Mike McCarthy: Kellen Moore wants to light the scoreboard up, I want to run the damn ball

Detroit Lions v Dallas Cowboys
Getty Images

Cowboys coach Mike McCarthy says he and his former offensive coordinator, Kellen Moore, don’t always have the same vision for what an offense should do.

McCarthy says Moore wants to score points, but McCarthy thinks the Cowboys need to run the ball to win, even if that means scoring less.

I’ve been where Kellen’s been,” McCarthy said, via Michael Gehlken of the Dallas Morning News. “Kellen wants to light the scoreboard up, but I want him to run the damn ball so I can rest my defense. I think when you’re a coordinator, you know but you’re in charge of the offense. Being a head coach and being a play caller, you’re a little more in tune with (everything). I don’t desire to be the No. 1 offense in the league. I want to be the No. 1 team in the league with the number of wins and a championship. And if we’ve got to give up some production and take care of the ball a little better to get that, then that’s what we’ll do because we have a really good defense.”

But if McCarthy wants to keep his defense off the field, the best way to do that is for his offense to gain first downs. And the Cowboys’ offense was more efficient when passing the ball than when running the ball last season, as is usually the case with NFL offenses after decades of rules and strategy changes have benefited the passing game. If McCarthy insists on running the ball more in 2023, that may result both in fewer points on the scoreboard and in fewer wins.

94 responses to “Mike McCarthy: Kellen Moore wants to light the scoreboard up, I want to run the damn ball

  1. Instead of light up the scoreboard, McCarthy’s going to run up the losses this year.

  2. A head coach who does not have a reputation to be a forward thinker is telling us he prefer to run the ball… SHOCKING!!!!

  3. Wasn’t this the same guy who after Green Bay was in some barn studying amd evolving to be successful in today’s NFL?

    At no point did he notice that it is QB league? Did the pay for QB and WR vs RB not give him a clue to value of position?

    On the upside, with comments like this, the annual pre-season Cowboy SB hype won’t happen this year.

  4. cookerduff123 says:
    March 2, 2023 at 6:35 am
    An excuse, and throwing his former OC under the bus. Classy.
    ________________________________________________________________________

    So being truthful an saying what everyone already knows is wrong? Ok. I forgot we are in a society that can’t handle any type of critical discussion.

  5. As a Packer fan, Mike McCarthy saying he wants to run the football made me almost spit my coffee across the room. Maybe hes grown as a coach, but Ill continue to be a skeptic.

  6. This is going to end well … They don’t even know if either of their RBs from last year will be playing for them this year.

  7. Dak is highly inaccurate. Always making his receivers reach for the ball. Hard to miss the window on a handoff.

  8. Isn’t his defense built to pass rush and can be run on? So he wants to make it harder on his D all the way around….sounds brilliant

  9. “All these damn kids with their fancy pants points scoring! Back in my day we pounded the ball right up the middle twice and THEN threw. The way God intended! Now that I am calling the plays everyone is going to know exactly what we are going to be doing. Let them TRY to stop us!”

    Mike McCarthy practicing in front of the mirror…

  10. Good luck Cowboys fans, between your head coach and owner you’re more than doomed!

  11. Ask yourself – when he was Coach in GB, did they ever run into situations where more points would have won some games? I don’t mean scoring 60 but maybe 24 instead of 17?

  12. Honest question. If your defense is tired, isn’t the opposing offense tired too?

  13. Moore understands that you have to score to win in this league not run the ball. Dallas will be looking for a new coach this time next year.

  14. Isn’t McCarthy the HC? I’m sorry, I thought a HC would drive such decisions.

  15. It took about a week to know that Mike’s whole “I deep self evaluation” thing was BS. This is still the same guy with 10 year old playing madden level game clock management. He said he doesn’t want the best offense….. okay Mike. I get a feeling Dallas would be running the wishbone if Mike could get his way.

  16. McCarthy remains the worst. I hate that Jerry continues to keep him around when there were way better HC options out there. Without Kellen trying to score points, I’m afraid the Cowboys will revert back to being a boring .500 team.

