a lot, but not so much when you’ve already made over 300 mil. The roster is not that good. ARodgers will make a good living after FB. Don’t see him coming back for the money. Not sure how much he even likes playing FB. If he had Brady’s drive and competitiveness, he may have 10 rings instead of 1.

  70. The Packers are screwed. Of course they are stuck with a $60 million bill for next year. Rodgers is not going anywhere and no one else will take him.

  71. It just shows how inept the Packer front office is. Gutekunst needs to be fired.

  72. DeVante Adams has said he wants to be involved in choosing a new Raiders quarterback. Could that be because he doesn’t want Rodgers there? xD

  73. That #1 pick for a clipboard holder sure cost them big, now if Rodgers sticks around 1 more year, Love is gone and if they would have picked another weapon on the offense instead, GB may have had a decent team.

  74. The Packers went from holding all the cards to Aaron now holding them. Goes to to show you how poor the management is in Green Bay.

  75. GO get Adams back. he clearly went to the Raiders to be with Carr. He doesn’t want to be there.

  76. He didn’t write the contract, he signed it. Just like they wanted him to do.

  77. Rodgers track record in the postseason (with the exception of 2010) is not good.
    ===========

    Only 9 QBs in history have more postseason wins.

    Won at least 1 game in 7 of the last 10 Playoff trips.

  78. “Only 9 QBs in history have more postseason wins.”

    Aaron Rodgers is tied for 8th place all time with 11 wins. But to put that in some perspective, Joe Flacco has 10 postseason wins.

  79. the bottom line, ‘cuz Stone Cold says:
    January 9, 2023 at 3:59 pm
    Rodgers track record in the postseason (with the exception of 2010) is not good.
    ===========
    Only 9 QBs in history have more postseason wins.
    Won at least 1 game in 7 of the last 10 Playoff trips.

    The Packers have been good enough to make the playoffs fairly often. However, the team’s record in the post-season during Rodgers’ tenure is barely above .500, hardly elite. His play yesterday wasn’t very inspiring, the Packers looked pretty bad in the red zone. The team panicked when negotiating with Rodgers last year. Should have let him walk and would have received a pretty nice haul in return.
    Going forward the Packers should do what’s best for the club. If that means sitting Rodgers while playing Jordan Love, fine. Let the $60M man stew on the sideline.

  80. He sees warm weather climate QB positions open in Miami, Tampa, Rams, and hometown SF may be interested too depending on how the playoffs go.
    I think he’s wanted to go somewhere else for a couple years and this may be the year to do it.

  81. I don’t get all the hate on Rodgers. It comes across as personal, like he showed up to your brother’s wedding drunk and peed in the corner during the signing of the registry. He’s a football player, and a good one. Of course he’ll stay in Green Bay. Money, plus he and his newer receivers are a lot more in sync now. However, there is a problem. NFC North will be even stronger next year. Vikings are good, Lions are on an upswing, Bears have 1st pick in the draft plus Fields. Packers won’t get to .500.

  82. San Francisco likely has zero interest in acquiring Rodgers. He’s approaching his “use by date” and the Niners don’t need all the drama that comes with Rodgers

  83. Receivers drop key passes, fumble at key moments, defenders commit key personal fouls, but Rodgers gets the blame 💀 the hate for him is real

  84. I totally get the Rodgers hate. Even as a Packers fan, who’s seen him lead his team to a ton of wins and lots of entertainment, his act has grown pretty stale. I very much wanted the GBP to trade him last off season, if we had we’d be in the catbird seat like Seattle, a better team long term holding a boatload of draft picks, and NOT sitting on an insane contract. Everyone piles onto Gutey for the decision to resign and extend him. Two years ago everyone blamed Gutey for drafting Jordan Love like it was the ultimate disrespect, when in fact he was taking a smart calculated risk on the future. No one knows exactly who is pulling the strings in GB on a signing of that magnitude but you can bet the choice wasn’t just for Brian Gutekunst, Murphy and LaFleur certainly had their say. Say what you will about Gutey and Rodgers, but Gutey’s 2022 draft class looks very, very good.

  85. The media can’t enough of this guy. He’s a perennial choker and just had his most dreadful season, yet here we are talking about how he “holds all the cards for 2023.” Anyway to spin him as being the ultimate winner when he’s a whiny showboat.

  86. gibson45 says:
    January 9, 2023 at 12:07 pm
    People seem to forget that AR was the MVP the past two seasons. This was a down season caused by many issues; including OL injuries the first half of the season, the changeover in the WR position, and some poor choices by AR. However, there were plenty of great plays by AR. He still has plenty of talent.

    ——————————–

    You seem to be full of apologies for this overrated team.

  87. Aaron Rogers is still the most accurate pocket passer in the league. If the pack gave him an ounce of support at receiver and maybe some blocking, they would be in the superbowl every year. He has carried the club on his back for long time, management should have gotten some draft picks right by now. Some west coast team should pay the big bucks and ride him to the promised land next year.

  88. TheTruth says:
    January 9, 2023 at 11:46 am

    fmc651 says:
    January 9, 2023 at 11:22 am
    Gutey caved and he is finally paying the price. Gutey is in over his head that is clear. What did Gutey get for caving to Rodgers. A one and done playoff and failing to qualify for the playoffs losing season. Well done Gutey I hope you stay there for decades.
    —————————————————————————-
    One and done playoffs, but a QB that was the league MVP. ///////////////

    You are joking here? 1 & done as a 1 seed. Who cares about the wrong guy getting the MVP award. He didn’t deserve it last year and his performance in the playoffs was proof. The MVP seasons started by getting blown out by the Saints and then after beating the Bears again the media starting talking about Rodgers for MVP for no reason. And it continued.

  89. the last 2 seasons Rodgers pulls this retirement talk so the media is distracted and doesn’t talk about how poorly he played. How he went 1 and done in the playoffs as a #1 seed. Or a loss to the Lions at home to a team that had nothing to play for. And Rodgers could’ve made the playoffs with a win. I get it didn’t matter Rodgers & the packers were done in their first game again had the packers made it. The packers has trouble with the 49ers.

  90. $60 million a year and in a “win or the season ends” game, the Lions (with half a roster) kicked his ass on national television.

    Please stay in Green Bay, Aaron.

    Signed,
    The rest of the NFC North

  91. Rodgers strikes me as the kind of guy who might have the wisdom to say, “I have enough money now. I think I’ll create a foundation to give a lot of it away. Buh-bye.”

  92. People seem to forget that AR was the MVP the past two seasons.

    So what? Lamar has an MVP and nothing else besides being 14 yrs younger than Mr Arrogant.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.