Will Jets pursue Aaron Rodgers or Derek Carr?

Oakland Raiders v Green Bay Packers
Getty Images

Derek Carr is a free agent. Aaron Rodgers isn’t. The Jets reportedly are interested in both. For now, though, they can talk only to Carr.

They did just that over the weekend, meeting with Carr. According to Connor Hughes of SNY.tv, the visit went “very well.”

Carr reportedly wants to pick his next team before are agency begins, so that he can assist in the recruiting of other potential free agents. He has visited the Saints. Other visits could occur.

The Jets could also visit with Rodgers, if he emerges from his four-day darkness retreat wanting to play, and not wanting to play for the Packers, who reportedly are done with him, anyway.

The clock is ticking. Free agency begins in only three weeks. Rodgers need to figure out what he’s going to do so the Jets can figure out whether to sign Carr — who is younger, cheaper, and requires no draft-pick compensation — or trade for Rodgers, a four-time MVP who may be getting dangerously close to his football expiration date.

57 responses to “Will Jets pursue Aaron Rodgers or Derek Carr?

  1. For the record, this isn’t the first time McGinn has been hyper critical of Rodgers. In 2020, McGinn suggested that LaFleur, in his first year coaching the Packers, had “had enough of Rodgers’ act and wanted to change the narrative.” Rodgers won MVP that season and backed it up with another MVP in 2021.

  2. I don’t understand why any team would give anything for Rodgers. He doesn’t have it anymore and he will probably only play one more year at the most. Who would want the headache of these off season will he/won’t he play? Plus, with his salary it doesn’t make any sense to give anything up for him. I think the Packers are stuck with him unless he retires.

  3. Who in their right mind believes Carr has the cache to recruit other FAs to, of all places, the Jets? Also, the only reason he can choose his next team is because Raiders ownership is nuts. No one likes Rodgers, but the suggestion that Carr is of equal talent is asinine. The one similarity is they’re both past peak.

  4. I’d rather keep a cheaper and better Mike White than sign Derek Carr. Signing a way inconsistent Carr would be such a Jets move.

  5. Kinda hoping for Rodgers. He would completely self destruct in the NY market. For once, there would be some NY football developments that are fun to watch.

  6. How can A Rod ever get out of Favre’s shadow if he follows him to the Jets? What’s next, will Rodgers “borrow” money from the state of Mississipp too?

  7. Carr is younger less expensive and will buy in to the program. Garappolo would also. Rodgers does not even know if he wants to play or not.

  8. Carr reportedly wants to pick his next team before are agency begins
    Free
    Rodgers need to figure out what he’s going to do
    Needs

  9. The jets dont look like a bad team outside of their qb spot. I think Carr improves this team enough that they will be able to hang with the big dogs. A motivated Rodgers could make this team a legit contender. I will say this….there’d be an awful lot of hilarious meltdowns if that came to pass.

  10. They hired a coach two years ago, and he drafted a QB with the #2 overall pick in the draft. So, why are we even having this QB conversation? Would you want to go to the Jets if you were Aaron Rodgers? Somebody is screwing things up in NY. Draft a QB #2, and already butchering that up? Zach Wilson could go to the 49ers and win super bowls. Plural. The Jets are the Jets. That’s not a cliche. Aaron Rodgers will probably sign with the 49ers.

  11. Carr on the Jets is a pretty scary thought. Considering what Carr did in 2021 with very little talent around him, amidst a train wreck of a season, speaks volumes for what he is capable of doing. I write off 2022 as “the Josh McDaniels year”. The Raiders picked the wrong guy to keep.

    With the Jets talent on offense and defense, QB is their 800 pound gorilla sized hole in their roster. If Mike White can make that team click, Derek Carr could take them to the next level.

    As for Aaron Rodgers, who needs that headache?

  12. The Rodgers’ situation is probably dependent on what happens during his current seance sessions.

  13. “Rodgers need to figure out what he’s going to do so the Jets can figure out whether to sign Carr — who is younger, cheaper, and requires no draft-pick compensation — or trade for Rodgers, a four-time MVP who may be getting dangerously close to his football expiration date.”

    All of that is true and it could even been added that Carr is not the diva that Rodgers is. But even at this point, Rodgers is still a better QB than Carr.

  14. I’m kind of thinking Rodgers was pissed someone leaked his box experiment but I think he is pissed more at when it is. If no one knew when he was doing this he had the advantage to pull strings on the packers but if we knew it was over the weekend everyone would be pressing, okay you had your fun whats the decision.
    Maybe he is trying to screw the time line so the pack cant get rid of him? Just sayin

  15. The Jets will explore Derek Carr. I do think the Niners would be the best place. When you need 5 QB’s to compete, something is amiss. No guarantee with Purdy. Their window will close soon. Uber talented team, where 4 QB’s were not enough. Carr has missed 3 games in 9 years. I would guess they have cap issues or will have them soon. Niners just need a healthy QB who can hit the broad side of a barn.

