Jonah Williams asks Bengals to trade him

Baltimore Ravens v Cincinnati Bengals
Getty Images

The Bengals plan to play the newly signed Orlando Brown at left tackle and that’s not sitting all that well with the player who has been manning the position.

Ian Rapoport of NFL Media reports that Jonah Williams has told the Bengals that he wants to be traded. Williams has started all 47 games he’s played for the Bengals over the last three seasons.

That run does not include the last two games the Bengals played in last season’s playoffs as a knee injury kept him out of the lineup. Williams had knee surgery in February to address that issue and is expected to be fully cleared at some point in the spring.

Williams is set to make $12.6 million in the fifth and final year of his rookie contract. We’ll find out in the near future if the Bengals or someone else will be paying that salary.

75 responses to “Jonah Williams asks Bengals to trade him

  1. Lol that’s pretty funny. Didn’t they spend a ton of money on the OL last year? What happened to la’el collins? Hard to fault Jonah for not wanting to move to RT I mean they just signed a guy who did the same thing he’s doing now. Good for him. Bengals gonna bengal.

  2. He hasn’t been horrible but he hasn’t exactly been great either, I’m surprised he is demanding a trade instead of trying to increase his value before he hits free agency, one year at RT would show versatility and that’s what a lot of teams are looking for in lineman now.

  3. Ahhh, the Bengals. I really have no idea what they’re thinking. Jonah Williams is going to be due big money after this year, and you can’t pay two tackles like that … while also paying two #1 receivers, while also paying what could be the richest contract in NFL history to your QB. This is going to be a quick rise and fall for that club, with no rings to show for it.

  4. This is about 0% surprising. Did the Bengals really think that Williams would be happy that they signed someone to take his spot and not be unhappy about it?

  5. This guy is always injured, and not very good when he’s not injured. Beggars shouldn’t be choosers.

  6. Williams is better than Brown…. They got Brown for cheap, but Brown is about to close up shop and call it a career. He got paid, not near what he thought he would, so he’s mad. Brown is a career whinebag and doesn’t have that strong, let me prove it to you, mentality.

  7. Jonah Williams became a turnstile once the middle of the O-line got fixed in 2022. He only appeared to be good because there was zero reason to attack him prior to that. He could salvage his career and hit free agency as a versatile tackle if he plays decent on the right side this year. Or maybe they told him he’s the left guard and he didn’t like that? Mike Brown doesn’t flinch and they probably aren’t going to find someone for $12M to do better so he’s stuck. It’s only one year, he’s gonna just have to gut it out.

  8. Jonah Williams’ overall PFF grade last year was 61.2. He allowed 12 sacks.
    Orlando Brown Jr’s overall PFF grade last year was 75.8. He allowed 4 sacks.

    The Bengals needed a better left tackle. I’m sorry Williams is upset but I’m not even sure they can get much for him in a trade.

  9. terrellpryorstattooartist says:
    March 17, 2023 at 10:48 am
    Lol that’s pretty funny. Didn’t they spend a ton of money on the OL last year? What happened to la’el collins?
    ________________________________________________________________________________

    Collins was pretty bad by most metrics and his contract was always really a 1 year deal with some fancy money added onto a 2nd year for cap purposes. Orlando Brown is the first player I’ve ever heard of demand and actually get a trade because he couldn’t play left tackle. That sounded ridiculous then and it sounds ridiculous now for Jonah Williams. Big difference is that Brown is a lot better and Williams has only one year left and no way he’d be tagged.

  10. Williams has always been so so and when playing at his best he was average. He was tied for the league lead in sacks allowed at 12 and if he thinks the team signing someone who allowed zero is disrespectful, the only person he has to blame is himself.
    ~~~~~~,
    terrellpryorstattooartist says:
    March 17, 2023 at 10:48 am
    Lol that’s pretty funny. Didn’t they spend a ton of money on the OL last year? What happened to la’el collins? Hard to fault Jonah for not wanting to move to RT I mean they just signed a guy who did the same thing he’s doing now. Good for him. Bengals gonna bengal.

    As for Collins the line was playing well until he was injured near the end of the year and will probably start on IR. The RG we signed ,Cappa, was great until he was rolled up on the last game of the season and missed the playoffs. Karras the center that was signed had a solid year and stabilized that position nicely. It’s astounding the opinions people can have with no knowledge of a situation.

