Robert Saleh: Aaron Rodgers’ wish list is a “silly narrative”

USA TODAY Sports

Before Aaron Rodgers was officially traded from the Packers to the Jets, the quarterback had reportedly given New York a so-called wish list of players he’d like to have on the roster in 2023.

The Jets have added players Rodgers is familiar with like receiver Allen Lazard, receiver Randall Cobb, and offensive lineman Billy Turner.

On Friday, head coach Robert Saleh was asked about that wish list and whether there was a conversation about players Rodgers wanted to have with him on his new team. That gave Saleh an opportunity to push back and he took it.

“So, I can try to say this as respectfully as I can — I’m not attacking anyone. It’s just that I do think it’s a silly narrative, with regards to a ‘wish list,’” Saleh said in his press conference. “And I say that because there’s 32 teams in the NFL. And it’s common practice for when there’s changes, when you have a new coaching staff, when you have people coming in, that you surround those people with people they’re familiar with.

“I had a wish list — Solomon Thomas, Marcell Harris, D.J. Reed, Kwon Alexander — guys who I’ve worked with who were very familiar with our messaging, very familiar with our scheme, who can come in and play. We had it on offense with Laken Tomlinson, Tevin Coleman, and guys who have been in the system. Shoot, Tom Brady goes to Tampa and he gets [Rob] Gronkowski and Antonio Brown. So, it is very common for new faces to want old faces — to be able to come in and accelerate the installation of a program.”

Moreover, Saleh added, those players are familiar with new offensive coordinator Nathaniel Hackett — not just Rodgers.

“Everything’s being pinned on the quarterback — it’s not just him,” Saleh said. “Hackett has something to say about it. He loves Lazard, loves Randall, took Billy Turner with him to Denver and wanted him here in [New York]. So, of course you’re going to surround a coach with people who he feels will be able to plant the flag.

“So, that whole narrative of whatever people are trying to put on the quarterback, I think it’s tired.”

Somewhat tongue-in-cheek, Saleh was then asked if his team is planning to bring in tight end Marcedes Lewis. Saleh laughed and said, “You never know.”

But Saleh said that when it comes time to play, Rodgers’ familiarity with a certain player won’t override who gives the Jets the best chance to win.

“At the end of the day, the best 53 will be on the football team,” Saleh said. “And then the best 11 will be on the football field when it’s time to snap the ball. But at the same time, the reason why we’re excited to bring those guys is because they stand for everything we believe in. Look at Allen Lazard, he came in as an undrafted free agent and he’s got all this unbelievable ability to him and he’s made himself. Randall has such an amazing amount of experience. Billy Turner has so much experience. But they’re internally driven individuals who just want to win football games. And they love the game of football.

“And it’s like, well why wouldn’t you bring them in to help accelerate and plant the flag and echo the message that Nathaniel and his staff are trying to accomplish?”

We’ll see who’s on the roster and who ends up on the field in September.

74 responses to “Robert Saleh: Aaron Rodgers’ wish list is a “silly narrative”

  1. It’s not a wish list…..it’s just a coincidence they’ve signed all the players on the list

  2. Moreover, Saleh added, those players are familiar with new offensive coordinator Nathaniel Hackett
    __________

    But are any of them familiar with whoever will take over playcalling from Hackett midseason? Because that is a thing with him.

  3. If Rodgers is only there for 1-2 years, he wouldn’t be so pissy and fussy. He is a diva through and through with heavy dosage of passive-aggressiveness. But he’ll behave at the beginning.

  4. This is hardly unique to this situation. In the trades if someone leaves a general contractor and starts out on their own, they’re going to try to take people the work well with along with them. My brother is a teacher and they got a new Superintendent this year. Brought her whole staff with her. I’ve worked in tech startups my whole career. Someone leaves a larger tech farm to start their own, they’re poaching coders. Sales teams are the same way. People act like this is somehow a unique situation because they don’t like Rodgers and want to act like he’s the only one who has ever left a job and wanted to bring the old crew with him. He most definitely is not.

  5. I’d laugh so hard if the packers end up being better than the jets. It’ll be the 2023 version of Broncos & Seahawks.

  6. Rodgers thinks he’s Brady. It’s that simple, If it blows up, which it likely wwill, the Jets are 2-3 seasons+ back in the doghouse with nothing. Woody Johnson is older and is tired of himself being the problem, so he doubled down again like a moron does.

    Zach Wilson won’t be improving either. Look at his college tape. That’s what he is. A hero ball small QB who doesn’t understand the position and never played anyone good in college.

    LOL

  7. Packer fans who for years defended Rodgers as a great teammate/leader/person despite his antics and anecdotal evidence to the contrary are now trashing him after he forced his way out od green bay. Is anyone surprised?

  8. Yup, bring in all of those players so you can be one and done in the playoffs!

  9. So Randall Cobb is the best option? Alan Lazard is worth $60 million? Billy Turner, etc. etc.
    Keep talking Mr. Salah someday we might believe you.

    Good luck wrangling “The Cult”.

