Sean Payton explains decision to release Brandon McManus

Denver Broncos OTAs
Getty Images

The Broncos surprisingly released kicker Brandon McManus earlier this week. It arguably shouldn’t have been a surprise.

“Ultimately, you’re constantly looking at what’s in the best interest for your team,” head coach Sean Payton told reporters. “A lot of the time, money and what your ‘musts’ are come into it. You guys know this better than anyone, the transactions continue here from now until training camp. There may be a player of two that we are still looking to sign. We factored a lot of that in and then we made that decision.”

By releasing McManus, the Broncos avoided $3,650,000 in salary, and created that same amount in cap space.

Beyond the salary, there’s another element that potentially influenced the decision. Payton is a disciple of Bill Parcells, and Parcells generally liked his kickers and punters to be seen and not heard.

McManus last year boycotted OTAs, and then he showed up for the last sessions to explain why he didn’t show up. The year before, McManus was one of the public voices speaking out against OTAs, at a time when the union tried to get more and more players to withhold services during voluntary drills.

Regardless of the Payton-Parcells angle, the union activity likely didn’t sit well with new ownership, given Wal-Mart’s very strong and successful efforts to avoid unionization. (Google what happened after a small group of meat cutters in Jacksonville, Texas became the first employees in company history to vote to unionize.)

Thus, while McManus still has something to add (as evidenced by Jacksonville’s decision to pounce on him quickly), his release in Denver potentially sends a not-so-subtle message to the locker room. And particularly to the players who can be easily replaced.

20 responses to “Sean Payton explains decision to release Brandon McManus

  1. Logic-free……

    “A lot of the time, money and what your ‘musts’ are come into it.

    You guys know this better than anyone, the transactions continue here from now until training camp.

    There may be a player of two that we are still looking to sign.

    We factored a lot of that in and then we made that decision.”

  2. He will look stupid once the Broncos lose 2-3 games because of missed kicks. McManus is a top 5 kicker in the NFL.

  3. Sean makes examples out of somebody. First year it was Wayne Gandy with the saints.

    Nothing new wait until everyone is in the building and cut someone as an example

  4. Seems silly to cut a reliable kicker to save $3.6M. It’s important to be able to count on them and this guy is one of the better ones

  5. KC fan here just to laugh at Denver’s continued incompetence. Its hilarious to see some media once again jumping on their bandwagon: last year it was b/c of Wilson and this year its Payton. Both are past the point of being relevant. So I take it Payton won’t be trying a 65 yard FG to win game 1. I can’t wait though for when the new kicker misses a chip shot or an extra point and it costs them the game. And I can’t wait to see the locker room turn on how he treats players. Can’t wait!

  6. McManus has been inconsistent and was terrible beyond 50. He was paid a premium for mediocre performance. Not a surprise.

  7. This isn’t walmart. Bronco management better be careful or they might start costing themselves free agents

  8. Problem with Payton’s Parcells imitation is it’s not 2010 it’s 2023. Players aren’t intimidated by a faux tough guy routine from coaches like Payton. Have a feeling it’s not only the mountains that will be rocky this coming year in Colorado it will be Payton’s relationship with the players.

  9. McManus was only a somewhat above average kicker. His biggest weak point was his relative lack of success on 50+ yard field goals. His lifetime average on those is only 56%, which is actually below average in the NFL these days; and especially surprising since he plays half his games in Mile High. I’ll be curious to see how well he does on long kicks in Jacksonville.

  10. A guy that makes $3+ mil a year to kick a ball a handful of times a week was lobbying to spend less time at work? Good for Payton lol

  11. Sorry, Broncos fans….welcome to the Payton kicking carousel

    Condolences,
    New Orleans

  12. pkrlvr says:
    May 26, 2023 at 10:02 am
    A guy that makes $3+ mil a year to kick a ball a handful of times a week was lobbying to spend less time at work? Good for Payton lo
    ——————————————————————————————
    How often do you volunteer to work and not get paid? It’s like everything beneficial the NFLPA negotiated for the players, they allow the NFL to ignore it.

  13. If you look into his stats a little deeper and realize he can’t make it past 53 yards, threw multiple sideline tantrums when he wasn’t called on to kick 63-65 yard attempts, had a god awful shank when they finally did allow him…it actually makes sense why they didn’t want to pay him $3+ million a year anymore. As for the “reliable kicker” comments, he was the 25th best kicker in the league last year based on accuracy lol.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.