  11. Bungles are a floundering, failing org. Once that Burrow contract hits they’re back to being perennial six game winners.

  12. Of course he’s upset. They signed a player, who isn’t an upgrade at LT, to replace him and then paid that player the money that was likely earmarked for him next year.

  13. he knows that the big bucks is at LT, just like Orlando Brown knew the same thing a few years ago with the Ravens.

  14. I’m no Bengals follower, but there must have been a reason why the team decided to sign another player to take his spot. Was he a turnstile?

  15. Trade him. He’s a middle-of-the-pack LT, coming off an injury. Have someone else pay the $13M. They already have an upgrade under contract for the future.

  16. I’ve always liked Jonah and wanted to believe injuries held him back from reaching his fullest potential.

    But…reality is, Jonah allowed a league high 13 sacks last year, had a 61.2 PFF grade, and the much maligned Jackson Carman played better at LT than he did.

    I would like to see what he could do at RT, but if we hadn’t picked up his 5th year option, we likely wouldn’t have re-signed him anyway. So if he wants out, give us a 7th and we can part ways.

  17. Bengals fan here. Not one fan that has watched this man play every single game he has ever played feels sad that he wants to leave. He was tied for the league lead in sacks allowed with 12 last year and was glaringly the worst lineman we had last year especially after about week 5 or 6 when Karras, Volson, Cappa, and Collins were playing a lot better. He was legitimately a saloon door. Slightest amount of resistance but if you give a little push he will just swing wide open! Or God forbid someone used a spin move, then he would just completely wiff and look confused like the DE just went invisible and he couldn’t figure out what happened. Great move by the Bengals and good luck to Williams. Who Dey

  18. His play last season was not first round talent. Towards the end of the season he was getting blown up all the time.

  19. And the Bengals requested that he block for the Quarterback and help open up the running game. I guess everyone wants something.

  20. haha, look at the haters crawling out of the woodwork now acting like they have a clue of the quality of Jonah’s play. (it’s not good btw). Sounds like Jonah’s a bit butthurt but so what, you should have played better Jonah. If you do leave I won’t miss the continual site of you standing over Joe Burrow while he’s again laying on his back with your blocking responsibility on top of him. You should have been the best lineman on the team, you weren’t even close.

  21. Irrelevant. He is gone after this year (maybe before if they draft D Jones). 2 SB’s in 4 years and then it will get dicey but they will compete for the Lombardi for the next decade.

    Package Mixon w Williams for a 3rd rounder and take a bad contract back.

  22. sadbengalsfan says:
    March 17, 2023 at 10:48 am
    He hasn’t been horrible but he hasn’t exactly been great either, I’m surprised he is demanding a trade instead of trying to increase his value before he hits free agency, one year at RT would show versatility and that’s what a lot of teams are looking for in lineman now.

    Right tackles make less money than left tackles. The very act of moving from the left to the right, will cost him money no matter how he plays. And it won’t show his “versatility“. It’s pretty much assumed that anyone who can play left tackle can play right tackle.

  23. Brown isn’t the best left tackle in the league but he’s definitely an upgrade over williams. Williams was awful and he was a terrible draft pick. Trade him for anything at this point that’s 12 million off the cap

  24. Slightest amount of resistance but if you give a little push he will just swing wide open! Or God forbid someone used a spin move, then he would just completely wiff and look confused like the DE just went invisible and he couldn’t figure out what happened.
    ——–
    Why do you think the Chiefs let OBJ walk? He’s a great LT if he can stand in one spot and hand check a DE. The minute you put a DE or OLB that has speed, quickness or a decent spin move OBJ is toast, the man literally has no footwork. Its like he stands in a bag of wet cement. The Chiefs constantly had to help OBJ out by putting an extra TE next to him and chip who ever was pass rushing OBJ. The Chiefs traded for Taylor because they saw that OBJ had reached his ceiling athletically and Taylor was far more athletic than OBJ. Good luck paying OBJ millions only to wish he had signed a 2 year contract instead of a 4 year one.

  25. For a first round pick the Bengals got 5th round talent. Clean out yer locker already dude. When you get out played by Carmen freaking Jackson it’s time to move on…and take your bloated salary with you.

