NFL approves putting ball on 25-yard-line following fair catches on kickoffs

Super Bowl: Rams vs Bengals
Getty Images

The NFL delayed a vote on a proposed rule change involving fair catches on kickoffs Monday, but circled back to it on Tuesday and the change was approved by team owners.

As a result of the approval, the ball will be placed on the 25-yard-line if teams make a fair catch inside the 25-yard-line on kickoffs. That rule is in place at the college level and the stated reason for the proposed change was increasing player safety given the number of injuries that happen on kickoffs.

Special teams coordinators around the league had a different view of the impact of the rule change, however, and came out against it recently. In addition to seeing it as a possible step toward eliminating kickoffs entirely, there has been discussion that the rule change could encourage squib kicks and other attempts to force teams to field kickoffs and negate potential increases in safety in the process.

The rule change was approved for the 2023 season only, so the issue will be revisited next offseason after everyone sees how things play out before deciding about whether or not to make it permanent.

92 responses to “NFL approves putting ball on 25-yard-line following fair catches on kickoffs

  1. Terrible idea! There was a reward for a kicker who could kick a high ball landing between the 5-10 that might pin the other team deep, but now that is negated. May as well just start on the 25 and skip the kickoff altogether.

  2. The wussification of NFL football is almost complete. Once they eliminate tackling, the job will be complete.

  3. This is dumb… We will see nothing but squib kicks before the kickoff is eliminated entirely.

    Crap like this is why a start up league will eventually compete directly with the NFL.. look at what is happening to the PGA.

  4. Just another example of Corrupt Roger promising favors for votes. And then the teams that don`t give into his corruption get shafted like he did Cincinnati last year. I love football but have begun hating the NFL. I havn`t bought a ticket in 5 years now. Stopped buying merchandise 3 years ago and stopped buying the Sunday ticket last season. I still watch for free but i won`t put another dime in that crooks pocket. He is worse than any politician out there!

  5. What is wrong with people? Kickoffs are an exciting and integral part of the game. To treat it like it’s a punt is silly. No one–except the owners, apparently–wants to see fair catches on kickoffs. Little by little, piece by piece, the NFL “brain trust” is trying to kill the greatest game on earth. It started when they got rid of the most exciting thing in all of sports: sudden death overtime. And the erosion of the game’s excitement continues. It’s infuriating.

  6. So, they can wave to call a “fair” catch, in which nobody can touch them or impede then in any way, and for that they’re rewarded with 15-20 free extra yards?

    Obviously, the fair catch rule is necessary for players’ safety. But what exactly does this bring, except removing more of what defense still remains in the game?

  7. Why is the NFL so determined to make itself suck? Half the games are already borderline unwatchable due to horrible officiating, frequent stoppage of play and other factors.

  8. I think the bigger picture is that the NFL wants to do away with the kick off to get rid of special teams players off the roster. Soon it will be no kick offs and they will just place the ball on the 25. Then they will focus on punts. They want smaller rosters and less coaches and support staff so the money goes further. They are jealous of the NBA cost structure.

  9. Just eliminate kickoff’s all together then? What are we doing here…

  10. What I’ve always had difficulty understanding is why returners will field the ball in the end zone and try to return it. They rarely make it past the 25…

  11. Wow… Special teams coaches & players – the guys in the trenches – explained the unintended consequences that would result in voting for this rule, and the suits decided they knew better. As usual.

  12. So, does a kickoff into the end zone still come out to the 20 or can a returner call for a fair catch in the end zone and get it out to the 25? No more just letting it bounce in the end zone and waiving ones arms?
    I guess the phrase “leave well enough alone” is not in the NFL vernacular.

  13. Why would you squib kick and potentially put the other team at the 30 or 40? Squibs could go out of bounds too. I’d rather do the standard kickoff and drop it at the 9 yard line and see if the returner dares to give it a go.

  14. I promise this isn’t the end of the world. They have done this in college for some time and people still love the game. If a returner catches the ball and wants to return it they still can. I don’t understand the backlash except for a desire to bash the league for some reason

  15. They’re so concerned about player safety, yet they continue to schedule Thursday night games giving players insufficient recovery time after a Sunday game. So basically they’re only concerned about player safety as long as it doesn’t hurt their bottom line.

  16. “The stated reason for the proposed change was increasing player safety given the number of injuries that happen on kickoffs.”

