Bruce Arians: Baker Mayfield was a better prospect than the QBs in the 2023 draft

NFL: MAR 20 Buccaneers Press Conference
Getty Images

Former Buccaneers head coach Bruce Arians remains involved with the team as the special advisor to General Manager Jason Licht, and Arians believes that the Bucs got themselves a very talented quarterback when they signed Baker Mayfield in free agency.

In fact, Arians said that Mayfield was a better prospect than Bryce Young, C.J. Stroud and Anthony Richardson, the three quarterbacks taken within the first four picks in the 2023 NFL draft.

“I can honestly say out of these four, I had Baker rated higher,” Arians said, via PewterReport.com. “That’s an honest opinion – coming out [of Oklahoma].”

Of course, highly rated prospects don’t always pan out, and through five NFL seasons Mayfield hasn’t played like a No. 1 overall pick. But Arians believes that had more to do with the environment Mayfield was drafted into than with Mayfield himself.

“He had a tough time playing hurt and things didn’t work in Cleveland. That happens to a lot of guys. Timmy Couch was no bust. Timmy Couch got broken the hell up in Cleveland. I coached him. Helluva player,” Arians said.

With Tom Brady retired, Mayfield and 2021 second-round pick Kyle Trask will compete to be the Buccaneers’ next starting quarterback. Arians said he likes Trask and, “I think this is going to be a nice battle.”

33 responses to “Bruce Arians: Baker Mayfield was a better prospect than the QBs in the 2023 draft

  1. Panther said the same thing last year, the year before that the same thing about Darnold and the year before that I think they said Bridgewater’s a QB with a pulse so sign him.

  2. Um,you just admitted out loud he’s still a prospect after several years in the NFL. That fact alone should have had you taking a draft prospect that can still get better.

  3. He’s had his ups and downs, but he earned his way to delivering that first Browns playoff win in 30 years and coming close to beating the Chiefs in the divisional round. Few to none of the QBs drafted this year – or any year – will take a team that far.

    The Browns are just an awfully-run team. Starting Mayfield off with that historically bad run of coaching, it’s a minor miracle he emerged from that to lead a playoff season. Then they just panicked and went crazy over a dubious QB, which of course now looks as ridiculous as it is.

    I don’t know if Mayfield will reach his old peak or not, but he’s shown talent and is on a solid team in a bad division, so it’s as good a situation as possible.

  4. From a football standpoint, this is an idiotic statement, because Mayfield is not a 1st round talent, let alone first overall. This is also very insulting for the 2023 class. The only explanation I see from Arians is a desperate attempt to prop up a QB from his organization. But again, we always expect some class, decency, and more importantly, intelligence from a former NFL HC.

  5. Couch was no bust, now that’s funny I don’t care who you are lol

  6. The first round QBs this year were taken way too high. Smells of desperation. Mayfield has been up and down.

  7. Arians Nation thinks a superbowl “entitles” him to spew out lame comments like that. The much traveled Baker Mayfield has had several years to prove he can cut it in this league, much more than other more talented QB’s. I’d take Trey Lance over this dude right now.

  8. Bruce Arians also loved Jameis Winston, so let’s be realistic about this man’s scouting ability.

  9. Thus guy not only craves attention, he once thought Jameis Winston wss good.

  10. “Baker Mayfield was a better prospect” and “Timmy Couch was no bust”.
    The fool is strong with this one.

  11. Tim Couch led the Browns to the playoffs in 2003. He was an excellent QB but he had poor weapons and an even worse offensive line. The dude was beat up as bad or worse than David Carr was with the Texans. Couch would have had a much better career if the Browns had gotten him better protection and skill players.

  12. To everybody saying Jameis Winston sucks, that’s unfair. I think he’s going to hold Derek Carr’s clipboard just fine. Better than most.

  13. Mayfield was very good until NFL defensive coordinators put together a book on him. Then he didn’t have the skills necessary to overcome the book. He was shut down. Really good QB’s can overcome defenses designed to offset their talents because they have many talents; Mayfield didn’t and doesn’t…

  14. kevpft says:
    May 5, 2023 at 12:00 pm
    He’s had his ups and downs, but he earned his way to delivering that first Browns playoff win in 30 years and coming close to beating the Chiefs in the divisional round. Few to none of the QBs drafted this year – or any year – will take a team that far.

    The Browns are just an awfully-run team. Starting Mayfield off with that historically bad run of coaching, it’s a minor miracle he emerged from that to lead a playoff season. Then they just panicked and went crazy over a dubious QB, which of course now looks as ridiculous as it is.