  26. It’s unfortunate….even with sincere effort by the front office to spend money and find Joe Burrow consistent protection up front,college football just doesn’t produce Anthony Muñoz OTs anymore.

  27. amunoz78 says:
    March 17, 2023 at 11:02 am
    Clear $12M and add a third rounder? Sure.
    ———————————————-
    His 5th year is fully guaranteed. How do you just clear $12 million? The Bengals are on the hook for that money. New club could just pay him minimal salary.

  28. Once the middle of the line improved last year, Williams became exposed as the weak link. I always liked his potential, but it never materialized. In a league short on OL talent, let’s hope he’ll get a shot elsewhere if the Bengals can find someone else who thinks $12M is worthy of his skills. I’d take a 3rd/4th round pick for him at this point.

  29. Jonah is a turnstile and he had to protect Burrow’s blind side. He allowed a league high sacks last season. He’s always hurt. They replaced him with a better LT. Coming out of the draft, there were questions about him playing tackle because his arms aren’t long enough. He projected more as a guard. If they trade him, it’s because they don’t think he’s better than La’el Collins and, at this point, he hasn’t shown that he is. Get what you can get for him. The Bengals will be just fine without him.

  30. religionisforidiots says:
    March 17, 2023 at 11:10 am
    Bungles are a floundering, failing org. Once that Burrow contract hits they’re back to being perennial six game winners.

    ——-

    lol – how’s that Lamar signing going?

  31. darthhelmut says: Why do you think the Chiefs let OBJ walk? He’s a great LT if he can stand in one spot and hand check a DE. The minute you put a DE or OLB that has speed, quickness or a decent spin move OBJ is toast, the man literally has no footwork. Its like he stands in a bag of wet cement. The Chiefs constantly had to help OBJ out by putting an extra TE next to him and chip who ever was pass rushing OBJ. The Chiefs traded for Taylor because they saw that OBJ had reached his ceiling athletically and Taylor was far more athletic than OBJ. Good luck paying OBJ millions only to wish he had signed a 2 year contract instead of a 4 year one.

    __________________________________________________________________

    Williams gave up 12 sacks last year. Orlando Brown Jr. gave up 4.

  32. religionisforidiots says:
    March 17, 2023 at 11:10 am
    Bungles are a floundering, failing org. Once that Burrow contract hits they’re back to being perennial six game winners.

    Seriously, you should pay attention to what’s happening around you. In case you haven’t noticed, the Bengals haven’t made too many mistakes the past few years. They have their franchise QB in place, they have great #1 and #2 receivers, their GM and coach are solid, the pieces are coming together. They will soon have the same challenges the Chiefs currently have along with every other team whose QB1 is no longer on their rookie contract. That’s just the way the NFL is.
    Burrow’s window will remain wide open for as long as he’s healthy, same as Mahomes, Allen, Herbert, Lawrence and possibly a few more. Nothing against Hurts, he might be in this group too. However, he did have the benefit of having several star players around him and the best O-line in the league.

  33. springfield says:
    March 17, 2023 at 11:00 am
    Williams is better than Brown…. They got Brown for cheap, but Brown is about to close up shop and call it a career. He got paid, not near what he thought he would, so he’s mad. Brown is a career whinebag and doesn’t have that strong, let me prove it to you, mentality.
    —————————————
    Did you mean to comment another topic? Brown is about to call it a career?
    How old do you think this guy is ? He’s not going anywhere soon , your statement makes 0 sense . You know most of the guys in the NFL hold out for what they think they’re worth . He’s an above average LT and a great RT. Brown is 26 years old and was drafted in 2018. Tackles can play well into their 30s

  34. The bengals should absolutely trade him. He’s a young first round pick. They already have collins on the roster, and RT is easier to fill than left. Get a safety and a 5th rounder, and wish him well.

  35. BonnieReadsAndWrites says:
    March 17, 2023 at 11:03 am
    Jonah Williams’ overall PFF grade last year was 61.2. He allowed 12 sacks.
    Orlando Brown Jr’s overall PFF grade last year was 75.8. He allowed 4 sacks.

    The Bengals needed a better left tackle. I’m sorry Williams is upset but I’m not even sure they can get much for him in a trade.