  17. Last season was the most balanced season for the offense but Moore always struggled to develop a good rhythm and often put the defense back on the field too quickly, due to too many 3 and outs.

  18. Same ol same ol. This team is going nowhere. Oh well, as long as the TV ratings are high and the gate receipts are healthy Jerry is happy.

  19. Nope this day and age people don’t understand scoring slowly.

    Scoring slowly is a beautiful thing when your trying to mask your other team weaknesses. The cowboys certainly could have run the ball more effectively. And yes running the ball well will also have your team running less plays therefore your team should be more rested overall..

    I don’t think he is a good coach by a long shot but less plays per game certainly would help with overall team wear and tear considering how long a season is..

  20. It is so comforting to see McCarthy at the helm of this overhyped underperforming franchise.
    Dave Campo, Jason Garrett, etc, etc. The song remains the same. Almost three decades of irrelevance.
    That is all.

  21. Not a good look after hes gone to throw him under the bus for your ineptitude as a coach. The Boys willnever win another Super Bowl in our lifetimes because of the owner.

  22. There isn’t a Cowboys fan alive who thinks it’s a good idea for McCarthy to take over play calling. He already has game-management issues, so giving him MORE to do during games doesn’t bode well.

  23. Hey Mike, you won 4 games by a TD or less. Yeah, concentrate on running the ball even if it means scoring less.

  24. The Packers can trade me to Dallas and have Dak. I may not like Mike as a coach but would love to play for Jerry. He has deeeeeeeeeep pockets. Money talks.

  25. They threw the ball 556 times last year, and ran it 531 times. Seems pretty balanced for an NFL offense in 2022. They won 12 games. And if they were honest, the defense let them down in their playoff loss as much as the offense did.

  26. In 2010 – the year the Packers won their only Super Bowl of the last 27 years – their leading rusher was Brandon Jackson with 703 yards. No other rb had more than 281 (John Kuhn). They had just 13 rushes for 50 yards in their Super Bowl victory.

    The next season, they did lead the NFL in scoring had the best record in the league at 15-1. James Starks led the team with 556 yards rushing. In the playoffs, they suddenly got conservative. They outrushed the Giants 157 – 95 and won the time of possession battle…and lost by 17 points.

    I don’t know why McCarthy is stuck in 1978. He need only look at his own experiences with the Packers.

  27. That’s funny since you are paying a mediocre QB $45 million to throw the ball not hand off.

  28. The Cowboys were 6th in rushing attempts, 9th in rushing yards and 2nd in Rushing TDS, the cowboys threw the ball 556 times and ran its 531 times, how much more running does one need to do?

  29. How did that work for Jason Garrett, Mike? Name the last “power running” offense to win it all. It sounds like Jerry told him to use a 1990’s offense or else.

  30. ‘Being the head coach and playcaller,” so who was actually calling the plays? Him or Moore? Dogging your former coordinator publicly, nice move. Running the ball the majority of the time and scoring fewer points will not win you a championship anymore.

  31. Blaming the tired Defensive players on the offense for scoring too fast or not burning up more time on the clock by running is crap. If the offense was bad, had lots of turnovers, etc…. I would say he has a point. Sometimes the defense needs to make the stops to get off the field. I’m not impressed with a HC that can’t dictate to his OC or DC the philosophy the team will take.

  32. watsonisaperv says:
    March 2, 2023 at 8:03 am
    It took about a week to know that Mike’s whole “I deep self evaluation” thing was BS. This is still the same guy with 10 year old playing madden level game clock management. He said he doesn’t want the best offense….. okay Mike. I get a feeling Dallas would be running the wishbone if Mike could get his way.

    ____________________________________

    As exotic as Offenses have become these days, the wishbone might actually screw a defense up… Hahaha

  33. So the OC had so little respect for the HC he just went his own way for the last 3 seasons?

    BTW, Cowboys were 8th in rushing yards last season.