  10. Giants sign Isaiah Hodgins after the Bills cut him. Without him, the Giants do not make the playoffs. Complete difference maker with the injuries the Giants had at WR.
    Daboll is considered ‘smart’ for adding someone who he knew from his time in Buffalo. Total under the radar move that happens 50 times a season, if not more. Just really obvious in Hodgins case.

  11. So, yes, there’s a wish list and it’s a silly narrative because we all have a wish list? The reason it’s a narrative is because Aaron Rodgers GETS his wish list even though Randall Cobb is wayyyy past his prime,yet if you don’t treat him right, your star QB will pout and scheme until he gets his way. It happened in Green Bay and will happen in NY. THAT is why it is a narrative. Silly or otherwise.

  12. It’s not a wish list it’s a demand , I thought the NY press was suppose to tough ? you’d think
    he’d been asked by now why is he a 9-11 denier or the the best he’s a 9-11 doubter . Guess you gotta have some stones to ask real tough questions .

  13. The thought that the Jets could make the playoffs this season is a “silly narrative”. More likely trade will go down as a great fleecing of Gang Green.

  14. With all these GB guys coming over that means an equal amount of Jets will become former Jets who leave behind a lot of unhappy friends on the team this is not good for positive team building .

  15. His wish list is going to be “I wish I could get out of here,” soon enough.

  16. Saleh is right. I guarantee you the offensive coaches have more input than Rodgers, although they’re all on the same page. Brady didn’t have to explain to the Bucs’ coaches why Gronk might be a good fit if they wanted to hit the ground running.

  17. Pfft. The entirety of mainstream news from 2019 to now has been one big silly narrative.

  18. This guy is as unhinged as his mediocre coaching idol LOL!

  19. Unless the Jets best 53 doesn’t include Randall Cobb… then we’ll make an exception for Aaron and still keep Cobb on the roster

  20. Saleh might call the list a silly narrative, but he didn’t deny it. Already circling the wagons in Jersey.

  21. Robert Saleh being a good head coach is a “silly narrative”.

  22. itsunclepauley says:
    May 5, 2023 at 3:00 pm
    Imagine that, a reasonable explanation
    /////
    I can only assume you’re being sarcastic. Nobody is buying what he’s selling.

  23. What’s got me laughing is this narrative about how “all” these guys are coming to the Jets from Green Bay. Four players formerly from Green Bay have signed with the Jets. FOUR! That’s it! “All these guys” saying that make me laugh!!

  24. harryhodag says:
    May 5, 2023 at 3:20 pm

    Allan Lazard is worth $60 million?

    —————————————————————-

    Silly question as the Jets signed Lazard for substantially less than $60 million.

  25. When Rotoworld’s player news reported the Jets signed Randall Cobb, they sarcastically said “We’re monitoring the status of Donald Driver and James Jones.”

  26. Silly or not, I know the Jets would never have signed Cobb if Rodgers was not there.

  27. cheeseisfattening says:
    May 5, 2023 at 3:16 pm
    Packer fans who for years defended Rodgers as a great teammate/leader/person despite his antics and anecdotal evidence to the contrary are now trashing him after he forced his way out od green bay. Is anyone surprised?

    Might want to do some research. Never forced his way out. Murphy wanted him gone dah!

  28. Who cares and Tom did the same thing. Bottom line if the Jets win they will be happy with who ever is the roster and if they don’t, they will be unhappy. I’m hoping unhappy as I’m a Phins fan. No more off season let’s just play football all year long.

  29. Only dummies thought there was a literal list. We know those that Rodgers expressed interest in playing with, and the guys he has played with that he will talk up any chance he gets. From the Jets perspective if a player makes you team better is all that matters. Part of that absolutely can be if you have already seen they have a connection (on the field) with your starting QB. Cobb is literally the only one I doubt adds value, but that is 100% because of his injury issues. When he is on the field he contributes.

  30. packers76 says:
    May 5, 2023 at 3:26 pm
    It’s not a wish list it’s a demand , I thought the NY press was suppose to tough ? you’d think
    he’d been asked by now why is he a 9-11 denier or the the best he’s a 9-11 doubter . Guess you gotta have some stones to ask real tough questions.
    he
    ———————-
    Journalism is dying profession. These guys are told what to write. NY has 4 newspapers but now people in Alaska have access to 1000 newspapers. Plus it’s the Jets. Most people really don’t care.

    As far as is WTC beliefs…it will be said. We shall see if Fireman Ed is a Fireman first. I would hope so.

  31. Curious that Rodgers wants the same guys he couldn’t get it done with in Green Bay, but now thinks he can get it done with in New York.

  32. So , if I have got this correct , Peyton Manning thinks this move is great , but some idiots from Wisconsin , and some keyboard warriors and haters from elsewhere , about anything or anyone who is a bit “different”, have an opposing view.
    Who would you put your money on. Lolololool !

  33. Good luck Jets fan. Along with Rodgers you also inherited a bunch of tin foil hat packer trolls. They will be on every story. It’s like 20 more tb6 or whatever he is calling himself now.

  34. It’s just a silly narrative. Has anyone sorted the bags of M&M’s yet so we can get his requested bowls of green M&M’s for his locker?