    —————————————————————

    Why don’t you take a look at the number of pressures Brown allowed, only to be saved by the fact Mahomes is a magician in the pocket? Not to mention the Chiefs had to chip with a RB at least 50% of the time for him. He is a horrendous pass blocker. I mean absolutely terrible.

    Brown is not better than Williams. There’s a reason he only got 16 million a year and the world champions didn’t want him back. It’s a wash at best.

  36. Why do you think the Chiefs let OBJ walk? He’s a great LT if he can stand in one spot and hand check a DE. The minute you put a DE or OLB that has speed, quickness or a decent spin move OBJ is toast, the man literally has no footwork. Its like he stands in a bag of wet cement. The Chiefs constantly had to help OBJ out by putting an extra TE next to him and chip who ever was pass rushing OBJ. The Chiefs traded for Taylor because they saw that OBJ had reached his ceiling athletically and Taylor was far more athletic than OBJ. Good luck paying OBJ millions only to wish he had signed a 2 year contract instead of a 4 year one.

    _________________________________________

    Chiefs fans are hilarious. I’m not going to pretend that I know anything about Taylor because I don’t but Jonah Williams gave up 8 more sacks last year than OBJ and the fact that OBJ can at least “stand in one spot and handcheck a DE” is a dramatic improvement over Jonah Williams. It’s crazy that you guys win the super bowl and are still obsessed with the Bengals. Rent free baby

  37. If Jonah is traded then who is going to offer Joey a helping hand up when he’s lying on his back?

  38. The bar keeps raising and if you cant hit it then bye bye. You want volunteers not hostages. The Bengal haters are so bitter, better learn to deal with it guys. Looks like w the contract structures this team will keep its core longterm.

  39. The chiefs offered OBJ more than double what the Bengals got him for but now they “didnt want him” haha

  40. I had so much hope for Williams when we picked him, he had the resume and pedigree coming out of Bama and all the talking heads thought he would be our LT for a decade but he started off missing his entire rookie year and then came back and looked pretty good but he’s clearly regressed to the point that our former first round tackle was leading the league in sacks last year! Then his backup looked better than he did and he’s made that he has to play RT for one year and make 12 million??? As I mentioned earlier teams love a franchise LT but if you can’t be that they want versatile guys who can play anywhere on the line and if he was smart he would try to ball out at RT and hit free agency with some buzz.

  41. This is only slightly surprising. Bengals wanted to move him to RT in case Lael Collins (who tore his ACL on Christmas eve) isn’t ready to go at the start of the season. Jackson Carman can cover for Collins if needed. Jonah is a middle of the pack LT. He gave up a lot of sacks but didn’t allow a high amount of pressure, it’s just the pressure to sacks conversion rate against him was high. Myles Garrett will be sad to see him go but he’d be an upgrade for a number of teams. If he’s traded, his guaranteed salary goes with him and the Bengals would gain cap space. They may assume part of the cap hit to facilitate a trade and improve the pick they get in return.

  42. Williams gave up 12 sacks last year. Orlando Brown Jr. gave up 4.
    ——-
    Look who OBJ had playing next to him, Thuney and next to Thuney was Creed Humphrey. Maybe you missed the part where I said the Chiefs would put an extra TE to help out OBJ on obvious passing downs. Also McKinnon was maybe the best blocking RB in the NFL and they almost always put him on OBJ’s side to help out on passing plays and Mahomes is just plain hard to sack, he moves out if the pocket about 50% of pass plays.

  43. religionisforidiots says:
    March 17, 2023 at 11:10 am

    Bungles are a floundering, failing org. Once that Burrow contract hits they’re back to being perennial six game winners.

    ====

    So making to two straight AFCCGs and one Super Bowl, striking gold with a franchise QB and assembling a strong core of skill players is “floundering, failing”?

    You have absolutely no idea what you’re talking about and lose all credibility with nonsense comments like that.