    Where are these statistics? Surely if they exist, they can be shared with us?

  17. Why not just do away with human football players entirely? Use AI players in a Madden Football type virtual environment and you’ll never have to worry about injuries again.

  18. So if they don’t signal a fair catch then its business as usual. The optics of that one guy getting seal sharked by someone who missed the fair catch signal will probs make this a one and done rule.

  19. Keep it up NFL keep pissing off the customers. Gonna get too big for your britches.

  20. So, end of game, receiving team needs a FG to tie or win. This assures that team needing, on average, 35 yards to get into FG range. Or basically 2-3 plays. Taking the 25 would be the smart play for most teams. This will increase the odds of made for TV drama to close out games, which is undoubtedly the primary consideration behind the change.

  21. I’m fine with this. Just hold my finger on the fast forward button a little longer after having glided through the preceding commercial break.

  22. Just another step along the way to eliminating the most exciting play in football, the kickoff return for a TD.

  23. Every year the NFL pushes the envelope of their stupidity. There just doesn’t seem to a floor of how far down they’ll go.

    Flexing Thursdays and now this. That’s two idiotic decisions in two days. What will they do by tomorrow?

  24. By 2030, there will be no more kickoffs. The suits are ruining this sport.

  25. So the kicker has no incentives to try to pin them deep in their territory if it gets fielded on the 1 yard line?

  26. NFL is already been deemed a waste of time, even before this rule when the league won the AFC title and Super Bowl for the Chiefs only a couple years after winning the “Super” Bowl for the Chiefs the first time around.

  27. The root cause for this is the NFLPA and former players suing the NFL due to injuries suffered while playing. The players claimed that the NFL failed to educate players about the risk of injury (players can barely read, understand logic, and/or talk) and ‘didn’t do enough’ to protect players from the very risks for which those same players earn generational wealth. These idiotic rules changes will not stop until players agree to an ironclad waiver of liability which protects the NFL from liability for injuries.

  28. “Hey lets see how much we can ruin football and still have people watch it” – Roger Goodell probably

  29. Kickoffs have not been exciting for many many years thanks to 95% of kickoffs ending in a touchback and 99% of returns being negated by a penalty!

  30. I would like to be the first person to congratulate players like Billy ‘Whiteshoes’ Johnson, Devin Hester, Dante Hall, Josh Cribbs, etc., that your contributions to the NFL are no longer needed, therefore, your career did not exist.

  31. A few years ago, the Ravens proposed that having the ball go through the uprights on a kickoff be worth one point to the kicking team. I hated the idea then, but now it may be the only way to have excitement on the kickoff.

  32. To hell with this.

    I have my season tickets listed for sale.

    Definitely fed up with Goodell destroying my favorite professional sports league.

  33. You know that 20 – 30 years ago, we’d used to make jokes about this kind of stuff and laugh…

  34. therealraider says:
    Crap like this is why a start up league will eventually compete directly with the NFL.. look at what is happening to the PGA.
    ==

    The AFL was the last start-up league that had any real success going against the NFL, and that was in the 1960s when the NFL was much smaller and had only one TV network, allowing the AFL to secure its own broadcast deal.
    While the AFL was briefly successful at competing for top players, it didn’t have the resources to sustain a head-to-head completion and eventually had to merge with the established NFL.
    The original USFL was even more aggressive going after top talent, but it too lacked the financial resources to sustain a long-term bidding war for talent. Its TV contract netted only a fraction of what the NFL was making on three networks, and once it moved to the fall and challenged the NFL head-to-head it crumbled quickly.
    In this century, no start-up league will ever have the capital or resources to compete directly with the NFL and its billionaire owners.
    More to the point, where do you think the NFL is getting the ideas for these idiotic rules changes? They’re stealing them from start-ups like the XFL and the USFL.
    Money aside, in this era of safety concerns and lawsuits the idea that some start-up league can or will restore pro football to the rules and style of play it once embodied — let alone compete succesfully against the NFL — is wishful thinking at best.

  35. Changing rules 2 weeks after the schedule release is a Richard-type move there, Goodell

  36. I don’t like it personally, nor most of the rules changes over the past 15 years or so; but many of them are necessary for football to continue because of lawsuits, being able to have kids continuing to play football, etc. However, at some point, and we are very close to that now, if not already there; it will cease to be football. It may be an enjoyable sport to watch and/or play, but it won’t be the game we all know. Unfortunately, it is the evolution of the sport, and we also see it affecting basketball with all the 3 pointers, etc, and baseball with the launch angles and the HR, walk, or strikeout emphasis.

