Aaron Rodgers isn’t “mentally or emotionally” ready to make decision on his future

Detroit Lions v Green Bay Packers
Getty Images

Aaron Rodgers has had nine days to ponder his future, since Green Bay’s season came to an abrupt conclusion via a home loss to the Lions in Week 18. He needs more time before deciding on what he wants to do in 2023.

Appearing with Pat McAfee and former teammate A.J. Hawk, Rodgers said, as to making decisions about his future, he’s “not mentally or emotionally at that point” to make a decision about his future.

He suggested that, after a few weeks, he’ll be in a “better frame of mind” to consider his future. For now, he said he “has a feeling” where he’s leaning.

Rodgers exited Lambeau Field as if he won’t be back. He spoke in his final press conference in ways that suggested maybe he had played his last game with the Packers.

The options are fairly narrow: (1) play for the Packers; (2) play for someone else; or (3) retire.

He can retire without owing any money back to the Packers, but he’d be giving up roughly $60 million in 2023 compensation. He could try to finagle a trade to a new team, if that team is willing to take on $60 million in financial liability. (The Packers could choose to pay some of the money to facilitate a trade.)

And while it appears that he considered joining a new team in 2022 before deciding to stay put, he could decide to finally give it a try somewhere else, if he believes he can thrive in a new spot.

“Do I still think I can play?” Rodgers said. “Of course. Of course. Can I play at a high level? Yeah, the highest. I think I can win MVP again, in the right situation. Right situation, is that Green Bay or is that somewhere else, I’m not sure. But I don’t think you should shut down any opportunity. Like I said during the season, It’s got to be both sides like actually wanting to work together moving forward, and I think there’s more conversation to be had.”

He offered a pretty strong clue as to what would prompt him to not want to play for the Packers.

“I think no player wants to be part of any type of rebuild,” Packers said. “I said that years ago. Reloads are a lot of fun, because you feel like you’re close. You’re only a couple guys away.”

So does he think the Packers are only a couple guys away? Or will he be looking for a team that is only one guy away, as in him?

Rodgers also will be paying attention to whether the Packers will be bringing back some of his favorite teammates. He mentioned tight end Marcedes Lewis, receiver Randall Cobb, tackle David Bakhtiari, receiver Allen Lazard, and tight end Robert Tonyan.

“We’ll see their desire to re-sign these certain guys who are ‘glue’ guys in the locker room,” Rodgers said, later making it clear that, if the Packers decide to rebuild, Rodgers will have no interest in playing there.

Whatever he chooses to do, the decision likely will come early in the offseason, like it did last year. The Packers need to know who their quarterback will be. And if Rodgers would play for someone else, the sooner he makes that move, the better.

Wherever he goes (if he does something other than go home), he needs to be all in, throughout the offseason program. His teammates, whether in Green Bay or somewhere else, need to get comfortable with him. He needs to get comfortable with them.

In 2022, there’s a line to be drawn between Rodgers not being around and the rookie receivers taking a long time to get themselves sufficiently comfortable. If he’s in (and he says if he’s in, he’ll be all-in), he needs to be all in.

70 responses to “Aaron Rodgers isn’t “mentally or emotionally” ready to make decision on his future

  1. Aaron Rodgers isn’t mentally or emotionally ready for a lot of things. Just add this to that long list…

  2. He said he would like to play for Miami. However, Miami is tight on salary cap room for 2023 so they’d have to be VERY creative to get Rodgers.

  3. Ah, the annual “will he, won’t he?” Can we just flip a coin and decide for him?

  4. Please go away…and take Brady with you
    So sad to see when the greats have no idea of when to give it up.

  5. lol thats funny. All his ‘favorites’ he mentioned are on the verge of retirement themselves except for Lazard, who sounded like he didnt give AF about Aaron in a recent interview and also has suggested he wants to play somewhere else.

