Tiki Barber suggests Aaron Rodgers is too sensitive to survive New York media scrutiny

Green Bay Packers v Buffalo Bills
Getty Images

At a time when many assume that Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers will emerge from 96 hours in voluntary solitary confinement with a plan to play for the Jets, a former player who knows plenty about the way the media in New York covers pro athletes thinks Rodgers won’t be able to handle the things inevitably written and said about him there.

Former Giants running back Tiki Barber, reacting on his WFAN radio show to Rodgers’s recent complaints about reporting by Ian Rapoport and Adam Schefter, suggested that Rodgers is too delicate to tolerate the intensity of the Big Apple’s giant spotlight.

“If he is that sensitive that he gets upset that people, reporters, opinion-makers, influencers, whoever, want to talk about him, he is going to struggle in New York,” Barber said, via SI.com. “And I don’t know if it’s the right fit for him. I don’t know if I want him in New York if this is going to be his reaction to things that don’t matter.”

Barber echoed a point that was made here, after Rodgers ranted that Rapoport and Schefter “don’t know shit” about him.

“If Aaron Rodgers doesn’t want people talking about him, talking about his offseason, talking about his personal life, talking about all these things that are going on with Aaron Rodgers, he needs to stop talking,” Barber said.

“When you go, and you do something that feels odd to normal society — which is going to sit in a cabin in the woods for four days in complete sensory isolation, [the media is] gonna talk about it. You have to. It’s our job to. And for him to get offended by that, he’s not going to handle the intensity of the New York mediascape — that’s obviously traditional media, social and everything else — if he’s here.”

Amen to all of that. Rodgers is like so many athletes and celebrities who want fame and attention on their own terms. All the praise, with none of the criticism.

Hey everybody, look at me . . . what the hell are you looking at?

For selfish reasons, I want Rodgers to play for the Jets. It’s good for business. Even if it’s bad for the Jets and Rodgers.

Indeed, here’s the first subject for intense scrutiny if/when Rodgers agrees to play for the team owned by Woody Johnson. Rodgers recently argued that members of the media have painted him as a villain at the direct behest of Big Pharma. Johnson’s fortune came directly from one of the three companies that made a COVID vaccine (Johnson & Johnson). During Rodgers’s introductory press conference, someone inevitably will ask whether it’s hypocritical for Rodgers to take a paycheck indirectly from a Big Pharma conglomerate at which he’s apparently big mad.

In other cities, the question wouldn’t get asked. In New York, you can bank on it happening.

34 responses to “Tiki Barber suggests Aaron Rodgers is too sensitive to survive New York media scrutiny

  1. Exactly the same point dispelling the notion that Rodgers could prosper under Belichick’s coaching when he’s so delicate in his feelings. Brady may be less physically talented but he was the most coachable player who would do things less flashy in order to win Super Bowls, not MVPs.

  2. Rodgers would eat it up! He loves controversy and being right! NY wouldn’t scare him for a second. It’d make great entertainment!

  3. At $50,000,000 a year, I don’t think Rodgers cares too much what NY media has to say when at most this is a two-year rental…

  4. He was upset on how it was getting reported, inaccurate, incorrect, and calling out the media for this which needs to get done, he is a lot of things but he could care less what the meda or anyone else thinks of him, if you haven’t figured that out yet you are not paying attention,

  5. The hair bun is out of style in New York….& the rest of the USA for that matter….I’d love to see his meltdowns at the Pressers though!!!!

  6. Given his past reactions it is almost certain that the NYC media will go out of their way to provoke him. That environment needs someone like Eli Manning who would not break his monotone in a press conference if his clothes were on fire.

  7. For selfish reasons, I want Rodgers to not-play for the Jets.
    It’s a stupid move for the Jets, they are no where near ready for a Superbowl run.
    Don’t blow picks and money chasing a pipe dream. Instead draft more good players, including a QB.

  8. “… he is going to struggle in New York”

    I honestly don’t think he has the intestinal fortitude to deal with it at all.

  9. Exactly the same point dispelling the notion that Rodgers could prosper under Belichick’s coaching when he’s so delicate in his feelings. Brady may be less physically talented but he was the most coachable player who would do things less flashy in order to win Super Bowls, not MVPs.
    ============

    He’s Belichicks w@ttest wildest dream.

    I hate the idea, because I despise everything about that franchise, but I think that is one of the few destinations where Rodgers may get right again.

  10. I am certain that Aaron Rodgers wants everyone to think that he could care less about what Tiki Barber thinks, but in reality he very much cares about pretty much every critical public critique, including Tiki.

  11. Tiki is right. I think last night’s South Park had a perfect analogy for it too. The Prince of Canada (obviously Harry) and his wife (Meghan) running all over on a world tour, demanding privacy. Holding signs that said “We want our privacy!” and “Stop looking at us!” while doing everything humanly possible to attract attention and working on their “brand” part of which is “victim.” Half surprised Aaron didn’t show up in the episode because it would have been a perfect fit.

  12. Tiki is right. Even in small-town Green Bay Rodgers still has problems over reacting to media. NYC is the media capitol of the US. When he tries to play the victim card he’ll be eaten alive. The NYC-based tabloids would constantly dig into his life and try to provoke him (and probably succeed) just for headlines. If there’s any real (Favre-level) dirt, the NYC’s big paper may pick it up and that will make it a national story.

  13. He wants to control the narrative as he sees fit, facts be damned. He gets indignantly sensitive when he’s exposed as a poser, albeit a well-schooled one.

  14. Rogers overcame the shadow of Demi-god, Brett Favre and plays in a community where the franchise is legendary and there are no other shows in town. I think rogers can handle NY where they have been dealing with losing franchises across all sports and would throw flowers at his feet for gracing the jets with his presence.

    Ego maniac tiki barber was happy to tear down the giants and Eli and both flourished when he and shockey left town. Please, we don’t care what tiki barber thinks.

  15. Aaron rodgers is too sensitive to survive anywhere except green bay whose fans fawn over any packer football player because they literally have nothing else.

  16. Thanks for that insightful and painfully obvious media scrutiny, Tiki. Now, if you want to be really helpful, you’ll tell me where to find the best luau spot in Manhattan.

  17. cheeseisfattening says:

    whose fans fawn over any packer football player because they literally have nothing else.
    ++++++
    did JJ break the record?

  18. “Attention? You want the attention? You can’t handle the attention!” – Apologies to Jack Nicholson.

  19. billshistorian says:

    I think rogers can handle NY where they have been dealing with losing franchises across all sports and would throw flowers at his feet for gracing the jets with his presence.
    ###

    Facts not in evidence.

    With the noteworthy exception of the city of Buffalo the state of NY as a whole has quite a history of championships in professional sports.

    MLB – 30 championships

    MLS – 1 championship

    NBA – 2 championships

    NFL – 8 championships

    NHL – 8 Championships

    That’s 49 championships for NY.

  20. Tiki’s trash. Cheats on his pregnant wife, criticizes his coach and teammates publicly. I’m a jets fan and even I was happy for the giants when they won the Super Bowl the year after he retired.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.