Things were heating up with Jets, but Derek Carr felt far more comfortable joining the Saints

Oakland Raiders v New York Jets
Getty Images

Maybe Derek Carr didn’t have a “slight lean” toward the Jets after all. Or maybe that was leaked to nudge the Saints to beignet or get off the bidet.

Regardless, a source with knowledge of the situation tells PFT that Carr signed with the Saints because Carr felt “far more comfortable” with the situation in New Orleans.

Things were heating up with the Jets, the source said, but the Saints had always been the most aggressive suitor for the former Raiders captain. The Saints were the first ones to pursue Carr, and they actually made a trade offer to the Raiders for his prior contract. The Saints were the only ones to do that.

It’s unclear whether the Jets would have committed to Carr without knowing whether Aaron Rodgers absolutely is in play. And it’s possible Carr wouldn’t have thrived under the white-hot glare of the New York media market. By the end of the first week, there’s a decent chance Carr will have blocked 90 percent of the reporters and columnists based in New York.

Regardless, the Jets have made it clear they’ll be adding a veteran quarterback. With Carr out of the mix, the primary options are Rodgers and Jimmy Garoppolo.

Carr will be the answer in New Orleans for at least two years. Whether he gets a third depends on the first two. The fourth, as explained here, likely won’t happen.

26 responses to “Things were heating up with Jets, but Derek Carr felt far more comfortable joining the Saints

  1. He made the right choice, because the Jets are a train wreck of an organization

  2. Smart choice by Carr – get out of the cutthroat AFC and into the weakest division in the NFL. Jets didn’t have a chance – do you think Carr really wanted to face the Dolphins, Bills, and Patriots 6 times a year?! Carr will be one of the top 3 or 4 QBs in the NFC and could win the division with a 9-8 record. The only better choice would have going to the Panthers (better Coach, better players) but it sounded like that wasn’t really a possibility.

  3. Saints will be pushing for a rule change to allow big fluffy pillows to be placed in the pocket so Carr will have a soft place to land when he curls up under the pass rush.

  4. I bet if he could have faced the Pat’s more than twice a year, he would have signed with the Jets.

  5. Jets lost out on Carr because they refuse to abandon Wilson. Would Garapollo behave differently? Wouldn’t Garapollo be looking for something better than a 1-2 year rental? I just can’t see Rodgers as a NYJ either, unless the Packers kick him out the door.

    Quickly, it seems like the Jets options are limited. Maybe they can trade for a tagged Lamar. Outside of that, it’s signing a bridge QB to compete with Wilson (Mayfield, Minshew, Bridgewater, Marriotta). Hope Wilson is worth it.

  6. Good for Derek Carr, I wish him well. Time to show everyone it wasn’t ‘just him’ as a Raider.

  7. casualfan says:
    March 6, 2023 at 5:58 pm
    Smart choice by Carr – get out of the cutthroat AFC and into the weakest division in the NFL. Jets didn’t have a chance – do you think Carr really wanted to face the Dolphins, Bills, and Patriots 6 times a year?! Carr will be one of the top 3 or 4 QBs in the NFC and could win the division with a 9-8 record. The only better choice would have going to the Panthers (better Coach, better players) but it sounded like that wasn’t really a possibility.
    _____________

    Carr doesn’t care about any of those things. Free agents don’t care about about how many games the team might win or being one of the best QBs in the division. They care about who gives them the most guaranteed money, period. None of that other stuff matters.

  8. Jets need to find a bridge QB and perhaps Winston could be that guy! It makes no sense trading for Rodgers who might play only one year like Brett. Winston is better than wilson and wont cost mutch at all. Other than drafting another QB in round 1, I would go cheap and let mike white and winston battle it out. Keep the number one pick and rebuild the line.

  9. I guess Im just not as high on the Jets as some seem to be. I dont think theyre as good as they think they are. Carr’s better of in New Orleans in a weak NFC division with obtainable expectations. Hed be on the hot seat in NY year one if they failed to make the playoffs.

  10. Cold weather and the brutal New York media Carr couldn’t handle. Now he can hang out in a weak division where 8 wins can grab you the division title.

  11. Carr doesn’t want to win. He doesnt want to be great. He knows he’s got tiny hands, is 0-9 in games below 39°. But if he wanted to win he’d go to the team with the best defense and gamble on himself. Weak.

  12. Who wouldn’t rather play on a dome team, out of the cold, in a very mediocre division.

  13. Lets see…

    Small hands…a 0-11 cold weather record (with small hands)…a thin-skinned entitled millennial…embedded in a ROUGH media environement…oh and oh yeah, the Bills…

    Yeah…New Orleans with its dome, warm weather and southern hospitality sound FAR better for a a medioCARR Qb like Derek…

    Smart move…

  14. They were never heating up. He wants to play for Allen again I’m sure he’s very comfortable in that situation the guy was his coach his rookie year.

  15. outlawdanman says:
    March 6, 2023 at 6:09 pm
    I bet if he could have faced the Pat’s more than twice a year, he would have signed with the Jets.

    ————————

    Facing the Pats defense is not attractive to any QB. They lose because they cant score, not because of their defense.

  16. Say and think what you may, there was 0 chance of Carr NOT going to the Saints, if the nfl schedule gods set the saints up for their toughest schedule Carr will only see 5 bad weather outdoor venues and what are the chances the saints play the eagles, commanders, giants,packers, and Seahawks, ALL on the road in december/January on the nfc side of scheduling. The Carr doesn’t do good in cold weather !!!

  17. As far as the weather goes, the Saints road schedule is pretty much cake. The only games that may be an issue weatherwise might be at Green Bay, New England and possibly Charlotte.

    So if Carr fails this season it certainly won’t be because of the weather (A combined 10 games against the NFC South and AFC South certainly won’t hurt.)

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.