  44. Sign a guy who is a RT pretending to be a left tackle to play LT, and anger the guy you drafted thats played LT foryou at a decent level. Makes a ton of sense. Brown should be a RT just becasue his daddy played LT doesnt give him some kinda god given right to be a AvG overpaid LT

  45. sadbengalsfan says:
    March 17, 2023 at 10:48 am
    He hasn’t been horrible but he hasn’t exactly been great either, I’m surprised he is demanding a trade instead of trying to increase his value before he hits free agency, one year at RT would show versatility and that’s what a lot of teams are looking for in lineman now.
    ————–
    That’s not true. Teams would always rather have a true left tackle than someone versatile and as an average or above average left tackle he would easily make more than as a great right tackle or as someone versatile(btw you should know that if your key attribute is your versatile it really just means you dont excel at any 1 thing)

  46. Can’t wait to see the Bengals struggle after they pay Burrow and Chase $80 million/year combined. 30% of their cap.

  47. Jonah’s performance at LT last season put Joe Burrow’s health at risk. He can’t stay at LT. Honor your contract and start somewhere else on the OL. He can go anywhere he wants after next season. He might pull a better comp pick than a trade pick right now. Mike Brown loves his comp picks.

  48. ghostoflondon says:
    March 17, 2023 at 10:49 am
    Ahhh, the Bengals. I really have no idea what they’re thinking. Jonah Williams is going to be due big money after this year, and you can’t pay two tackles like that … while also paying two #1 receivers, while also paying what could be the richest contract in NFL history to your QB. This is going to be a quick rise and fall for that club, with no rings to show for it.

    137263Rate This—————————————————————————————-

    You don’t have a clue what you’re talking about. There’s a reason the Bengals felt the need to go out and sign a LT giving him the largest signing bonus ever for the position. Jonah Williams is average on his best days, which are few and far between. If they can find a sucker willing to trade for Jonah and his $12.6 mil contract, they should consider themselves lucky. After this season, if he gets a big pay day, the GM who gives it to him will be making a huge mistake and should be working alongside Todd McShay at ESPN. Hopefully the Bengals can find someone as clueless as you to give them a draft pick to take that $12.6 mil contract off their hands.

  49. Orlando Brown Jr. was 22nd amongst 36 tackles in pressure rate. He might not have given up as many sacks, but the pressure was there. A lot of people state that Mahomes plays “street ball”, but look deeper and you’ll see that many times he was running from backside pressure. That in itself saved the sack totals for OBJ.
    OBJ did have a front row seat for Arden Key rolling up on Mahomes and almost taking him out of the postseason.

  50. These comments prove 2 things. 1- The Bengals really make other teams mad and they cannot wait for the fall. 2-no one ever watched Jonah Williams play football. He’s lucky if he starts anywhere at any position. Without looking it up I’m gonna say he’s played the equivalent of maybe 2.5 of his 4 years in the league. Not saying he’s a bum, but he’s not anywhere near a starting left tackle for a team with super bowl asperations. 3- people think versatility is a bad thing. If you are barely an NFL Left tackle (as he is), versatility is your key to a few more contracts.

  51. Funny how these (mostly) sour grape Chiefs fans think they know souch more than every single football expert out there. The Brown deal was a GREAT move by the Bengals.

  52. Just love these chiefs fans saying they let Brown walk. They tried like hell to re-sign him up until free agency started and he wasn’t feeling the long contract with little guaranteed money. Say what you want but if you were offering Taylor, a right tackle 80 million with 60 guaranteed you at least offered that to Brown and he balked. Now you’re butburt becaose he’s going to your Kryptonite and will be used to beat you…again. Plus he signed for less money to be with us too so that must hurt.

  53. TSP says:
    March 17, 2023 at 11:12 am
    Of course he’s upset. They signed a player, who isn’t an upgrade at LT, to replace him and then paid that player the money that was likely earmarked for him next year.
    ————————————————————————————————————————————————
    You either havn`t watched them play or you have ZERO idea what your watching.
    Brown is a 4 time Pro Bowler at age 26 and Williams allowed the most sacks in the NFL last season. It is a clear upgrade to anyone that knows anything about football.

  54. Jonah Williams demanded a trade. On his way to meet his agent the wind blew by him and sacked the guy standing next to him.

  55. Maybe Jonah should play better and not give up 12 sacks and 43 pressures. Wouldn’t have to bring in someone better at your job if you did yours Jonah.

  56. Trade him….for what? A bag of balls? This guy is lucky enough to still have a starting job in the league. Factor in he’s making 12.6 million dollars this year and….you’re not going anywhere pal. He should actually be in jail as being an accessory to assault. Defensive ends repeatedly beating him and planting burrow into the ground and he just sits there complicit.trade? More like… Lock him up!