    I don’t know if Mayfield will reach his old peak or not, but he’s shown talent and is on a solid team in a bad division, so it’s as good a situation as possible.
    __________________________________________

    Blake Bortles, Tim Tebow and Mark Sanchez won playoff games too and like Baker Mayfield they were still busts. The Browns at that time had an elite offensive line, an elite Defense and weapons galore. All the tanking had paid off except they drafted a bust at QB. The Defense that forced 5 turnovers won the Browns only playoff game in 30 years. Mayfield has been the worst QB in the the last two seasons.

  15. All he’s telling us with this statement is that he doesn’t know how to evaluate QB prospects accurately

  16. I get all the hate people have for Mayfield but to be fair he played on a awful team in Cleveland and not only had to play against quality teams but also had to play against the terrible ownership that Cleveland is and will always be including to many divas
    I’m hoping that he has a good season for the Bucs

  17. Baker is not a top 50 QB prospect as of today. That’s more important than 4 years ago, right?

  18. wahoo21 says:
    May 5, 2023 at 2:16 pm
    I get all the hate people have for Mayfield but to be fair he played on a awful team in Cleveland and not only had to play against quality teams but also had to play against the terrible ownership that Cleveland is and will always be including to many divas
    I’m hoping that he has a good season for the Bucs
    __________________________________________

    Or he was an Awful QB and Diva who ruined an otherwise very good team. He had more talent around him than any QB in the league. Bryce Young will probably lead a weaker panthers team than Mayfield inherited to the playoffs.

  19. Arians setting up Bowles to fail again just like that comment about the roster being more talented than when they won the Super Bowl, which was obviously nonsense. I don’t think he’s being malicious because he’s now on the sidelines and wants to support the team, but he knows this isn’t true, and even if it was, Mayfeild has been in the league five years now, so it doesn’t matter. What purpose does the comment serve except lead to disappointment when a rookie and a second year QB outplays him in Carolina and Atlanta?

  20. Of course, highly rated prospects don’t always pan out, and through five NFL seasons Mayfield hasn’t played like a No. 1 overall pick. But Arians believes that had more to do with the environment Mayfield was drafted into than with Mayfield himself.
    =============================

    And 75% of the time the #1 reason is those QBs go to a bottom feeder that has few if any weapons and a poor OL and it’s a lot of the reason the QB bust rate for 1st round QBs is hovering right at 70%, then add to that these teams throw these kids to the wolves way too early. The NFL might be the “next level” but it’s about 4-5 levels above anything they’ve ever played in. The NFL only takes 250-260 college players and only 1/2 of them makes an NFL teams 53 man opening day roster so the NFL is the Creme De La Creme of the sport and most rookie QBs aren’t ready when they’re put into the game Day 1 or week 5-6.

  21. realfootballfan says:
    May 5, 2023 at 2:52 pm
    Arians setting up Bowles to fail
    ======================

    That has got to be one of the stupidest things I’ve ever heard about a sports team! Why would any GM or owner “set someone up to fail? It makes absolutely no sense since the GM just like the HC butt is on the line and he chances losing his job over the team failing also? This is the same thing I heard about Bidwell when he hired Wilks, why would an 85+YO owner set a HC up to fail when he knows he only has a few years left on the planet? It makes absolutely NO SENSE AT ALL THAT THEY WOULD JUST THROW THOSE YEARS AWAY JUST TO WATCH SOMEONE FAIL! If the owner/GM doesn’t like their HC that much they’d just fire them, not ruin the whole team just to get rid of the person.

  22. This is because the offense coordinator will be vastly better than leftwich, whom was there because of him. So his boy is toast and will look like a genius in his mind after next season now

  23. dales

    Maybe you can’t read or missed the part where I said I don’t think it’s malicious. Did you think the team last year was as talented as the Super Bowl team? He’s also not a GM or anything at this point. He’s just a fan. But what he said is utterly stupid, and I’m a huge Arians fan.

  24. People act like a QB exists in a vacuum. Baker played under four different HCs his first four years. Haslam is an awful owner, and the organization has no stability.

    Baker proved what he could do in 2020, and then the team kept him on the field with serious injuries in 2021 when they should’ve shut him down for the season by week 5. They then burned every bridge with him in the off season.

    Baker has a lot of issues, he’s not perfect by any means, but he was drafted by a team that had gone 1-31 and ended up helping them get to the playoffs – and actually win a game. The team then decided to spit in his face and open the vault for a sex offender.

    Baker hasn’t been a bust by any means. The Browns are an organization that drafts poorly (most of the time) and that is in constant flux due to bad ownership. The team was more responsible for Baker’s performance in Cleveland than he was.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.