  16. Neither, Aaron Rogers is simply an average quarterback with no leadership skills despite his age. The salary he demands is absurd. Carr cannot compete a 5 yard completion on 3rd down in the 2nd half leaving the defense on the field almost the entire half. Carr has never won a playoff game and cannot play in the cold. Better look somewhere else or develop something on your own roster.

  17. Rodgers appears to have passed his expiration date immediately after signing his whopping contract last year. No wonder the Packers are pissed, he totally mailed it in this past season.
    The Jets or anybody else interested in Rodgers better make sure he’s willing to earn his salary.

  18. You can hate on Rodgers all you want but Carr is no Rodgers when it comes to Quarterbacking. If the jets want a legitimate shot at a Super Bowl the next 2 or 3 years it’s got to be Rodgers. If they’re satisfied with hanging behind the Bills and Dolphins and make an occasional playoff spot, then it’s Carr.

  19. Packers may be “done” with Rodgers, but they’re not done with his contract. Rodgers has all the leverage.

  20. The Jets want him,
    But he hates them
    Packers want somebody else,
    You jut can’t win
    And so it goes,
    Till the day you die,
    This thing they call football
    Will make you cry
    Your team is bad,
    It’s on the brink,
    One thing for sure,
    Love stinks,
    Love stinks, yeah yeah.
    Love stinks,
    Love stinks, yeah yeah.

  21. Carr has a lower ceiling but more years left, and probably won’t show up to camp with a rare jungle bird perched on his head and when everyone wants to ask about the bird they get ridiculed for daring to ask about the bird.

  22. Both QBs are better than Wilson. That being said, I think Douglas would prefer Carr simply because he would not have to give up players or draft capital. On the other hand, I think Johnson feels Rogers is the Jet’s missing link to go deep into the playoffs next season.

  23. OF COURSE the Jets are gonna pursue both. My money’s on things looking positive with Carr, but they still make a play for Rodgers, with the deal falling through… so late in the game that Carr decides to sign somewhere else and they end up with Garappolo… who gets them to 5-1 before getting injured for the season and they end up 7-10 or 8-9.

    It’s not that I hate the Jets, or even like seeing them fail. It’s just that I’ve been following the NFL long enough to understand the true meaning of “the Jets are gonna Jet”

  24. Whoever they pursue, they will end up botching it and end up going into next season with Jacoby Brisset or something.

  25. It is only speculation until the aaron Witch Project concludes the transitional period of planetary alignment.

  26. For two days and nights now I have locked myself away in my very dark bedroom contemplating Aaron Rodgers next move and after deep,serious thought I have come to the conclusion that Mr. Rodgers will in fact elect to retire instead of going to play for another team. if he went to another team that team would demand he show up for all off season workouts and meetings rather than being allowed to choose which ones he attends.on another team he may not be considered the coach or General Manager but just the quarterback.expect an announcement of his retirement coming soon on your favorite sports outlet.

  27. Friendly reminder that these are Derek Carr’s career stats. Please tell us when he was ever a good QB, let alone a great one:

    2014
    33rd in Y/A, 30th in Passer Rating, 13th most INTs

    2015
    26th in Y/A, 19th in Passer Rating, 9th most INTs

    2016
    18th in Y/A, 8th in Passer Rating, 28th most INTs

    2017
    19th in Y/A, 19th in Passer Rating, 7th most INTs

    2018
    20th in Y/A, 18th in Passer Rating, 20th most INTs

    2019
    9th in Y/A, 8th in Passer Rating, 19th most INTs

    2020
    7th in Y/A, 10th in Passer Rating, 19th most INTs

    2021
    7th in Y/A, 14th in Passer Rating, 5th most INTs

    2022
    18th in Y/A, 26th in Passer Rating, 1st most INTs

  28. edmcgon says:
    February 20, 2023 at 10:40 pm
    Carr on the Jets is a pretty scary thought. Considering what Carr did in 2021 with very little talent around him, amidst a train wreck of a season, speaks volumes for what he is capable of doing. I write off 2022 as “the Josh McDaniels year”. The Raiders picked the wrong guy to keep.

    With the Jets talent on offense and defense, QB is their 800 pound gorilla sized hole in their roster. If Mike White can make that team click, Derek Carr could take them to the next level.

    As for Aaron Rodgers, who needs that headache?

    ———————-

    Did you just say Carr had no talent” around him with Adams, Waller, Renfrow, Jacobs, etc?

    LOL!

    You people are embarrassing. Carr is loaded with excuses as are Raiders fans who are clueless.

    The best move you could have ever made was hiring Ziegler/McDaniels, clean house, have patience and don’t have Davis meddle. We’ll see if the latter can happen or not.

  29. As a GB fan I have seen the good and the bad with Rodgers.He is either moody and average or he can have a chip on his shoulder and play lights out. Even at the age of 39 if he moves to another team they may get the chip on shoulder Rodgers as he sets out to prove GB wrong.

