Report: Colts are exploring whether Commanders tampered with Andrew Luck

Divisional Round - Indianapolis Colts v Kansas City Chiefs
Getty Images

The loop has now been completed.

On Saturday, ESPN published an article that mentioned in passing the Commanders inquired about Andrew Luck when searching for a potential starting quarterback in 2022. The article did not specify whether the Commanders asked the Colts, or whether the Commanders reached out to Luck or someone connected to him.

On Sunday night, we posted an item about the Luck nugget. Not long thereafter, Colts owner Jim Irsay tweeted a warning to anyone who has contacted Luck, saying it would be a “clear violation” of the league’s tampering rules.

Now, ESPN reports that the Colts are “seeking to learn more about what exactly transpired and whether any tampering occurred.”

This shouldn’t be very difficult to piece together. John Keim of ESPN.com wrote the article that mentioned the inquiry about Luck. He should know, or should be able to find out, whether the Commanders asked the Colts or Luck or someone tied to Luck.

The Colts should be able to figure out whether, in conversations that culminated in the trade that sent Carson Wentz to Washington, the Commanders asked about Luck. If Luck was never mentioned by the Commanders to the Colts, it’s more likely that tampering occurred.

It could be a simple situation of Irsay making assumptions before making inquiries. If, as it turns out, the Commanders directly approached the Colts about Luck and did not contact Luck or anyone close to him, there would be no tampering violation.

Time will tell whether Irsay’s allegation hits the mark, or whether he reacted to the item about the Commanders being interested in Luck without asking his football employees about it. And it could be the first example of a team trying to seize upon the precedent created by the league’s handling of the Jonathan Gannon tampering situation to leverage better draft position from a team that allegedly tampered.

60 responses to “Report: Colts are exploring whether Commanders tampered with Andrew Luck

  1. It’s absurd the Colts even have his “rights” 4 years after retiring and 2 years after his contract would have ended.

  2. Friggin Snyder, happy to see you go. 5 years from now absolutely no one will remmeber him. He will be able to dock his yatch anywhere and no fan will notice. OR HE WILL BE IN JAIL.

  3. When they heard about the Eagles getting a 3rd round pick as a settlement, why not poke around lol.

  4. nepobaby owner isray sure seems to have a strange obsession with Mr. Snyder. jealously due to the fact Mr. Snyder is a self-made billionaire no doubt.

  5. I STILL don’t understand how the Eagles had to swap their 3rd rounder PLUS GIVE UP next year’s 5th rounder to move from 94 to 66.

    Maybe Mr Florio you can find out please. To me even though the Cards “self reported”–which I highly doubt–it would seem to me that THEY would have to give up a draft pick or 2–NOT the Eagles.

  6. He’s been retired for 5 years, how is it tampering? There isn’t any statue of limitations? If the Vikings called Dan Marino and wanted to see if he could still fling it, they would be tampering w/ the Dolphins?

  7. Someone needs to explore how many teams the Colts have cheated without any punishments.

    Pumped in crowd noise with witnesses from multiple teams who corroborated it with no investigation done of any kind, Competition Committee cheating for years with Bill Polian, working with the commissioner to demand a framejob of Brady in 2015, while caught in a federal court doing so, etc.

  8. Andrew Luck retired nearly 5 years ago. Enforcing tampering rules on this is stupid.

  9. Wouldn’t it be funny if this ended up with the new owners backing out of the deal and Snyder ending up with the team?

  10. This is naked play for a free draft pick.

    I will believe its tampering when Irsay can show me where Andrew Luck’s name is on the roster. The man is retired and the Colts have his rights. IF Luck wanted to play to WFT, the Colts are entitled to negotiate compensation at that time. This is an attempt to strong-arm a pick out of WFT.

  11. Sounds like something the Commanders would do. I don’t think they are sneaky… I just think they are flat out STUPID. The sooner Snyder and company empty their offices the better. Good riddance.

  12. Tampering is stupid and should be negotiated out of existence in the next CBA. Employees are not slaves. And in any case, ol’ Neck Beard quit the sport.

  13. I think it’s laughable that the commanders would think Luck would come out of retirement for them.

    But, I don’t care what the colts think happened since they tanked their season anyway. They deserve nothing.