  35. Players who weren’t good enough for Rodgers in Green Bay are now good enough to join him in New York? A little glimpse into the real Rodgers that Jets fans are getting. Wait til they start losing games.

  36. Funny, not too long ago Packers fans were crying about getting 2 first rd picks, Rodgers is a 4 time MVP, etc, etc.
    To Rodgers now sucks, he won’t do anything with the Jets blah blah
    It’s comical. At least they can still all watch the Bucks…..oh wait…
    forget that too.

  37. cheeseisfattening says:
    May 5, 2023 at 3:16 pm
    Packer fans who for years defended Rodgers as a great teammate/leader/person despite his antics and anecdotal evidence to the contrary are now trashing him after he forced his way out od green bay. Is anyone surprised?
    ________________________________________________

    This … coming from someone who in 2009, raced out and bought a purple Favre jersey that said THANKS TED on the back nameplate, only to have it relegated to toilet paper by 2011. Is anyone surprised?

  38. Juding by the comments, no one here read or understood what are very salient comments by Saleh. The snark and jet hating on here is tired.

  39. Bringing in the QB’s buddies is no way to build a winning football team. See: Green Bay, 2021 & 2022. Why the Jets’ management goes along with this is an exercise in ignorance and futility.

  40. gullyfoyleblog says:
    May 5, 2023 at 6:28 pm
    Juding by the comments, no one here read or understood what are very salient comments by Saleh. The snark and jet hating on here is tired.

    They are bitter , haters , who are genuinely worried.
    Pity their angst. Lollll.

  41. Funny, not too long ago Packers fans were crying about getting 2 first rd picks, Rodgers is a 4 time MVP, etc, etc.
    To Rodgers now sucks, he won’t do anything with the Jets blah blah
    It’s comical. At least they can still all watch the Bucks…..oh wait…
    forget that too.
    ====================================================================================
    Perfect.

  42. A lot of Packers want to follow AR to NY; nothing’s going on in GB.

  43. cheeseisfattening says:
    May 5, 2023 at 3:16 pm
    Packer fans who for years defended Rodgers as a great teammate/leader/person despite his antics and anecdotal evidence to the contrary are now trashing him after he forced his way out od green bay. Is anyone surprised?
    ////://://///
    Both things can be true and are true. There is no question Rodgers changed his tune after the Love pick. Come on, as usual, catch up.

  44. Yeah, right. There’s no way Haxckett was like “We really should go get Randall Cobb.”

  45. No Wish List ?? C’mon man,… you’ve signed 4 or 5 ex Packers. I laughed out loud when someone posted the New York Packers. HaHaHaHa,..
    GB still embraces Rodgers but don’t tell me he wasn’t behind these signings. I really don’t care,… but at least be truthful.

  46. Jets can’t keep their story straight. 10 days ago they said there was no wish list from Rodgers.

  47. It better be silly. You just mortgaged your franchise for a 40 year old QB who couldn’t best Detroit at home to make the playoffs in the abysmal NFC…. Won’t get part Burrow. Mahomes, or Allen

  48. Allen Lazard’s career was going nowhere fast when the Packers plucked him off a practice squad somewhere and gave him opportunities. Now the Jets are bringing the show to New York and he has signed a big-a$$ contract! Aaron Rodgers and Gutey made the difference ion his life. Hope he does well in New York with Aaron. He’s got to step up his game to live up to the big buck$. 2023 season will be entertaining to say the least.

  49. Alan Lazard has somehow turned himself, a blocking WR, into a $60,000,000 player. I don’t know how he’s done it. He was an average 3 in Green Bay. Congratulations to him I guess

  50. randalpnaditch says:
    May 6, 2023 at 10:16 am
    Alan Lazard has somehow turned himself, a blocking WR, into a $60,000,000 player. I don’t know how he’s done it. He was an average 3 in Green Bay. Congratulations to him I guess

    20Rate This

    ———————-

    Rodgers is doing what Brady did. If you kiss the primadonna’s butt and make him look good, you get into the Circle of Trust.

    The problem is the fontleroy will throw you under the bus if he needs to.

  51. The Jets thought being in new york they were bigtime they are to small time to handle that very complicated fella .

  52. You could see the fake smiles by Saleh at that introductory press conference he knows he is in for a long bad year. Same with that complicated fella all washed up new haircut we didn’t recognize him until he gave those fake smiles he’s a team cancer and now he’s your problem Jets no ours.

  53. dudeicle says:
    May 6, 2023 at 12:47 am
    Can’t wait to see the Pats beat them twice again this year
    ——————————————————
    Pats win both meetings last season. One game was by a whopping 5 points, in which Zach Wilson tossed 3 interceptions. The second game was by seven points. Zach Wilson passed for 77 yards. The Pats didn’t even get a go ahead score until less than a minute left in the game. I’m not a Jets fan, but I wouldn’t be over confident now that Wilson is not in the field to gift wrap you a game.

  54. Rodgers recent postseason record is also a silly narrative.
    ==========

    Has your QB won a game in 5 of 6 Playoff trips?

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.