  34. It was bugging me, so I checked. The Cowboys were 7th top ranked team in rushing attempts & 9th in Yards per game last season. Would have thought it was much lower with his comments.

  35. Brandon in Northwest Suburbia says:
    March 2, 2023 at 8:53 am
    In 2010 – the year the Packers won their only Super Bowl of the last 27 years – their leading rusher was Brandon Jackson with 703 yards. No other rb had more than 281 (John Kuhn). They had just 13 rushes for 50 yards in their Super Bowl victory.

    The next season, they did lead the NFL in scoring had the best record in the league at 15-1. James Starks led the team with 556 yards rushing. In the playoffs, they suddenly got conservative. They outrushed the Giants 157 – 95 and won the time of possession battle…and lost by 17 points.

    I don’t know why McCarthy is stuck in 1978. He need only look at his own experiences with the Packers.

    322Rate This

    —————

    You just answered your own question. Kuhn was a very good all around FB. I wish the Pats had him in 2010 when Brady wanted to be in the shotgun 50 times a game to throw to Welker.

    The concept is balance. It’s not about how many yards you get or what someone’s fantasy ranking is.

    Also, there’s nothing wrong with 703 yards in a passing league for a lead back.

    In a particular game, particular situation, if you are predictable running the ball or can’t do it, you become one dimensional.

    It’s about concept not how talented your lead RB is. Kuhn caught passes, blocked and got an occasional hand off.

    And, if you have things other teams don’t have, 1978 or not, it’s an advantage.

    Not everything in life needs to be one way or another.

  36. In 2010 – the year the Packers won their only Super Bowl of the last 27 years –
    —–
    We are ignoring the 1997 SB win?

  37. In 2010 – the year the Packers won their only Super Bowl of the last 27 years – their leading rusher was Brandon Jackson with 703 yards. No other rb had more than 281 (John Kuhn). They had just 13 rushes for 50 yards in their Super Bowl victory.

    The next season, they did lead the NFL in scoring had the best record in the league at 15-1. James Starks led the team with 556 yards rushing. In the playoffs, they suddenly got conservative. They outrushed the Giants 157 – 95 and won the time of possession battle…and lost by 17 points.
    ============

    2010, week 1, Ryan Grant went down with a knee injury.

    The 3 previous seasons;

    2007 – 956 rushing yards, 1101 yards from scrimmage (7 starts)
    2008 – 1203 rushing yards, 1319 yards from scrimmage
    2009 – 1253 rushing yards, 1450 yards from scrimmage

    With Grant back in 2011, he and Starks combined for 1621 yards from scrimmage.

    The RB was a big part of McCarthys offense.

    And this was the absolute peak of their talent. Driver, Jennings, Nelson, Finley, Jones, Cobb, Grant, Kuhn, Starks.. there weren’t enough passes to go around.

  38. i’m having a hard time following Mike here. He is talking about lighting up the scoreboard like it’s a bad thing. isnt the entire point of football to score more points than the other team?? scoring a lot of points seems like a good way to accomplish that. And i’m not a coach i’m just a fan, but even I know your offense will be a lot
    more effective when you take what the defense gives you, not force feeding your running backs

  39. Name the last “power running” offense to win it all
    ==========

    Seattle should have won 2

  40. Does this mean that they will be drafting a fullback? Oh, the days of Moose Johnson.

  41. This seems very out of character for McCarthy, who I always admired and respected for the way he conducted himself professionally.

  42. If he wants more of a balanced approach, that’s fine. He doesn’t need to criticize Kellen Moore, he should have directed him to incorporate more runs into the game plan. He’s the HC, right? What he says goes, right? McCarthy must have given Moore a green light on the game plan each week, so who’s really the problem there?

  43. The modern NFL fan has been brainwashed by fantasy football that the only true measure of a good offense is if they can score 50 points a game by passing. The problem is those types of offenses are not all that successful for the very reason McCarthy states. Eventually your defense wears down and you have a track meet. Exciting for fans but likely to lose to an offense that is just as capable.
    McCarthy did have the ‘point-a-minute’ approach in Green Bay and that was a contributing factor to the team often failing to make the Super Bowl. The defense spent a lot of time on the field.