  14. Irsay has his 10 favorite Aerosmith-autographed guitars tackling the case.

  15. cbwv1974 says:
    May 8, 2023 at 11:51 am
    He’s been retired for 5 years, how is it tampering? There isn’t any statue of limitations? If the Vikings called Dan Marino and wanted to see if he could still fling it, they would be tampering w/ the Dolphins?
    ———–
    No, there’s absolutely no such thins as “statue of limitations” and the fact you don’t know it’s “statute of limitations” pretty much guarantees you dong know what your talking about. Besides that it’s not hard to hard understand, a player under contract can’t just step away and then be free of their contractual obligations. If their under contract then the contract tolls until they return(if they return).

  16. It’s amazing how many supposed football fans don’t understand how this is tampering. When he retired he still had contract time left. So the Colts still own his rights. And no that doesn’t expire because then that would present a loophole players could just retire and then come back when their contract is up if they didn’t like their team. So unless Andrew Luck comes back and plays out the remaining years on his contract he’s still controlled by the Colts as far as Football goes. For all the people in here that think they’re Geniuses they sure don’t understand a bunch of simple football rules

  17. “Quitter Andrew Luck”

    Moving on to ther things in live isn’t quitting.

  18. Um, this is NOT tampering Luck has been gone for years. How do the Colts still have his rights when hes not under contract?

  19. The Commanders hid Luck’s copy of Dune and didn’t give it back for over twenty minutes!

  20. It’s absurd the Colts even have his “rights” 4 years after retiring and 2 years after his contract would have ended.
    ——————————————————————————————————————–
    OK i`ve seen several of these dumb takes. I player has to actually play to get a accrued season towars his contract or pension. Otherwise you would have players with one year left on their contracts be able to just sit out and become a free agent the next season. That would be absurd.
    There is nothing absurd about having to actually fulfill a contract to get out of it. That`s what contracts are for.

  21. First Deflate-Gate and now this? The Colts deserve a wedgie and then shoved into a locker.

  22. “Moving on to Other things in live isn’t quitting.” That is exactly what it is. He was an NFL QB and decided to not be an NFL QB anymore. Dictionary definition of quit = leave (a place), usually permanently.

  23. Florio ought to enlighten us on how long a team can claim ownership of the rights to a “retired player”. Is it ad infinitum?

  24. Irsay robbed them with the wentz trade so he’s already received compensation.

  25. Players are drug tested and can be suspended or banned from the NFL. Someone needs to test known drug user Irsay and send him out the door hand in hand with Snyder.

  26. 12brichandfamous says:
    May 8, 2023 at 12:08 pm
    This is naked play for a free draft pick.

    I will believe its tampering when Irsay can show me where Andrew Luck’s name is on the roster. The man is retired and the Colts have his rights. IF Luck wanted to play to WFT, the Colts are entitled to negotiate compensation at that time. This is an attempt to strong-arm a pick out of WFT.

    00Rate This

    ——————

    Irsay has been controlling Sheriff Goebbels the beginning.

  27. I remember the time when Jon Gruden & the Buccaneers traded for Jake Plummer, who then retired. Whiteout ever setting foot in Tampa, the Bucs were able to recoup a portion of his signing bonus since he did not honor his contract.

  28. Dearest mother —
    As I said lo those many months past, I have long since suffered the cruelties of the battlefield for the last. Nevertheless, scallawags persist in questioning my resolve. While, the roar of the cannon and the rush of the fight do from time-to-time tempt, I remain resolute in my decision. Fear not, the farm is my final respite.
    — Andrew

  29. Why is this even a thing? If they were interested in Luck, wouldnt it be important to know if Luck was interested in a return to the field? If he was, then you discuss a trade. If he isnt, thats it, nothing else

  30. No, there’s absolutely no such thins as “statue of limitations” and the fact you don’t know it’s “statute of limitations” pretty much guarantees you dong know what your talking about. Besides that it’s not hard to hard understand, a player under contract can’t just step away and then be free of their contractual obligations. If their under contract then the contract tolls until they return(if they return).

    Don’t not dong*

  31. Irsay literally talked about Lamar Jackson, saying they would be interested him, all the while he signed his tender with the ravens….

  32. Hot mess of an organization is angry at hot mess of an organization.

    Clots vs Commies.

    Where’s the popcorn?