    Seriously if your favorite targets are Marcedes Lewis and Randall Cobb you need to retire, ASAFP

  6. Maybe some mind altering drugs will help. It sure got him prepared for this last season….eye roll.

  7. Well is anyone ever really emotionally or mentally ready to “decision” on their future?

  8. You gave him all the power, and now he is going to use it. There is no realistic option of the team deciding to move on. Aaron can move on if he chooses. And by the way, the “in this article, I think pretty much sums up Aaron Rodgers——-
    “Do I still think I can play?” Rodgers said. “Of course. Of course. Can I play at a high level? Yeah, the highest. I think I can win MVP again, in the right situation.————

    That tells you all you need to know. Aaron Rodgers thinks of Aaron Rodgers first, which is fine when you’re talking contract, but he thinks about Aaron Rodgers first on the football field. Notice he didn’t talk about winning a Super Bowl. Because he doesn’t care. He wants to be known as the MVP. It doesn’t care about the team. He’ll be the same way no matter where he goes. They never should have given him the control like that. They should have told him in June, you’re either in or out. If you’re in, we want total commitment like a guy that makes 50,000,000+ per year. If you you’re out, that’s fine. At least we’ll know where to start.”

  9. 2022 Aaron Rodgers: 27 touchdowns, 12 interceptions
    2022 Justin Fields: 25 touchdowns, 11 interceptions (in two less games)

  10. That’s code from Rodgers meaning:

    I just want to smoke my mushrooms for the next 5 months and not think about anything worthwhile. Cause I can.

  11. Sequels are never as good as the original! “A beautiful mystery” part 2, is no exception! Make a decision Erin.

  12. Sounds to me like the AR passive-aggressive train is getting warmed up in ol Green Bay.

  13. If the Packers had kept winning, they might have been active through the Super Bowl–roughly a month from now. So why is there such pressure to make decisions immediately? Everything is some outrage or crisis these days when it doesn’t have to be.

  14. Gutey, please just say we’re not resigning any of your favorite guys so it’s time to move on.

  15. Dude making 50 mil a year worrying about his emotional status.

    Just retire Rodgers, your arrogance far outweighs your talent

  16. Really only see the Raiders as a team that would be willing to trade for him that he would be willing to play for, and not much for that contract like a maybe 6th or a 7th; if Green Bay agrees to pay part of it then a better pick. Other than that, The ongoing storyline of, maybe, sure, I need a vacay, I will decide later, etc, etc will happen right up to the time he walks on to the field for training camp (OTA’s are not required and don’t expect him to be there)…he is not walking away from that money, leaving it to GB’s management to make a decision which is basically let Love walk for whatever they can get or cut/trade Aaron and make Love the starter. One of these QB’s will not be with Green Bay next year.

  17. Perhaps a couple of days of hot oil treatments and cucumber wraps will soothe his raging inner conflict.

  18. The only question is if he comes back to Green Bay or if he asks to be traded. He’s not walking away from that $$$.

  19. chickensalad43 says:
    January 17, 2023 at 4:02 pm
    2022 Aaron Rodgers: 27 touchdowns, 12 interceptions
    2022 Justin Fields: 25 touchdowns, 11 interceptions (in two less games)
    __________________________

    That 26 passing and 1 rushing for Rodgers and 17 passing and 8 rushing for Fields.

  20. chickensalad43 says:
    January 17, 2023 at 4:02 pm
    2022 Aaron Rodgers: 27 touchdowns, 12 interceptions
    2022 Justin Fields: 25 touchdowns, 11 interceptions (in two less games)

    Including rushing TDs in the touchdown list is cute. Fields threw for a 2242 yards versus Rogers’ 3695, only the third time he was below 4000 yards in his career if he played more than 9 games. Also only the third time he’s had double digit INTs.
    So yeah, an aging Aaron Rodgers is still exponentially better than Justin Fields.

