Kyle Shanahan: It’s going to be harder for Trey Lance to win starting job

San Francisco 49ers v Houston Texans
Getty Images

Trey Lance began last year as the 49ers starting quarterback.

But his time as QB1 didn’t last long, as he suffered a fractured ankle in just the second game of the season.

Because Brock Purdy‘s elbow injury will keep him from participating in the offseason program, Lance will have a chance to take major reps this spring — though head coach Kyle Shanahan said on Tuesday that Sam Darnold will also get first-team reps, too.

But with Purdy’s on-field success last year, Lance has just an outside shot at being San Francisco’s starting quarterback when the 2023 season begins. But that may change if Purdy isn’t healthy by the start of the year.

“I think it’s going to be harder for him to [win the starting QB job],” Shanahan said Wednesday at the league’s annual meeting. “Brock played eight games. Trey had that job going into last season and if he would’ve played eight games like that, no one else would’ve been able to come in and beat him out. But with Brock being hurt, it does open him up. It does give him a chance.

“I don’t know how Brock’s going to come back. I don’t know exactly when he’s going to come back. So, I don’t have an exact answer for that. But right now, because he is hurt, it’s nice to focus on Trey, it’s nice to focus on Sam and see how they do at OTAs and — most likely — see how they’re playing leading into training camp because I think it will take some time for Brock.”

The N0. 3 pick of the 2021 draft, Lance has appeared in eight games with four starts, which means Lance has played very little football since the 2019 season, in part due to the pandemic. But Shanahan said Lance is doing well in his rehab and has been throwing.

“He’s been traveling around, working with some quarterback coaches throwing the ball and I’m excited to get into Phase I [of the offseason program] and we can start working together,” Shanahan said.

The head coach added that Lance’s attitude toward San Francisco’s QB situations is as good as it can be.

“Trey is a great person but he’s also smart and he knows what he saw. He knows the level that Brock played at so he understands that,” Shanahan said. “I’ve talked to Trey the same way I’m talking to you guys now, so he gets it.

“Trey’s just excited to be healthy and excited to come in and get those reps and show what he can do.”

25 responses to “Kyle Shanahan: It’s going to be harder for Trey Lance to win starting job

  1. If San Fran had a time machine, would they still make that trade and select Trey Lance?

  2. Even when Trey was healthy he looked raw and did not throw with anticipation. Maybe the 49ers can make him a RB. He has miles to go before he is a good QB and Kyle understands that.

  3. Lance has played about 2 dozen games in his life, high school, college and pros but anyone who doesn’t think he’s ready to start in the NFL is a racist hater. The bitter invectives thrown at Joe Montana for pointing out the obvious was stunning. The current GM and HC combo has done a great job resurrecting the 49ers from the cellar but committing all that draft capital on Lance baffled most of the league

  4. I told anybody who’d listen Trey was not the answer on draft day.
    He was raw and inaccurate coming out of college and when you have a team built to win now, you don’t have time to develop and handcuff the other 53 remaining players l

  5. There haven’t been a lot of positive quotes about a guy they spent 3 first round picks to acquire from Shanahan. Seems odd, usually the coach and GM try to build up confidence in their chosen QB.

  6. patsfan4lifedynasty says:
    March 28, 2023 at 2:20 pm
    They should have drafted Mac Jones

    _____________________

    Why? Brock is better.

  7. Pretty sure trey will go to a team that doesn’t get a QB in this draft. The niners got darnold to cover while purdy gets healthy.

  8. The 49ers could not have handled this worse.
    He obviously needed more time than most first round quarterbacks because of his inexperience and lack of starts, but the team still drafted him highly, rushed him in before he was probably ready, got him injured, and now say it’s going to be hard for him to win the starting job.
    If you were intentionally trying to mess this up, it would be hard to surpass the mistakes the 49ers have done with Lance.
    A stupefying level of incompetence from an otherwise well run organization.

  9. Shanahan has a history of choking badly when the pressure is on. The trade up for Lance is yet another example.

  10. So why not trade him? His value isn’t going to increase if Purdy is the starter. Get something for him now while you can.

  11. Still stunned the 9ers gave up so much for a dude with virtually no track record. Wow. They bought him, they keep him. This has major mistake written all over it.

  12. Short of an injury to some other QB, it will be IMPOSSIBLE for Lance to start EVER.

  13. It sure looks like the 2021 QB draft was way overrated. Trevor Lawrence looks to be developing into a stud QB, but man the rest of them are basically questionable to just god awful.

    Justin Fields looks questionable but with potential upside, Mac Jones is borderline questionable/not good, Trey Lance is trending toward not good and Zack Wilson is just god awful.

    Just think how good the San Fran defense would be had they stayed at the 12th pick and drafted Micah Parsons, instead of trading 3 first round picks and a 3rd rounder for Trey Lance . . . they could have rode with Jimmy G for one year and then still drafted Brock Purdy as Mr. Irrelevant.

  14. 7 of the next 12 players drafted made the PB. Imagine they drafted Sewell, Micah, Chase, etc and kept them picks!

  15. Most of the comments always feature hindsight armchair GM’s taking shots at a team for doing x,y or z. Problem is that doesn’t take into account what the team was facing at the time they made the deal. The trade up was made because they couldn’t count on Garoppolo to stay healthy and wanted a young QB to groom for a year under Garoppolo with the intention of then extending their window long term. Hasn’t worked out with Lance so far due to injury but it doesn’t mean the plan was flawed. It just went a different direction when a 7th round pick a year later became that young QB they had hoped to extend the window with. Doesn’t really matter how it happens as long as it happens. If Lance is a competitor and comes in and plays lights out to try and win the job back, it’s even better for the team, but they believe they have a young long term option they can win with so to criticize them for how they did it is a colossal waste of time.

  16. jlbay says:
    March 28, 2023 at 3:35 pm
    It sure looks like the 2021 QB draft was way overrated. Trevor Lawrence looks to be developing into a stud QB, but man the rest of them are basically questionable to just god awful.

    Justin Fields looks questionable but with potential upside, Mac Jones is borderline questionable/not good, Trey Lance is trending toward not good and Zack Wilson is just god awful.

    Just think how good the San Fran defense would be had they stayed at the 12th pick and drafted Micah Parsons, instead of trading 3 first round picks and a 3rd rounder for Trey Lance . . . they could have rode with Jimmy G for one year and then still drafted Brock Purdy as Mr. Irrelevant.
    ———-
    Well hindsight is perfect isn’t it.

    In my opinion though, Lance’s story is incomplete so far. If he plays for a season and doesn’t do well, you can label it the way you want and close it.

    Of course, the whole thing is complicated with emergence (and injury) of Brock Purdy.

  17. “There haven’t been a lot of positive quotes about a guy they spent 3 first round picks to acquire from Shanahan. Seems odd, usually the coach and GM try to build up confidence in their chosen QB.”

    I don’t recall Shanahan ever sounding positive regarding a player. The guy is more cryptic than Bellichick.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.