  33. Tampering rules for players/ coaches out of the league are horribly outdated.

  34. Isn’t it up to the NFL to “explore” this? Super Sleuth Jimmy is on the case! The great news is that anything to do with the Colts and by association Irsay has the potential to be worth a laugh or twelve!!

  35. Look – I get it! I’m a Washington fan! I want that Snyder and everything associated with him out of town yesterday, but this isn’t helping! Let the slimeball sell the team and not introduce anything else that makes him linger!

  36. cbwv1974 says:
    May 8, 2023 at 11:51 am
    He’s been retired for 5 years, how is it tampering? There isn’t any statute of limitations? If the Vikings called Dan Marino and wanted to see if he could still fling it, they would be tampering w/ the Dolphins?
    ——————————————————————-
    Like it or not, the Colts will continue to hold the rights to Andrew Luck until he meets his contractual obligation. Retire two years early and decide to come out of retirement at any time, then you are still under the remaining portion of the contract. Your example is junk. Agin, you don’t have to like it, or agree with it, but those are the contractual obligations.

  37. If the Commanders do something, anything, inevitably it will be a league rules infraction.

  38. I mean was this “hey Luck’s agent, does he ever think about coming back?” Or “hey Luck we’ll give you $100 million up front if you force a release”. Because one is tampering the other is little more than curiosity.

  39. First of all: this story came to light because John Keim from ESPN (and on the Commanders beat) reported it. It’s not like Jim Irsay sleuthed it out. He’s just reading the articles like anyone else.

    And second: Keim writes in the ESPN piece, as this is a direct quote: “Even so, they didn’t feel the same urgency they did last offseason, when they called every team that might have a quarterback available. They even phoned about retired Andrew Luck, just in case.”

    While the wording is somewhat ambiguous, it is entirely possible they called the Colts about Luck, not Luck directly. The first sentence says they called every TEAM in the league. The second sentence says, “They even phoned ABOUT Luck.”

    Stop acting like it’s been reported or that there is any evidence that has been presented that they reached out directly to Luck. It’s entirely possible they talked to Ballard and IRsay is simply trolling or clueless.

  40. Irsay is looking for a cheapy. He needs all the help he can get to get a competent qb.

  41. K says:
    May 8, 2023 at 2:44 pm
    Irsay literally talked about Lamar Jackson, saying they would be interested him, all the while he signed his tender with the ravens….
    +++++++++++++++++++++++++++
    Jackson was not under contract and able to speak to any team. Not tampering in the slightest.

  42. goodellthegrifter says:
    May 8, 2023 at 11:53 am
    Someone needs to explore how many teams the Colts have cheated without any punishments.

    Pumped in crowd noise with witnesses from multiple teams who corroborated it with no investigation done of any kind, Competition Committee cheating for years with Bill Polian, working with the commissioner to demand a framejob of Brady in 2015, while caught in a federal court doing so, etc.

    ————————————————

    Chalk up another complaint for the “long suffering” Pats fans. LOL

  43. Did the league ever finish investigating the Colts refusal to disclose Andrew Luck’s broken ribs and lacerated kidney?

  44. 12brichandfamous says:
    May 8, 2023 at 3:47 pm
    K says:
    May 8, 2023 at 2:44 pm
    Irsay literally talked about Lamar Jackson, saying they would be interested him, all the while he signed his tender with the ravens….
    +++++++++++++++++++++++++++
    Jackson was not under contract and able to speak to any team. Not tampering in the slightest.

    Except he was, on the franchise tag. He just signed an actual long term deal, he’s not a free agent. Why wasn’t he able to go to multiple teams for no draft pick compensation?

    He wasn’t free duh

  45. 12brichandfamous says:
    May 8, 2023 at 3:47 pm
    K says:
    May 8, 2023 at 2:44 pm
    Irsay literally talked about Lamar Jackson, saying they would be interested him, all the while he signed his tender with the ravens….
    +++++++++++++++++++++++++++
    Jackson was not under contract and able to speak to any team. Not tampering in the slightest.

    *****

    And if he was free, if you recall he represented himself, he wasn’t an agent

    From the NFL- Because he is not an NFLPA certified agent, teams are not permitted to speak with teams regarding Jackson or any other player. “To be clear, Mr. Jackson is not currently represented by an NFLPA certified agent,”

  46. Luck would like to play again, but no one wants him because the hair on his neck is too long. -Cam Newton

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.