  44. This only validates that he’s not the head coach for all intents and purposes. If he had a fundamental difference of philosophy with his OC that means he wasn’t managing him. As I’ve stated before, if McCarthy was a valuable coaching asset in this league, he’d be somewhere else running the show. He’s in Dallas because it’s the best he can do!

  45. McCarthy did have the ‘point-a-minute’ approach in Green Bay and that was a contributing factor to the team often failing to make the Super Bowl. The defense spent a lot of time on the field.
    ==========

    2009-2011, the talent was obscene. 2011, they were the 2nd best offense ever. They’re still sitting at #4.

    I don’t think it was a mentality. I think it was circumstantial. Teams couldn’t cover the field. Especially before Finleys neck injury. And I cited Grants production. They could and did run it when they needed to.

    .. there aren’t enough hours in the day to cover what went wrong with that defense. McCarthy and Capers had no answers, clearly, and Ted Thompson wasted tons of Draft capital on guys that couldn’t play.

  46. And every D-coordinator smiled with that comment, Mike’s offense has always been a very obvious two runs, pass/run on third and punt. Rodger’s ability to adlib, forget the original play call is the only reason the GB offense did anything. Dak is nowhere near the talent of Aaron to cover what is very basic and easily defended play calling.

  47. Football outsiders destroyed this myth 5 years ago in their article “Defense and rest time” evaluation. Defenses don’t perform any better after their offenses have long drives vs short drives. It’s a big myth.

  48. Translation: If we don’t take the ball out of Dak’s hands, the opposing defense will.

  49. Mike McCarthy is going to be a great coach one day if they ever decide to determine the outcome of games by time of possession instead of points.

  50. Run or pass, to eat up the clock you just need to get first downs. Some QBs built a whole career dinking and dunking to score points and have success, including one with 7 rings.

  51. This only validates that he’s not the head coach for all intents and purposes. If he had a fundamental difference of philosophy with his OC that means he wasn’t managing him.
    ===========

    Moore was Jones’ guy. Could McCarthy manage him?!

    These are the problems you deal with when you don’t have a football man running the operation.

  52. Dallas already runs the ball more often than 2/3 of the league. The problem is that they try too many BIG plays and end up going 3 and out often. They need ball control, regardless of whether they are passing or running. Combine that with Dak throwing a averge of at least one interception a game, and it explains why Dalls gets bounced out of the playoffs early every year.
    Dallas has the second best turnover differential in the league. The problem is that they throw more interceptions than any other team in the league.
    The problem is Dak and the plays being called, which is McCarthy

  53. Kellen Moore wants to score! Not me! I just want to run the ball–who cares if it’s 3 runs and a punt. Run the damn ball! And nevermind if I’m telling the defense ahead of time what play I’m running! I’m running the damn ball!

  54. When they move on from Zeke, if they try to make Pollard the RB who rushes 20-25 times a game. It will be successful until he is carted off the field in game 5. And by next year that speed and burst he shows will be gone because he will be so beat up.

  55. 7-8 years ago when the Cowboys had a best in the league o-line I might have agreed with him. Most of those guys are retired or at the end of their careers though.

    Cowboys just aren’t built to run the ball that well at this moment in time. Either in line personnel or RBs. Elliott is washed up and Pollard has the injury bug.

    Switching to a run based offense would take a few years of drafting o-linemen at the top of the draft.

    Just wishing it to be so doesn’t work.

    MM is gone after this season

    What do I know though, I’m just some schmuck and not an NFL coach. Actually the fact that McCarthy doesn’t realize this is kinda frightening.

  56. Of course, you could just institute a training and conditioning program so that in crunch time of the 4th quarter or especially in overtime – your team is much better conditioned than your opponents are – and thus never especially winded.

    Built for 5 quarters of pro football instead of just barely a full 4 quarter game.