  57. Apparently Chief fans don`t understand football as much as the media gives them credit for. Brown was 18th of 64 tackles in pass rush win rate while Jawan Taylor was 37th, Brown is also a much better run blocker. Brown got 16m a year and has been a Pro Bowl left tackle while Taylor got 20m a year and has never played left tackle but their criticizing the Bengals front office and not theirs? LOL

  58. I think they would put Brown at RT if they could but in order to get him signed they agreed to give him the LT spot. Jonah should suck it up and play for 12.5M next year just like Jessie Batea did last year. Williams has short arms and is a little above average when healthy. I give him credit for playing through injuries last year which is why his production was down. Go out and dominate at RT or play LG wherever you are needed and you can pull an Orlando Brown next year. I wouldn’t trade him because he will be healthy next year and much better, still only 25 yrs old.

  59. As a Chiefs fan I didn’t want to give Brown big money because I fear he is a guy that once paid will lose his desire to work. And my theory will be tested after the Bengals hand him the 31 million dollar check this weekend. Obviously I don’t know the man so I could be wrong but I really would have hesitated in giving him all the money up front. As far as football money goes he will be getting peanuts after the big bonus check. Not sure that will be incentive enough to make him work hard. Also, Patrick and Andy made him look better than he was. But Burrow is excellent at getting the ball out fast so who knows.

  60. His QB was used as a tackle dummy for defenses weekly. Brown is better at the position. Unhappy then retire

  61. Don’t understand most of the comments in this article unless it’s just jealousy. Brown is a clear upgrade over Williams

  62. Williams is probably in the 16-24 range of LT’s. He’d be an upgrade for a few teams. $12M isn’t outrageous for a LT. There are probably a few teams that might pony up a 6th or 7th round pick for him. The Bengals probably draft a 3rd or 4th round RT and see what happens.

  63. As a lifelong Chiefs fan, Bengals fans are going to be in a rude shock when they see Orlando Brown Junior attempt to protect Joe Burrow. Brown is a statue that needed help on nearly every passing down while his run blocking was subpar. He’s nearly 6’9 and really struggles against Bull and Speed rushers. Thuney had to help him out repeatedly, as did TE’s Blake Bell (when healthy), Noah Gray and even Travis Kelce from time to time.

    I get that Bengals fans are competitive with the Chiefs and hopefully, it’ll be a great rivalry for the next decade but the Chiefs could have easily matched that deal but chose instead to let him walk, which is extremely rare for young offensive tackle, let alone, Left Tackle, who’s now been let go by not one, but two good football teams.

    Keep that in mind when the Bengals lose a close game due to a sack given up by Brown at the worst possible time.

  64. ezpkns34 says:
    March 17, 2023 at 5:04 pm
    Don’t understand most of the comments in this article unless it’s just jealousy. Brown is a clear upgrade over Williams.
    ———-
    Better than bad still doesn’t equal good. Despite being drafted #1 overall in 2013, Eric Fisher was never anything special but Brown was a huge downgrade from Fisher.

  65. austinspencer says:
    March 17, 2023 at 12:46 pm
    Can’t wait to see the Bengals struggle after they pay Burrow and Chase $80 million/year combined. 30% of their cap.

    The Bengals situation will be no different than any other team with an elite QB and an elite receiver. Burrow will get paid and so will Chase, but so will several other QBs and receivers and whatever other elite players at all positions. The salary cap continues to increase so the one thing we know for sure is that contracts for all star players will be going up. The elite will always get paid. The challenge is to have enough quality players on rookie contracts and a few bargain free agent signings to boot.

  66. Williams was signed in 2019 and missed the whole season. In 2020 He played in 10 games but 2 of them he never finished due to injury. In 2021 he played 20 of 21 games In 2022 he played in 17 of 19 games (Buffalo was cancelled). Playoffs he played in 1 playoff game but was hurt and never finished. Missed the next 2 games. Last 3 years he started 47 games out of 56 games but got hurt in 3 games and never finished. So out of 72 games he played in 47. He never lived up to the hype out of college. If he doesn’t want to be a team player then get his ass out of Cincinnati. Pay me 12 million a year! Maybe if he was a good LT Bengals wouldn’t be looking elsewhere.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.