  37. Funny comments about Goodell on this. People act like he is a dictator doing anything he wants with the NFL. He is simply the commissioner doing the bidding of the NFL owners! If they do not like what he is doing they would fire him. If he does not like proposals he submits (which come from committees) they would vote them down. If they do not like his punishment (based on rules established) they would fire him. Any ire towards anything done should be all towards the owners at they are in control.

  38. I’m sure this makes the game slightly safer. But this makes the whole play a waste of everyone’s time.

  39. If you call for a fair catch at the 30 you lose 5 yards? Fair catches should not happen on a kickoff.

  40. You people DO KNOW the rule has been in the college ranks, right?

    None of them squib kicks it and college football is popular as ever. NO ONE screams college sports “is ruined” like you whiners.

    You people are just embarrassing.

  41. Spot both teams 14 points and start the game at what would be the 4th quarter. That would eliminate 3 quarters worth of injury risk.

  42. Another poster wondered what stupid thing will they do by tomorrow?

    Decide that a square ball would make the game more exciting for fans.

  43. Fair catch on a kickoff? How often does that happen? This isn’t on punts.

  44. Kickers will adjust by kicking line drives that hit fast and continue towards the end zone, forcing the receiver to field it and get crushed by the defense.

    they have forgotten that the fair catch was put into place to ends injuries

  45. johnc44 says:
    May 23, 2023 at 11:59 am
    I still watch for free but i won`t put another dime in that crooks pocket. He is worse than any politician out there!
    __________________

    You are not watching for free, you are still paying your cable bill every month. There is no such thing as watching for free unless you are watching a pirated signal and even then you are still paying for the internet connection.

  46. “Trust us, we know what we’re doing.” — League with a 17 game regular season that encourages gambling but suspends players for it, thereby impacting the odds of the gambling it wanted in the first place

  47. Chickenbiscuit said: “They have done this in college for some time and people still love the game. If a returner catches the ball and wants to return it they still can.”

    I have to agree; for the same reason that returners now catch a ball 8 yards deep and return it (they all have the confidence to believe they will break a long one, or at least get out past the 25), very rarely will a player call a fair catch on a kickoff. I think everybody’s going berserk over nothing.

  48. League’s gone the wrong way here, need the XFL to bail us out. Kicking team has 11 players on the field.. plus the kicker.. and receiving team has no blockers and MUST return the ball past the 50. Who’s comin with me!?

  49. If I’m a coach and go to great lengths to find a very good kick-returner and he fair catches the ball at the 5-yardline I seriously doubt he will be returning kicks in the next game.

  50. They should just make both teams hop around the field in potato sacks, this will add to safety as well. The most common injury would be burlap burn…

  51. The NFL is an absolute joke. “We care very deeply about player safety. BTW, let’s use the Damar Hamlin situation to try to push neutral site conference championship games so we can make more money.”

  52. v2787 says:
    May 23, 2023 at 11:59 am
    What is wrong with people? Kickoffs are an exciting and integral part of the game. To treat it like it’s a punt is silly.
    _________________

    Nothing is wrong with enhancing player safety. Something is wrong with people who enjoy watching players get injured more than athletic competition of the game.

  53. lovef111 says:
    May 23, 2023 at 12:03 pm
    Why is the NFL so determined to make itself suck?

    Lol This!

  54. Well, if the fans give the NFL an inch, they will or eventually will want to take a mile. We just had the anti game going fan Thursday game flexing nonsense and now the NFL Ok’d this crap in the name of “player safety”. Player safetymy @ss. If the NFL really actually cared about player safety, they would make the players wear those oversized dorky helmet covers and eliminate tackling completely so nobody gets a boo boo from playing professional tackle football for millions. Just waiting for the day when the NFL just switches to two hand touch or flag football similar to the garbage probowl or let’s get real stupid, let’s just remove the players from the equation entirely. Let’s just replace the NFL football that we know and love with Madden footballvwith VR, as in, the NFL just shows Madden season gameplay on tv each week. The fans better start speaking up or this is going to get ugly.