  30. forgotmypassword says:
    February 21, 2023 at 8:39 am

    OF COURSE the Jets are gonna pursue both. My money’s on things looking positive with Carr, but they still make a play for Rodgers, with the deal falling through… so late in the game that Carr decides to sign somewhere else and they end up with Garappolo…

    _______________

    That may be the best thing that could happen to the Jets. No Rodgers drama and Garappolo, as long as he can stay healthy, is a better QB than Carr.

  31. I’m a 50+ year Packer fan and I’m ready to see Rodger’s move on. But don’t buy into the washed-up, over-the-hill talk. Rodgers had a broken thumb the last half of last season. He has plenty of great football left in him, the problem is he becomes so complacent in Green Bay. If he can play re-energized, focused and with a chip on his shoulder, whatever team he’s on is going to be considered a contender.

  32. myvietnamwasfightingtheclap says:
    February 20, 2023 at 9:27 pm
    Who in their right mind believes Carr has the cache to recruit other FAs to, of all places, the Jets? Also, the only reason he can choose his next team is because Raiders ownership is nuts. No one likes Rodgers, but the suggestion that Carr is of equal talent is asinine. The one similarity is they’re both past peak.
    —————————————————————
    Why would Carr have to recruit anyone? The NY market does a good job of that as does a team that is trending upward, versus those going through a rebuild. Carr is not of equal talent with Rodgers. Maybe a team would rather get Carr at $30 million, instead of giving up a potential top draft pick and pay $50 million. That’s Carr, a top pick who would hopefully be an immediate impact player and an extra $20 million to bring in 1-2 top free agents, or just bring in Rodgers.

  33. All I want to hear is Rodgers won’t play in Green Bay in 2023. I don’t care if he gets traded or retires, just go.

  34. Yes I’m sure Rodgers and Carr are both stoked to be coached by the brilliant high school offensive coordinator Nathaniel Hackett.

  35. Aaron is the cheaper option at his salary of $30 million for this year and what now would be a small haul of draft picks, which maybe more of we will taking anything to get rid of him type deal. And whoever gets him can walk away at no cost next year. It is the grossly incompetent front office of Green Bay that has to give him another $30 million in cash and absorb that $100 million dead cap hit, the type that is franchising killing for a half of decade at watching a lot of young talent with little dead cap hits be cut to absorb that hit. Carr is going to want to be around $40 plus million a year probably 5 year deal and he has yet to prove over the past decade or so that he can actually win meaningful, when the count NFL games. Raiders need to sell tickets add Aaron would do that or Green Bay realizes their only real option is to keep Aaron and trade Love to draft another QB.

  36. If the Jets want to win now, as they have repeatedly said after the regular season, then Rodgers is the obvious choice. If they want to go cheap and wait a few years, get some good players in the draft then Carr is the way to go. It’ll be interesting.

  37. Honestly, it probably doesn’t matter. With Nathaniel Hackett and Todd Downing running the show Pat Mahomes would look like a journeyman.

  38. Packer fans keep pointing out that the last time Rodgers stunk up a season, he won two MVPs. Well, we can debate whether or not he should have been the mvp (Mahomes should have been for at least one of those seasons), but you cannot ignore that Rodgers is older, even more of a malcontent, and openly dislikes working with new WR’s. Oh, and he plays the Favre game of “will I or won’t I come back”. If you get past all of that, you cannot ignore the ridiculous contract he has, for an 8-9 QB that doesn’t even appear to like playing football anymore.

  39. If Carr has a choice, he should run, not walk, to the Jets as fast as he can. It’s a tough division, but the team has one of the best cores of young talent in the league and the arrow is pointing straight up for both sides of the ball. New Orleans looks like it’s heading into rebuild territory.

    I think Rodgers still has it but would need a situation he’s really pumped up for to avoid it being more of the malaise we saw last season. And even if he’s pumped, he’d still have to fight his way through a far better conference than the one he’s already had so much trouble with. Worse teams than the Chiefs, Bengals, and Bills have sent him home each season.

  40. The Jets have enough talent outside of QB that they can contend for a Super Bowl in the next two years. Carr is not that guy. Rodgers even at his current age on a good team could win a Super Bowl, talent-wise. I think that makes the choice an easy one, personality aside.

  41. Why wouldn’t Rodgers want to be in New York? The life he could have there! Wes Edens and Marc Lasry, primary owners of the Milwaukee Bucks and co-owners and business partners with Aaron Rodgers are well-connected New York billionaires. Rodgers is dating Wes’s daughter, Mallory Evans.

    I’m guessing? New York Jets!

  42. Why wouldn’t Rodgers want to be in New York?
    ==========

    Its not even big fish small pond for him… he’s been the ONLY fish. He has total control of the narrative.

    Think he can function without that? I don’t.

    Think he’d be able to toe the line, drawing checks from a guy that owns a massive chunk of big pharma?

    There’s two strikes….

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.