  21. He might not have Randall Cobb to teach the receivers this offseason, so hopefully Aaron will be the one teaching receivers. I just don’t get why other QBs like Mahomes is taking in the rookies during the summer to work together, and Aaron isn’t doing the same. He’s the highest paid player in the league. He should work for it but won’t.

  22. onereasonableman says:
    January 17, 2023 at 4:03 pm
    Sounds to me like the AR passive-aggressive train is getting warmed up in ol Green Bay.

    81Rate This

    ————–

    Brady started his last night in Tampa.

    Brady has shown the others this path.

  23. Apparently Rodgers’s emotions exist somewhere outside of his mind. He’s waiting to see what they tell him to do.

  24. Rodgers should re enact the Lebron’s legendary mishap “decision”, and use it to make fun of his own situation.

  25. So funny to read the comments from all the nobody’s in here. You are a fan, he is a multi-millionaire that has won MVP 4 times from a sport that you have ZERO talent in. But hey, you have huge keyboard muscles.

  26. He already checked out. He doesn’t really want to play but 60 million is sure hard to pass up. So I think he will show up and give half an effort.

  27. He doesn’t see the field like he used to and he’s hesitant to pull the trigger. The Packers are going to move on, one way or the other.

  28. Wonder how much of the Rodgers hate would turn when he is traded to the respective team of the fans on here?AR did not have a normal year by his standards,and I think the Packers should move on and start the rebuild with Love.But in reality there are still only a handful of QBs in the league as good or better.Mahomes,Allen,Burrow are better.Hurts,Herbert,Lawrence maybe as good.Need more from them yet.Prescott,Tua,Jones,Lamaar step below.Rest of the QBs not even in the conversation.

  29. I’m a long suffering Lions fan that is finally looking at his team going in the right direction. Please, Rodgers, return. That $50 million you eat up will guarantee that the team isn’t able to get better for quite some time.

  30. Aaron Rodgers isn’t “mentally or emotionally” able to make most adult decisions. But as long as he strings the packers along until they grovel to him and screw up their cap for years to come its alright by me.

  31. Well he has til a couple weeks before the draft to let Guty know! Or they can make his decision for him! If he stays Love will be traded! If lazard leaves might be able to keep Cobb! Lewis, Crosby, I don’t know!

  32. Huge temptation to take a swing at this one but there’s too much crap going on in the world already, so let’s be nice instead and wish him and his fans well.

  33. thetomahawk says:
    January 17, 2023 at 4:47 pm
    Wonder how much of the Rodgers hate would turn when he is traded to the respective team of the fans on here?AR did not have a normal year by his standards,and I think the Packers should move on and start the rebuild with Love.But in reality there are still only a handful of QBs in the league as good or better.Mahomes,Allen,Burrow are better.Hurts,Herbert,Lawrence maybe as good.Need more from them yet.Prescott,Tua,Jones,Lamaar step below.Rest of the QBs not even in the conversation.

    ____________

    Two words, No Thanks.

  34. Heck he hasn’t even decided which lie he’s telling about getting vaccinated…how the hell do you expect him to decide on a multi-million dollar career…

  35. tippiwoo says:
    January 17, 2023 at 4:31 pm
    So funny to read the comments from all the nobody’s in here. You are a fan, he is a multi-millionaire that has won MVP 4 times from a sport that you have ZERO talent in. But hey, you have huge keyboard muscles

    ///////////////

    I do planks

  36. Love how his main concern is ‘winning MVP again’, and never seems to be about winning a 2nd Superbowl Ring. #Priorities

  37. tippiwoo says:
    January 17, 2023 at 4:31 pm
    So funny to read the comments from all the nobody’s in here. You are a fan, he is a multi-millionaire that has won MVP 4 times from a sport that you have ZERO talent in. But hey, you have huge keyboard muscles.
    ———————————————————————————————
    You might be a fan that thinks success on the field allows for him to act like an entitled jerk. The rest of us who judge people on who they are not what they do on the field are absolutely correct in criticizing the self entitled, whiny jerk that Rodgers has become. Doesn’t take muscles to see the obvious.