  55. Is anyone speaking any sense in these meetings or is everyone yes men? These decisions are getting worse and worse yearly. Someone tell them they don’t have to change rules every year like they think they do…. Cuban is looking like a genius for his foresight of the ditch the NFL is driving towards.

  56. Terrible, terrible rule change. It’s going to make the game more boring and wipe out a key strategic aspect of the game.

    It would be one thing if I really believed this would have any effect on player safety. They won’t spend a little money to make the field surface better, but they’ll make the game more boring.

    Every possession change now becomes one more 5-minute stretch to ignore.

  57. allinforallen says:
    May 23, 2023 at 12:12 pm
    So, does a kickoff into the end zone still come out to the 20 or can a returner call for a fair catch in the end zone and get it out to the 25? No more just letting it bounce in the end zone and waiving ones arms?
    I guess the phrase “leave well enough alone” is not in the NFL vernacular.

    ————-
    A kickoff going into the end zone already comes out to the 25. It has for a few seasons now.

  58. I try to imagine watching for the first time and seeing something that makes no sense and trying to justify what I’ve just seen. This is one of those random, fish out of water rules that is just too stupid to explain to a casual fan.

  59. chickenbiscuit says:
    May 23, 2023 at 12:16 pm

    I promise this isn’t the end of the world. They have done this in college for some time and people still love the game. If a returner catches the ball and wants to return it they still can. I don’t understand the backlash except for a desire to bash the league for some reason

    ===

    College is different. Despite the avalanche of money pouring into it, it’s still amateur sport played by students, so there should be more restrictions. This is pro sports, which pays its players millions and has no reason to exist apart from providing excitement and competitive entertainment. Too many guard rails, and you’ve removed everything that provides drama and thus its entire purpose.

  60. Nfl is stupid, well this takes the purpose of the kick off, whats next they have get rid of kickoffs and just start at the 50 yard line.

  61. What will the game be called when nobody’s foot is ever allowed to kick a ball again? I know soccer fans in other countries that ALREADY think calling it “football” ludicrous.

  62. Bring out the flags, no reason for tackling in the NoFunLeague anymore.

    Might as well just eliminate kickoffs at this point, I imagine punts will be next.

  63. I got even a better idea. Let’s have it where whoever wins the coin toss wins the game. Then we would we totally cut down on players injuries. Let’s not forget that you will save a lot of money on beer watching the “game” at home, not having to watch minutes upon minutes of those commercials. The prices of those games and parking would go way down, too. Seriously, the NFL just won’t stop ruining the game. Where I used to watch football non-stop all day Sunday when there was an actual GAME being played, I hardly watch anymore.

  64. The punting team surrenders the ball, aside from an error in fair catching by the receiving team. A kickoff is anybody’s ball after 10 yards. So, what is the justification for fair catch privilege for one team? Note I did not imply receiving team.

  65. just start the drive after touchdowns on the 25 yard line ….no need to kick off NFL is a joke …….shame on them (owners) for ruining a great game

  66. I think this is stupid, as it really decreases the value of both a good kicker, and also Kick Returns.

    That being said, I also don’t think that the solution is going to be “Squib” kicks by Kickers.
    A squib kick is going to get to the returner MUCH faster, and therefor the coverage team will have WAY less time to get downfield to cover. The result will be a BETTER return than the 25 in most cases.

    I suspect this will end up CAUSING more injuries. Dumb move.

  67. warpumpkin115 says:
    May 23, 2023 at 2:15 pm
    Well, if the fans give the NFL an inch, they will or eventually will want to take a mile. We just had the anti game going fan Thursday game flexing nonsense and now the NFL Ok’d this crap in the name of “player safety”. Player safetymy @ss. If the NFL really actually cared about player safety, they would make the players wear those oversized dorky helmet covers and eliminate tackling completely so nobody gets a boo boo from playing professional tackle football for millions.
    _____________

    I don’t think that anyone who talks about boo boos and dorky helmet covers really cares about player safety. When you talk about players making millions it sounds a lot like you believe those salaries entitle you to enjoy the players getting hurt.

  68. The game is inherently dangerous the moment a player suits up and goes out on the field of play.

    For those posters that never played the game (from high school on up), you do not have a clue.

  69. This is a horrible idea. The kicking teams practice and take pride in being able to down a kickoff near the goal line. Now a great kickoff by the kicker means nothing if the opposing team can catch it.