  57. Well, Kellen found the right spot with the Chargers and Herbert’s arm. Good luck, Mike.

  58. Wasn’t he the guy who was pass happy in GB? Maybe that’s because he had Rodgers. Now that he has Dak he knows he can’t pass as much.

    Still, it’s doubtful that the cowboys will be any better off with him calling plays.

  59. There is good basis for McCarthy’s focus on run-run controlling the clock but it can become predictable if not mixed with early down passes a good bit.

  60. Learning from others is a good way to get ahead in life!

    The Bucs for example: Arians wanted to light the score board up – exciting every game and Super Bowl…
    Bowles wants to run the ball – Boring, many loses, blown out in the playoffs!

  61. To understand Mike M you got to understand he is a he man kind of guy. He still thinks you pound the ball and show your opponent how much tougher you are then them. Its a mindset from old time football.
    The problem you waste the talents of great QB’s trying to prove you can mow the other team down, aka his modem in GB.
    He once said he loves O linemen with short arms because they can run block better. Short armed linemen arent valued due to lack of pass blocking abilities.
    Ya Dallas is in trouble because running teams lose by falling behind and cant make up the ground on the ground.

  62. If he didn’t have a QB who was losing games for them, he wouldn’t be saying this.

    As others have said, the Cowboys are one of the most frequent rushing teams in the league, and they have run the ball well.

    A QB and coach you can’t trust when the chips are down won’t be solved by this kind of diversion.

  63. McCarthy has been and implosion from day one and its not going to get much better with McCarthy still in the Big D.Three yards and a cloud of dust.

  64. Dak throws too many picks

    ” And if we’ve got to give up some production and take care of the ball a little better to get that, then that’s what we’ll do “

  65. $49 million a year for Dak to hand the ball off to a RB. The Cowboys have turned into a bunch of finger pointers and bad excuse makers.

  66. So in other words the Chargers will be good next year and the Cowboys will be bad.

  67. It’s a QB league. The rules favor the forward pass. Throw the ball, get out to a lead, play solid defense, then run out the click by running the damn ball down their throats. But that only happens if you have a dominant offensive line. So it sounds like Kellen Moire should be the head coach, and McCarthy the running backs coach. Or a high school coach.

  68. Passing attacks are more successful when the opponent respects the run. If the opponent knows y9ou can’t run effectively, they will be ball-hawking all game.

  69. McCarthy is exerting power gained by the last two years, however, there are many factors that indicate McCarthy made not be the source of the last two years of success. Quinn was hired by front office, McCarthy wanted to keep Nolan. The last two years saw a huge uptick in turnovers caused by the defense. No offense Coach Marinelli, but Quinn has been a huge upgrade.
    The drafting of Parsons, Diggs, the health of Lawrence and smart free agent additions on defense.
    This last year saw an offensive line that played well and had depth. Drafting Tyler Smith was a great move.
    This year Prescott was hurt..after he came back he threw the ball poorly possibly related to injury, yet Cowboys ran the ball well.
    Bottom line the changes by Quinn and some great pickups on defense especially Parsons has been the far more of a factor than McCarthy.
    McCarthy likes his “ guys” hence his dislike of Moore from the start. We will see.

  70. The Dallas offense was third best in the league at points scored.

    The Dallas defense was 5th best in the league at points allowed.

    The problem is that Dallas choked in the playoffs, as usual.

  71. I liked Kellen and hope he does well with the Chargers. I do think his offense needs to be a little tougher, they seemed to get pushed around. Less wine/cheese and more shots/beer.

  72. McCarthy, like Belechick, received undo praise by having a generational QB winning games. As a Cowboy hater it was great to see them hire McCarthy. And then after watching Dak run 14 yards and try and place the ball down himself I realized Dak is an unreliable playoff QB. Which is awesome if you don’t like the Cowboys. If I were a Cowboys fan, I would be wishing ol’ Jerrah would ride off into the Texan sunset and the team can actually make smart football decisions.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.