  38. Mr. Pragmatic says:
    January 17, 2023 at 5:21 pm
    thetomahawk says:
    January 17, 2023 at 4:47 pm
    Wonder how much of the Rodgers hate would turn when he is traded to the respective team of the fans on here?AR did not have a normal year by his standards,and I think the Packers should move on and start the rebuild with Love.But in reality there are still only a handful of QBs in the league as good or better.Mahomes,Allen,Burrow are better.Hurts,Herbert,Lawrence maybe as good.Need more from them yet.Prescott,Tua,Jones,Lamaar step below.Rest of the QBs not even in the conversation.

    //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////

    So you’re saying he’s about the middle of the pack now for $60 mil, and you’re fine with that? Right on! Go pack Go

  39. Translation: I better go drop some more acid before I decide if I want to come back and rob this place for 60 mil next year.

  40. It’s only been a week and it’s a $60M decision — it makes sense to wait at least a little bit. The question is if his perception of a “re-load” is the same as management’s.

  41. I’m just glad the headline didn’t say ‘Aaron Rodgers isn’t “mentally or emotionally” stable.’ I would have gone ballistic. Phew!

  42. So sad to see sports stars who cannot walk away from the game before their talents drastically decline. Its obvious both Brady and Rodgers best years a far behind them, but its hard to walk away from all that money.

  43. “We’ll see their desire to re-sign these certain guys who are ‘glue’ guys in the locker room,” Rodgers said,
    ++++++
    Please pick your top 3 AFC teams, and feel free to take as much of the glue as you want.

    Gute will figure out the numbers. Best o’ luck.

  44. If he stays Love will be traded! If lazard leaves might be able to keep Cobb! Lewis, Crosby, I don’t know!
    ++++++
    If he stays the Packers will unload Rodgers at the deadline for whatever (given the acquirng team will still end up paying Rodgers half his salary).

    You extend Love before that happens (if you have faith in him). Why would you trade Love? He’s still cheap one more year.

    Roll him out for the 2nd half, and use the $25 million of “found” cap money to frontload new deals for Gary/Dillon/Runyan.

  45. It’s time to move on. The Packers aren’t going to surround him with the pieces he needs to get to another SB. Let the Love era begin.

  46. It is UNFATHOMABLE that the Favre situation is repeating itself right before our eyes. TO.THE.LETTER! Just inconceivable.

    The Packers flat out hosed themselves with this guy. Pretty clear he’s not going to win another Super Bowl, and they’ve handed him all the leverage on a silver platter.

    Rodgers Favre’ing it too. Thinks the grass is greener elsewhere, but he’s too afraid to force his way out and alienate his hero worshipers.

    .. starting to hope his heiress girlfriend convinces him he has better things to do with his life.

  47. Winning another MVP comes before winning a Super Bowl with Rodgers. That should tell teams all that they need to know, and make them stay away.

  48. No owner in GB, big problem in situations like this. If Rodgers is gone this year or next, or whenever he retires, the Packers fans are going to be MISERABLE. They wont be rolling out a THIRD HOF Qb anytime soon after he is gone. Rodgers has all the leverage, but he is being selfish: you signed a 3 year deal, did that much change in a year? The front office still has no clue, that much is the same.

  49. The Jordan Love insurance policy is looking better and better all the time. Make it happen. Ask yourselves: Could he be worse than former first-rounder Christian Ponder, who started for the Vikings four years? Until Love takes the reins, nobody knows. I’d like to find out.

  50. he should get together with Brady. They can do a tv special. ‘Another Big Decision … Or Not’

  51. The Packers already deserve every downside that comes their way for kowtowing and re-signing Rodgers instead of maximizing his equity into support around Love for several years. If they make it worse by continuing to enable Rodgers to influence front-office personnel decisions, somebody has to lose their job.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.