  70. Automatically starting at the 25 yard line is SO boring…..especially since they keep changing the rules so the offense can score more and necessitate more kickoffs. Oh wait, I guess they’ll eliminate the kickoff entirely and just place the ball at the 25 yard line. But no, they won’t do that either. Know why? Because it will elminate a TV commercial/timeout. Instead of before and after the kickoff, there will only be the “in place” of the kickoff.

  71. I dont get why Goodell hates Kickoff returns, but whats even the point of kicking it off? Just start at the 25. (Or actually move back to the 20)

  72. chickenbiscuit says:
    May 23, 2023 at 12:16 pm
    I promise this isn’t the end of the world. They have done this in college for some time and people still love the game. If a returner catches the ball and wants to return it they still can. I don’t understand the backlash except for a desire to bash the league for some reason

    The answer is simple…..people that hate change love complaining.

  73. I’m so tired of hearing about for ‘player safety’ but this is the same league that allows 2, 3, 4 players to hold up the person with the ball so someone can then come in and forcibly try to strip. Yeah, player safety! Let’s get back to old school football.

  74. Cue all the creepy Goodell fanboys claiming Goodell has done a good job growing the league and improving the quality of the product.

    LOL

    Imagine being so easily duped as an adult. My goodness.

  75. kevpft says:
    May 23, 2023 at 2:27 pm
    Terrible, terrible rule change. It’s going to make the game more boring and wipe out a key strategic aspect of the game.

    It would be one thing if I really believed this would have any effect on player safety. They won’t spend a little money to make the field surface better, but they’ll make the game more boring.

    Every possession change now becomes one more 5-minute stretch to ignore.

    ——————-

    The worst is it’s all a guise to try to show the public this is about “player safety”. Goodell is a disgrace as one of the country’s greatest frauds.

  76. Between touchbacks on kickoffs, fair catches on punts, and deadly accurate (even from 50+ yards) field goal kickers, there is very little excitement in the kicking game anymore.

  77. Next step, putting flag belts on the OBs, TEs and WRs. Any contact with the Wide Outs will be a penalty. smh…

  78. dryzzt23 says:
    May 23, 2023 at 12:56 pm
    The root cause for this is the NFLPA and former players suing the NFL due to injuries suffered while playing. The players claimed that the NFL failed to educate players about the risk of injury (players can barely read, understand logic, and/or talk) and ‘didn’t do enough’ to protect players from the very risks for which those same players earn generational wealth. These idiotic rules changes will not stop until players agree to an ironclad waiver of liability which protects the NFL from liability for injuries.
    ————————————-

    I would suggest that anyone who doesn’t care about player safety is a soulless monster. I love football, but these safety measures aren’t just about the NFL, the sport is struggling with player safety at all levels. We can’t have a blood-lust top level of the sport and expect parents to start their kids down that path at a young age.

    Things change – and your bitterness over player salaries is pointless and stupid. The athletes who play the game deserve to earn whatever the NFL marketplace will pay them. If you don’t care about player safety because of what they’re paid, then there’s something wrong with you.

  79. whateverworks77 says:
    May 23, 2023 at 1:08 pm
    I would like to be the first person to congratulate players like Billy ‘Whiteshoes’ Johnson, Devin Hester, Dante Hall, Josh Cribbs, etc., that your contributions to the NFL are no longer needed, therefore, your career did not exist.

    ————————
    Matthew Slater retired at just the right time too. He was about to be rendered extraneous.

  80. I would suggest that anyone who doesn’t care about player safety is a soulless monster. I love football, but these safety measures aren’t just about the NFL, the sport is struggling with player safety at all levels. We can’t have a blood-lust top level of the sport and expect parents to start their kids down that path at a young age.
    ============

    Do active players care? Sure they care after the fact, realizing their bodies have been destroyed. Realizing they’ll need specialized medical care the rest of their life.

    Look at the disciplinary system. ALL fines and suspensions are reduced. All of them. Who oversees that disciplinary system? Former gladiators.

    Why do players put up with cheapshot artists like Vontez Burfict and Thomas Davis? Donkey Kong Suh committing multiple assaults on the field.

    Why haven’t the players fought harder against helmet-to-helmet hits on defenseless receivers?

    Players should do some soul searching of their own.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.